MAOR214: Land and Water 1

Week Four Lecture Notes: Land and Water in Māori Thought

Introduction

  • Main Topic: The week focuses on the significance of land and water in Māori culture, including historical perspectives and contemporary implications.

  • Concepts of Ownership: Discussion will include reflections on ownership and relationships shaped by different world views.

Overview of Key Concepts

  • Kaupapa: Refers to the broader concepts of land and water.

  • Relationships and Worldviews: How human relationships with the environment (land and water) vary across different cultural frameworks:

    • Christian Perspective: Humanity's relationship with God establishes a hierarchy.

    • Scientific Perspective: Denies the existence of a divine being.

    • Māori Perspective: Humans descend from gods, embodying a divine essence, known as iiratua.

Exploring Taxonomies and Hierarchies

  • Hierarchies between genders, particularly in Christian thought versus Māori thought:

    • Christian Thought: Male superiority reminiscent of the relationship between God and humans.

    • Scientific Views: Similar echoes of gender hierarchy noted in the works of Darwin and Aristotle regarding women.

    • Māori Thought: The first human, Hine Ahu One, is portrayed as female, highlighting gender balance and complementarity.'

      • Also provides direct relationship with the environment

Human-Natural World Relationship

  • Existential Threats: Discussion on climate change as a significant concern of present generations, compared to past fears like nuclear war.

    • Examine how worldviews have brought us here

  • Potential Solutions: Exploring how Māori thought may offer alternatives to contemporary issues.

Core Concepts in Māori Thought

  • Mauri: A living essence that exists in all entities.

    • Analogy with Star Wars: Compared to The Force.

    • All entities (animals, plants, rocks, etc.) possess unique mauri.

      • Things Western thought consider inanimate

      • e.g. Mauri stone

    • Mauri is dynamic; it can be enhanced or diminished through practices:

    • Enhancement: Practices aimed at preserving or enhancing mauri.

    • Diminishment: External factors that can reduce mauri.

  • Mana: Reflects authority and personal or collective power.

    • Two types of mana:

    • Intrinsic Mana: Inherent power inherited from creation, consistent throughout a person’s lineage.

    • Extrinsic Mana: Depends on one’s actions and can be earned or lost through behavior.

    • All entities (human and non-human) possess intrinsic mana.

    • Can be diminished through things like acting out of line with values

Whakapapa and Relationships

  • Whakapapa: The genealogy or lineage connecting humans to the environment, emphasizing familial relationships.

  • Papatuanuku: Represents the Earth, with no hierarchical view over humanity, which contrasts sharply with many Western ideologies.

    • Personification of land#

      • Literal relationship with land

  • Language Insight: The word whenua refers to both land and placenta, demonstrating deep interconnectedness and nurturing relationships between humans and the land.

    • Nourishment

Land and Water Discussions

  • Papatuanuku and Ranginui: Co-primal parents of everything, reinforcing the connection between humanity and the natural world.

    • Whakapapa creates direct links to the environment.

      • Matches the theory of evolution

        • However, entities like mountains are not considered to be alive

          • Nazi thinking also drew from Darwin’s thinking (eugenics)

            • (British invented concentration camps)

              • (Also forced sterilisation of indigenous peoples)

    • Their children often embody aspects of the environment

      • By humanity descending from them, it relates the environment to them

    • Wai was created through their gried at their separation

  • Depictions in Māori cosmology:

    • The first human creation is from the Earth, emphasizing humanity’s intrinsic ties to the environment.

  • Discussions on artworks and cultural symbolism (such as Robin Kahuke’s Whakapapa of Water).

    • Represents creation and interdependence of elements.

Water’s Role in Māori Thought

  • Tangaroa: Personifies the ocean, his offspring depict significant water origins.

    • Connection between land and water is evident in genealogies.

    • Different types of water has its own whakapapa (Parawhenuamea)

  • Spiritual Significance of Water:

    • Linked to individual and communal identity, well-being, and spirituality.

    • Bodies of water are seen as living entities with their own mauri, mana, and autonomy.

    • Tears of Rangi and Papa

    • Each body of water has its own identity

Tapu and Noa
  • Water is crucial for rituals and balancing tapu (sacred) and noa (ordinary).

    • Mitigating between the two was fundamental to Maori society

  • Seen as a medium for purification and spiritual transition.

Obligations and Guardianship

  • Kaitiaki: Concept of guardianship extends to both humans and nature, emphasizing reciprocity in care for the environment.

  • Environmental practices include prohibitions against waste disposal into water bodies.

  • Distinctions between what is considered pollution versus natural interference.

  • Belief water is an indicator of, not only the well-being of the water, but the surrounding area

  • Taniwha are kaitiaki

    • Decentres humans

Contemporary Context and Issues

  • Discussion of modern challenges related to land and water, including water rights and environmental laws in New Zealand.

    • Reflections on the Waitangi Tribunal and its stance on water as a taonga (treasure).

    • Tikanga also changes and adapts to change

  • Global perspective on environmental exploitation contrasts with Māori values regarding communal and environmental responsibility.

Ethical and Philosophical Implications

  • Māori worldview questions the assumption of ownership and domination over nature, suggesting instead a relationship of respect and stewardship.

  • The concept of water as a measure of well-being that is interconnected with the health of wildlife and ecosystems.

Linguistic Connections

  • Examination of Māori terms for different types of water, each with implications:

    • Wai: Water in general.

    • Wai Māori: Freshwater. (does not emerge in traditions initially)

    • Wai Keno: Polluted water.

    • Wai Tai: Saltwater.

    • Wai Araki: Therapeutic or curative waters, highlighting their value.

  • Places are often named in relation to their water e.g. Waikato, Aoraki, Waimakariri

Mihi and Pepeha

  • Mihi and Pepeha: Introductions that establish identity through relationships to land and water, indicating how integral the natural world is to Māori identity.

    • Structure and order: Land and water first, before identifying human relationships.

  • Rather than stating the mountain you own, it is the mountain you belong to

Environmental Disaster

  • Flooding

    • In cases like the Nile, flooding is essential for the land and farmers

      • However, flooding in places where they have not historically suggests it is negative and man-made

        • Could be interpreted as being punished by the land

          • ‘Natural consequences’

          • Similar to Biblical traditions

Wrapping Up

  • Emphasis on how these discussions about land and water in Māori thought offer alternative frameworks for understanding environmental interactions.

  • Preview of future lectures that will build on these themes.

  • In Maori thought, you cannot own land and water

    • Selling is unheard of because you have a relationship with the land

Final Thoughts

  • Considerations on the nature of existence, interconnectedness, and the pools of knowledge that extend not only in theoretical discussions but also through direct relationships with the land and water.