INTRO

Part 1 - Introduction and Theory

This is the material from your Introduction that you should actually understand well enough to explain aloud, including the main papers and the logic leading to each hypothesis. I would learn the argument, not the wording of your dissertation.


1. The whole Introduction as one chain

Your Introduction essentially makes this argument:

Psychopathy is multidimensional
↓
GM, CU and II involve different emotional, motivational and behavioural characteristics
↓
These traits are developmentally relevant during adolescence
↓
Videogaming is common and provides an engaging context in which these characteristics may be expressed
↓
Responses to violent gaming differ between individuals
↓
FAA provides a neurophysiological measure related to emotional and motivational functioning
↓
FAA itself is context-sensitive and may differ according to frontal location
↓
Existing psychopathy-FAA findings are mixed and appear to depend on trait dimension + task context
↓
Almost no work has examined FAA during active gameplay
↓
Nobody had directly examined GM, CU and II against FAA during active violent videogame play in adolescents
↓
Your study addresses that gap.

If you're ever asked:

"How did you arrive at your research question?"

that's basically your answer.


2. Psychopathy

Definition

Psychopathy is a multidimensional personality construct involving interrelated:

interpersonal + affective + behavioural traits.

Your dissertation uses the three-factor model. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

GM - Grandiose-Manipulative

Interpersonal dimension

Characterised by:

  • dominance

  • manipulation

  • superficial charm.

CU - Callous-Unemotional

Affective dimension

Characterised by:

  • reduced empathy

  • shallow affect

  • diminished guilt.

II - Impulsive-Irresponsible

Behavioural dimension

Characterised by:

  • impulsivity

  • sensation seeking

  • poor behavioural control. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Easy memory:

GM = how you deal with OTHER PEOPLE
CU = how you FEEL
II = how you BEHAVE


3. Why use a multidimensional model?

This is an important potential question.

"Why didn't you just examine total psychopathy?"

Because treating psychopathy as one total construct could obscure dimension-specific neurophysiological associations.

GM, CU and II involve different emotional, motivational and behavioural characteristics, so there is theoretical reason to expect them to show different FAA patterns.

And your results ultimately supported the value of this decision:

II was associated with FAA while GM and CU were not.

Even within II, the lower-order traits differed, with Irresponsibility particularly implicated.

So your study demonstrates exactly why analysing psychopathy as a multidimensional construct can be informative.


4. Why adolescents?

There are several layers to this answer.

Adolescence is a period of development

Your dissertation describes adolescence as a period of:

heightened neural plasticity + cognitive development + socio-emotional development. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Psychopathic traits aren't necessarily fixed

They can:

decrease, remain stable or increase across development.

Importantly, your dissertation reports that:

GM → relatively malleable

CU → more stable

II → moderately stable. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

So adolescent psychopathic traits should not automatically be treated as permanent adult characteristics.

Nature AND environment

Psychopathic traits are substantially influenced by genetics, but their expression can also be shaped by environmental experiences. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why are elevated traits still important?

Because persistently elevated traits are associated with adverse:

psychosocial + antisocial outcomes. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Good viva answer

"Adolescence is particularly relevant because psychopathic traits are already observable but remain developmentally variable. GM appears relatively malleable, CU more stable and II moderately stable, so studying adolescents allows us to investigate neurophysiological correlates without assuming that these traits are fixed or inevitably progress to adult psychopathy."


5. Why videogaming?

Your argument is not that videogaming is inherently harmful.

That's important.

Videogaming is highly prevalent during adolescence. Your dissertation reports:

34% of adolescents aged 11-15 reported daily online gaming. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Gaming can have positive functions, including:

relaxation + social connection.

And poorer outcomes appear to be more strongly associated with problematic gaming symptoms than simply:

frequency or duration of gaming. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

So avoid saying:

"Gaming is bad for adolescents."

Your argument is instead:

Gaming is common, engaging and behaviourally meaningful, making it useful as an experimental context.


6. Why FPS games?

FPS = First-Person Shooter.

Your dissertation defines them as involving:

weapon-based combat from the player's perspective.

They provide a:

competitive + rewarding environment relevant to emotional and motivational functioning. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

That becomes particularly useful for FAA because gameplay involves motivational demands such as:

goal pursuit + rapid responding.


7. Why violent videogaming specifically?

Your argument is fairly cautious here.

Violent videogaming may be relevant to psychopathic traits because it provides an:

immersive + goal-directed context. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

But the literature is mixed.

This is important because an examiner could challenge you with:

"Isn't violent gaming associated with aggression?"

