Economics Chapter 4: Desired Consumption and Savings
Desired Consumption and Saving in a Closed Economy
Foundational Assumptions of the Model:
Closed Economy Assumption: The model assumes an economy with no international trade, eliminating net exports (). Consequently, domestic production is entirely allocated among domestic households, firms, and the government.
Desired vs. Realized Quantities:
: The aggregate expenditure households plan or desire to spend on consumer goods and services.
: The portion of aggregate national income that households and the government desire to save rather than consume.
: The additions to physical capital stock that firms desire to acquire.
Actual (Realized) GDP vs. Desired Expenditure:
National Income Accounting Identity:
This equation is an identity that holds true by definition () when measuring realized economic activity through the expenditure and income approaches.
Desired Expenditure Equation:
This equation represents a market equilibrium condition rather than an identity. It can be untrue when desired plans diverge from realized transactions.
: Consumers may plan to spend a specific amount, but unforeseen liquidity constraints, credit rationing, or shocks cause realized consumption to differ from planned consumption.
: Unplanned inventory accumulation or liquidation occurs when business sales fall short of or exceed projections, causing realized investment () to deviate from desired investment ().
Treatment of Government Spending ():
Government purchases () appear without a desired superscript () because fiscal expenditures are fixed according to budgeted legislative plans; hence, realized equals budgeted .
Household Spending and Savings Decisions:
Three Basic Allocation Choices for Disposable Income:
Spend all income: Consumption equals disposable income, yielding zero savings ().
Spend less than income: Consumption is less than disposable income, yielding positive savings ().
Spend more than income: Consumption exceeds disposable income, yielding negative savings (), financed via debt accumulation or asset liquidation (dissaving).
The Consumption Smoothing Motive:
Forward-looking consumers prefer a relatively stable consumption stream across periods over high volatility.
During high-earning years (e.g., peak working age), individuals accumulate savings to maintain their standard of living during retirement when labor earnings drop sharply.
Determinants of Desired Consumption () and Desired National Saving ():
National saving definition:
Expected Real Interest Rate ():
Mechanism: A higher real interest rate raises the return to saving and increases the opportunity cost of immediate consumption, inducing individuals to substitute future consumption for current consumption.
Current Real Income ():
Mechanism: Because the marginal propensity to consume is less than one (), an increase in aggregate income expands both current consumption and saving. For example, if income rises by \\$100 and consumption expands by \\$80, the residual \\$20 flows into national savings (\Delta S^d = \\$20).
Household Wealth:
Mechanism: An expansion in non-human or human wealth provides greater lifetime resources, enabling higher current consumption without necessitating current saving. Given unchanged and , an increase in directly reduces .
Expected Future Income ():
Mechanism: Anticipation of higher future earnings reduces the necessity to accumulate precautionary or retirement balances today, prompting households to elevate current consumption and reduce current saving.
Fiscal Policy and the Ricardian Equivalence Proposition:
Definition of Fiscal Policy: Government alterations of public expenditures () or tax revenues ().
Ricardian Equivalence (R.E.) Proposition: Rooted in classical economic theory (originating from David Ricardo), R.E. posits that deficit-financed fiscal actions have no real impact on aggregate demand, output (), or national saving ().
Core Assumptions of Ricardian Equivalence:
Perfect Foresight: Taxpayers accurately anticipate the future tax liabilities generated by current government deficits.
Economic Rationality: Consumers fully comprehend the government's intertemporal budget constraint, realizing that a debt-financed tax cut today necessitates an equal present-value tax hike tomorrow.
Scenario 1: Increase in Government Spending without Tax Increases (, ):
The increase in creates a fiscal deficit, reducing government saving ().
Forward-looking consumers anticipate future tax increases to amortize the debt and service interest.
Households depress current consumption () and increase private saving () by an offsetting amount.
Effect on National Saving: In , the expansion in is counterbalanced by the contraction in , resulting in . Deficit financing yields no stimulative impact on aggregate output.
Scenario 2: Tax Cut with Constant Spending (, ):
A reduction in current taxes elevates disposable income, but households recognize the liability of higher future taxes.
Desired consumption remains unaffected ().
All additional disposable income is channeled into private saving (), exactly matching the decline in government saving ().
Effect on National Saving: remains constant ().
Validity in the Real World:
Classical vs. Keynesian Divide: Classical economists utilize R.E. to argue that fiscal fine-tuning is ineffective, whereas Keynesian economists argue that borrowing constraints, short horizons, and myopia cause fiscal interventions to influence real activity.
When R.E. Fails: Consumers face liquidity constraints, lack foresight, or expect that economic growth will generate sufficient tax revenues to eliminate the debt burden without raising tax rates.
Empirical Responses when Ricardian Equivalence is Invalid:
Desired Investment and the Capital Stock
The Investment Concept:
Desired Investment (): The flow of expenditures businesses wish to allocate toward physical capital goods (), such as machinery, factories, and technology equipment, captured within the component of GDP.
Capital Stock Dynamics:
An increase in desired investment raises future capital stock ().
A reduction in investment below the rate of physical depreciation () causes the aggregate capital stock to shrink over time.
Cost-Benefit Analysis of Capital:
Marginal Benefit — Marginal Product of Capital ():
The additional output generated by adding one extra unit of capital, holding labor and other inputs fixed.
Diminishing Returns: As additional units of capital are deployed, each successive unit adds less incremental output than the unit before. Consequently, the curve slopes downward when plotted against the quantity of capital ().
Marginal Cost — User Cost of Capital ():
The total economic cost of using one unit of capital over a specified duration (e.g., one year).
Determinants of :
Price of capital (): Purchase price per physical unit of capital.
Depreciation rate (): The annual fraction of capital lost to physical wear and tear or obsolescence.
Expected real interest rate (): The borrowing cost or opportunity cost of capital funds.
User Cost Formula:
Graphical Characteristic: Because the price of capital, real interest rate, and depreciation rate are fixed parameters for individual competitive firms, is constant across units of , forming a flat, horizontal line on a diagram with capital on the horizontal axis.

