Political Ideologies

Political Ideologies

  • Political Ideologies are practical implementations of normative theories.

  • Examples of political ideologies include:

    • Liberalism

    • Conservatism

    • Socialism

    • Fascism

    • Feminism

    • Environmentalism

Liberalism

  • Etymology of Liberalism:

    • Originates from the Latin word liber, meaning 'free' or 'one seeking liberty'.

  • Public Perception in the United States:

    • The contemporary understanding of liberalism varies.

    • Its association with individuals or political parties is perceived as either positive or negative, contingent on one's personal perspective and political ideology.

  • Major Philosophers and Theorists:

    • Classical Liberalism:

    • John Locke

    • Adam Smith

    • Modern Liberalism:

    • T. H. Green

    • Jane Addams

Classical Liberalism - John Locke

  • Seminal Work:

    • Two Treatises of Government

    • Advocates for:

      • Protection of individual liberties.

      • Limited government.

    • Rejects authoritarianism, emphasizing that the state exists to serve the people.

  • State of Nature:

    • Describes a time prior to the establishment of governments.

    • Questions regarding human existence in this state include:

    • Why would individuals transition from the state of nature?

    • Locke posits that freedom is fundamentally essential to human nature.

  • Key Concepts from Locke:

    • Natural Human Rights include:

    • Life

    • Liberty

    • Property

    • Human Rationality:

    • Does not imply perfectibility of society.

    • Laws of Nature:

    • Reason allows individuals to discern laws governing human behavior.

      • Preserve oneself.

      • Avoid harming others.

      • Initiating conflict risks personal safety and contravenes nature's laws.

  • Role of the State:

    • States exist primarily to safeguard life, liberty, and property rather than to impose morality or rationality.

Classical Liberalism - Adam Smith

  • Contributions to Economics:

    • As a moral theorist, Smith focuses on capitalism's relationship with liberalism, considering the two mutually reinforcing.

    • Individual rationality serves as the foundation of both.

  • Purpose of Government:

    • To provide security and public goods, primarily through the development of economic systems transitioning from barter to cash.

  • Economic Progression:

    • The logical progression from barter to cash systems is questioned, leading to discussions on contemporary economic models.

Classical vs. Modern Liberalism

  • Transition Overview:

    • Differences between classical and modern liberalism focus on the rationale for government intervention and the definition of liberty.

    • Classical liberalism emphasizes minimal government versus modern liberalism, which advocates for a more expansive definition of liberty, reflecting the following:

    • Early proponent: T. H. Green (1836-1882).

    • Advocates broader inclusivity in the understanding of freedom.

Modern Liberalism

  • Key Characteristics:

    • Interventionist Government:

    • Governments intervene in economic and social matters.

    • Expansive Liberty:

    • Focuses on opportunities for individuals to contribute meaningfully to society.

  • Advocacy Positions:

    • Supports:

    • Safe working conditions.

    • Social safety nets, enhancing individual freedom.

    • Natural and economic equality along with collective societal welfare.

  • Reference to Founding Documents:

    • Quote from the Preamble to the U.S. Constitution emphasizes commitment to welfare and justice:

    • "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity…"

Modern Liberalism - Jane Addams

  • Contributions:

    • Founder of Hull House in Chicago, which served as a model for social safety nets established during the New Deal of the Roosevelt Administration.

Modern Liberalism - New Deal

  • Key Reforms:

    • Federal Emergency Relief Administration: Provided funds to states for relief programs aimed at the unemployed.

    • Works Progress Administration (WPA): Created jobs for the unemployed through federal funds.

    • Banking Act of 1935: Introduced governmental controls over the banking industry.

    • National Labor Relations Act: Offered federal protection to workers wishing to unionize and prohibited antiunion practices by employers.

Conservatism

  • Overview:

    • Conservatism reasserts classical liberal positions while rebranding these views to differentiate from modern liberalism.

    • Contemporary classical liberals are often referred to as libertarians, advocating for limited governmental intervention.

Libertarianism

  • Core Policies:

    • Supports:

    • Legalization of drugs.

    • Censorship prohibition on books and movies.

    • Gun ownership rights.

    • Abortion rights.

Types of Conservatism

  • Classical Liberal Conservatism:

    • Advocates for minimal government involvement and capitalism.

    • U.S. example: Rockefeller Republicans.

  • Traditional Conservatism:

    • Established through works of Edmund Burke (1729-1797).

    • Seminal text: Reflections on the Revolution in France

  • National Conservatism: Newer movement within right-wing politics, characterized by anti-liberal sentiments.

Traditional Conservatism - Edmund Burke

  • Key Ideas:

    • Burke argues against rational governance, emphasizing human emotional and unpredictable behavior.

    • Asserts inherent inequality among people.

  • Core Arguments:

    • Advocates for guidance from traditional authorities to ensure societal stability and morality through:

    • Family structures

    • Religious beliefs

    • Government laws.

  • State's Role:

    • Government should prioritize societal needs over merely protecting natural rights; individuals must feel a structured social existence.

  • Reason and Tradition:

    • If reasoning is seen as unreliable, society should adhere to tradition for guidance in governance.

Traditional Conservatism Today

  • Rejection of limited government ideology:

    • Advocates for state intervention to foster societal morality.

    • Example: The Family Research Council promotes what it labels the "pro-family" values advocating for various conservative stances on social issues:

    • Anti-abortion policies.

    • Opposition to same-sex marriage legalization.

    • Support for school prayer.

    • Opposition to public school sex education.

Conservatism Conflict

  • Division within Conservatism:

    • Traditional Conservatism opposed to Classical Liberal Conservatism, highlighting tensions between differing goals of minimizing versus utilizing governmental authority for moral purposes.