Detailed Notes on John Wesley and Methodism Chp. 25-26
John Wesley and Methodism
In the late 1735 and early 1736, a Moravian group sailed to the New World intending to preach to the Indians of Georgia. John Wesley, a young Anglican priest, was on board, invited by Governor Oglethorpe to be a pastor in Savannah, with hopes of converting the Indians.
During the voyage, Wesley learned German to communicate with his Moravian companions. When a storm hit, the ship was in danger. The Moravians remained calm and sang, while Wesley realized he was more concerned about his own safety than that of others. After the storm, he questioned the depth of his faith after learning the Moravians did not fear death. Upon reaching Savannah, Wesley sought advice from a Moravian regarding his pastoral and missionary work, questioning his own spiritual standing.
Wesley records the conversation in his diary, questioning if he felt the presence and witness of God within himself. He admitted to not knowing if he knew Jesus as his personal savior, fearing his faith was in vain. These events left him confused, as he had always considered himself a good Christian. Wesley's father, Samuel, was an Anglican priest, and his mother, Susanna, diligently taught her 19 children about religion and morality. John's miraculous survival of a fire at age five led his mother to believe God had special plans for him. At Oxford, Wesley excelled as both a scholar and a devout individual.
He assisted his father in the parish and later returned to Oxford, joining a religious society founded by his brother Charles and friends. They committed to a strict life of holiness, including weekly communion, regular devotions, prison visits, and Bible study. John Wesley became the leader, and other studentsmocked them as the "holy club" or "Methodists" because of their methodical lifestyle.
As a pastor in Georgia, Wesley faced challenges. He expected his parishioners to follow the same strict standards as the holy club, while they only wanted to attend services. His brother Charles left Georgia due to disappointment with his work, but John persisted despite his lack of success. Subsequently, a dispute arose when Wesley denied communion to a young bride he deemed frivolous, leading to a lawsuit for defamation and his forced departure.
Returning to England, Wesley sought guidance from the Moravians, and Peter Buller became his advisor. Wesley concluded he lacked saving faith and should stop preaching, but Buller encouraged him to continue until he found it. On May 24, 1738, Wesley had a transformative experience at a society in Aldersgate while someone was reading Luther's preface to the Epistle to the Romans. He felt his heart "strangely warmed" and gained assurance of his salvation through faith in Christ.
Following this experience, Wesley focused on the salvation of others. He visited the Moravian community of Herrnhut but decided against becoming a Moravian, finding their spirituality incompatible with his own temperament and social concerns. Meanwhile, George Whitfield, another former member of the holy club, had become a renowned preacher after a similar experience at Aldersgate. Whitefield invited Wesley to assist him in Bristol since he needed to return to Georgia. Despite accepting, Wesley had reservations about Whitfield's open-air preaching methods, initially believing it wrong to save souls outside of church buildings, but eventually reconciled with it.
Wesley was also concerned about the emotional responses to his preaching, with some people weeping and collapsing in anguish before expressing joy and feeling cleansed. Over time, such extreme reactions decreased. Wesley and Whitfield eventually separated due to theological differences regarding predestination and free will. Wesley adopted the Armenian position, differing from Whitfield's Calvinism.
Whitfield, with the Countess of Huntingdon's help, established the Calvinist Methodist Church, mainly in Wales. Wesley, however, intended to remain within the Church of England, aiming to inspire faith among the masses, similar to pietism in German Lutheranism. He avoided scheduling conflicts with Anglican services and viewed Methodist meetings as preparation for Anglican worship and communion, emphasizing communion as the center of worship. Although he had no intention of forming a separate church, the movement required organization.
In Bristol, Wesley's followers formed societies that met in homes and later in their own buildings. As these societies grew, they were divided into classes of 11 members, each with a leader, who met weekly for scripture reading, prayer, discussion, and fundraising. This structure allowed participation from those excluded from the Church of England's structure and gave women a prominent role through female-led classes. As the movement expanded, Wesley traveled extensively, preaching and organizing. Despite opposition from the Bishop of Bristol, who criticized his itinerant preaching, Wesley famously declared, "The world is my parish."
