Performance Management in the Civil Service

General Overview and Definitions of Performance Management

  • Performance Management (PM) is defined by University of Kansas (KU Human Resource Management) as an ongoing, continuous process of communicating and clarifying job responsibilities, priorities, performance expectations, and development planning that optimize an individual’s performance and aligns with organizational strategic goals.

  • McKenzy & Company (Performance Management) defines it as an essential business strategy whereby both formal and informal processes are deployed to help align their employees, resources, and systems to meet their strategic objectives. Organizations that get PM right become formidable competitive machines.

  • According to Aguinis (2007), PM is a continuous process of identifying, measuring, and developing the performance of individuals and teams and aligning performance with the strategic goals of the organization.

  • Henry Ford famously noted: ‘Coming together is a beginning; keeping together is progress; working together is success.’

Performance Management (PM) in the Public Service

  • Performance Management in the Public Service is a continuous process by which Managers/Directors, Supervisors, and team members work together to plan, monitor, review, and assess targets which contribute to the overall strategic goals and plans of an organization and also develop the knowledge, capacity, and skills of staff.

  • Actors responsible for PM include:

    • Senior Management (Minister, Chief Director).

    • Department Directors (and analogous grades) and below.

    • HR – serving as Organizer/Reporting unit.

    • Managers, Directors, and Supervisors.

    • Team members.

    • Full-staff participation is required across the board.

Objectives and Principles of the PM System

  • The primary objectives of the PM system are to:

    • Ensure effective and efficient public service delivery to the citizenry.

    • Increase transparency and accountability in public service delivery.

    • Provide a reliable, dispassionate means to assess the level and quality of work done by staff and officers.

    • Confirm competencies and identify capacity gaps.

  • Principles governing PM include:

    • Strengthening the linkage between the Director/Supervisor/Head of Department’s Agreement/Targets and the Staff Performance Appraisal to the Sector Medium Term Development Plan (SMTDP) and Minister’s Priorities.

    • Strengthening the usage of basic PM tools, such as the setting of targets.

    • Emphasizing results-oriented and output targets.

    • Measuring critical process inputs as well as output indicators.

    • Creating a cordial and productive working relationship between Supervisor/Appraiser and Appraisee.

    • Maintaining a progressive process where instruments are reviewed annually to capture emerging Public Sector reforms.

Elements of a Performance Driven Culture

  • A performance-driven culture is an organizational culture wherein the entire organization is driven by a motivation to perform and achieve organizational success.

  • Key elements include:

    • An established legal framework for Performance Management.

    • Self-motivated staff with a sense of continuous learning.

    • A 360-degree feedback system involving Managers/Directors/Appraisers, Appraisees/Evaluees, Subordinates, and Clients.

    • Addressing demand needs leading to career development.

    • An effective reward and sanction regime.

    • An established Performance Improvement Plan.

Strategic Alignment and Legal Basis

  • PM is linked to the National Development Framework through a hierarchy:

    • 1. Sector Medium Term Development Plans (SMTDPs), SDGs, and SONA.

    • 2. Institutional Annual Action Plan.

    • 3. Chief Director Performance Agreement.

    • 4. Deputy Clerk / Directors Performance Agreement.

    • 5. Staff Appraisal.

  • The legal basis for the PM system is rooted in:

    • Civil Service Act 1993 (PNDCL 327):

    • Section 7: Mandates the Head of Civil Service (HCS) to ensure general efficiency.

    • Section 88: Establishes the recognition and award system for meritorious performance (Sub-sections 1 & 2).

    • Public Sector Performance Management Policy.

    • National Public Sector Reform Strategy.

PM Measurement Tools and Implementation Phases

  • Performance Assessment Tools used include:

    • Performance Agreements: Used for Chief Directors, Directors, and Heads of Departments/Institutions.

    • Staff Performance Appraisal Instrument (SPAI): Used for Assistant Deputy Directors (and analogous grades) and below.

  • PM Implementation Phases:

    • 1. Performance Planning.

    • 2. Mid-Year Review.

    • 3. End-of-Year Assessment.

    • 4. Decision Making.

History of PM Reforms in the Civil Service

  • 1997 - 2007: PM was limited to Department Directors and synonymous grades; there was an absence of a rigorous framework for lower grades.

  • 2013 / 14: Adopted the Public Service Commission’s (PSC) Staff Performance Appraisal Form for Deputy Directors and below; Agreements were signed by Directors and Chief Directors.