Condition for Profit Maximization ():
Firms maximize total profits by investing in capital up to the point where the marginal benefit equals the user cost:
Disequilibrium Adjustments:
If : The marginal cost of capital exceeds its marginal productivity. The firm expands profits by utilizing less capital ().
If : The marginal benefit exceeds the marginal cost. The firm increases profits by acquiring additional capital ().
Optimal Capital (): The unique stock where , leaving zero incentive to adjust the capital base.

Factors Shifting Optimal Capital () and Desired Investment ():
Shifts in the User Cost ():
Driven by changes in , , or .
Example: An increase in raises (), shifting the horizontal cost line upward. The intersection with the downward-sloping curve occurs at a lower capital stock (), which decreases desired investment ().

Shifts in Marginal Productivity ():
Driven by technological innovations, productivity gains, or increases in complementary factors of production.
Example: A technological breakthrough raises the productivity of machinery, shifting the entire curve outward and to the right (). At a constant user cost , the profit-maximizing level of capital increases (), leading to an increase in desired investment ().

Taxes on Capital and Investment:
Taxes levied on firm revenue or corporate income diminish the post-tax return generated per unit of capital.
With an income tax rate , the firm's net marginal product equals .
Tax-Adjusted Profit-Maximizing Condition:
Tax-Adjusted User Cost of Capital ():
Effect of Higher Taxes: .
Numerical Illustration:
Baseline: UC = \\$200, with MPK = UC = \\$200 achieved at .
Tax Implementation ( or ):
UC_{tax} = \frac{\\200}{1 - 0.20} = \frac{\\200}{0.80} = \\$250
The tax elevates the effective user cost to \\$250, contracting optimal capital to and dampening desired investment ().