Wesley needed more preachers. He initially opposed lay preaching but, influenced by his mother Susanna, recognized it as God's solution. These lay preachers would not replace the clergy or offer communion but would complement the Church of England's sacramental functions. Among these lay preachers were women, filling roles unavailable in the ordained clergy. Wesley organized his followers into a connection, with societies forming circuits under a superintendent. To manage the connection, he held periodic meetings involving both Anglican clergy and lay preachers, which evolved into the annual conference where circuit assignments were made. Early Methodists faced violence and resentment from clergy and nobility due to the movement's empowerment of lower classes. Opposition eventually lessened.
Wesley reluctantly parted ways with the Moravians due to their quietism. Significant conflicts arose with the Anglican Church, although Wesley wished to remain within it. While some Anglicans saw Methodism as a reflection of their own shortcomings, others resented its disruption of parish boundaries. Wesley felt compelled to reach those the church was not serving. A legal issue added tension. English law required non-Anglican services and buildings to be registered, placing Methodists in a dilemma: registering implied separation from Anglicanism, while not registering was illegal. In 1787, Wesley instructed his preachers to register, marking a step towards separation.
Three years earlier, Wesley had taken a more theologically significant step. Believing bishops and presbyters were the same in the early church, he ordained presbyters, though he hesitated to avoid alienating Anglican leaders. The independence of the United States created new challenges. Most Anglican clergy had been loyalists and returned to England, making it hard for Americans to receive communion. The Bishop of London refused to ordain clergy for the U.S. Wesley, despite opposing the rebellion, believed communion was essential and ordained two lay preachers as presbyters and Thomas Cook as their superintendent in 1784.
He later ordained others for Scotland and elsewhere, while still insisting on avoiding a break with the Church of England. His brother Charles considered ordinations a break already. In 1786, the conference allowed Methodist gatherings to conflict with Anglican services where Anglican churches were inadequate or priests were inept. Despite Wesley's denials, Methodism was becoming a separate church by his death. Methodism's success in England stemmed from addressing needs created by the Industrial Revolution. It reached uprooted populations who had lost connections with the church due to urbanization.
In North America, Methodism thrived among settlers moving westward, who lacked traditional ecclesiastical ties. North American Methodists formed a separate church earlier than their British counterparts. In 1771, Wesley sent Francis Asbury to the colonies, driving Methodism's westward expansion. Despite Wesley's opposition to American independence, American Methodist preachers were largely supportive or neutral. This led to the organization of the Methodist Episcopal Church in the U.S., against Wesley's wishes. The name "Episcopal" resulted from a conflict over titles: Wesley used "superintendent," but Coke and Asbury called themselves "bishops," angering Wesley. American Methodists subsequently adopted bishops, while English Methodists did not. Wesley died in 1791. Afterward, Methodism faced internal struggles regarding Anglicanism, eventually leading to the formation of independent Methodist churches in England and elsewhere.
Colonial Empires and Religious Motivations
Roger Williams advocated for religious freedom in civil states, arguing against enforced uniformity due to its potential for conflict and persecution, even hypocrisy. The 16th century saw the rise of Spanish and Portuguese empires, while the 17th century witnessed the emergence of French and British empires in North America. It's common to contrast the British colonies with Spanish ones, citing religious motives for the British versus gold for the Spanish.
However, economic factors were also major drivers for the British, who lacked access to the same resources as the Spanish, such as treasure and exploitable populations. British investors focused on commerce and agriculture, often using indentured labor rather than free colonists. While religious freedom was more prevalent in some British colonies like Rhode Island and Pennsylvania, others were intolerant. The destruction of indigenous populations in the U.S. was extensive, driven by a desire for land rather than labor, unlike the Spanish.
