ethological explanation
AO1
aggression is innate, genetically determined in order to aid survival
ethologists study non human animals and extrapolate findings to humans because we are all subject to the same forces of natural selection
adaptive because it increases territory and resources
animal aggression is more ritualistic, involving threat displays and appeasement displays
the defeated is forced out into new territory
species is spread out over a wider area so that there is less pressure on food resources and less competition which is advantageous
adaptive because it establishes dominance hierarchies
dominance gives special status, resources and mating rights
innate releasing mechanisms - evolved automatic biological response in the brain
animals have built in neural structure, which when exposed to specific stimuli, will cause the release of an automatic behaviour response (a fixed action pattern)
environmental stimulus → innate releasing mechanism started → fixed action pattern deployed
Lea - FAP has 6 characteristics
stereotyped - relatively unchanging sequences of behaviours
universal - found in every individual of the species
unaffected by learning - same regardless of experience
ballistic - once triggered follows inevitable course of action
single purpose - can only occur in a specific situation
response to identifiable specific stimulus
tinbergen - presented make stickelbacks with a series of wooden models with different shapes . regardless of shape if the model had a red spot, the stickelback would aggressively display and attack it - but if there was no red spot there was no aggression, even if the model looked realistically like a stickelback
this suggests that aggression is an innate response that is meant to be adaptive
therefore, the ethological explanation has increased validity
AO3
a strength of the expl is that there is supporting researched linked to genetics and evolution
brunner et al’s research showed that there is a genetic basis for aggression. twin and adoption studies also showed that there is a significant genetic component to aggression in humans. furthermore, there is also research suggesting that aggression is adaptice
these lines of rsearch point towards an innate bases to aggressive behaviour
this suggests that the ethological approach is correct in claiming that aggression is genetically determined, heritable and adaptive
CA - nisbett foudn that one type of homicide was more common amongst white men in the south of US than the north. reactive aggression is a response to threats. nisbett concluded that the difference was caused by a culutre of honour in the south, which is less prevalent in the north. so this kind of aggression comes from a learned social norm rather than being instinctive. therefore, culture can override innate predispositions
one limitation is that aggression against members of the same species is not just ritualistic
jane goodall observed a 4 year war during which male chimps from one community killed all the members of another tribe
they did this in a systematic way. in some cases, the victim would be held down whilst rival chimps committed a sustained attack. there was nothing ritualistic about it and the attacks continued despite appeasement displays from the victim
this contradicts the etho expl that same species aggression aids species survival and is harmless and ritualistic
another limitation is that FAPs may not be fixed
hunt pointed out that FAPs are infleunced by environ factors and learned experiences. the duration of each behaviour varies from one individuak to another, and even in the same individual from one encounter to another
because they are modifiable, thologists prefer the term ‘modal behaviour pattern’
therefore, the patterns of aggression are much more flexible than lorezn thought