Goods Market Equilibrium in a Closed Economy
Equilibrium Conditions in Goods Markets:
Expenditure Approach: Equilibrium requires total production (real output ) to equal total desired aggregate expenditure:
Saving-Investment Approach:
Recall that national saving is defined as .
Rearranging the expenditure equilibrium condition yields:
Substituting establishes the equivalent goods market clearing condition:
Both formulations are algebraically equivalent. Rather than contrasting output with demand, the goods market equilibrium can be framed as clearing desired saving against desired investment.
The Graphical Model of the Closed Economy Goods Market:
Variable Assignments:
Vertical Axis: Expected real interest rate (), which functions as the endogenous clearing price.
Horizontal Axis: Quantities of desired national saving () and desired investment ().
Slope of the Curves:
Desired Saving Curve (): Slopes upward because a higher real interest rate incentivizes deferred consumption, increasing national saving ().
Desired Investment Curve (): Slopes downward because a higher real interest rate elevates the user cost of capital, depressing optimal capital and investment spending ().
Market Equilibrium (): The intersection of and identifies the unique goods-market-clearing real interest rate ().

Equilibrium Adjustment Mechanisms:
Excess Supply of Saving ():
When , desired saving exceeds desired investment ().
Savers cannot find sufficient investment borrowers for their funds. To attract borrowers, financial intermediaries bid down real interest rates until drops back to .
Excess Demand for Investment Funds ():
When , desired investment exceeds desired saving ().
Firms demand more investment capital than households are willing to lend. Competition for loanable funds drives interest rates up until rises back to .

Curve Shifts vs. Movements Along Curves:
Movements Along Curves: Variations in the real interest rate () represent movements along both the and curves because is plotted on the vertical axis.
Shifts of the Desired Saving () Curve:
Caused by shifts in current income (), expected future income (), wealth, government purchases (), or taxes () when R.E. fails.
Example: An increase in household wealth stimulates current consumption, shifting the curve leftward from to . At the initial interest rate, investment exceeds saving, bidding the equilibrium real interest rate upward from to (point A to point B).

Shifts of the Desired Investment () Curve:
Caused by technological developments altering , fluctuations in physical capital price (), depreciation rates (), or business taxes ().
Example: A productivity shock boosts the expected , raising and shifting the curve rightward from to . Competition for savings forces the equilibrium real interest rate upward from to (point A to point C).

The Goods Market Equilibrium in an Open Economy
Balance of Payments Accounts:
The balance of payments tracks all economic transactions occurring between a home nation's residents and the rest of the world over a specified time period.
Credits (, Inflow): Any transaction producing an inbound cross-border payment to domestic entities.
Debits (, Outflow): Any transaction producing an outbound payment to foreign entities.

