Criminal Law: Evaluation - Attempts & Murder

Attempts: Suggested Answer

  • A criminal attempt occurs when a defendant tries to commit an offense but fails to complete it.

  • The Criminal Attempts Act (CAA) 1981 aimed to improve and codify the law on criminal attempts but still has issues.

  • Before the CAA 1981, common law governed attempts, using different tests like the 'last act test', 'rubicon test', and 'series of acts test'.

    • These tests were confusing and unclear about when planning turns into an attempt.

  • Section 1(1) of the CA 1981 defines an attempt as an act that is 'more than merely preparatory' to the commission of an offense, coupled with the necessary mens rea.

    • The 'more than merely preparatory' test aimed to set a clearer standard.

    • In Gullefer, the judge added that the defendant must have 'embarked upon the crime proper,' potentially creating another test.

  • Application of the 'more than merely preparatory' test can be inconsistent:

    • Boyle and Boyle: Damaging a hinge was more than merely preparatory to burglary.

    • Tosti and White: An attempt was met even without damage to the door.

    • Some argue the defendants in Tosti might have changed their minds.

    • Campbell: The defendant had not embarked on the crime proper because he had not entered the post office or brandished the imitation firearm; his actions were "merely preparatory".

      • This case has been criticized because his intent was clear, and apprehension before entry shouldn't matter.

  • The 'more than merely preparatory' test poses problems in cases involving violent acts, requiring a level of confrontation, as seen in Jones and Geddes.

    • Geddes: A man found hiding in a toilet with supplies to falsely imprison a child was not convicted because his actions were deemed merely preparatory.

      • The court stated that implementing the plan had not yet begun.

      • The Law Commission in their 2009 consultation paper identified the problem seen in R v Geddes and suggested the creation of two offenses to replace the single offence in the 1981 Act.

  • The CA 1981 improved the law on impossibility via s. 1(2), making it possible to be guilty of attempting the impossible.

    • In R v White, the defendant was held liable even though he was incompetent at carrying out the offense.

  • Difficulties remain, as illustrated by Anderton v Ryan, where the defendant was initially found not guilty because the recorder was not actually stolen.

    • The courts did not want to prosecute the D for what she thought she was doing, rather than what she was actually doing.

    • This case highlights the challenge of prosecuting attempts without penalizing thoughts alone.

    • Anderton v Ryan was overruled in R v Shivpuri, which referenced the CA 1981, emphasizing the 'more than merely preparatory' standard.

  • Mens rea for attempt: requires mens rea for the attempted crime.

    • Whybrow: Only intent to kill suffices for attempted murder, setting a high burden of proof.

      • This prevents those liable for attempted GBH or GBH with intent from automatically becoming liable for attempted murder.

  • The Law Commission suggests the 'more than merely preparatory' test is vague and allows for too much confrontation.

  • The Law Commission proposes two offenses:

    • 'Attempt': when someone intends to commit an offense but doesn't complete it.

    • 'Criminal preparation': for preparations immediately connected to the commission of the offense (as in Geddes).

Murder: Suggested Answer

  • The law on murder lacks a definite definition of words and contains outdated language which already suggests need for reform.

  • The actus reus (AR) of murder is the unlawful killing of a reasonable person in being under the Queen's peace.