HOTEL Week 7 Notes

1066: A Turning Point in English History

  • The year 1066 marks a significant turning point in English history, particularly due to the Norman Conquest.
  • The Bayeux Tapestry likely did not depict the coronation of William the Conqueror, which signified a new royal lineage for England.

Political Changes

  • New Royal Dynasty: The conquest brought a king from a family that had never reigned in England before. This marked the beginning of a new royal dynasty whose successors continue to reign to this day.
  • Numbering of Kings: The numbering of kings was restarted after the Norman Conquest, with Edward I etc. being post-conquest.
  • William's Claim: William the Conqueror claimed ownership of all of England, a significant break from the Anglo-Saxon system where the king was a large landholder among many.
  • Shift in Power: The nobility was significantly stronger in relation to the king before William's conquest. William redistributed land among his followers, changing the dynamics of power.
  • Anglo-Norman influence: Close political relationships emerged between England and France, influencing subsequent historical developments.

Social Changes

  • Elite Replacement: The Normans and their allies replaced the Anglo-Saxon elites, impacting political and ecclesiastical leadership (bishops, abbots, monks).
  • Linguistic Influence: Anglo-Norman French replaced English as the language of the elite.
  • Peasant Interaction: Peasants had to interact with lords who spoke French, creating a linguistic divide.
  • Impact on Population: This change mainly affected the top 1% of the population, who held political and intellectual power and were now French-speaking Normans.
  • Latin Revival: Latin made a comeback as a written language of government, reinforcing multilingualism in England.

Continuity After the Conquest

  • Efficient Administration: The Anglo-Saxon administrative system, developed due to the need for efficient tax collection to finance wars against the Scandinavians, was retained by the Normans.
  • Intermarriage: Intermarriage between Normans and Anglo-Saxons led to a blended elite after two to three generations.
  • Bilingualism: The intermarriage produced bilingual Normans, strengthening over the centuries.
  • English Language Continuity: 97-98% of the population continued to speak English.
  • Perspective Matters: The impact of the conquest depends on whether you look at it from the top-down (elite) or bottom-up (general population) perspective.
  • Gradual Linguistic Shift: England did not start speaking French from one year to another; English continued to be spoken predominantly.

Connection Between Politics and Linguistic Development

  • There is a close connection between political events and linguistic development, especially in the Middle Ages.

English as a Germanic Language

  • English is examined in relation to other West Germanic dialects (German, French, Dutch).
  • The session assumes knowledge of German, French, and Dutch.

Key Terms Explained

  • Afrikaans: Not defined in this section.
  • Plosives: Not defined in this section.
  • Fricatives: Not defined in this section.
  • Abricate: A combination of a plosive and a fricative, more common in languages like High German or Swiss German.
  • Cognate: Words with the same origin, sharing an etymology. Examples: log (noun and verb), Dutch liefde, German Liebe. They are from a single origin so Latin amor, Italian amore, French amour are cognates between each other but not with the earlier examples.
  • Diglossia: A sociolinguistic term referring to the use of different languages or dialects in a society, based on the social status of the language; high-status language vs. low-status language. For example, French in Luxembourg's court system vs. the local dialect.
  • Registers: High register, for example, you can avoid swear words in English, and low register, if you include some.
  • Monophram: A single vowel sound.
  • Diphthong: The d prefix meaning two means this is two vowels together. The process of making monophrams into diphthongs is diphthongization. Example: The word for house in most Germanic languages was 'us,' but in West Germanic dialects, the 'u' diphthongized into 'r' or 'l'.
  • Monophramization: The reverse of diphthongization. A diphthong is reduced to a simple vowel.
  • Palatization: A sound change in which a consonant is articulated near the palate. It involves moving the tongue towards the hard palate. For example, a 'G' sound moving towards the palate may become a 'J' sound, or a 'K' sound becoming a 'C'. It often happens because you have a front vowel E or A.

Dialectal Continuum

  • Language borders are rare within the same language family; instead, there is a gradual change from one language to another.
  • This gradual shift creates dialects, as seen in the shift from Kent to Thurzo, creating dialects like Geordie and Glaswegian.
  • English, with its Germanic origins, fits into this gradual shift.

West Germanic Dialects

  • Comparison of Old English with present-day languages like Frisian, Dutch, and Low German.

Impact of the Norman Conquest

  • The Norman Conquest fundamentally changed English, adding French influences.
  • The claim is that without the Norman Conquest, English might resemble Dutch more closely.

Continental West Germanic Dialects

  • Historically, there was a dialectical continuum stretching from areas near Austria and South Tyrol to areas where North Germanic languages are spoken.
  • Four Main Classes
    • High German: Spoken in higher altitudes.
    • Low German: Spoken in low mountain areas. Historically includes dialects such as Dutch, Flemish.
    • Middle German: Between High and Low German, with features of both.
    • Frisian: Spoken along the North Sea coast between the Netherlands and Denmark.

Differences Between English and High German

  • Loss of Post-Vocalic Consonant Clusters: In Old English, post-vocalic consonant clusters disappeared, while they remained in Old High German.
    • Example: soft (Old English) vs. sanfter (Old High German).
  • Second Germanic Consonant Shift: Primarily affects High German, not Low German or English.
    • Involves changes to consonants such as P, T, K, which become affricates or fricatives.
    • Example: ship (English) vs. chef (German), water (English) vs. Wasser (German), make (English) vs. machen (German).
  • Effects on Dental Fricatives: Initial dental fricatives (like