Chapter 10: Agents

10.1 Getting someone else to do it

  • Agency occurs when a business owner (the principal) has workers who deal with third parties (suppliers, customers, other employees, other businesses) on the business’s behalf.

  • A business owner is legally bound by statements, contracts, or payments made by a worker who is authorised to act on the business owner’s behalf.

  • The binding can extend to torts and crimes committed by an authorised worker, depending on the scope and nature of the authority.

  • A person who acts on behalf of another in dealing with a third party is called an agent; the person they are acting for is the principal.

  • The principal may be an individual or a corporation, and the same is true of the agent and the third party.

  • Illustrative mappings (examples of agents and principals):

    • Employer ↔ Employee

    • Auctioneer ↔ Employer

    • Mercantile agent ↔ Employer

    • Solicitor ↔ Client

    • Real estate agent ↔ Client

    • Stockbroker ↔ Client

    • Director ↔ Corporation

    • Partner ↔ Partner

    • Donee of power of attorney ↔ Donor of power of attorney

  • Practical takeaway: The agency relationship creates legal accountability for the principal’s dealings when the agent acts within their authority.

10.2 Scope of authority

  • If the agent acts within the scope of their authority, the contract or legal relation is between the principal and the third party; the agent incurs no personal liability.

  • There are five main ways in which an agent can be authorised to act on behalf of a principal:

    • express actual authority

    • implied actual authority

    • apparent authority

    • agency of necessity

    • authority by ratification

Express actual authority
  • The principal expressly authorises the agent, in writing or verbally, to act on the principal’s behalf.

  • The authorisation should clearly state:

    • the duration of the agent’s appointment,

    • the precise scope of the agent’s authority,

    • and (if relevant) the agent’s entitlement to any commission or payment.

Power of attorney (express actual authority by written grant)
  • A power of attorney is a written grant of express actual authority to an agent, empowering the agent to sign documents and make decisions on behalf of the principal.

  • Two types of power of attorney:

    • general power of attorney\text{general power of attorney}

    • enduring power of attorney\text{enduring power of attorney}

Implied actual authority
  • The principal can authorise the agent to act by implication, for example:

    • by instructing the agent to carry out a particular task on the principal's behalf, or

    • by appointing them to a position in a way that makes it obvious the agent will be required to contract with a third party on the principal’s behalf.

Implied actual authority (continued)
  • Whenever an agent is expressly authorised to act on behalf of a principal, there is a grant of implied authority to do all things incidental to carrying out the main task.

  • An agent may have implied authority to act to give business efficacy to a contractual arrangement (to carry out necessary actions to implement the main task).

Apparent authority
  • An agent has apparent authority if:

    • the third party did not know that the agent did not have actual authority,

    • the principal held the agent out as having authority (e.g., by appointing the agent to a position or past conduct), and

    • the third party relied on that holding out and reasonably assumed the agent had actual authority.

  • If all three requirements are satisfied, the principal is bound by the agent’s actions, even if the principal expressly told the agent not to enter into such a contract or act in that manner on the principal’s behalf.

  • Key cases illustrating apparent authority include: Panorama Developments (Guildford) Ltd v Fidelis Furnishing Fabrics Ltd (1971); Summers v Solomon (1857); Tooth v Laws (1888).

Agency of necessity
  • An agency of necessity exists if four requirements are satisfied:

    • The agent has possession or control of property belonging to the principal,

    • The principal’s property is under threat,

    • The agent cannot contact the principal to obtain express instructions,

    • The agent acts in good faith to protect the principal’s property.

  • Case example: Great Northern Railway Co v Swaffield (1874).

Authority by ratification
  • Even if an agent acts without actual or apparent authority, the principal can ratify the act after learning of it, authorising it retrospectively.

  • If ratified within a reasonable time, it is as if the agent acted with the principal’s actual authority at the time of the act.

  • Case example: Bolton Partners v Lambert (1889).

10.3 The agent's duties

  • The agent–principal relationship is fiduciary: the agent is in a position of trust and responsibility and owes duties to the principal under the law of equity.

Duties of an agent
  • Duty to account

  • Duty to follow instructions

  • Duty of confidentiality

  • Duty to act in the best interests of the principal

  • Duty to communicate information

  • Duty of care

  • Duty to act personally

Duty to follow instructions
  • The agent must obey lawful instructions of the principal when exercising authority.

  • If the agent breaches by not following lawful instructions, they will be personally liable for harm caused to the principal as a result.

  • The agent is not liable for instructions from the principal that are unlawful.

Duty to communicate information
  • The agent must communicate information relevant to the agency to the principal.

  • The agent should pass on information learned in the ordinary course of business that a reasonable agent would consider relevant.