* **Two Primary Accounts:**
* **Current Account ():**
* *Net Exports ():* Records export sales of goods and services (credit, +$) and import purchases (debit, -).\n * *Net Factor Income from Abroad (NFIA):* Records dividends and interest earned on foreign assets owned by domestic residents minus payments disbursed to foreign holders of domestic assets.\n * CA = NX + NFIANFIA = 0CA = NX.)\n * **Financial Account (FA):**\n * Tracks purchases and sales of financial assets (equities, bonds) and direct investments in physical capital (real estate, manufacturing plants).\n * *Acquisition of Foreign Assets:* Recorded as a financial debit (-) because domestic capital exits the country to purchase foreign claims.\n * *Foreign Purchases of Domestic Assets:* Recorded as a financial credit (+$) because foreign funds flow inward.
* **The Balance of Payments Identity:**
*
* Every international trade transaction in the current account is settled via an equal, opposite transaction in the financial account. For instance, if a nation runs a current account surplus of \\$1\text{ million} (NX = \\$1\text{ million}), domestic residents acquire \\$1\text{ million} in claims on foreign assets, creating an offsetting financial account debit (FA = -\\$1\text{ million}).
National Wealth and Net Foreign Assets ():
Components of Aggregate National Wealth:
Domestic physical assets (land, buildings, aggregate capital stock ).
Net Foreign Assets ().
Net Foreign Assets Formula:
The Dynamic Accounting Link:
Goods Market Equilibrium Formulation in an Open Economy:
Equilibrium Output Equation:
Absorption ():
Total desired domestic spending by households, businesses, and government:
Net Exports as the Output-Absorption Gap:
If : Domestic production exceeds domestic absorption. The surplus output is exported (), generating a current account surplus and positive net foreign lending.
If : Domestic spending outstrips domestic output. The economy imports the deficit (), resulting in a current account deficit financed by net foreign borrowing.
Saving-Investment Relationship:
Substituting into saving yields:
Assuming :
In an open economy, national saving does not have to equal domestic investment. The excess of national saving over domestic investment equals net foreign lending ().
Small Open Economy Model:
Core Characteristics:
A small open economy represents a fraction of global markets and cannot influence the World Real Interest Rate ().
The world real interest rate () is exogenous and determined by global capital market equilibrium.
Interest Rate Arbitrage: The domestic real interest rate must converge to the world real interest rate (). If , domestic lenders invest abroad for higher yields; if , domestic borrowers seek international capital at cheaper rates.
Equilibrium with Net Foreign Lending ():
Data: Y = \\$20\text{ billion}, G = \\$4\text{ billion}, . At : C^d = \\$11\text{ billion}, I^d = \\$1\text{ billion}.
National Saving: S^d = Y - C^d - G = 20 - 11 - 4 = \\$5\text{ billion}.
Absorption: C^d + I^d + G = 11 + 1 + 4 = \\$16\text{ billion}.
Net Exports / Foreign Lending: NX = Y - Absorption = 20 - 16 = \\$4\text{ billion}.
Goods Market Clearing: 5\text{ billion} = \\1\text{ billion} + \\$4\text{ billion}. The \\$4\text{ billion} of excess saving is lent in world financial markets.

