Financial Analysis and Decision Making: Time Value of Money

Core Foundations of Time Value of Money

  • Definition: The time value of money (TVM) is a foundational financial principle stating that a unit of currency available at the present time is worth more than the same unit of currency received in the future due to its potential earning capacity.
  • Key Factors Explaining the Time Value of Money:
    • Risk: Uncertainty surrounds future cash flows or expected returns. Unforeseen future developments or economic changes can prevent anticipated benefits from materializing.
    • Inflation: The general and sustained rise in overall price levels over time, which erodes purchasing power and increases nominal interest rates.
    • Opportunity Cost: The lost opportunity or potential financial benefit foregone when selecting one particular investment or financial option over a competing alternative.

Simple Interest vs. Compound Interest

  • Simple Interest:

    • Interest generated or paid strictly on the original principal amount invested or borrowed.
    • Interest earned in prior periods is not added to the principal balance and does not earn additional interest.
    • Formula:     I=PV×r×nI = PV \times r \times n
    • II = Total interest earned
    • PVPV = Principal or present value sum invested
    • rr = Annual interest rate (expressed as a decimal)
    • nn = Number of interest-bearing periods (typically years)
    • Example Calculation:
    • Principal invested (PVPV): £1,000\pounds 1{,}000
    • Interest rate (rr): 10%=0.1010\% = 0.10
    • Time horizon (nn): 5 years5\text{ years}
    • Annual interest earned: £1,000×0.10=£100\pounds 1{,}000 \times 0.10 = \pounds 100
    • Total interest earned over 5 years: I=(£1,000×0.10)×5=£500I = (\pounds 1{,}000 \times 0.10) \times 5 = \pounds 500
    • Total ending balance: £1,000+£500=£1,500\pounds 1{,}000 + \pounds 500 = \pounds 1{,}500
  • Compound Interest:

    • Interest calculated on both the original principal sum and the cumulative reinvested interest earned from prior periods.
    • Formula:     FV=PV×(1+r)nFV = PV \times (1 + r)^n
    • FVFV = Future value
    • PVPV = Present value
    • rr = Annual interest rate
    • nn = Number of interest-bearing periods (years)
    • Year-by-Year Schedule (\pounds 1,000 invested at 10% for 5 years):     | Year | Balance at Start of Year | Interest Earned in Year | Total Cumulative Interest | Balance at End of Year |     | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |     | 1 | £1,000.00\pounds 1{,}000.00 | £100.00\pounds 100.00 | £100.00\pounds 100.00 | £1,100.00\pounds 1{,}100.00 |     | 2 | £1,100.00\pounds 1{,}100.00 | £110.00\pounds 110.00 | £210.00\pounds 210.00 | £1,210.00\pounds 1{,}210.00 |     | 3 | £1,210.00\pounds 1{,}210.00 | £121.00\pounds 121.00 | £331.00\pounds 331.00 | £1,331.00\pounds 1{,}331.00 |     | 4 | £1,331.00\pounds 1{,}331.00 | £133.10\pounds 133.10 | £464.10\pounds 464.10 | £1,464.10\pounds 1{,}464.10 |     | 5 | £1,464.10\pounds 1{,}464.10 | £146.41\pounds 146.41 | £610.51\pounds 610.51 | £1,610.51\pounds 1{,}610.51 |
    • Total Interest Earned: £610.51\pounds 610.51
    • Formula Calculation:     FV=£1,000×(1+0.10)5=£1,610.51FV = \pounds 1{,}000 \times (1 + 0.10)^5 = \pounds 1{,}610.51FV=£1,000×1.10×1.10×1.10×1.10×1.10=£1,610.51FV = \pounds 1{,}000 \times 1.10 \times 1.10 \times 1.10 \times 1.10 \times 1.10 = \pounds 1{,}610.51
    • Financial Benefit of Compounding:
    • Depositing funds under compound interest yields an additional £110.51\pounds 110.51 (£1,610.51−£1,500.00\pounds 1{,}610.51 - \pounds 1{,}500.00) compared to simple interest over a five-year period.

