Parties

Political Parties: History & Overview

Announcements

  • Watch lecture videos on rights/liberties and bureaucracy on Blackboard.

  • Important dates:

    • Exam #2: Monday, 11/18

    • Representation Paper due: 12/1 at midnight

    • Office hours today: 2:30-4:30 HW-1728

    • Early voting in NY: 10/26-11/3, Election Day: 11/5

Ask a Political Scientist

  • Inquiry about the Working Families Party (WFP) endorsing Kamala Harris:

    • WFP leans more progressive than the Democratic Party.

    • They often endorse the same candidates, but not always.

    • Voting for Harris under WFP boosts their credibility and helps maintain their ballot line.

Overview of Political Parties

Theoretical Foundations

  • Theory of Responsible Party Government:

    • Public preferences should translate into governmental policy.

    • Political parties aim to win elections to enact policies.

    • Each party has a political program, or a set of policies.

Challenges in Reality

  • Divided Government:

    • Different parties controlling different legislative bodies complicates policy translation.

    • Since the 1970s, divided government has been the norm.

  • Bounded Rationality:

    • Voters face cognitive limitations, influencing their political decisions.

    • This challenges the assumption that voters can adequately hold politicians accountable.

Functions of Political Parties

Recruitment and Election Strategies

  • Parties recruit political candidates by leveraging resources like money and visibility.

  • Strategies for winning elections include:

    • Political advertising campaigns.

    • Voter registration and turnout initiatives.

    • Providing expertise and data for candidates.

Organizing Governance and Opposition

  • After elections, party members organize within legislative bodies.

  • Functions include:

    • Electing leadership in Congress.

    • Planning legislative strategies and discipline among party members.

Party Organization

  • Structure:

    • Parties exist on national, state, and local levels.

    • National committees are pivotal for fundraising and outreach, responsible for party platforms.

  • Hill Committees:

    • Strengthened by increasing congressional partisanship; they raise money and set campaign priorities.

  • Local Organizations:

    • Historically supported by urban political machines.

Historical Context of Political Parties

Initial Perspectives on Parties

  • Founding fathers viewed parties as detrimental to government and social order:

    • Benjamin Franklin, George Washington, and John Adams warned of the dangers of party divisions.

    • Initially, parties were seen as temporary.

    • Constitutional protection of party activities (speech, assembly).

Development of the Two-Party System

  • Duverger's Law:

    • Single-member districts coupled with plurality voting result in a two-party system, inhibiting third-party emergence.

  • Single vs. Multi-Member Districts:

    • U.S. utilizes single-member districts.

    • Encourages strategic voting, reinforcing the dominance of two major parties.

Impact of Third Parties

  • Although often unsuccessful, third parties can influence major parties and eventually transition into them.

  • Historic instances include:

    • Progressive reforms in the early 1900s.

    • Ross Perot's emphasis on national debt in 1992.

Evolution of Political Parties

Historical Development Stages

  1. First Party System (1786-1830):

    • Federalists (strong national government) vs. Democratic Republicans (states' rights).

  2. Second Party System (1830-1860):

    • Emergence of Whigs (industrial progress) against Democrats (states' rights).

  3. Third Party System (1860-1896):

    • Ideological shifts post-Civil War creating modern Republican Party.

  4. Fourth Party System (1896-1932):

    • Struggles over gold vs. silver standards; emergence of strong interest in progressive reforms.

  5. Fifth Party System (1932-1980):

    • Focus on New Deal initiatives, broadening social rights, and entrenching Democratic dominance.

  6. Sixth Party System (1980-present):

    • Modern ideological realignment centered around race, social values, and economic policies.

Recent Political Dynamics

  • Transformation of political allegiances during the civil rights era.

  • Southern Strategy by Republicans consolidating support among Southern white voters.

  • Increasing corporate influence in both major parties.

Current Party Positions

  • Democratic Party:

    • Demand-side economics, support for civil rights, pro-choice on abortion, regulatory environmental policies.

  • Republican Party:

    • Supply-side economics, restrictions on civil rights, pro-life abortion stance, less regulation on the environment.

  • Chomsky's Observation:

    • The U.S. exhibits characteristics of a ruling 'business party.'

Conclusion

The Role of Political Parties

  • Political parties play a crucial role in electoral processes and shaping policy within a democracy; their influence continues to evolve with societal changes and voter behavior.