Lecture 8: Language and Reading I

Course Information - Weeks 8, 9, + 10

  • Lectures:

    • No face-to-face lectures for 2 weeks.

    • Pre-recorded videos, broken into shorter chunks.

    • Week 10: In-person.

  • Tutorials:

    • Week 8: As normal.

    • Week 9+10: Online self-directed tutorial.

    • Assumption that students have completed it.

  • Marks released at the time of recording:

    • Brief Report Part A

    • Online Quiz 1

  • Marks Brief Report Part B:

    • Potentially impacted by public holidays

    • Online Quiz 2:

      • Open for Week 9

      • Monday 00:00 – Sunday 23:59

      • Remains open in Week 10 for late attempts

      • Recommend using university computers for IT support

Lecture Overview

  • Part 1: What is language?

  • Part 2: Building blocks and rules?

  • Part 3: Written language and reading

  • Part 4: The Dual Route Model of Reading

  • Learning Objectives:

    • Describe four qualities of human language that theories need to explain.

    • Discuss evidence that people are biologically prepared to learn language, as well as some core features of Chomsky’s contribution to psycholinguistics.

    • Define phonemes and morphemes, their roles in language, and how children become sensitive to the sounds of their native language.

    • Describe the ways we undergo the process of reading and the Dual Route Model.

Some Questions to Consider

  • How do we understand individual words, and how are words combined to create sentences?

  • How can we understand sentences that have more than one meaning?

  • How do we understand stories?

  • Does language affect the way a person perceives colours?

What is Language?

  • System of communication using sounds or symbols.

  • Expresses feelings, thoughts, ideas, and experiences.

    • Cats: meow

    • Monkeys: call

    • Bees: dance

The Creativity of Human Language

  • Hierarchical system: components that can be combined to form larger units.

  • Governed by rules: specific ways components can be arranged.

  • Examples:

    • Words → Phrases → Sentence

    • The umpires talked to the players.

The Universality of Language

  • Deaf children invent their own sign language.

  • Everyone can develop a language and learn to follow its complex rules.

  • Cross-culturally, language is universal.

  • Similar in development.

  • “Unique but the same.”

  • Different words, sounds, and rules, BUT:

    • All have nouns, verbs, negatives, questions, tense.

Studying Language in Cognitive Psychology

  • Psycholinguistics: Discover psychological process by which humans acquire and process language.

  • Areas of study:

    • Comprehension: understand spoken and written language

    • Speech production: physical and mental processes

    • Representation: language in the mind and brain

    • Acquisition: learning language

Neurolinguistics: Language and The Brain

  • First understanding about role of the brain comes from Broca and Wernicke in the 19th century

  • First to identify specific parts of the brain responsible for different aspects of language processing

Lateralisation of Language

  • Language is predominately a left-hemisphere function.

  • In deaf people, the cortical areas devoted to sign language are the same as for spoken languages.

  • Therefore, the regions of the brain devoted to language are specialised for symbolic representation and communication (not specifically spoken and heard language).

Different Linguistic Processes

  • Different linguistic processes such as syntactic, lexical, and phonological processes are located in the perisylvian regions of the left hemisphere

  • Angular gyrus – audio-visual integration

Split Brain Research

  • Commissurotomy for intractable epilepsy

  • Information presented to the left visual field goes to the right hemisphere

  • Right hemisphere can’t communicate with the left

  • Unable to produce a verbal report of stimuli

  • BUT can select the correct object, because right hemisphere does control the left arm

Behavioural Alternatives Used in Research

  • Tachistoscopic presentation to the left or right hemisphere

  • Record the aspects of the stimuli that subjects can report

  • Measure reaction and accuracy

Right Hemisphere

  • Split brain subjects can only make simple semantic judgements.

  • Problems with pragmatics (social communication)

    • Humour

    • Metaphor

    • Sarcasm

  • Difficulties with the non-literal, figurative meaning

  • The reason why singing and prose often spared in aphasia

  • Left hemisphere features predominately in comprehension and production

  • Right hemisphere is needed to generate full richness and ‘colour’

Critical Period for Language Development

  • Brain receptive to language for a short period of time during development.