Religious dissidents sought refuge in the colonies to escape persecution, with some promoting religious tolerance as a matter of both convenience and divine will. Sir Walter Raleigh's attempts to colonize Virginia in the late 16th century failed. Permanent colonization began in 1607 with the founding of Jamestown for economic reasons, although there was a chaplain intending to establish the Church of England. Initially, Puritan principles influenced the colony, but King James opposed Puritanism and took direct control in 1624.
Later, Charles I granted Maryland to a Catholic proprietor. Virginia found economic success in tobacco cultivation, which led to the importation of slaves in 1619. The Puritan Revolution in England did not significantly impact Virginia, as settlers focused on economic prosperity rather than religious conflict. The Church of England adapted to the plantation owners' interests and did little to convert slaves, fearing it could affect their slave status. Laws were passed to ensure baptism did not change a slave's condition.
The adaptation of the church alienated lower classes, who turned to dissident movements or migrated to Maryland. Quakers also gained influence, and later, Methodism. The Carolinas, founded in 1663, attracted dissidents from Virginia due to religious freedom. Their society was similar to Virginia's, with the upper classes belonging to the Church of England and the lower classes becoming Quakers or Baptists. However, many had little contact with any church. Georgia was founded to halt Spanish expansion and serve as an alternative to debtors' prisons.
Although Anglicanism was the official religion, it had little impact, and the Wesleys failed as pastors. The Moravians had some success. The preaching of George Whitefield significantly influenced Georgia's religious life. Methodists and Baptists built upon his work. Puritanism had the greatest impact in New England, where colonies were founded primarily for religious reasons. The Plymouth Plantation was established by separatists who sought to create a community based on their religious principles. In the Mayflower Compact, they agreed to obey just laws enacted by their own government. They settled in Plymouth and survived with the help of the Indians. The Massachusetts Bay Company, composed of non-separatist Puritans, aimed to closely follow New Testament practices. Archbishop Laud's persecution led 10,000 Puritans to flee to New England, strengthening Massachusetts Bay and creating Connecticut and New Haven.
During the English Civil War, the colonies remained neutral. The restoration of the Stuarts and James II's attempts to consolidate the northern colonies caused some disruption, but religious tolerance was granted. The Puritan colonies saw theological controversies, including debates over infant baptism and the need for a conversion experience. Some advocated for believer's baptism, while others supported infant baptism to maintain a Christian commonwealth. The halfway covenant emerged to include those who had been baptized but not converted.
The controversy surrounding the halfway covenant led to animosities and a decline in optimism. There were also debates about the government of churches. Congregational rule was adopted, limited by adherence to a confession of faith enforced by civil authorities. The Salem witch trials in 1692 resulted in the execution of 20 people. The trials sparked by accusations from young girls and fueled by existing superstitions. Eventually, the authorities stopped the investigations, and the courts reversed the decision, deciding it had been injustice and ordered indemnifications to be paid to the families of the victims. Increase Mather and his son Cotton criticized the proceedings but contributed to the atmosphere surrounding the trials. In New England, the Mayhew family worked for the conversion and education of the Indians for five generations. John Eliot gathered converts in villages ruled by Mosaic law, teaching them European methods and translating the Bible into Mohican.
In 1675, King Philip's War broke out, and many converted Indians were killed or enslaved. The intolerance led some to leave the Puritan colonies. Roger Williams, expelled from Massachusetts, founded Providence, Rhode Island, on the principle of religious freedom and separation of church and state. He believed worship should be sincere. Anne Hutchinson founded Portsmouth on similar principles. These communities grew with the influx of Baptists, Quakers, and others. Williams obtained legal recognition for Rhode Island in 1644. He became a Baptist but later denounced all churches. The Baptists in Providence were divided between General Baptists and Particular Baptists. The Baptist movement spread, facing persecution in some colonies. During the Great Awakening, Calvinism surged, boosting Particular Baptists. Maryland became a center for Roman Catholicism, founded by Cecil Calvert, Lord Baltimore, with a policy of religious freedom.
