Land Law Lecture:
Registration of Title:
Overriding interests Or interstate with overriding status
Statutorily defined circumstances in which interests will bind a purchaser of land not appearing on the register of title of the land in question
Have them because:
Impractical and undesirable to require registration of all interests
Informally created rights
Short-term rights
Public rights
Registration not intended to replace physical inspection of land.
Why do we have overriding interests?
Because registration of some interstate is ‘unnecessary, impractical or undesirable’ (Law Commission Working Paper no 37)
Because tehre are circumstances in which it would not be reaosnble to ecxpect a person to protect their interests on the register
Overriding interests
Those which bind at the time of first registration are set out in Schedule 1 to the Land Registration Act 2002
Those which bind on later dealings with already registered land are set out in Schedule 3 to the Land Regisrtaion Act 2002
Schedule 3
Para 1: legal leases for 7 years or less and Relevant social housing leases
Para 2: Interests of persons in actual occupation
Para3: Certain legal easements
Para4-9 =public right of way
Para 1: Legal Leases
Which leases will be legal?
Those granted by deed: s52 LPA1925
Or those granted informally if covered by section 54(2) LPA 1925 exception
No formality required for
Leases for 3 years or less, which
Take effect in possession,
At the best rent reasonably obtainable without taking a fine
I.e. if these conditions are satisfied the lease will be legal despite not being granted by deed.
Some short leases will not override
Grant of lease under Part 5 Housing Act 1985 under ‘right to buy’ provisions
Grant of a lease of a dwelling-house to a private landlord where tenants right to buy is preserved
Grant of a lease to take effect in possession more than three months from the date of teh grant.
Also overriding under Para 1A = certain social housing leases
Para 2: Interests of persons in ‘actual occupation’
2 elements:
An interest (proprietary)
Actual Occupation
Qualifications: Schedule 3 para 2©
The occupation being relied on must be obvious on a reasonably careful inspection of the land
(Unless the purchaser has actual knowledge of teh interest in question)
Para 2(b)
An interest will not override if
An inquiry was made of teh right-holder AND
He failed to disclose the right when he could reaosnbly be expected to do so.
Actual occupation
Abbey NAtional Building Society v Cann (1991)
The date for ascertaining whether a person is in actual occupation is the date of completion of transaction, not the (later) date of registration.
Getting loan in order to buy the property
Mother made a contribution to the price but not on the paperwork
Just before completion, they started moving in furniture and moved in.
He registered the transaction
Williams and Glyn’s Bank v Borland (1981)
Words ‘actual occupation’ to be given ordinary meaning. Physical presence is required.
matrimonial home, registered only under husbands name but wife had given money too.
Mortgaged at the bank who were unaware of her contributions and they failed to enquire.
Court found the wife’s interest was turned by her actual occupation into an overriding interest
Temporary absence does not necessarily mean you are not in actual occupation : Bustard (2010)
But there must be some evidence of occupation and a continuing intention to occupy: Bustard (2010); Thomas v Foy
Actual occupation
No single test
Some degree if permanance and continuity
length of absence is relevant
Intentions of right holder is relevant
Personal circumstances of person seeking to claim interest
Choker v Choker 1984
husband and wife.
Husband transferred house to friend and changed the locks while she was in pregnant in hospital
Court found despite her temporary absence she was in actual occupation.
Para 3 Legal Easements and Profits
An easement or profit will have overriding status under Sch 3 only if:
It is legal; and
It arose by prescription or implied grant or reservation.
Further restriction: to be overriding an easement must:
Be actually known about by the purchaser;
OR
Obvious on a reaosnbly careful inspection of the land; OR
Have been exercised in the year before the disposition of the land.