Impact of Compounding Frequencies

  • Compounding can take place at various frequencies within a year (e.g., daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually).
  • General Intra-Year Compounding Formula:   FV=PV×(1+rm)n×mFV = PV \times \left(1 + \frac{r}{m}\right)^{n \times m}
    • mm = Number of compounding periods per year
  • Comparative Example (£1,000\pounds 1{,}000 principal at 10%10\% interest over 5 years5\text{ years}):
    • Annual Compounding (m=1m = 1):     FV=1,000×(1+0.10)5=£1,610.51FV = 1{,}000 \times (1 + 0.10)^5 = \pounds 1{,}610.51
    • Half-Yearly / Semi-Annual Compounding (m=2m = 2):     FV=1,000×(1+0.102)5×2=1,000×(1.05)10=£1,628.89FV = 1{,}000 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.10}{2}\right)^{5 \times 2} = 1{,}000 \times (1.05)^{10} = \pounds 1{,}628.89
    • Quarterly Compounding (m=4m = 4):     FV=1,000×(1+0.104)5×4=1,000×(1.025)20=£1,638.62FV = 1{,}000 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.10}{4}\right)^{5 \times 4} = 1{,}000 \times (1.025)^{20} = \pounds 1{,}638.62
    • Monthly Compounding (m=12m = 12):     FV=1,000×(1+0.1012)5×12=£1,645.31FV = 1{,}000 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.10}{12}\right)^{5 \times 12} = \pounds 1{,}645.31
    • Weekly Compounding (m=52m = 52):     FV=1,000×(1+0.1052)5×52=£1,647.93FV = 1{,}000 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.10}{52}\right)^{5 \times 52} = \pounds 1{,}647.93
    • Daily Compounding (m=365m = 365):     FV=1,000×(1+0.10365)5×365=£1,648.61FV = 1{,}000 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.10}{365}\right)^{5 \times 365} = \pounds 1{,}648.61

Discounting Cash Flows and Present Value

  • Discounting Concept: The mathematical process of determining the present value of a future cash flow by adjusting it backward in time using a specific discount rate.
  • Present Value Formula:   PV=FV(1+r)nPV = \frac{FV}{(1 + r)^n}
  • Intra-Year Discounting Formula:   PV=FV(1+rm)n×mPV = \frac{FV}{\left(1 + \frac{r}{m}\right)^{n \times m}}
  • Comparative Example (£100,000\pounds 100{,}000 target savings goal in 5 years5\text{ years} at a 10%10\% discount rate):
    • Annual Discounting (m=1m = 1):     PV=£100,000(1+0.10)5=£62,092.13PV = \frac{\pounds 100{,}000}{(1 + 0.10)^5} = \pounds 62{,}092.13
    • Quarterly Discounting (m=4m = 4):     PV=£100,000(1+0.104)5×4=£61,027.10PV = \frac{\pounds 100{,}000}{\left(1 + \frac{0.10}{4}\right)^{5 \times 4}} = \pounds 61{,}027.10
    • Monthly Discounting (m=12m = 12):     PV=£100,000(1+0.1012)5×12=£60,778.87PV = \frac{\pounds 100{,}000}{\left(1 + \frac{0.10}{12}\right)^{5 \times 12}} = \pounds 60{,}778.87
    • Weekly Discounting (m=52m = 52):     PV=£100,000(1+0.1052)5×52=£60,682.19PV = \frac{\pounds 100{,}000}{\left(1 + \frac{0.10}{52}\right)^{5 \times 52}} = \pounds 60{,}682.19
    • Daily Discounting (m=365m = 365):     PV=£100,000(1+0.10365)5×365=£60,657.18PV = \frac{\pounds 100{,}000}{\left(1 + \frac{0.10}{365}\right)^{5 \times 365}} = \pounds 60{,}657.18

Applied Exercises and Solutions

  • Exercise 1: Future Value of a Single Deposit

    • Problem: Calculate the future value of $400\$400 deposited at an annual interest rate of 6%6\% for 4 years4\text{ years}.
    • Solution:     FV=400×(1.06)4=400×1.262477=$504.99FV = 400 \times (1.06)^4 = 400 \times 1.262477 = \$504.99
  • Exercise 2: Present Value Calculation

    • Problem: Calculate the present value of $5,000\$5{,}000 at an interest rate of 10%10\% for 10 years10\text{ years}.
    • Solution:     PV = \frac{\5{,}000}{(1 + 0.10)^{10}} = \frac{\5{,}000}{2.593742} = \$1{,}927.72
  • Exercise 3: End-of-Year vs. Beginning-of-Year Uneven Cash Flows

