Portfolio Diversification and Relevant Risk Analysis

Recap of North Air, West Air, and Tex Oil Example

  • Initial Individual Asset Statistics:     * For the three stocks—North Air, West Air, and Tex Oil—the expected return for each individual stock is 10%10\%.     * The total risk, measured by standard deviation (SDSD), is 13.42%13.42\% for each individual stock.

  • Performance of an Equally Weighted Portfolio of North Air and West Air:     * Expected Return (ERER): 10%10\%     * Standard Deviation (SDSD): 12.07%12.07\%

  • Performance of an Equally Weighted Portfolio of All Three Stocks:     * Expected Return (ERER): 10%10\%     * Standard Deviation (SDSD): 4.40%4.40\%

Core Concepts: Portfolio Diversification, Optimal Investment Choice, and Relevant Risk

  • Module Goals:     * Deepen the understanding of statistical concepts beyond simple calculation to explore three fundamental pillars of finance.     * Concept 1: Portfolio Diversification: How combining assets reduces total risk.     * Concept 2: Optimal Investment Strategy: How to select the best portfolio among multiple options.     * Concept 3: ‘Relevant’ Risk of an Asset: Identifying the specific risk of an asset that an investor actually cares about when that asset is part of a portfolio.

  • Analytical Framework:     * The discussion begins with a simplified 3-stock setting (North Air, West Air, Tex Oil) and progresses to realistic settings in later modules.     * Importance of Correlations: Analysis highlights the significance of correlations between stocks within the portfolio, as well as the correlation between the total portfolio and an individual stock within it.

The Nature and Calculation of Portfolio Diversification

  • Core Finance Principle 2: The expected returns of a portfolio are always equal to the weighted average of the expected returns of each asset in that portfolio.

  • Definition of Diversification: Diversification occurs when the standard deviation of a portfolio is less than the weighted average standard deviation of each individual asset in the portfolio.

  • Diversification Logic: Diversification exists if SDportfolio<∑(wi×SDi)SD_{\text{portfolio}} < \sum (w_i \times SD_i).

  • Case Study Example (North Air and West Air):     * Portfolio Composition: 50%50\% investment in North Air and 50%50\% investment in West Air.     * Expected Return Calculation: 0.5×0.1+0.5×0.1=0.1 or 10%0.5 \times 0.1 + 0.5 \times 0.1 = 0.1 \, \text{or} \, 10\%.     * Weighted Average Standard Deviation: 0.5×0.1342+0.5×0.1342=0.1342 or 13.42%0.5 \times 0.1342 + 0.5 \times 0.1342 = 0.1342 \, \text{or} \, 13.42\%.     * Observed Portfolio Standard Deviation: 12.07%12.07\%.     * Evidence of Diversification: Because 12.07%<13.42%12.07\% < 13.42\%, diversification has occurred. The extent of diversification in this instance is 13.42%−12.07%=1.35%13.42\% - 12.07\% = 1.35\%.

Benefits and Rationale Behind Diversification

  • Risk-Return Tradeoff Improvement: Diversification allows an investor to reduce risk without negatively impacting the expected return. This is shown by comparing the individual stocks to the equally weighted portfolio.

  • Period-Specific Returns (2005–2010):     * Year 2005: North Air 21%21\%, West Air 9%9\%, Portfolio 15%15\%     * Year 2006: North Air 30%30\%, West Air 21%21\%, Portfolio 25.5%25.5\%     * Year 2007: North Air 7%7\%, West Air 7%7\%, Portfolio 7%7\%     * Year 2008: North Air −5%-5\%, West Air −2%-2\%, Portfolio −3.5%-3.5\%     * Year 2009: North Air −2%-2\%, West Air −5%-5\%, Portfolio −3.5%-3.5\%     * Year 2010: North Air 9%9\%, West Air 30%30\%, Portfolio 19.5%19.5\%

  • Why Diversification Occurs: It happens because certain risks associated with each asset are eliminated when combined.

  • Uncorrelated Risks:     * Factors that affect the returns of one asset but have low or no impact on others are eliminated.     * Example 1: Fire insurance is a tool to mitigate uncorrelated risk.     * Example 2: The possibility of a strike at one company is an uncorrelated risk.

  • Negatively Correlated Risks:     * Factors that have opposite impacts on different assets are eliminated.     * Example: In a vacation resort, weather impacts two stores differently—one selling sunscreens and the other selling umbrellas.

  • Correlated Risks (Non-Eliminable):     * Factors that affect all firms in a portfolio in the same way cannot be eliminated through diversification.     * Example: In the airline industry, crude oil prices and the overall state of the economy affect all airline stocks similarly, thus representing correlated risk.

