Hamlet Act II Exhaustive Study Guide: Analysis of Scenes, Metaphors, and the Antic Disposition
Hamlet's Interruption and Manipulation of Polonius
Overhearing the Spying Plot:
- Hamlet overheard the secret conversation between King Claudius and Polonius, making him fully aware that Polonius is actively using his own daughter, Ophelia, for personal and political gain.
- Polonius's strategy will ultimately cost him his relationship with his daughter.
The Pimp and Prostitute Analogy:
- Polonius's manipulation of Ophelia is directly comparable to a pimp controlling a prostitute for monetary and personal benefit.
- Polonius uses Ophelia as bait to extract information from Hamlet to advance his standing with Claudius.
- Applying the prostitute metaphor serves as a deliberate insult to degrade both Claudius and Polonius.
Awareness of Surveillance:
- Hamlet uses veiled commentary to inform Polonius that he is fully aware of their plan to spy on him using Ophelia.
Conception in the Sun Metaphor:
- Hamlet speaks to Polonius about Ophelia potentially conceiving by walking in the sun.
- While literal conception via sunlight is biologically impossible, Hamlet uses this imagery to target Polonius's deep-seated anxiety regarding his inability to protect his daughter's virtue and safety.
- This exploitation of paternal anxiety aligns with Polonius's ongoing paranoia throughout the play.
Interference with Hamlet's Communication:
- Hamlet signals to Polonius that he knows Polonius forced Ophelia to reject Hamlet's letters.
- Hamlet demonstrates his understanding that Polonius controls Ophelia due to paranoia regarding the consequences of their relationship.
Nonsensical Behavior and the "Fishmonger" Insult:
- Hamlet exhibits nonsensical speech patterns, repeating phrases such as "words, words, words."
- Hamlet labels Polonius a "fishmonger."
- A fishmonger is a common merchant who sells fish, comparable to a butcher in a grocery store.
- While fishmonger is a standard occupational term, it is completely nonsensical within the context of their conversation because Polonius was the chief assistant and advisor to King Hamlet and currently serves Claudius.
- Hamlet knows Polonius's actual high-ranking status; calling him a fishmonger is a calculated disrespect wrapped in apparent madness.
The Mechanics and Risks of Hamlet's Feigned Madness
Second Application of the Antic Disposition:
- This encounter marks Hamlet's second explicit execution of his feigned madness or "antic disposition."
Contrast with the Ophelia Encounter:
- Hamlet's behavioral strategy with Polonius differs fundamentally from his performance around Ophelia.
- Around Ophelia, Hamlet engaged in physical theater: removing his clothing, remaining silent, and staring at her intently.
- Around Polonius, Hamlet relies on verbal nonsensical banter, clever wordplay, and direct insults.
Risks of Inconsistent Madness:
- Hamlet's varying manifestations of madness create tactical disadvantages.
- Inconsistency raises suspicion among observers, prompting them to question whether he is experiencing genuine psychological illness, such as schizophrenia or multiple personality traits, or actively calculating a plot.
- Adopting distinct personas for different individuals requires Hamlet to recall precisely which lie or demeanor was presented to each person. Forgetting these details risks self-confusion, exposure, and escalating conflict.
Decoding "Tedious Old Fools" and the Dual Target of Insults
Textual Context of Line and Line :
- At Line , Polonius announces his departure, stating: "My honorable lord, I will most humbly take my leave of you."
- Hamlet responds with: "You cannot, sir, take from me anything that I will more willingly part withal—except my life, except my life, except my life."
- At Line , as Polonius exits, Hamlet speaks an aside to himself.
Analysis of the Plural Noun "Fools":
- Hamlet refers to the departing figure by stating: "These tedious old fools!"
- The deliberate use of the plural form "fools" (a five-letter word ending in 's') indicates that Hamlet's insults are directed at more than one individual.
- The term "fools" encompasses both Polonius and King Claudius.
- This plural reference confirms that Hamlet recognizes Polonius and Claudius as joint conspirators in spying on him.
Arrival and Interrogation of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern
Reunion with Childhood Companions:
- Following Polonius's exit, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern enter the scene.
- As long-time childhood friends, their initial interaction with Hamlet is comfortable and familiar.
Deciphering the Initial Greeting:
- At Line , Hamlet inquires about their state, to which Rosencrantz replies: "As the indifferent children of the earth."
- Rosencrantz means that they are doing fine and living an average, uncomplicated existence.
- Guildenstern adds: "Happy in that we are not over happy. On Fortune's cap we are not the very button."
- Guildenstern's response is a attempt at respectful humor: being "over happy" would be inappropriate and disrespectful given the recent death of Hamlet's father, King Hamlet.
