Criminal Law: Evaluation - Attempts & Murder
Attempts: Suggested Answer
A criminal attempt occurs when a defendant tries to commit an offense but fails to complete it.
The Criminal Attempts Act (CAA) 1981 aimed to improve and codify the law on criminal attempts but still has issues.
Before the CAA 1981, common law governed attempts, using different tests like the 'last act test', 'rubicon test', and 'series of acts test'.
These tests were confusing and unclear about when planning turns into an attempt.
Section 1(1) of the CA 1981 defines an attempt as an act that is 'more than merely preparatory' to the commission of an offense, coupled with the necessary mens rea.
The 'more than merely preparatory' test aimed to set a clearer standard.
In Gullefer, the judge added that the defendant must have 'embarked upon the crime proper,' potentially creating another test.
Application of the 'more than merely preparatory' test can be inconsistent:
Boyle and Boyle: Damaging a hinge was more than merely preparatory to burglary.
Tosti and White: An attempt was met even without damage to the door.
Some argue the defendants in Tosti might have changed their minds.
Campbell: The defendant had not embarked on the crime proper because he had not entered the post office or brandished the imitation firearm; his actions were "merely preparatory".
This case has been criticized because his intent was clear, and apprehension before entry shouldn't matter.
The 'more than merely preparatory' test poses problems in cases involving violent acts, requiring a level of confrontation, as seen in Jones and Geddes.
Geddes: A man found hiding in a toilet with supplies to falsely imprison a child was not convicted because his actions were deemed merely preparatory.
The court stated that implementing the plan had not yet begun.
The Law Commission in their 2009 consultation paper identified the problem seen in R v Geddes and suggested the creation of two offenses to replace the single offence in the 1981 Act.
The CA 1981 improved the law on impossibility via s. 1(2), making it possible to be guilty of attempting the impossible.
In R v White, the defendant was held liable even though he was incompetent at carrying out the offense.
Difficulties remain, as illustrated by Anderton v Ryan, where the defendant was initially found not guilty because the recorder was not actually stolen.
The courts did not want to prosecute the D for what she thought she was doing, rather than what she was actually doing.
This case highlights the challenge of prosecuting attempts without penalizing thoughts alone.
Anderton v Ryan was overruled in R v Shivpuri, which referenced the CA 1981, emphasizing the 'more than merely preparatory' standard.
Mens rea for attempt: requires mens rea for the attempted crime.
Whybrow: Only intent to kill suffices for attempted murder, setting a high burden of proof.
This prevents those liable for attempted GBH or GBH with intent from automatically becoming liable for attempted murder.
The Law Commission suggests the 'more than merely preparatory' test is vague and allows for too much confrontation.
The Law Commission proposes two offenses:
'Attempt': when someone intends to commit an offense but doesn't complete it.
'Criminal preparation': for preparations immediately connected to the commission of the offense (as in Geddes).
Murder: Suggested Answer
The law on murder lacks a definite definition of words and contains outdated language which already suggests need for reform.
The actus reus (AR) of murder is the unlawful killing of a reasonable person in being under the Queen's peace.