  • Case example: John D Wood & Co (Residential & Agricultural) Ltd v Knatchbull (2002).

Duty to act personally
  • The agent is obliged to carry out the principal’s instructions personally.

  • Delegation to another person or a sub-agent is not allowed unless the principal gives permission.

  • Case example: John McCann & Co v Pow (1974).

Duty of care
  • The agent must carry out the principal’s instructions with due care and skill.

  • If the agent fails to meet the standard of a reasonable agent in the same circumstances, they breach the duty and may be liable in negligence.

  • Case reference: Provincial Insurance Australia Pty Ltd v Consolidated Wood Products Pty Ltd (1991).

  • Note: A gratuitous (unpaid) agent still owes a duty of care, though the standard may be lower.

Duty to act in the best interests of the principal
  • The agent has a fiduciary obligation not to exercise authority in a way that conflicts with the principal’s interests.

  • The agent should avoid self-dealing or placing themselves in a position where their own interests conflict with the principal’s.

  • Case references: Hewson v Sydney Stock Exchange Ltd (1968).

  • If the agent acts for two principals whose interests conflict (or if a principal’s actions create a conflict of interest), the agent is in breach.

Duty to act in the best interests – secret commissions
  • The agent is breached if they receive a secret commission from a third party, as it conflicts with the principal’s interests.

  • Receiving a secret commission is not only a breach of fiduciary duty; it can also be a criminal offence, potentially resulting in fines or imprisonment.

Duty of confidentiality
  • The agent must maintain the principal’s confidentiality.

  • They must not disclose or use information about the principal for their own benefit or without permission, or use information gained during the agency for personal gain.

Duty to account
  • The agent must keep proper records of funds spent or received on behalf of the principal.

  • They must produce these records when asked by the principal.

  • The principal’s money and property must be kept separate from the agent’s own assets.

10.4 The agent's entitlements

Remuneration
  • The agent has no inherent right to remuneration.

  • Remuneration is only due if the principal and agent have agreed that the agent should be paid; it is a term of the contract between the two.

  • Remuneration arrangements can include:

    • a flat fee,

    • a commission based on a formula applied to a transaction amount,

    • or other agreed arrangements.

Indemnity
  • All agents are entitled to be indemnified by the principal, meaning reimbursement for payments made, expenses incurred, and liabilities assumed while carrying out the principal’s instructions.

Lien
  • If the principal owes money to the agent (remuneration or indemnity) and refuses to pay, the agent is entitled to a lien over any of the principal’s property in the agent’s possession.

10.5 Liability of the agent and the principal

Personal liability of the agent
  • As a general rule, any deal negotiated by the agent on behalf of the principal is between the principal and the third party; the agent is merely an intermediary and not personally liable.

  • An agent will be personally liable if the circumstances show that the parties intended the agent to be personally liable.

Undisclosed principal and personal liability
  • If the agent did not disclose that they were acting as an agent (undisclosed principal), the agent will be personally liable.

  • If the principal is undisclosed and the third party later learns of the principal’s existence, the third party may enforce the contract against either the principal or the agent (but not both).

Warranty of authority (personal liability)
  • An agent will be personally liable to the third party for breach of warranty of authority if all of the following are satisfied:

    • The agent claimed to be contracting on behalf of the principal,

    • The agent did not actually have authority to act for the principal,

    • The third party relied on the agent’s representation and would not have entered the contract without that representation.

Vicarious liability of the principal
  • Whether the principal is liable for torts or crimes committed by their agent depends on the level of control exercised over the agent by the principal.

  • If the agent is an independent contractor and not subject to direct control, the principal is unlikely to be liable for the agent’s actions.

  • If the agent is an employee, the principal is more likely to be vicariously liable for the agent’s torts or crimes, provided they were committed while carrying out the principal’s instructions.

  • Relevant authorities: Century Insurance Co Ltd v Northern Ireland Road Transport Board (1942); Deatons Pty Ltd v Flew (1949).

10.6 Concluding the agency

Termination by the parties
  • The agency ends when any of the following occurs:

    • The agent completes the tasks appointed by the principal to complete,

    • The appointed duration expires,

    • The principal and agent agree to terminate the relationship,

    • The principal dismisses the agent for breach of contract or breach of duties,

    • The principal revokes or limits the agent’s authority.

Automatic termination
  • Termination occurs automatically if any of the following happens:

    • Either the principal or the agent dies,

    • Either the principal or the agent loses the capacity to contract,

    • Either the principal or the agent becomes bankrupt,

    • The subject matter of the agent’s appointment becomes illegal,

    • The contract between the principal and agent is frustrated.