  • However, if no linguistic input is received, no development of language.

Critical Period for Language Development

  • Language must be interactive.

  • Sensitive periods.

  • Syntax: 2 - 4 years, after puberty it may be impossible to acquire fluent syntax.

  • Examples:

    • Genie: rescued at 14

      • Reasonable number of words, no syntax

    • Chelsea: deaf, fitted hearing aids at 30

      • Developed some language skills almost devoid of syntax

    • Isabelle: rescued at about 6 years

      • Developed near normal language skills

Second Language Acquisition

  • Incredibly complex!!

  • Dependent upon large range of factors

  • Age of acquisition

  • Resulting skill level

  • Immersion

  • Location of acquisition (e.g., school or home-based)

  • Naturalistic vs. explicit instruction

Second Language Acquisition - Questions

  • What’s the actual question we have …

  • Do bilinguals hear language the same way?

  • Does the brain process grammar the same way?

  • Does the brain process the words in the same way?

  • Concrete words? Abstract words? etc

  • Overall second language acquisition vs. specific factors of acquisition?

  • How do you get matched monolingual controls for all these factors?

  • Brain structure and function will be dependent on all these factors

Perceiving and Understanding Words

  • Lexicon: all words a person understands

  • Phonemes: shortest segments of speech that, if changed, changes the meaning of the word e.g., b – i – t versus p – i – t

  • Morphemes: smallest units of language that has meaning or grammatical function e.g., insect bug versus computer bug

Perceiving and Understanding Words & Phonemic Restoration Effect

  • Warren (1970)

  • Covered phonemes with a cough

  • Phonemic restoration effect: “fill in” missing phonemes based on context of sentence and portion of word presented

  • Top-down processing

  • Influenced by words that follow

Perceiving and Understanding Words - Speech segmentation

  • (Image of my name segmented)

Sentences: Words are Rarely Alone …

  • Components of language are not processed in isolation

    • Phonemes → Morphemes → Words → Phrases → Sentences

  • Generativity: capacity to create an endless series of new combinations from a small set of fundamental units e.g., “malware,” “spyware”, “selfie”

  • Semantics: meanings of words and sentences

  • Syntax: rules for combining words into sentences

Sentences: Syntax

  • Can violate syntactic rules but still be meaningful

    • e.g., “Try not. Do or do not. There is no try.”

    • e.g., “If no mistake have you made, yet losing you are, a different game you should play”

  • Syntactic rules also do not depend on meaning

    • “Colourless green ideas sleep furiously”

    • “Jabberwocky” poem: “Twas brillig, and the slithy toves did gyre and gimble in the wabe . . .”

Understanding Sentences

  • Parsing: mental grouping of words in a sentence into phrases

  • Temporary ambiguity: When the initial words are ambiguous, but the meaning is made clear by the end of the sentence

    • Cast iron sinks quickly rust

  • Garden path sentences: Sentences that begin by appearing to mean one thing, but then end up meaning something else

Understanding Sentences - Syntax-first approach to parsing

  • Syntax-first approach to parsing: sentence grammatical structure determines parsing

  • Late closure: parser assumes new word is part of the current phrase

    1. Cast iron

    2. Cast iron sinks

    3. Cast iron sinks quickly

    4. Cast iron sinks – quickly rust

Demonstration: Late Closure

  1. Determine where the first phrase ends

  2. Determine the words “doing” the late closure

  • The shopper felt the fur coat was overpriced.

  • Because he always jogs a mile seems like a short distance to him.

  • The mechanic maintained the truck was working beautifully

  • The secretary applauded for his efforts was soon promoted.

  • The old man the ships."

  • The horse raced past the barn fell

Understanding Sentences

  • Syntax-first parsing: sentence grammatical structure determines parsing

  • Late closure: parser assumes new word is part of the current phrase

  • Interactionist parsing: semantics and syntax both influence processing while reading a sentence

    • The spy saw the man with the binoculars

      1. The spy saw the man … with the binoculars

      2. The spy saw … the man with the binoculars

      3. The bird saw the man with the binoculars

Understanding Text and Stories

  • Coherence: relating information from one part of the text to another part of the text

  • Inference: readers generated information not explicitly stated in the text

    • Anaphoric: connecting objects/people

    • Instrumental: tools or methods

    • Causal: events in one clause caused by events in previous sentence

Importance of Reading

  • Reading is one of the most intricate workings of the human mind

  • The development of reading and writing makes it possible to communicate over space and time.