  • 2020: Revised and customized PM tools (Agreements and Appraisal Instruments) to respond to emerging issues and feedback.

  • 2021: Rolled out the Revised PM tools and developed the E-SPAR platform.

  • 2022 - 2024: Piloted E-SPAR in 12 Ministries and 8 Departments in 2022. It has been running at full scale since 2023.

The Staff Performance Appraisal (SPAR) Implementation Process

  • Planning Phase: Issue circulars, set targets, and prepare composite planning reports. Appraiser and Appraisee meet to define specific job schedules, review competencies, and agree on a Learning Plan.

  • Mid-Year Phase: Issue circulars; review, expunge, or maintain targets; prepare composite mid-year reports. Discuss progress of work, competency development, and status of learning programs.

  • End-of-Year Phase: Issue circulars; Appraiser assesses Appraisee awarded scores; prepare composite Planning (Assessment) report.

  • Decision-Making Phase: Management uses scores for Rewards, Sanctions, Learning and Career Development plans, and promotion prospects.

Components of the Staff Performance Appraisal Instrument

  • Performance Targeting & Reporting:

    • Focus Areas must be indicated for various staff categories.

    • Targets must be derived from Directorate/Department/Unit Action Plans and job descriptions.

    • Targets must be SMART.

    • Resources required must be listed.

  • Competencies: Broad competencies must be stated with clear descriptions.

  • Staff Learning Plan:

    • Programmes to enhance competencies.

    • Includes: Academic courses, Scheme of Service related courses, workshops, conferences, on-the-job training, knowledge sharing fora, personal readings, book reviews, webinars, coaching, and mentoring.

Performance Assessment Grading and Criteria

  • The End-of-Year Assessment includes:

    • 1. Appraisee’s Self-Assessment.

    • 2. Performance Assessment.

    • 3. Competencies Assessment.

    • 4. Overall Scores awarded.

  • Performance Rating Scale:

    • Excellent: 85 - 100

    • Very Good: 75 - 84

    • Good: 65 - 74

    • Satisfactory: 50 - 64

    • Unsatisfactory: 49 and below

Key Definitions and PM Pitfalls

  • Focus Area: Broad thematic areas consistent with Ministry mandates/SDGs. Parameters: max 7 keywords, sector-specific nouns (e.g., Implementation, Monitoring), institutional-specific technical terminology. It must last over long assessment periods.

  • Target: Key output expected via specific activities. Must be SMART:

    • S - Specific: Use active verbs like compile, prepare, produce.

    • M - Measurable: Numerical or period-based (e.g., 2, 4, Quarterly).

    • A - Achievable/Attainable: Resources are available and within jurisdiction.

    • R - Realistic: Capacity exists to undertake the scope.

    • T - Time-bound: A set finality/deadline.

  • Output: Final pictorial, video, or documentary evidence of achievement.

  • Outcome: Immediate results achieving the output, leading to the Focus Area.

  • Common PM Pitfalls:

    • Poor metrics (weak link between targets and organization objectives).

    • Deficient target setting.

    • Lack of effective dialogue between Appraiser and Appraisee.

    • Failure to carry out Performance Improvement Plans for non-performing staff.

The Ghana Civil Service: Composition and Mandate

  • Definition: The bureaucratic wing of governmnent responsible for policy formulation and implementation.

  • Composition: 23 Ministries, 2 Extra-Ministerial Organizations (Office of the President, Office of the Head of the Civil Service), and 27 Departments.

  • Values: Bureaucratic, Hierarchical, Anonymity, Loyalty, Neutrality.

  • OHCS Motto: Loyalty, Excellence, Service.

  • Constitutional Mandate: Listed under Article 190 (1) (a) of the 1992 Constitution. Article 193 requires the President to appoint the Head of Civil Service. Local Government Service was decoupled in 2011.

  • Membership: Includes persons in designated Civil Service posts in the Office of the President, Ministries, and Departments at the national level whose emoluments are paid directly from the Consolidated Fund.

Strategic Importance and Emerging Challenges

  • The development of Ghana depends largely on Civil Service performance.

  • A robust PM system creates an adaptive, agile, and innovative civil service to address modern issues:

    • Inadequate infrastructure and low productivity.

    • Skill and capacity gaps.

    • High youth unemployment.

    • Insecurity and threats of terrorism.

    • Environmental pollution and global warming/climate change.