* **Equilibrium with Net Foreign Borrowing ():**
* *Data:* Y = \\$20\text{ billion}, G = \\$4\text{ billion}, . At : C^d = \\$15\text{ billion}, I^d = \\$5\text{ billion}.
* *National Saving:* S^d = Y - C^d - G = 20 - 15 - 4 = \\$1\text{ billion}.
* *Absorption:* C^d + I^d + G = 15 + 5 + 4 = \\$24\text{ billion}.
* *Net Exports / Foreign Borrowing:* NX = Y - Absorption = 20 - 24 = -\\$4\text{ billion}.
* *Goods Market Clearing:* 1\text{ billion} = \\5\text{ billion} + (-\\$4\text{ billion}). The \\$4\text{ billion} domestic shortfall is borrowed from abroad.
* **Exogenous Shocks in a Small Open Economy:**
* *Adverse Temporary Supply Shock (e.g., Severe Ice Storm):* A temporary disaster reduces output (). Consequently, desired saving decreases (), shifting the schedule leftward. Because is fixed globally and investment demand is unchanged, net foreign lending contracts ().
* *Positive Productivity Shock on Capital ():* A technology gain raises the expected return on physical capital, shifting the curve outward. With and constant, a greater share of national saving finances domestic investment, causing net foreign lending to decline ().
Large Open Economy Model:
Core Concepts:
A large open economy is sufficiently large that its domestic saving and investment choices influence the global real interest rate ().
The global economy is modeled as two interconnected regions: the Home country () and the Foreign country (the rest of the world, ).
Global Equilibrium Condition:
World real interest rate () equates desired international lending by one economy to desired international borrowing by the other:
Market-Clearing Mechanism for Global Interest Rates:
At an arbitrary interest rate of : Home desired lending (S_H^d - I_H^d = 6.5 - 2.5 = \\$4\text{ billion}) exceeds Foreign desired borrowing (I_F^d - S_F^d = 6.0 - 5.0 = \\$1\text{ billion}). This excess supply of world lending bids the global interest rate downward.
At the market-clearing rate of : Home desired lending (S_H^d - I_H^d = 5.5 - 3.5 = \\$2\text{ billion}) exactly matches Foreign desired borrowing (I_F^d - S_F^d = 7.0 - 5.0 = \\$2\text{ billion}). Hence, the equilibrium world real interest rate is .
Step-by-Step Exercise Solutions
Exercise 1: Optimal Capital Stock and Taxes on Business Revenue:
Problem Statement: Consider an economy with marginal product of capital . Price of capital is , expected real interest rate is (), and depreciation rate is ().
(a) Determine the User Cost of Capital ():
(b) Calculate the Desired Capital Stock ():
Set :
(c) Calculate with a Tax Rate on Revenue ():
Set :
(d) Calculate if Decreases to \\$800 with a Tax ():
Set :
Exercise 2: Balance of Payments Classification (Canada):
Part 1: Transaction Categorization:
Canada buys goods from China: Debit (), Current Account (). Outflow of funds to import foreign merchandise.
A Canadian bank receives interest on a loan to Brazil: Credit (+$), Current Account (CANFIA).\n * *Canadian firms sell shares to American investors:* Credit (+$), Financial Account (). Inflow of funds from foreign acquisition of domestic financial assets.
Canadian firms sell lumber to American buyers: Credit (+$), Current Account (CANX).\n * *Canadians receive interest payments on Japanese bonds:* Credit (+$), Current Account (). Inflow of cross-border investment return ().
Part 2: Dual Accounting Settlement:
Transaction: A Canadian firm imports materials from a Japanese firm, and the Japanese firm uses the proceeds to purchase Canadian government bonds.
Canadian Balance of Payments Entry:
Current Account (): Debit () entry under merchandise imports.