Your answer should be:

The evidence is not that straightforward.


8. Jahic et al. (2021)

Who?

Justice-involved adolescents.

Finding

Violent videogame play was associated with traits including:

manipulation + remorselessness. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why did you include it?

Because it provides evidence that violent gaming may relate to characteristics overlapping with psychopathic traits.

But don't overinterpret it

It does not establish that violent games cause psychopathic traits.

Your own study is also not testing whether violent games cause psychopathy.


9. Przybylski & Weinstein (2019)

This is an important counterbalance.

Study

Large preregistered study of adolescents aged 14-15.

Finding

No association between:

violent gaming and aggression. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why is this useful?

It shows that the violent gaming literature is mixed, preventing you from constructing an overly simplistic:

violent gaming → aggression

argument.


10. Borrego-Ruiz & Borrego (2025)

Your dissertation uses this review to show that associations have been reported between violent gaming and:

desensitisation

reduced empathy

lower prosocial behaviour

moral disengagement

BUT:

findings are mixed. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

That's the key thing to remember rather than every outcome.


11. Rashwan et al. (2026)

This one is useful because it introduces individual differences/problematic gaming.

Problematic gamers

Reported greater:

emotional blunting + aggression + desensitisation.

Non-problematic gamers

Violent gaming was associated with:

emotional blunting through desensitisation

but not directly with aggression. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why does this matter to YOUR study?

It suggests responses to violent gaming are not uniform.

Characteristics of the individual may matter.

And that gives you the transition:

Perhaps individual differences in psychopathic traits are associated with different neurophysiological responses during gaming.

That's where FAA enters your argument.


12. What exactly is FAA?

Frontal alpha asymmetry (FAA) reflects the relative difference in alpha power between the left and right frontal cortices. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Alpha

Your study uses:

8-13 Hz.

But the most important conceptual fact is:

Alpha power is inversely related to cortical activity.

Therefore:

↑ alpha power = ↓ underlying cortical activity

↓ alpha power = ↑ underlying cortical activity. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

You need to know this cold because everything else depends on it.


13. FAA direction - DON'T GET CAUGHT OUT

For your primary F4/F3 measure:

FAA = ln(F4 alpha) - ln(F3 alpha)

F4 = right.

F3 = left.

Therefore:

Higher/positive FAA

More alpha on the right relative to left

→ less right cortical activity

→ relatively greater left-frontal activity.

Lower/negative FAA

More alpha on the left relative to right

→ less left cortical activity

→ relatively greater right-frontal activity.

Memorise this exact chain

RIGHT ALPHA = LEFT ACTIVITY.

and

LEFT ALPHA = RIGHT ACTIVITY.

If someone asks:

"Your participants with higher II had lower FAA. What does that actually mean physiologically?"

Answer:

"It reflects relatively greater left-frontal alpha power and, because alpha power is inversely related to cortical activity, relatively greater right-frontal cortical activity."


14. Why F4/F3 and F8/F7?

FAA can be measured at different frontal locations.

Your dissertation distinguishes:

F4/F3 → mid-frontal

F8/F7 → lateral-frontal. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why examine both?

Because FAA associations can vary across frontal regions.

Your Introduction gives several examples.

Dharmadhikari et al. (2019) and Lopez-Duran et al. (2012)

Depression-related differences during emotional tasks appeared at:

F8/F7

but not:

F4/F3.

Thibodeau et al. (2006)

Resting effects have been reported as stronger at:

F4/F3.

Monni et al. (2022)

Some personality associations appeared only at:

F8/F7. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

So why was F4/F3 primary?

Your literature supported F4/F3 as an established mid-frontal FAA measure, while the evidence that effects can differ regionally justified adding F8/F7 exploratorily.

A safe answer is:

"F4/F3 was the primary electrode pair, while F8/F7 was examined exploratorily because previous evidence suggests FAA associations can vary across mid- and lateral-frontal regions."


15. Davidson's Approach-Withdrawal model

This is your principal theoretical framework.

The important idea is:

Frontal asymmetry reflects motivational direction rather than simply emotional valence. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

That distinction matters.

Relatively greater LEFT-frontal activity

Associated with approach processes, including:

reward seeking + behavioural engagement.

Relatively greater RIGHT-frontal activity

Associated with withdrawal processes, including:

avoidance + behavioural inhibition. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Therefore:

higher FAA → relatively greater left activity → approach

lower FAA → relatively greater right activity → withdrawal


16. Motivation ≠ emotional valence

This is a really good conceptual question.