    • Problem: Uneven annual cash deposits of $100\$100 in Year 1, $200\$200 in Year 2, and $300\$300 in Year 3 are made at an interest rate of 10%10\%. Calculate the total accumulated value at the end of Year 3.
    • Case 1: Deposits made at the END of each year:
    • Year 1 cash flow compounds for 2 years: \100 \times (1.10)^2 = \121121
    • Year 2 cash flow compounds for 1 year: \200 \times (1.10)^1 = \220220
    • Year 3 cash flow compounds for 0 years: \300 \times (1.10)^0 = \300300
    • Total Future Value: $121+$220+$300=$641\$121 + \$220 + \$300 = \$641
    • Case 2: Deposits made at the BEGINNING of each year:
    • Year 1 cash flow compounds for 3 years: \100 \times (1.10)^3 = \133133
    • Year 2 cash flow compounds for 2 years: \200 \times (1.10)^2 = \242242
    • Year 3 cash flow compounds for 1 year: \300 \times (1.10)^1 = \330330
    • Total Future Value: $133+$242+$330=$705\$133 + \$242 + \$330 = \$705
  • Exercise 4: Semi-Annual Compounding vs. Monthly Discounting

    • Problem: A deposit of $100\$100 is made for 5 years5\text{ years} at an annual interest rate of 7%7\%. Calculate the future value with semi-annual compounding, and the present value with monthly discounting.
    • Solution:
    • Semi-Annual Future Value:       FV=100×(1+0.072)5×2=100×(1.035)10=$141.06FV = 100 \times \left(1 + \frac{0.07}{2}\right)^{5 \times 2} = 100 \times (1.035)^{10} = \$141.06
    • Monthly Present Value:       PV=100(1+0.0712)5×12=100(1.005833)60=$70.54PV = \frac{100}{\left(1 + \frac{0.07}{12}\right)^{5 \times 12}} = \frac{100}{(1.005833)^{60}} = \$70.54
  • Exercise 5: Investment Cash Flow Valuations

    • Cash Flow Schedule: Year 1 = $10,000\$10{,}000; Year 2 = $25,000\$25{,}000; Year 3 = $140,000\$140{,}000. Required cost/interest rate = 8%8\%
    • Case 1: Present Value with End-of-Period Payments:
    • Year 1 PV: $10,000(1+0.08)1=$9,259.26\frac{\$10{,}000}{(1 + 0.08)^1} = \$9{,}259.26
    • Year 2 PV: $25,000(1+0.08)2=$21,433.47\frac{\$25{,}000}{(1 + 0.08)^2} = \$21{,}433.47
    • Year 3 PV: $140,000(1+0.08)3=$111,138.96\frac{\$140{,}000}{(1 + 0.08)^3} = \$111{,}138.96
    • Total Present Value: $9,259.26+$21,433.47+$111,138.96=$141,831.69\$9{,}259.26 + \$21{,}433.47 + \$111{,}138.96 = \$141{,}831.69
    • Case 2: Future Value of Cash Flows at End of Year 3:
    • Year 1 FV: \10{,}000 \times (1.08)^2 = \11,66411{,}664
    • Year 2 FV: \25{,}000 \times (1.08)^1 = \27,00027{,}000
    • Year 3 FV: \140{,}000 \times (1.08)^0 = \140,000140{,}000
    • Total Future Value: $11,664+$27,000+$140,000=$178,664\$11{,}664 + \$27{,}000 + \$140{,}000 = \$178{,}664
    • Case 3: Present Value with Beginning-of-Period Payments:
    • Year 1 PV (time t=0t=0): $10,000(1+0.08)0=$10,000\frac{\$10{,}000}{(1 + 0.08)^0} = \$10{,}000
    • Year 2 PV (time t=1t=1): $25,000(1+0.08)1=$23,148.15\frac{\$25{,}000}{(1 + 0.08)^1} = \$23{,}148.15
    • Year 3 PV (time t=2t=2): $140,000(1+0.08)2=$120,027.43\frac{\$140{,}000}{(1 + 0.08)^2} = \$120{,}027.43
    • Total Present Value: $10,000+$23,148.15+$120,027.43=$153,175.58\$10{,}000 + \$23{,}148.15 + \$120{,}027.43 = \$153{,}175.58

Annuities and Perpetuities

  • Annuity Definition: A series of equal periodic cash flows over a specified period. Cash flows may be inflows (returns earned) or outflows (investments made).