Financial Account (): Credit (+$) entry under foreign portfolio investment (sale of domestic government debt).\n * Net Balance: The debit in CAFACA + FA = 0.\n\n* **Exercise 3: Closed Economy Goods Market Equilibrium:**\n * *Given Data:* Full-employment output Y = 900G = 200.\n * *Schedules:*\n * At r = 3\%C^d = 600I^d = 140\n * At r = 4\%C^d = 590I^d = 130\n * At r = 5\%C^d = 580I^d = 120\n * At r = 6\%C^d = 570I^d = 110\n * *Part (a): Find Desired National Saving (S^d = Y - C^d - G = 900 - C^d - 200 = 700 - C^d):*\n * r = 3\% \implies S^d = 700 - 600 = 100\n * r = 4\% \implies S^d = 700 - 590 = 110\n * r = 5\% \implies S^d = 700 - 580 = 120\n * r = 6\% \implies S^d = 700 - 570 = 130\n * *Part (b): Determine Equilibrium Values (r^S^dI^d):*\n * Equilibrium occurs where S^d = I^dr = 5\%S^d = 120I^d = 120.\n * Equilibrium real interest rate: r^ = 5\%.\n * Verification of Output-Expenditure Clearing:\n * Y = C^d + I^d + G = 580 + 120 + 200 = 900.\n * Both S^d = I^dY = C^d + I^d + G hold simultaneously.\n * *Part (c): Equilibrium when Government Purchases Decline to G = 160:*\n * New saving equation: S^d = Y - C^d - G = 900 - C^d - 160 = 740 - C^d.\n * Recalculated saving schedule:\n * r = 3\% \implies S^d = 740 - 600 = 140\n * r = 4\% \implies S^d = 740 - 590 = 150\n * r = 5\% \implies S^d = 740 - 580 = 160\n * r = 6\% \implies S^d = 740 - 570 = 170\n * New market equilibrium occurs at r^* = 3\%S^d = I^d = 140.\n * Output check: Y = C^d + I^d + G = 600 + 140 + 160 = 900.\n\n* **Exercise 4: Small Open Economy Equilibrium Schedule:**\n * *Given Data:* Full-employment output Y = \$25\text{ billion}G = \$6\text{ billion}.\n * *Schedules:*\n * r = 2\%C^d = 15I^d = 6\n * r = 3\%C^d = 14I^d = 5\n * r = 4\%C^d = 13I^d = 4\n * r = 5\%C^d = 12I^d = 3\n * *Calculations (S^d = Y - C^d - G = 25 - C^d - 6 = 19 - C^dS^d - I^dC^d + I^d + GNX = Y - Absorption):*\n * **At r = 2\%:**\n * S^d = 19 - 15 = \$4\text{ billion}\n * \text{Foreign Lending} = 4 - 6 = -\$2\text{ billion}\$2\text{ billion})\n * Absorption = 15 + 6 + 6 = \$27\text{ billion}\n * NX = 25 - 27 = -\$2\text{ billion}\n * **At r = 3\%:**\n * S^d = 19 - 14 = \$5\text{ billion}\n * \text{Foreign Lending} = 5 - 5 = \$0\text{ billion}\n * Absorption = 14 + 5 + 6 = \$25\text{ billion}\n * NX = 25 - 25 = \$0\text{ billion}\n * **At r = 4\%:**\n * S^d = 19 - 13 = \$6\text{ billion}\n * \text{Foreign Lending} = 6 - 4 = \$2\text{ billion}\n * Absorption = 13 + 4 + 6 = \$23\text{ billion}\n * NX = 25 - 23 = \$2\text{ billion}\n * **At r = 5\%:**\n * S^d = 19 - 12 = \$7\text{ billion}\n * \text{Foreign Lending} = 7 - 3 = \$4\text{ billion}\n * Absorption = 12 + 3 + 6 = \$21\text{ billion}\n * NX = 25 - 21 = \$4\text{ billion}\n\n* **Exercise 5: Small Open Economy Qualitative Shifts:**\n * *Baseline:* Initial position has a zero current account balance (CA = NX = 0r_w.\n * *(a) Future Income Rises (\uparrow Y^e):*\n * Anticipating higher future income, households raise current consumption and lower current saving (\uparrow C^d, \downarrow S^dS^d curve leftward.\n * Because the economy is small, the world real interest rate (r_wI^d) unchanged.\n * With lower saving and unchanged domestic investment, national saving falls below domestic investment (S^d < I^dCA < 0).\n * *(b) Business Investment Taxes Increase (\uparrow t):*\n * Higher business taxes elevate the tax-adjusted user cost of capital (\uparrow UC_{tax}\downarrow K^*I^d curve leftward.\n * National saving (S^d) remains unaltered because the tax target is business capital returns rather than household income.\n * Domestic investment contracts (\downarrow I^dS^d > I^dCA > 0).\n\n* **Exercise 6: Large Open Economy Policy Adjustments:**\n * *Baseline:* Symmetrical starting position with global interest rate clearing such that CA_H = CA_F = 0.\n * *(a) Increase in Domestic Willingness to Save (\uparrow S_H^d):*\n * The Home saving curve shifts rightward, creating an excess global supply of loanable funds at the initial world real interest rate.\n * The world real interest rate declines (\downarrow r_w).\n * *Home Country Impacts:* The lower interest rate stimulates domestic investment (\uparrow I_H^dCA_H > 0).\n * *Foreign Country Impacts:* Cheaper borrowing elevates foreign investment (\uparrow I_F^d\downarrow S_F^dCA_F < 0).\n * *(b) Increase in Foreign Willingness to Save (\uparrow S_F^d):*\n * The Foreign saving curve shifts rightward, driving down the world real interest rate (\downarrow r_w).\n * *Domestic (Home) Impacts:* The decline in r_w\uparrow I_H^d\downarrow S_H^d).\n * Because domestic investment now exceeds domestic saving (I_H^d > S_H^dCA_H < 0$$), financed by foreign capital inflows.