Ch 24: Money and the Federal Reserve System

Foundations of Money and the Barter System

  • Definition of Barter: trading one good or service directly for another without using money.

  • Simple: Item for item (or service for service).

  • The Problem of Coincidence of Wants: The problem with barter is that it takes time and requires both people to want what the other person has.

  • Coincidence of wants: Both people must want what the other person is offering.

  • Ex: You have apples and want oranges. You must find someone who has oranges AND wants your apples.

  • Wasted time: People spend time finding someone to trade with instead of using that time to work or be productive.

  • Exemplary Case Study of Barter Inefficiency:

    • Initial Scenario: Farmer Brown produces wheat and requires a pair of shoes. He brings bushels of wheat to the shoe store to trade for footwear.

    • Transaction Failure: The shoe store owner refuses the exchange because she does not need wheat; she wants coffee instead.

    • Intermediary Search: Farmer Brown encounters Mr. Jones, who possesses coffee and is willing to exchange it for bushels of wheat.

    • Terms of Exchange Negotiation: Before trading, Farmer Brown and Mr. Jones must establish the exchange rate (for example, calculating how many pounds of coffee equate to a single bushel of wheat).

    • Final Transaction: Once the wheat-for-coffee transaction is finalized, Farmer Brown must travel back to the shoe store to negotiate a secondary exchange, trading the acquired coffee for the desired shoes.

    • Economic Cost: This cumbersome sequence wastes significant time, generates high transaction costs, and restricts trade volume.

  • The Evolutionary Stages of Money:

  • 1. Barter: People traded goods directly for other goods.
    Ex: Trading a cow for food.

    2. Gold: People used valuable gold as money to buy things.

    3. Metal Coins: Standardized pieces of metal used as money, making trading easier because their value and weight were established.

    4. Paper Money: Paper bills used to pay for goods and services instead of carrying gold or coins.

    5. Plastic Cards: Debit and credit cards used to make electronic payments.

    • Debit = Uses money from your bank account.

    • Credit = Borrows money that you pay back later.

    6. Electronic Money: Sending and receiving money electronically through online banking, apps, and computer networks.

    7. Cryptocurrency: Digital money that uses cryptography and operates on decentralized networks, such as Bitcoin.

The historical progression of exchange mechanisms from direct barter to digital cryptocurrency

Core Functions and Desirable Properties of Money

  • Comprehensive Definition of Money: Anything people accept and use to buy goods and services

  • The Three Functions of Money:(depend on inflation, purchasing power )

    • Medium (means ) of Exchange: Using money to buy and sell goods and services.(Money is going to help you get )

    • Example: cash, debit card, electronic money (Zelle), credit card, and checks

      • Economic Impact: Money eliminates the need for a coincidence of wants.

      • Growth Channel: Money saves people time, allowing them to be more productive.

    • Unit of Account: Using money to measure and compare the prices or values of goods and services (to measure value

    • Example: price tag

      • Functionality: This explains why money is useful as a unit of account.

    • Store of Value: The ability of money to hold its purchasing power over time.

    • Simple: Money can keep its value over time, so you can save it and use it in the future

      • Functionality: Money allows you to save what you earn today and spend it in the future.

  • Status of Credit Cards in the Money Supply:

    • Credit cards are not money.

    • Because they represent a short-term loan (borrowed money) that you must pay back.

      Why? They do not satisfy the store-of-value function because the card represents debt, not money you own.

  • Liquidity of Money: How easily something can be converted into cash or used to make purchases.

  • Money is the most liquid form of wealth because you can use it immediately to buy goods and services without converting it into something else.

    Example:

    • Cash = Very liquid (you can spend it immediately).

    • House = Less liquid (you must sell it before getting money).

  • Four Additional Desirable Properties of Money:

    • Scarcity: There must be enough money for people to buy things, but not so much that money loses its value.

    • Portability: Money must be easy to carry and transfer.

    • Ex: credit card

    • Divisibility: Money must be able to be broken into smaller amounts.( break things down into pieces)

    • Ex: You can break a $20 bill into two $10 bills or four $5 bills.

    • Uniformity: All money of the same amount has the same value and quality

    • Ex: money has the same design and shape all over the country

  • Commodity Money versus Fiat Money:

    • Commodity Money: Is money that has value because of the material it is made from.

      • Examples: Gold and silver coins have value even when they aren't used as money.

    • Fiat (Decree) = law Money: Money that has value because the government declares it legal money, not because of the material it is made from.

    • Money we use today because it is legal tender

    • An item can serve as money even if the material it's made from has little or no market value.

      Why? Money works because people accept and trust it as a way to pay for goods and services.

    • Backing of the U.S. Dollar:

      • The U.S. dollar is backed neither by gold nor silver.

      • The dollar is backed by people's trust and confidence in the government and the Federal Reserve.

Cryptocurrencies and Modern Digital Currency Systems

  • Definition: Digital money that uses special technology to keep it secure and usually operates without banks or government control.( any form of digital payment)

  • Operational Mechanisms:

    • Blockchain Technology: A digital record that keeps track of all cryptocurrency transactions.