An examiner might ask:

"Is left frontal activity just positive emotion and right frontal activity negative emotion?"

No.

The Approach-Withdrawal model concerns motivational direction, not simply whether an emotion is pleasant or unpleasant.

A negatively valenced emotion can still involve approach motivation.

For example, anger can motivate someone to move towards/confront something rather than withdraw.

So:

positive ≠ automatically approach

negative ≠ automatically withdrawal.

That distinction is fundamental to FAA theory.


17. Reinforcement Sensitivity Theory

FAA has also been interpreted through Gray's Reinforcement Sensitivity Theory.

Your Introduction links:

BAS

Behavioural Activation System

with relatively greater:

left-frontal activity

and approach/reward processes.

BIS

Behavioural Inhibition System

with relatively greater:

right-frontal activity

and inhibition-related processes. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

But your dissertation still identifies Approach-Withdrawal as the principal framework for interpreting FAA. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

The more nuanced revised RST/conflict interpretation becomes especially important later in your Discussion after you obtain the opposite-to-predicted II result.


18. Resting FAA vs task-based FAA

Another very likely question:

"Why didn't you just use resting FAA?"

Resting FAA

Measures asymmetry while the participant is at rest.

It may capture more trait-like tendencies, but it might not reveal how frontal asymmetry changes or manifests during a particular emotional/motivational context.

Your dissertation notes that inconsistent findings may partly reflect reliance on resting FAA, which may fail to capture context-dependent processes. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Task-based FAA

Measures asymmetry during an activity.

This can provide a more ecologically relevant index of affective functioning because the person is actively responding to something. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why was that particularly useful here?

You weren't just interested in:

"What is this adolescent's FAA generally?"

You wanted:

"How are psychopathic traits associated with FAA while the adolescent is actively engaged in violent gameplay?"


19. Why FAA might relate to psychopathic traits

Now the two halves of the Introduction come together.

Psychopathic traits involve different patterns of:

emotion + motivation + behaviour.

FAA has been associated with:

emotional + motivational functioning.

Therefore:

Different psychopathic trait dimensions may have different FAA correlates.

But the existing literature is inconsistent.

And that's exactly what the next group of studies shows.


20. Batky et al. (2020) - KNOW THIS ONE

Participants

52 justice-involved adolescent males

aged:

13-18.

Conditions

FAA examined during:

rest + emotional processing.

Traits:

CU + GM + Daring-Impulsive (DI).

Broad finding

Psychopathic traits were not associated with:

resting-state or overall task-based FAA.

BUT there was an important CU finding.

Higher CU was associated with:

relatively higher FAA / greater RFAP across most conditions

BUT when participants were instructed to increase their emotional response:

higher CU → lower FAA / greater LFAP, resembling low-CU adolescents. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why is that important?

Because the association changed according to task demands.

That supports the idea that:

psychopathy-FAA relationships may be context-dependent.


21. Bontemps et al. (2022) - KNOW THIS ONE TOO

Participants

39 incarcerated male adolescents

mean age:

15.79 years.

Task

Self-referential processing.

Conventional scalp FAA

No significant associations between psychopathic traits and conventional FAA.

BUT source localisation found dimension-specific patterns

GM → predominantly greater RFAP

CU → more bilateral alpha with some right lateralisation

DI → predominantly greater LFAP. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why is this important?

Two reasons:

1. Dimension specificity

GM, CU and DI did not show identical neural patterns.

2. Measurement matters

Conventional scalp FAA showed nothing, while source localisation revealed patterns.

Therefore, a null scalp FAA result does not necessarily mean there is no underlying frontal difference.


22. Rybak et al. (2006)

This wasn't directly a psychopathy study.

Participants

65 males aged 5-17

with:

impulsive aggression + co-occurring psychiatric disorders.

Finding

Predominantly:

greater RFAP

associated with greater:

symptom severity + clinical impairment. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why include it?

Because adolescent psychopathy-FAA evidence is limited, so related characteristics such as impulsivity/aggression can provide additional information.

Important criticism

Aggression ≠ psychopathy.

And the participants had co-occurring psychiatric disorders.

Therefore, you cannot directly generalise the findings to adolescents with psychopathic traits.

Your dissertation explicitly acknowledges this. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION


23. Keune et al. (2017)

Now we move to adult evidence because adolescent research is sparse.

Population

Imprisoned adult males.

Finding

At rest:

higher CU → greater LFAP

while:

aggression was unrelated to FAA. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Remember:

greater LFAP → relatively greater right-frontal cortical activity → lower FAA.

