AMSCO 7.1

Shifting Power: Context and Implications

Historical Context

  • Quote by Russian Tsar Nicholas II (1905): "I shall never, under any circumstances, agree to a representative form of government because I consider it harmful to the people whom God has entrusted to my care."

Essential Question

  • How did internal and external factors contribute to change in various states after 1900?

Overview of Rebellion and Revolution (Early 1900s)

  • Intense rebellion continued into the early 1900s.
  • Nicholas II failed to grasp political opposition, leading to his assassination in 1918.
  • Significant rebellions in Russia, China, and Mexico undermined long-standing authoritarian regimes.
  • Revolutionaries challenged political and social orders, establishing new political philosophies.
  • Established land-based and maritime empires faced collapse due to internal and external pressures.
  • A new global order emerged by the century's end.

Revolution in Russia

State of Russia (Early 20th Century)

  • Russia lagged behind Europe, the United States, and Japan in wealth and military power.
Internal Challenges
  • Lack of promotion of economic growth and modernization:
    • Insufficient expansion of education for peasants.
    • Inadequate infrastructure development (roads, transportation networks).
    • Limited financial support for entrepreneurs.
  • Tsarist government resisted political reform, civil liberties, and broader participation in governance.
External Challenges
  • Weak economic base resulting in military weaknesses:
    • Crimean War (1853-1856): Russia lost to the Ottoman Empire, supported by Great Britain and France.
    • Russo-Japanese War (1904-1905): Russia's defeat marked the first time a non-Western power defeated a European state in modern history.

Key Events Leading to Russian Revolution

  • Bloody Sunday (January 22, 1905): Peaceful protest by thousands for better working conditions led to over 1,300 protestors being killed by imperial troops.
  • Revolution of 1905: Responding to Bloody Sunday, 400,000 workers held strikes. Tsar attempted to appease protesters but faced significant violence.
  • World War I (1914): Poorly trained and equipped Russian troops faced disastrous hardships, leading to extreme food shortages among civilians.
  • Bolsheviks' Rise: In the fall of 1917, led by Vladimir Lenin, seized power, establishing a communist government, aiming for worker ownership and collective prosperity.

Upheaval in China

Collapse of the Qing Dynasty

  • Qing Dynasty struggled against internal and external pressures, leading to its overthrow in 1911.
Internal Challenges
  1. Ethnic Tensions: Dominance of the Han Chinese over Manchu rulers, leading to widespread resentment toward Qing legitimacy.
  2. Famine Threats: Rapid population growth outstripped food supply; natural disasters exacerbated food insecurity.
  3. Low Government Revenue: Outdated tax systems prevented effective governance and maintenance of public infrastructure.
External Challenges
  • European industrialization threatened China's economic stability; European trade controlled by limited Canton city trading.
  • Traditional disdain for European products during this period.

Establishment of the Chinese Republic

  • Dr. Sun Yat-sen: Key figure in overthrowing the Qing, leading the new republic focusing on Confucian principles mixed with modern governance.
Sun Yat-sen's Principles (The Three People's Principles)
  1. Democracy: Advocated for governance by knowledgeable experts, restricting sovereignty to those deemed capable.
  2. Nationalism: Emphasized loyalty and patriotism toward central authority.
  3. Livelihood: Aimed to address wealth distribution disparities and economic exploitation.

Sun Yat-sen's Legacy

  • Limited military power led to power struggles with warlords; the Kuomintang later assumed power but struggled to execute Sun’s principles fully.

The Ottoman Empire's Decline

Collapse and Transformation

  • The Ottoman Empire, termed "the sick man of Europe," faced economic decline and loss of agricultural strength.
  • Reliance on trade without strong exports marked their weakness.
The Young Turks Movement
  • Emerged due to economic hardships, advocating for constitutional reform and Turkification.
  • Turkification aimed to unify the multiethnic citizenry under Turkish Identity, causing tension with Armenians.
Response to Foreign Influence
  • Resentment toward European economic domination led to a secret alliance with Germany during WWI.
  • Post-war dismantling of the Ottoman Empire, leading to the creation of new nation-states, including Turkey.

Rise of Atatürk

  • Mustafa Kemal: Leader of the Turkish National Movement; defeated occupying Allied forces and established the Republic of Turkey in 1923.
  • Atatürk focused on westernization and secular reforms:
    • Public education for both genders.
    • Abolishment of polygyny.
    • Expanded women's suffrage.
    • Promoted Western attire and cultural practices.
  • Ruled as a dictator until death in 1938 but aimed to modernize Turkey along Western lines.

Power Shifts in Mexico

Political Landscape at the Turn of the Century

  • Mexico, under dictator Porfirio Díaz, experienced stability with significant inequalities favoring foreign investors.
The Mexican Revolution (1910-1920)
  • Francisco Madero: Opposition candidate jailed by Díaz, led the revolution after escaping to form an alliance.
  • Key figures included Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata, who advocated for land redistribution.
  • Political turmoil led to approximately 2 million deaths and prolonged instability.
Major Outcomes of the Revolution
  • Constitution of 1917: Instituted principles of land redistribution, universal suffrage, and public education.
  • Formation of Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) in 1929: Dominated Mexican politics until 2000 despite allegations of corruption.