    • Decentralization: Cryptocurrency works without needing a bank or government to approve transactions.

    • Creation & Validation: This is how new cryptocurrency transactions are approved and recorded.

      • Proof-of-Work (Mining): Computers solve difficult math problems to verify transactions.

      • Proof-of-Stake (Staking): People commit some of their cryptocurrency to help verify transactions and secure the network.

    • Digital Wallets: Programs or devices that allow people to access and manage their cryptocurrency.

      • Public key: Like an address where people can send you cryptocurrency.

      • Private key: Like a password that gives you access to your cryptocurrency.

  • Common Examples:

  • 1. Bitcoin: The first and most popular cryptocurrency. Only 21 million bitcoins can ever exist.

    2. Ethereum: A cryptocurrency that allows people to create digital apps and automatic agreements.

    3. Altcoins: Any cryptocurrency other than Bitcoin. Examples: Solana and XRP.

    4. Stablecoins: Cryptocurrency designed to keep a steady value, usually matching the U.S. dollar

  • Key Risks:

    • Price Volatility: Crypto prices can go up and down very quickly. You can make money or lose money.

      2. Lack of FDIC Insurance: Cryptocurrency is NOT protected by FDIC insurance like money in an insured bank account. If you lose your crypto, the government won't automatically give your money back.

      3. Irreversibility: Crypto payments usually cannot be reversed. If you send money to the wrong person or get scammed, you may not get it back.

      4. Opaque (Not Transparent): It can be difficult to understand how some crypto companies operate or what is happening behind the scenes.

  • Economic Assessment: Cryptocurrencies are money because they satisfy the three functions of money

Definitions and Components of the Money Supply

  • Money supply: Total amount of money in the system

  • Two Primary Money Supply Metrics: Economists and the Federal Reserve classify the money stock into two official aggregate measures: M1M1 and M2M2.

M1: The Narrow Money Supply: Money that is readily available to spend (cash and checking account deposits).

  • Mathematical Formula:         M1=Currency+Checkable DepositsM1 = \text{Currency} + \text{Checkable Deposits}

  • Component Breakdown:

    • Currency: Physical money that people carry and use.(coin and paper money)

    • Checkable Deposits: Money in bank accounts that people can access whenever they need it, such as through checks, debit cards, or electronic transfers.

  • M2: The Broad Money Supply: Is the total amount of money in the economy that includes M1 plus near monies.

    • Mathematical Formula:         M2=M1+Savings Deposits+Small Time Deposits of less than $100,000M2 = M1 + \text{Savings Deposits} + \text{Small Time Deposits of less than } \$100,000

    • Component Breakdown:

      • Near Monies: Money that isn't used directly to pay but can easily be turned into cash.

        • Example: Money in a savings account.

      • Savings Deposits: Money you keep in a bank that earns interest.

        • Example: You put $500 in your savings account, and the bank pays you a little extra interest.

      • Examples: Passbook savings accounts, Money market accounts.

      • Small Time Deposits:Money you leave in a bank for a set amount of time to earn interest.

        • Example: You deposit $1,000 into a CD for 1 year. The bank pays you interest, but you may pay a penalty if you take the money out early. (such as Certificates of Deposit, or CDs\text{CDs}), with balances below $100,000\$100,000.

  • Comparative Liquidity:

  • M1 = More liquid (easier to spend immediately).

  • M2 = Less liquid (may need to be converted first).

  • Quantitative Money Supply Structure (2020 Data):

Composition and relative proportions of the M1 and M2 money supplies in 2020

Organizational Structure of the Federal Reserve System

  • Overview of the Fed: The Federal Reserve System (Fed), the central bank

    • The Fed controls how much money is available in the U.S. economy.

    • It influences the amount of money circulating through the economy.

    • Historical background:

    • Establishment of the Reserve Act of 1913

    • Lots of disagreement

    • following the finacel crisis of 1907

    2. What is the Federal Reserve System (Fed)?

    The Federal Reserve System is the central banking system of the United States.

    • It consists of 12 Federal Reserve District Banks.

    • These banks serve other banks and financial institutions within their assigned districts.

  • The Twelve Federal Reserve Districts:

    • District 1: Boston

    • District 2: New York ( Most important)

    • District 3: Philadelphia

    • District 4: Cleveland

    • District 5: Richmond (Virginia)

    • District 6: Atlanta

    • District 7: Chicago

    • District 8: St. Louis

    • District 9: Minneapolis

    • District 10: Kansas City

    • District 11: Dallas

    • District 12: San Francisco (territory includes both Alaska and Hawaii) last one

    • Half of New Jersey is covered by District 3 in the south, and half of NJ in the north is covered by New York 2


Federal Reserve organizational Structure

12 District Banks: The 12 main regional Federal Reserve Banks serve different areas of the United States.

25 Branch Banks: The 12 District Banks operate 25 additional branches to serve their regions.

Headquarters: The Federal Reserve Board is located in Washington, D.C., where central oversight takes place.

Geographic boundaries and city headquarters of the twelve Federal Reserve Districts across the United States
  • Institutional Governance Hierarchy:

    • The Board of Governors is a group of 7 members who oversee the Federal Reserve System.