Process of Reading

  • When reading a page of text, the eye moves in a series of small jumps and pauses called saccades and fixations.

  • The eye also jumps backwards in regressions.

  • Fixation: anywhere from 150ms–1sec150ms – 1 sec depending on context

  • Common words get shorter fixations, and all the information is acquired during fixations

  • Saccade: between 2020 and 50ms50 ms

  • Regiresions: also be dependent upon context.

How Do We Measure This?

  • During a fixation peripheral cues are important

    • Particularly to the right

      • Up to 15 characters to the right of fixation

      • Only about 3-4 characters to the left.

  • Is dependent on language reading in.

  • Reading skill

  • Difficulty of the text

  • We make 10-15% regressions.

Reading and Understanding Words

  • We each know as many as 50,000−100,00050,000 - 100,000 word forms

  • A typical reader identifies 2 or 3 a second

  • Even with presentation rates as high as 10 per second, word meanings get activated

  • Identification takes something of the order of 200ms200 ms

  • How is it done?

Processing Different Words

  • Flower

  • Meringue

  • Phoxs

  • Perplisteronk

  • Flint, stint, lint,

  • Week

  • Pachyderm

The Dual Route Model of Reading

  • The model consists of

    • The lexical route: recognition

    • The GPC (grapheme-to-phoneme) route: sounding-out

    • Applying known rules of language sounds (phonemes) to letters and letter combinations (grapheme)

Dual Route Model

  • (Image of the Dual Route Model)

  • Words like FLOWER, MERINGUE, YACHT are read through the direct lexical access route because they are familiar

  • Words like PERPLISTERONK, SPLAN, ECTOPLASM are read through GPC rules because you need to sound them out

Dual Route Model

  • Acquired phonological alexia

  • Can’t use the phonological route

  • Patient tries to access the lexical route

  • Example: SELDENT might be read as "seldom" or "season"

Dual Route Model

  • Acquired surface alexia

  • Can’t use the lexical route

  • Patient tries to sound out and makes regularisation errors

  • Example: MERINGUE might be read as "MERINGOO"

Best Way to Teach Reading?

  • Phonics wars: “don’t learn by sounding out”

  • Need to have:

    • Exposure to different types of reading material

    • Interest and enthusiasm for literature

  • Necessary for children to develop their lexical route, and develop a sight vocabulary (from dual route)

Language vs Reading

  • The brain did not evolve to read

  • Reading is not “natural” in the way that language is.

  • Unlike spoken (or otherwise) language, when reading, the brain recruits different cortical areas otherwise specialised for different functions

  • Reading is intrinsically interesting, but it is also a valuable way of understanding basic brain mechanisms

  • The neural dynamics involved in reading can help us understand the way the brain performs in other complex tasks

Reading and Understanding Words

  • Word superiority effect: letters are easier to recognise when they are contained in a word than when they appear alone or are contained in a nonword

  • Reicher (1969) flashed either a:

    • Word (FORK)

    • Letter (K)

    • Non-word (RFOK)

  • Followed immediately by a pattern and a letter

Reading and Understanding Words

  • Word frequency effect: respond more rapidly to high-frequency words

  • Lexical decision task: faster for words than non-words; high-frequency than low

  • Eye movements while reading: look at low-frequency words longer

  • Lexical ambiguity: words have more than one meaning

  • Context clears up ambiguity after all meanings of a word have been briefly accessed

Does It Even Matter?

  • Even if the letters in a word are jumbled (but the first and last letters are in the correct place), the word can still be read.

For next week …

  • Tutorials this week: Lab Report Results

  • Week 9 Lecture: Language + Reading II

  • Reading: Chapter 10

  • Upcoming Assessment: Module Quiz 2 open Monday – Sunday of Week 9