Lecture 8: Language and Reading I
Course Information - Weeks 8, 9, + 10
Lectures:
No face-to-face lectures for 2 weeks.
Pre-recorded videos, broken into shorter chunks.
Week 10: In-person.
Tutorials:
Week 8: As normal.
Week 9+10: Online self-directed tutorial.
Assumption that students have completed it.
Marks released at the time of recording:
Brief Report Part A
Online Quiz 1
Marks Brief Report Part B:
Potentially impacted by public holidays
Online Quiz 2:
Open for Week 9
Monday 00:00 – Sunday 23:59
Remains open in Week 10 for late attempts
Recommend using university computers for IT support
Lecture Overview
Part 1: What is language?
Part 2: Building blocks and rules?
Part 3: Written language and reading
Part 4: The Dual Route Model of Reading
Learning Objectives:
Describe four qualities of human language that theories need to explain.
Discuss evidence that people are biologically prepared to learn language, as well as some core features of Chomsky’s contribution to psycholinguistics.
Define phonemes and morphemes, their roles in language, and how children become sensitive to the sounds of their native language.
Describe the ways we undergo the process of reading and the Dual Route Model.
Some Questions to Consider
How do we understand individual words, and how are words combined to create sentences?
How can we understand sentences that have more than one meaning?
How do we understand stories?
Does language affect the way a person perceives colours?
What is Language?
System of communication using sounds or symbols.
Expresses feelings, thoughts, ideas, and experiences.
Cats: meow
Monkeys: call
Bees: dance
The Creativity of Human Language
Hierarchical system: components that can be combined to form larger units.
Governed by rules: specific ways components can be arranged.
Examples:
Words → Phrases → Sentence
The umpires talked to the players.
The Universality of Language
Deaf children invent their own sign language.
Everyone can develop a language and learn to follow its complex rules.
Cross-culturally, language is universal.
Similar in development.
“Unique but the same.”
Different words, sounds, and rules, BUT:
All have nouns, verbs, negatives, questions, tense.
Studying Language in Cognitive Psychology
Psycholinguistics: Discover psychological process by which humans acquire and process language.
Areas of study:
Comprehension: understand spoken and written language
Speech production: physical and mental processes
Representation: language in the mind and brain
Acquisition: learning language
Neurolinguistics: Language and The Brain
First understanding about role of the brain comes from Broca and Wernicke in the 19th century
First to identify specific parts of the brain responsible for different aspects of language processing
Lateralisation of Language
Language is predominately a left-hemisphere function.
In deaf people, the cortical areas devoted to sign language are the same as for spoken languages.
Therefore, the regions of the brain devoted to language are specialised for symbolic representation and communication (not specifically spoken and heard language).
Different Linguistic Processes
Different linguistic processes such as syntactic, lexical, and phonological processes are located in the perisylvian regions of the left hemisphere
Angular gyrus – audio-visual integration
Split Brain Research
Commissurotomy for intractable epilepsy
Information presented to the left visual field goes to the right hemisphere
Right hemisphere can’t communicate with the left
Unable to produce a verbal report of stimuli
BUT can select the correct object, because right hemisphere does control the left arm
Behavioural Alternatives Used in Research
Tachistoscopic presentation to the left or right hemisphere
Record the aspects of the stimuli that subjects can report
Measure reaction and accuracy
Right Hemisphere
Split brain subjects can only make simple semantic judgements.
Problems with pragmatics (social communication)
Humour
Metaphor
Sarcasm
Difficulties with the non-literal, figurative meaning
The reason why singing and prose often spared in aphasia
Left hemisphere features predominately in comprehension and production
Right hemisphere is needed to generate full richness and ‘colour’
Critical Period for Language Development
Brain receptive to language for a short period of time during development.
However, if no linguistic input is received, no development of language.
Critical Period for Language Development
Language must be interactive.
Sensitive periods.
Syntax: 2 - 4 years, after puberty it may be impossible to acquire fluent syntax.
Examples:
Genie: rescued at 14
Reasonable number of words, no syntax
Chelsea: deaf, fitted hearing aids at 30
Developed some language skills almost devoid of syntax
Isabelle: rescued at about 6 years
Developed near normal language skills
Second Language Acquisition
Incredibly complex!!
Dependent upon large range of factors
Age of acquisition
Resulting skill level
Immersion
Location of acquisition (e.g., school or home-based)
Naturalistic vs. explicit instruction
Second Language Acquisition - Questions
What’s the actual question we have …
Do bilinguals hear language the same way?
Does the brain process grammar the same way?
Does the brain process the words in the same way?
Concrete words? Abstract words? etc
Overall second language acquisition vs. specific factors of acquisition?
How do you get matched monolingual controls for all these factors?
Brain structure and function will be dependent on all these factors
Perceiving and Understanding Words
Lexicon: all words a person understands
Phonemes: shortest segments of speech that, if changed, changes the meaning of the word e.g., b – i – t versus p – i – t
Morphemes: smallest units of language that has meaning or grammatical function e.g., insect bug versus computer bug
Perceiving and Understanding Words & Phonemic Restoration Effect
Warren (1970)
Covered phonemes with a cough
Phonemic restoration effect: “fill in” missing phonemes based on context of sentence and portion of word presented
Top-down processing
Influenced by words that follow
Perceiving and Understanding Words - Speech segmentation
(Image of my name segmented)
Sentences: Words are Rarely Alone …
Components of language are not processed in isolation
Phonemes → Morphemes → Words → Phrases → Sentences
Generativity: capacity to create an endless series of new combinations from a small set of fundamental units e.g., “malware,” “spyware”, “selfie”
Semantics: meanings of words and sentences
Syntax: rules for combining words into sentences
Sentences: Syntax
Can violate syntactic rules but still be meaningful
e.g., “Try not. Do or do not. There is no try.”
e.g., “If no mistake have you made, yet losing you are, a different game you should play”
Syntactic rules also do not depend on meaning
“Colourless green ideas sleep furiously”
“Jabberwocky” poem: “Twas brillig, and the slithy toves did gyre and gimble in the wabe . . .”