This evidence helped inform your CU hypothesis.


24. Hjelle et al. (2024)

Population

Young adults.

Rest

No psychopathy-FAA association.

Empathy task

Psychopathy was associated with:

greater RFAP.

The authors interpreted this as potentially reflecting:

reduced responsiveness to others' suffering. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why important?

Again:

rest ≠ task.

A relationship appeared during an emotionally relevant task that wasn't evident at rest.

That strengthens your argument for task-based FAA.


25. Neal & Gable (2016)

This is particularly relevant to your II dimension.

They examined impulsivity facets.

The key result:

Different impulsivity facets showed different FAA patterns.

Most were associated with:

greater RFAP

while:

sensation seeking → greater LFAP. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why important?

II itself contains different characteristics.

So you shouldn't necessarily expect all aspects of II to share one FAA correlate.

This becomes extremely relevant when your own post-hoc analysis later finds:

Irresponsibility significant

but:

Thrill-Seeking and Impulsiveness non-significant.


26. Overall conclusion from psychopathy-FAA literature

Don't memorise every study independently without understanding the synthesis.

Your conclusion was essentially:

Psychopathy-related FAA appears to vary according to trait dimension and emotional/task context, and effects may be more apparent during tasks than at rest. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

That's why your study examines:

dimensions separately + active task-based FAA.


27. FAA during videogaming

There was very little adolescent research directly relevant to your question.

Adult gaming studies had linked gameplay FAA with:

motivation + arousal + individual differences. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Violent videogames are theoretically interesting because they can involve:

Approach-related demands

goal pursuit + rapid responding

BUT may also elicit:

Withdrawal-related responses

depending on the person's emotional engagement. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

So you shouldn't assume CS2 is a purely "approach" task for everybody.

That's actually quite important given your eventual findings.


28. Machnev et al. (2025)

Participants

Adolescent gamers.

Mean age:

15.02 years.

FAA

Resting FAA.

Main finding

No significant relationships between resting FAA and executive-function measures.

Exploratory finding

Greater LFAP → poorer behavioural regulation. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

This becomes particularly interesting in light of your results because:

your higher-II/Irresponsibility adolescents also showed greater relative LFAP/lower FAA.

But remember:

Machnev measured resting FAA, whereas you measured FAA during gameplay.

So it's supporting context, not direct replication.


29. Lianekhammy & Werner-Wilson (2015)

This is particularly relevant because they actually measured adolescents during gameplay.

Participants

Aged:

13-17.

Finding 1

Greater empathy was associated with:

greater LFAP during violent gaming.

Finding 2

The violent-game group showed:

greater LFAP than the other gaming conditions. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Why important?

It suggests gameplay FAA may depend on:

individual characteristics

AND potentially:

game content.

Again, that supports your rationale for examining individual differences in psychopathic traits.


30. Now the GAP

You need to be able to state this immediately.

Existing evidence showed:

Psychopathic traits ↔ FAA

and

Videogaming ↔ FAA

and

Psychopathic traits ↔ aspects of violent videogaming

BUT:

The relationship between distinct psychopathic trait dimensions and FAA during active violent videogame play in adolescents had not been directly examined. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

That's your research gap.


31. Your aim

To examine whether GM, CU and II traits were differentially associated with F4/F3 FAA measured continuously during violent videogame play. FINAL PSYCHOPATHIC DISSERTATION

Then:

significant associations → post-hoc lower-order traits

and:

F8/F7 → exploratory analysis because FAA may vary across frontal regions.


32. WHY did you predict each direction?

This is much more important than simply knowing H1-H3.

H1 - GM → higher FAA

Higher GM was predicted to relate to:

greater RFAP → higher FAA → relatively greater left-frontal activity → approach-related processing.

The rationale comes from GM characteristics and previous evidence suggesting GM-related right alpha/lateralisation patterns, including Bontemps.

So conceptually:

GM → interpersonal dominance/manipulation → approach-oriented characteristics → higher FAA.


H2 - CU → lower FAA

Higher CU was predicted to relate to:

greater LFAP → lower FAA → relatively greater right-frontal activity.

Why?

Previous CU evidence was mixed/context-dependent, but adult resting work such as Keune et al. (2017) linked higher CU with greater LFAP.

So your hypothesis predicted a lower-FAA/right-activity pattern.


H3 - II → higher FAA

Higher II was predicted to relate to:

greater RFAP → higher FAA → relatively greater left-frontal activity → approach-related processing.

