Comprehensive Study Notes on Representation, Federal Branches, and Legislative Mechanics
Representation and Regional Debates at the Constitutional Convention
Virginia Plan and Proportional Representation:
- Desired by states with large populations, partly due to having large slave populations.
- Proportional representation proposal logic: A state with people should receive votes, whereas a smaller state such as New Jersey with people should receive votes.
Regional Stances on Governance:
- Northerners: Favored equal representation by state (government by state) because they recognized their states had smaller populations.
- Southerners: Favored representation based on population numbers to leverage their larger population count.
Constitutional Population Calculation (Three-Fifths Formula):
- Representation determination clause: Calculated by adding the whole number of free persons, including individuals bound to service for a term of years, excluding untaxed Indians, and adding of all other persons.
- Every free person / white person was counted as whole person.
- Individuals bound in service for a term of years were included in the whole person count.
- Untaxed Indians were explicitly excluded from the population count.
- Enslaved persons were counted according to the ratio (three-fifths of all other persons).
Structural Design of the Federal Branches
Fear of Centralized Power:
- Framers viewed a strong central government as potential creation of a "monster."
- The nation had fought against a coercive central authority a mere years prior.
- Structural mechanisms were established specifically to keep the central government limited and balanced.
Original Centrality of Congress:
- Congress was originally designed to be the primary, main body of government.
- Primary legislative function: Making laws was seen as the crucial responsibility of government.
- Prominent figures such as John Adams and George Washington envisioned themselves serving within Congress to make these important laws.
Original Role of the Presidency:
- Initially conceived as a small attachment to the legislature—an executable office.
- Functioned essentially like a clerk, responsible for the day-to-day implementation and execution of laws that Congress passed, sparing congressmen from dealing with administrative nitty-gritty details.
Original Role of the Judicial Branch:
- Formed as a "judicial annex" consisting of a panel of judges.
- Designated to handle disputes arising from laws created by Congress, preventing congressmen from wasting time on individual legal conflicts.
Evolutionary Mechanics of Governance and Presidential Power
The Three Branches:
- Legislative Branch: Derived from the word "legislate" (meaning to make laws); intended as the principal primary branch.
- Executive Branch: Tasked with executing and enforcing laws.
- Judicial Branch: Tasked with resolving legal disputes.
Checks and Balances and Practical Deviation:
- Built-in checks and balances were designed to ensure no single branch possesses absolute power on paper.
- Over time, practical reality deviated significantly from original intent: the Presidency accumulated prestige, leading the public to view the President as the primary figure of government.
Legislative Veto and Override Process:
- Bill Stage: A proposed law remains a bill prior to receiving presidential signature.
- Presidential Veto: If the President refuses to sign, the bill is returned to Congress.
- Congressional Override: To overcome a presidential veto, Congress must achieve a () supermajority vote in favor of the bill.
- Comparative Difficulty: Achieving a basic simple majority () in Congress is already exceptionally difficult; requiring a vote highlights the immense veto power granted to a single individual.
Structure of the Electoral College
Total Tally:
- The Electoral College consists of a total tally of electoral dots/votes.
Calculation Formula:
- The sum uses the structural total count of Senate and House seats, rather than the individual sitting representatives themselves.
Questions & Discussion
- Student Greeting and Social Media Inquiry:
- Question: What is your name?
- Response: Brian.
- Exchange: Nice to meet you, Brian. / Nice to meet you too.
- Inquiry: You don't have IG? Instagram.