  • Classification of Annuities:

    • Ordinary (Deferred) Annuity: Cash flows occur at the end of each period.
    • Annuity Due: Cash flows occur at the beginning of each period.
    • Comparative Principle: An annuity due always yields a higher value than an equivalent ordinary annuity because every payment compounds for one additional period.
  • Future Value of an Ordinary Annuity:

    • Formula:     FVn=CF×{[(1+r)n−1]r}FV_n = CF \times \left\{ \frac{[(1 + r)^n - 1]}{r} \right\}
    • Application Example (Fran Abrams):
    • Fran Abrams wants to determine the total accumulated amount at the end of 5 years5\text{ years} for an ordinary annuity paying $1,000\$1{,}000 annually at an interest rate of 7%7\%
    • Formula Valuation:       FV_5 = \1{,}000 \times \left\{ \frac{[(1 + 0.07)^5 - 1]}{0.07} \right\} = \5,750.745{,}750.74
    • Detailed Cash Flow Compounding Breakdown:
      • Year 1 Payment ($1,000\$1{,}000): Compounds 4 years \rightarrow \1{,}000 \times (1.07)^4 = \1,310.801{,}310.80
      • Year 2 Payment ($1,000\$1{,}000): Compounds 3 years \rightarrow \1{,}000 \times (1.07)^3 = \1,225.041{,}225.04
      • Year 3 Payment ($1,000\$1{,}000): Compounds 2 years \rightarrow \1{,}000 \times (1.07)^2 = \1,144.901{,}144.90
      • Year 4 Payment ($1,000\$1{,}000): Compounds 1 year \rightarrow \1{,}000 \times (1.07)^1 = \1,070.001{,}070.00
      • Year 5 Payment ($1,000\$1{,}000): Compounds 0 years \rightarrow \1{,}000 \times (1.07)^0 = \1,000.001{,}000.00
      • Combined Sum: $5,750.74\$5{,}750.74

Future Value of an Ordinary Annuity Timeline

  • Present Value of an Ordinary Annuity:
    • Formula:     PVn=(CFr)×[1−1(1+r)n]PV_n = \left(\frac{CF}{r}\right) \times \left[ 1 - \frac{1}{(1 + r)^n} \right]
    • Application Example (Braden Company):
    • Braden Company wants to purchase an ordinary annuity paying $700\$700 at the end of each year for 5 years5\text{ years} at a required return of 8%8\%
    • Formula Valuation:       PV=7000.08×[1−1(1+0.08)5]=$2,794.90PV = \frac{700}{0.08} \times \left[ 1 - \frac{1}{(1 + 0.08)^5} \right] = \$2{,}794.90
    • Year-by-Year Discounting Method:       | Year (nn) | Cash Flow | Present Value Formula | Present Value |       | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |       | 1 | $700\$700 | 700(1+0.08)1\frac{700}{(1 + 0.08)^1} | $648.15\$648.15 |       | 2 | $700\$700 | 700(1+0.08)2\frac{700}{(1 + 0.08)^2} | $600.14\$600.14 |       | 3 | $700\$700 | 700(1+0.08)3\frac{700}{(1 + 0.08)^3} | $555.68\$555.68 |       | 4 | $700\$700 | 700(1+0.08)4\frac{700}{(1 + 0.08)^4} | $514.52\$514.52 |       | 5 | $700\$700 | 700(1+0.08)5\frac{700}{(1 + 0.08)^5} | $476.41\$476.41 |       | Total | | | $2,794.90\$2{,}794.90 |

Present Value of an Ordinary Annuity Timeline

  • Future Value of an Annuity Due:

    • Formula:     FVn=CF×{[(1+r)n−1]r}×(1+r)FV_n = CF \times \left\{ \frac{[(1 + r)^n - 1]}{r} \right\} \times (1 + r)
  • Present Value of an Annuity Due:

    • Formula:     PVn=(CFr)×[1−1(1+r)n]×(1+r)PV_n = \left(\frac{CF}{r}\right) \times \left[ 1 - \frac{1}{(1 + r)^n} \right] \times (1 + r)
  • Perpetuities:

    • Definition: An annuity with an infinite lifespan that provides a constant annual cash flow indefinitely.
    • Formula:     PV=CFrPV = \frac{CF}{r}
    • Application Example (Ross Clark Chair Endowment):
    • Ross Clark wishes to endow a university chair in finance requiring $200,000\$200{,}000 per year indefinitely. The endowment account earns an annual interest rate of 10%10\%
    • Calculation:       PV=$200,0000.10=$2,000,000PV = \frac{\$200{,}000}{0.10} = \$2{,}000{,}000
    • A initial gift of $2,000,000\$2{,}000{,}000 is required to fund the chair in perpetuity.