Maryland was governed by Catholic landowners, settlers arrived in 1634, but Protestants formed the majority. Protestants eventually took power, making Anglicanism the official religion and restricting Catholic rights. Pennsylvania also had a significant number of Catholics due to William Penn's policies. The Mid-Atlantic colonies, including New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, and Delaware, did not initially serve as refuges for particular religious groups. Pennsylvania was founded by Quakers, but it had a diverse population. New Jersey had Puritan and Quaker influences. New York was colonized by the Dutch Reformed Church then conquered by the British, and the Church of England was established. By the 18th century, Great Britain expanded its colonies in North America, with religious motivations playing a role in their founding.
Religious freedom gradually increased in the colonies, reflecting Rhode Island and Pennsylvania's examples. However, slavery, inequity, exploitation of Indians, and desires for a holy commonwealth diminished religious fervor.
The Great Awakening
The 18th century brought pietistic movements to North America. Presbyterians were split between those focused on strict adherence to teaching (old side) and those focused on experiencing grace (new side). The Great Awakening, a wave of pietism, further heightened the split.
Many colonists placed significant importance on personal religious experience, which the Great Awakening highlighted. It began in 1734 in Northampton, Massachusetts where Jonathan Edwards, a Calvinist pastor, preached the need for conversion. People responded strongly, and the movement spread throughout the area. Later, George Whitfield visited New England reviving the Awakening with his preaching of conversion. Presbyterian and other ministers participated, and pastors sparked emotional responses, prompting accusations of undermining worship. Movement leaders were typically not emotive but scholars, and they emphasized devotion and studying scripture of which could be seen in Edwards' sermons, which were careful expositions. Edwards and other leaders were orthodox Calvinists. Baptists and Methodists profited most from the movement.
The awakening led many to question infant baptism and convert to Baptists. The Great Awakening also drew Baptists and Methodists to the Western frontier to preach to settlers. This movement also fostered a sense of commonality among the colonies and new ideas about human rights and government. These influences inspired revolutionary events.
Beyond Christendom
The late 18th and early 19th centuries brought political changes, driven by new political ideas and the economic interests of the bourgeoisie. These changes include the independence of the United States, the French Revolution, and the independence of Latin America. These revolutions initiated an era of political and social change. The 19th century also saw geographic expansion of Christianity, similar to that of the 16th century. The expansion resulted in a universal church involving people of all races and nations, but it took place during a period of colonialism and economic imperialism.
At the start of the 19th century, European colonialism appeared to be declining. The independence of the United States and the Napoleonic Wars seemed to threaten European power. However, the opposite occurred, and the Napoleonic Wars focused Britain’s attention on seizing colonies held by its enemies. Britain's naval power allowed it to survive, seize colonies, and gain control of markets. Britain soon possessed former colonies. Also, the industrial revolution spurred colonial expansion, thus needing new markets, and industrial powers found them in Latin America and Asia. Neocolonialism and economic exploitation was created in Latin America. Also, European powers competed for control of markets, and foreign investors focused on agriculture and raw materials. Investments followed, leading to partnerships supporting oligarchical governments.
In Asia, European powers intervened militarily and, took over governments, driven by economic interests, weakness of local governments, and competition. By the 20th century, backlash from nations arose. Japan, China, Korea, and India emerged as political and economic powers. Colonialization sped up in Africa. Raw materials became the goal, thus nations sought to rule empires. Military might, technological advances made conquest possible. A vastly larger economic network connected to the world. Intellectual revolutions also took place where civilizations began to focus on observation and experimentation. Industrial application of the new knowledge was applied to energy production.
Piston steam engines aided transportation and production. Journeys were shortened. Internal combustion engines led to automobilies and the colonization of the Middle East. Aviation shrank the world. Renewable and nuclear power led to debate. The rapid development took others by surprise. Transportation and technology developed quickly. Samuel Morris invented Telegraph. Television become common and computers were used world wide. The world contained access to information, true or false, in libraries. It was the culmination developments. Western civilization saw itself as the reason for happiness.