      • 7 members are appointed by the U.S. President. (including the chair)

      • They must be confirmed by the U.S. Senate.

      • Each member serves one 14-year term (cannot be renewed).

      • Political independence

      • Their job is to supervise the U.S. banking system and control the money supply.

    • The Chair of the Board of Governors: Is the leader of the Federal Reserve and one of the members of the Board of Governors.

      • Appointed by the U.S. President.

      • Serves a 4-year term as Chair.

      • Current chair: Kevin Warsh

      • Acts as the main spokesperson for the Federal Reserve.

      • Has significant influence over monetary policy decisions (decisions about the money supply and interest rates).

    • Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC): Is the Federal Reserve committee that directs the buying and selling of U.S. government securities to control the money supply.

      • Buying securities: Increases the money supply.

      • Selling securities: Decreases the money supply.

      2. What is the makeup of the FOMC?

      The FOMC consists of 12 voting members:

    • 7 members of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors.

    • 1 president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.(#2)

    • 4 (on a one-year rotational basis) presidents of other Federal Reserve District Banks (everybody else)

    • Federal Advisory Council (FAC): Is a group of 12 prominent commercial bankers who advise the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors.

      • Each of the 12 Federal Reserve District Banks selects one banker each year.

      • Their job is to give advice to the Board of Governors.

      • They do not have the authority to make monetary policy decisions.

    • Commercial Banking System Infrastructure:

    • The banking system includes banks, S&Ls, and credit unions.

    • About 3,000 out of 8,000 banks belong to the Fed.

    • These banks hold about 70% of all commercial bank deposits.

Organizational hierarchy of the Federal Reserve System showing the relationships between the Board of Governors, FOMC, advisory bodies, and member banks

Operational Functions of the Federal Reserve System

  • The Seven Primary Functions of the Federal Reserve:

    • Controls money supply: Manages the amount of money in the economy.

    • - It could reduce or increase the amount of money that goes into the economy

    • Clears checks: Processes payments between banks.

    • Transfer money ( zelle)

    • Supervises banks: Makes sure banks follow rules and operate safely.

    • Maintains currency ( Important ) : Distributes money and replaces old bills.

    • Where it comes from

    • insurance can replace it ( FED)

    • Protects consumers ( New) : Ensures fair lending practices. \

    • (FDIC)

    • Manages government accounts: Handles the government's banking and gold.

    • Lender of last resort: Gives emergency loans to banks in financial trouble.(The Fed doesn’t give much help, only when they need it )

    • Too Big to Fail

    • - Chase

    • Bank of America

  • Clarification Regarding Currency Production:

  • Who prints money?

    • Federal Reserve: Does NOT print money. It distributes cash to banks.

    • Bureau of Engraving and Printing: Prints paper money (bills).

    • U.S. Mint: Makes coins.

  • Federal Consumer Protection and Regulatory Agencies:

    • Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC):

      • Created in 1933.

      • Protects bank customers' deposits up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank.

      • Helps prevent people from losing their money if a bank fails.

    • Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB):

    • A government agency that protects consumers when they use financial products and services.

    • Makes sure lenders are fair and honest.

    • Helps prevent hidden fees and unfair lending practices involving mortgages, credit cards, and student loans.

The U.S. Banking Revolution and Legislative History

  • Monetary Control Act of 1980:

    • A law that gave the Federal Reserve more control over banks, including banks that were not Fed members.

    • Made financial institutions compete more equally with one another.

    • Four Key Provisions:

      • 1. More Fed control: The Fed gained more authority over banks that were not Fed members.

      • 2. Borrowing reserves: All depository institutions could borrow reserves from Federal Reserve Banks.

      • 3. More competition: Different financial institutions could offer a wider variety of banking services.

      • 4. Removed interest rate limits: Eliminated interest rate ceilings, allowing institutions to offer more competitive interest rates.

  • The Savings and Loan (S&L) Crisis:

  • Lost advantage: S&Ls could no longer offer higher savings interest rates than commercial banks.

  • Increased competition: Banks competed more aggressively for depositors by offering higher interest rates.

  • Financial losses: S&Ls earned low interest on long-term mortgages but had to pay higher interest on customer deposits.

  • Risky lending: To make more money, some S&Ls began making risky loans and investments.

  • Insolvency: Many S&Ls failed because borrowers could not repay their loans. This drained the FSLIC's insurance funds.

  • Legislative Resolution of the S&L Crisis:

  • Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA):

    • Closed the failing FSLIC.

    • Transferred savings and loan deposit insurance to the FDIC.

    2. Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC):

    • Created by the government to take over failed S&Ls.

    • Sold off their assets, including foreclosed properties.

  • The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010:

  • Cause: Risky lending and poor bank supervision contributed to the 2007–2008 financial crisis.

  • Enactment: Signed into law in 2010 by President Barack Obama.

  • Purpose: Reduce financial risks, require banks to hold more money in reserves, and increase oversight of large banks.

  • Consumer protection: Created the CFPB to protect consumers from unfair financial practices.

  • Ongoing changes: Financial regulations continue to be debated and revised.