Conceptually, II includes:

impulsivity + sensation seeking + poor behavioural control

which can involve reward-driven/approach tendencies.

Related evidence, including Rybak et al. (2006), found greater RFAP in young males with impulsive aggression.

So you expected II to show an approach-related higher FAA pattern.

And what happened?

Exactly the opposite.

Higher II → significantly LOWER FAA.

That contradiction becomes the central question of your Discussion.


33. A subtle point about your hypotheses

If challenged with:

"But the previous literature was mixed. Why make directional hypotheses?"

Don't pretend the evidence was perfectly consistent.

A good defence is:

"The literature was mixed, particularly across tasks and populations, but there was sufficient theoretical and empirical evidence to make directional predictions. The Approach-Withdrawal framework provided the primary theoretical basis, supplemented by previous dimension-specific findings. The inconsistency in previous work was also one reason task context was important to investigate."

That's stronger than claiming your hypotheses were obvious.


34. What you should NOT claim

These distinctions are important.

Your dissertation does NOT show:

❌ violent games cause psychopathy
❌ psychopathic traits cause people to play violent games
❌ violent games cause aggression
❌ FAA diagnoses psychopathy
❌ right-frontal activity always means withdrawal
❌ adolescents with high psychopathic traits will become adult psychopaths
❌ II is the same thing as impulsivity
❌ Irresponsibility definitely reflects regulatory conflict
❌ task FAA is inherently "better" than resting FAA.

Instead:

Your study tests an association between individual differences in psychopathic traits and FAA during one specific active context.


35. Studies you REALLY need to know

You don't need to memorise every citation in your Introduction equally.

Tier 1 - know properly

Davidson (1992, 1998)
→ Approach-Withdrawal theory.

Batky et al. (2020)
→ adolescent psychopathy + FAA; CU pattern changed with emotional condition.

Bontemps et al. (2022)
→ adolescent psychopathy; conventional FAA null but source localisation dimension-specific.

Keune et al. (2017)
→ adult CU → greater LFAP at rest.

Neal & Gable (2016)
→ different impulsivity facets → different FAA patterns.

Machnev et al. (2025)
→ adolescent gamers; resting FAA largely null; exploratory greater LFAP linked with poorer behavioural regulation.

Lianekhammy & Werner-Wilson (2015)
→ adolescent gameplay FAA; empathy and violent gaming associated with greater LFAP.

Tier 2 - know the point

Rybak et al. (2006) → impulsive aggression, greater RFAP.

Hjelle et al. (2024) → rest null, task association.

Thibodeau et al. (2006) → regional FAA evidence/F4/F3.

Monni et al. (2022) → some personality associations differ by frontal location.

Przybylski & Weinstein (2019) → large preregistered adolescent study found no violent gaming-aggression association.

Jahic et al. (2021) → violent gaming associated with manipulation/remorselessness in justice-involved adolescents.

Rashwan et al. (2026) → outcomes differed according to problematic gaming status.

For the others, knowing why you cited them matters more than memorising sample sizes.


36. Potential examiner questions from Part 1

These are the ones I'd expect you to answer without notes:

  1. What are GM, CU and II, and why did you examine them separately?

  2. Why study psychopathic traits during adolescence?

  3. Why use the term "psychopathic traits" rather than classify adolescents as psychopaths?

  4. Why use videogaming as your task?

  5. Why specifically violent videogaming/CS2?

  6. Does the evidence show that violent gaming causes aggression?

  7. What is FAA?

  8. Why is alpha power interpreted inversely to cortical activity?

  9. What does higher FAA mean?

  10. What does lower FAA mean?

  11. Explain the Approach-Withdrawal model.

  12. Why isn't approach simply positive emotion and withdrawal negative emotion?

  13. How does RST relate to FAA?

  14. Why use task-based rather than resting FAA?

  15. Why F4/F3?

  16. Why did you additionally examine F8/F7?

  17. What did Batky et al. find?

  18. What did Bontemps et al. find?

  19. Why is Rybak not direct evidence for psychopathy?

  20. What does Keune tell us about CU?

  21. Why is Neal & Gable relevant to II?

  22. What previous research exists on FAA during adolescent gaming?

  23. What exactly was the gap in the literature?

  24. What was your primary aim?

  25. Why did you predict higher FAA for GM?

  26. Why did you predict lower FAA for CU?

  27. Why did you predict higher FAA for II?

  28. Given the mixed literature, why did you use directional hypotheses?

  29. What would higher right-frontal alpha power actually imply about cortical activity?

  30. Could your study tell us whether any FAA effect is specific to violent content?