Understanding Sentences
Parsing: mental grouping of words in a sentence into phrases
Temporary ambiguity: When the initial words are ambiguous, but the meaning is made clear by the end of the sentence
Cast iron sinks quickly rust
Garden path sentences: Sentences that begin by appearing to mean one thing, but then end up meaning something else
Understanding Sentences - Syntax-first approach to parsing
Syntax-first approach to parsing: sentence grammatical structure determines parsing
Late closure: parser assumes new word is part of the current phrase
Cast iron
Cast iron sinks
Cast iron sinks quickly
Cast iron sinks – quickly rust
Demonstration: Late Closure
Determine where the first phrase ends
Determine the words “doing” the late closure
The shopper felt the fur coat was overpriced.
Because he always jogs a mile seems like a short distance to him.
The mechanic maintained the truck was working beautifully
The secretary applauded for his efforts was soon promoted.
The old man the ships."
The horse raced past the barn fell
Understanding Sentences
Syntax-first parsing: sentence grammatical structure determines parsing
Late closure: parser assumes new word is part of the current phrase
Interactionist parsing: semantics and syntax both influence processing while reading a sentence
The spy saw the man with the binoculars
The spy saw the man … with the binoculars
The spy saw … the man with the binoculars
The bird saw the man with the binoculars
Understanding Text and Stories
Coherence: relating information from one part of the text to another part of the text
Inference: readers generated information not explicitly stated in the text
Anaphoric: connecting objects/people
Instrumental: tools or methods
Causal: events in one clause caused by events in previous sentence
Importance of Reading
Reading is one of the most intricate workings of the human mind
The development of reading and writing makes it possible to communicate over space and time.
Process of Reading
When reading a page of text, the eye moves in a series of small jumps and pauses called saccades and fixations.
The eye also jumps backwards in regressions.
Fixation: anywhere from depending on context
Common words get shorter fixations, and all the information is acquired during fixations
Saccade: between and
Regiresions: also be dependent upon context.
How Do We Measure This?
During a fixation peripheral cues are important
Particularly to the right
Up to 15 characters to the right of fixation
Only about 3-4 characters to the left.
Is dependent on language reading in.
Reading skill
Difficulty of the text
We make 10-15% regressions.
Reading and Understanding Words
We each know as many as word forms
A typical reader identifies 2 or 3 a second
Even with presentation rates as high as 10 per second, word meanings get activated
Identification takes something of the order of
How is it done?
Processing Different Words
Flower
Meringue
Phoxs
Perplisteronk
Flint, stint, lint,
Week
Pachyderm
The Dual Route Model of Reading
The model consists of
The lexical route: recognition
The GPC (grapheme-to-phoneme) route: sounding-out
Applying known rules of language sounds (phonemes) to letters and letter combinations (grapheme)
Dual Route Model
(Image of the Dual Route Model)
Words like FLOWER, MERINGUE, YACHT are read through the direct lexical access route because they are familiar
Words like PERPLISTERONK, SPLAN, ECTOPLASM are read through GPC rules because you need to sound them out
Dual Route Model
Acquired phonological alexia
Can’t use the phonological route
Patient tries to access the lexical route
Example: SELDENT might be read as "seldom" or "season"
Dual Route Model
Acquired surface alexia
Can’t use the lexical route
Patient tries to sound out and makes regularisation errors
Example: MERINGUE might be read as "MERINGOO"
Best Way to Teach Reading?
Phonics wars: “don’t learn by sounding out”
Need to have:
Exposure to different types of reading material
Interest and enthusiasm for literature
Necessary for children to develop their lexical route, and develop a sight vocabulary (from dual route)
Language vs Reading
The brain did not evolve to read
Reading is not “natural” in the way that language is.
Unlike spoken (or otherwise) language, when reading, the brain recruits different cortical areas otherwise specialised for different functions
Reading is intrinsically interesting, but it is also a valuable way of understanding basic brain mechanisms
The neural dynamics involved in reading can help us understand the way the brain performs in other complex tasks
Reading and Understanding Words
Word superiority effect: letters are easier to recognise when they are contained in a word than when they appear alone or are contained in a nonword
Reicher (1969) flashed either a:
Word (FORK)
Letter (K)
Non-word (RFOK)
Followed immediately by a pattern and a letter
Reading and Understanding Words
Word frequency effect: respond more rapidly to high-frequency words
Lexical decision task: faster for words than non-words; high-frequency than low
Eye movements while reading: look at low-frequency words longer
Lexical ambiguity: words have more than one meaning
Context clears up ambiguity after all meanings of a word have been briefly accessed
Does It Even Matter?
Even if the letters in a word are jumbled (but the first and last letters are in the correct place), the word can still be read.
For next week …
Tutorials this week: Lab Report Results
Week 9 Lecture: Language + Reading II
Reading: Chapter 10
Upcoming Assessment: Module Quiz 2 open Monday – Sunday of Week 9