The Role of Correlation in Risk Elimination

  • Correlation Scale: Correlation values range from −1-1 to +1+1. Lower correlation results in greater risk elimination.

  • Correlation = +1+1 (Perfectly Correlated):     * Returns move exactly together because all factors affect assets the same way.     * Diversification: None. Portfolio SDSD equals the weighted average SDSD of the assets.     * Example: Earthquake insurance contracts centered in a single geographical area.

  • Correlation = +0.5+0.5 (High Correlation):     * Returns largely move together. Most risk stems from factors affecting both firms similarly. Only minor diversification occurs.

  • Correlation = 00 (Unrelated):     * Factors affecting one asset have no impact on the other. Significant diversification occurs.     * Implication: Combining many assets with zero correlation can result in a virtually riskless portfolio (e.g., Fire Insurance).

  • Correlation < 00 (Negatively Correlated):     * Factors affecting one asset have the opposite impact on the other. Significant risk is eliminated even with a small number of assets.

  • Industry Application:     * The North Air and West Air portfolio only eliminated moderate risk (SD dropped from 13.42%13.42\% to 12.07%12.07\%—a correlation of 0.620.62).     * This is because companies in the same industry share factors like crude oil prices and economic conditions, making their risks largely correlated.

Achieving Greater Diversification

  • Approach 1: Adding Assets:     * Adding assets from unrelated industries is highly effective. Mathematically, one should seek assets with low correlation to the existing portfolio.

  • Approach 2: Altering Asset Weights:     * Changing the proportion of capital allocated to each asset can optimize risk reduction.

  • Case Study with Tex Oil:     * Addition of Tex Oil: Adding Tex Oil to the North Air/West Air mix created a three-stock equally weighted portfolio.     * Result: Expected Return stayed at 10%10\%, but Standard Deviation dropped significantly to 4.40%4.40\%.     * Why Tex Oil worked efficiently: Correlation between Tex Oil and North Air is −0.9233-0.9233; correlation with West Air is −0.7133-0.7133.     * The negative correlation stems from the fact that oil price increases hurt airline stocks but benefit oil stocks. Combining them cancels out the impact of oil price fluctuations.

  • Example of Weight Optimization:     * Investing 39.25%39.25\% in North Air, 12.7%12.7\% in West Air, and 48.05%48.05\% in Tex Oil provides an expected return of 10%10\% with a volatility of only 2.23%2.23\%.     * This specific weighting scheme allows for much more efficient elimination of oil price risk than equal weighting.

Optimal Portfolio Choice

  • Decision Rule: When presented with various investment options that have the same expected return, the optimal choice is the one with the lowest risk.

  • Maximizing Diversification: The optimal portfolio is the one that utilizes assets with the lowest correlations to achieve maximum risk reduction.

  • Case Study Conclusion: The optimal choice among the studied options is the weighted portfolio totaling 39.25%39.25\% North Air, 12.7%12.7\% West Air, and 48.05%48.05\% Tex Oil.

  • Worst Case Scenario: If all assets are perfectly correlated (Correlation = +1+1), the portfolio standard deviation is simply the weighted average of the standard deviations, and no benefit is gained from diversification.

Relevant Risk of an Asset

  • Total Risk Definition: The total risk of an asset is defined as the standard deviation of its returns, denoted SD(Ri)SD(R_i).

  • Relevant Risk Definition: The risk an asset adds to a specific portfolio. It is almost always less than the total risk of the asset.

  • The Mathematical Formula for Relevant Risk:     * Relevant Risk=SD(Ri)×Corr(Ri,Rp)\text{Relevant Risk} = SD(R_i) \times Corr(R_i, R_p)     * Where RiR_i is the return of the asset and RpR_p is the return of the portfolio.

  • Intuition for Relevant Risk:     * As long as the correlation between the asset and the portfolio is less than +1+1, the asset adds less than its total risk to the portfolio.     * This is because a portion of the asset’s individual risk is diversified away by the other assets in the portfolio.

  • Case Study Calculation:     * Data: Individual stock SD=13.42%SD = 13.42\%. Correlation of North Air (RiR_i) with the portfolio (RpR_p) = 0.90.9.     * Relevant Risk calculation: 0.1342×0.9=12.07%0.1342 \times 0.9 = 12.07\%.     * This represents the risk of the stock that is not diversified away.

  • Key Implications:     * Correlation Dependency: The lower the correlation of an asset with other assets in the portfolio, the lower its relevant risk.     * Portfolio Dependency: Relevant risk is not a fixed property of an asset; it depends on which portfolio the asset is added to. For example, North Air has less relevant risk in an equally weighted 3-stock portfolio than in a 2-stock portfolio because the 3rd stock (Tex Oil) provides more diversification opportunities.