- They attempt to ease Hamlet's grief through lighthearted banter without referencing his depression.
Underlying Mission from the Crown:
- Claudius and Gertrude specifically summoned Rosencrantz and Guildenstern to Denmark to probe Hamlet's state of mind and uncover the cause of his transformation.
- The exchange quickly devolves into crude banter regarding Fortune's private parts, characteristic of young men in their late teens or early twenties.
Honest World, Doomsday, and the Act II Deception Motif
Line to Line Exchange:
- At Line , Hamlet asks his friends why they have arrived and what news exists.
- At Line , Rosencrantz answers: "None, my lord, but that the world's grown honest."
- Hamlet counters that if Rosencrantz's claim were true, "then is doomsday near," because human nature is inherently dishonest.
The Overarching Motif of Dishonesty and Surveillance:
- Dishonesty, lying, and spying form the central motif repeated throughout Act II.
- Claudius murdered King Hamlet and concealed the crime to usurp the crown; if Claudius were forced to be honest and confess, it would mean total doom for his reign.
- Hamlet is secretly plotting to avenge his father's murder; disclosing his true intentions would lead to his immediate destruction.
- If Hamlet fails to avenge the murder, King Hamlet's soul remains trapped in purgatory, representing eternal doom for his father's spirit.
- Systematic spying destroys interpersonal trust, mutual respect, and personal integrity.
Hamlet's Controlled Confrontation:
- Having overheard Claudius and Gertrude enlist Rosencrantz and Guildenstern, Hamlet knows his childhood friends are acting as spies for the crown.
- Rather than reacting with overt emotional distress, physical anger, or direct accusations, Hamlet exercises self-control.
- He employs intellect and sharp wit, making pointed statements about human dishonesty ("the world's grown honest") to test their guilt.
Triple Meaning of "Denmark's a Prison"
Context of Line :
- At Line , Hamlet refers to Fortune's confinement and declares: "Denmark's a prison."
Three Interpretations of the Prison Metaphor:
- Physical Restriction: Claudius and Gertrude denied Hamlet permission to leave Denmark to return to his university studies in Wittenberg, Germany, keeping him physically confined to the court.
- The Monarch as the Country: In Elizabethan theatrical conventions, a monarch is frequently addressed by the name of the realm they rule ("Denmark" refers directly to King Claudius). Declaring "Denmark's a prison" identifies Claudius himself as the prison who murdered King Hamlet and prevents his soul from ascending to heaven.
- Moral and Political Corruption: Because the ruler of Denmark is a murderer, the entire political entity of Denmark functions as a corrupt institutional prison.
Relativism, Ambition, and the Slipping Control of the Antic Disposition
Perception and Reality:
- When Rosencrantz disagrees with the prison designation, Hamlet responds: "Why then, 'tis none to you, for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so. To me, it is a prison."
- This philosophical assertion posits that events and conditions lack inherent moral value; their quality depends entirely on human perception and psychological reaction.
- Life's adversities can be transformed into constructive lessons for personal growth, while positive gifts can lead to distraction or moral corruption depending on how an individual processes them.
- Hamlet applies this philosophy to his situation, striving to transform a traumatic tragedy (his father's murder) into a moral mission of justice.
The Metaphor of Ambition, Dreams, and Shadows:
- Rosencrantz and Guildenstern attribute Hamlet's sense of imprisonment to thwarted political ambition.
- Hamlet responds that he could be bounded in a nutshell and count himself a king of infinite space, were it not for his bad dreams.
- When they argue that bad dreams are themselves ambition, Hamlet breaks down the concept: ambition is merely the shadow of a dream, and a dream is itself only a shadow.
- Hamlet concludes that ambition is merely "a shadow's shadow."
Line Insult and Subsequent Cover-Up:
- At Line , Hamlet states: "Then are our beggars' bodies and our monarchs and outstretched heroes for beggars' shadows."
- This statement reduces monarchs (specifically targeting Claudius) and glorified heroes to the status of mere shadows cast by beggars.
- Immediately after uttering this treasonous insult to men he knows are Claudius's spies, Hamlet abruptly breaks off the intellectual debate, saying: "Shall we to the court? for, by my faith, I cannot reason."
Loss of Control in the Antic Disposition:
- Unlike his earlier calculated displays of madness—such as his staged appearance before Ophelia or his intentional wordplay with Polonius—this slip reveals Hamlet losing control over his speech.
- The emotional trauma and psychological toll of his situation cause him to blurt out a direct condemnation of Claudius.
- Recognizing that calling the King a beggar's shadow to royal informants puts him in grave danger, Hamlet immediately attempts to nullify his words by claiming mental incapacity ("I cannot reason") and changing the subject.