Political Ideologies
Political Ideologies
Political Ideologies are practical implementations of normative theories.
Examples of political ideologies include:
Liberalism
Conservatism
Socialism
Fascism
Feminism
Environmentalism
Liberalism
Etymology of Liberalism:
Originates from the Latin word liber, meaning 'free' or 'one seeking liberty'.
Public Perception in the United States:
The contemporary understanding of liberalism varies.
Its association with individuals or political parties is perceived as either positive or negative, contingent on one's personal perspective and political ideology.
Major Philosophers and Theorists:
Classical Liberalism:
John Locke
Adam Smith
Modern Liberalism:
T. H. Green
Jane Addams
Classical Liberalism - John Locke
Seminal Work:
Two Treatises of Government
Advocates for:
Protection of individual liberties.
Limited government.
Rejects authoritarianism, emphasizing that the state exists to serve the people.
State of Nature:
Describes a time prior to the establishment of governments.
Questions regarding human existence in this state include:
Why would individuals transition from the state of nature?
Locke posits that freedom is fundamentally essential to human nature.
Key Concepts from Locke:
Natural Human Rights include:
Life
Liberty
Property
Human Rationality:
Does not imply perfectibility of society.
Laws of Nature:
Reason allows individuals to discern laws governing human behavior.
Preserve oneself.
Avoid harming others.
Initiating conflict risks personal safety and contravenes nature's laws.
Role of the State:
States exist primarily to safeguard life, liberty, and property rather than to impose morality or rationality.
Classical Liberalism - Adam Smith
Contributions to Economics:
As a moral theorist, Smith focuses on capitalism's relationship with liberalism, considering the two mutually reinforcing.
Individual rationality serves as the foundation of both.
Purpose of Government:
To provide security and public goods, primarily through the development of economic systems transitioning from barter to cash.
Economic Progression:
The logical progression from barter to cash systems is questioned, leading to discussions on contemporary economic models.
Classical vs. Modern Liberalism
Transition Overview:
Differences between classical and modern liberalism focus on the rationale for government intervention and the definition of liberty.
Classical liberalism emphasizes minimal government versus modern liberalism, which advocates for a more expansive definition of liberty, reflecting the following:
Early proponent: T. H. Green (1836-1882).
Advocates broader inclusivity in the understanding of freedom.
Modern Liberalism
Key Characteristics:
Interventionist Government:
Governments intervene in economic and social matters.
Expansive Liberty:
Focuses on opportunities for individuals to contribute meaningfully to society.
Advocacy Positions:
Supports:
Safe working conditions.
Social safety nets, enhancing individual freedom.
Natural and economic equality along with collective societal welfare.
Reference to Founding Documents:
Quote from the Preamble to the U.S. Constitution emphasizes commitment to welfare and justice:
"We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity…"
Modern Liberalism - Jane Addams
Contributions:
Founder of Hull House in Chicago, which served as a model for social safety nets established during the New Deal of the Roosevelt Administration.
Modern Liberalism - New Deal
Key Reforms:
Federal Emergency Relief Administration: Provided funds to states for relief programs aimed at the unemployed.
Works Progress Administration (WPA): Created jobs for the unemployed through federal funds.
Banking Act of 1935: Introduced governmental controls over the banking industry.
National Labor Relations Act: Offered federal protection to workers wishing to unionize and prohibited antiunion practices by employers.
Conservatism
Overview:
Conservatism reasserts classical liberal positions while rebranding these views to differentiate from modern liberalism.
Contemporary classical liberals are often referred to as libertarians, advocating for limited governmental intervention.
Libertarianism
Core Policies:
Supports:
Legalization of drugs.
Censorship prohibition on books and movies.
Gun ownership rights.
Abortion rights.
Types of Conservatism
Classical Liberal Conservatism:
Advocates for minimal government involvement and capitalism.
U.S. example: Rockefeller Republicans.
Traditional Conservatism:
Established through works of Edmund Burke (1729-1797).
Seminal text: Reflections on the Revolution in France
National Conservatism: Newer movement within right-wing politics, characterized by anti-liberal sentiments.
Traditional Conservatism - Edmund Burke
Key Ideas:
Burke argues against rational governance, emphasizing human emotional and unpredictable behavior.
Asserts inherent inequality among people.
Core Arguments:
Advocates for guidance from traditional authorities to ensure societal stability and morality through:
Family structures
Religious beliefs
Government laws.
State's Role:
Government should prioritize societal needs over merely protecting natural rights; individuals must feel a structured social existence.
Reason and Tradition:
If reasoning is seen as unreliable, society should adhere to tradition for guidance in governance.
Traditional Conservatism Today
Rejection of limited government ideology:
Advocates for state intervention to foster societal morality.
Example: The Family Research Council promotes what it labels the "pro-family" values advocating for various conservative stances on social issues:
Anti-abortion policies.
Opposition to same-sex marriage legalization.
Support for school prayer.
Opposition to public school sex education.
Conservatism Conflict
Division within Conservatism:
Traditional Conservatism opposed to Classical Liberal Conservatism, highlighting tensions between differing goals of minimizing versus utilizing governmental authority for moral purposes.