Study Notes on Government and the Economy: Redistribution of Income
GOVERNMENT AND THE ECONOMY
REDISTRIBUTION OF INCOME
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
- Definitions:
- Income Inequality: Differences in income that exist between different groups of earners in society, illustrating the gap between the rich and the poor.
- Absolute Poverty: Individuals required to survive on less than $1.90 per day, as defined by the World Bank.
- Relative Poverty: Defined relatively to existing living standards; individuals at the bottom of a nation’s income scale.
- Reasons for Reducing Poverty and Inequality:
- Moral duty and ethical considerations.
- Economic benefits from improved living standards across the population.
- Government Intervention to Reduce Inequality and Poverty:
- Progressive Taxation: Tax rates increase as income increases.
- Redistribution through Benefits: Government welfare payments to support low-income individuals.
- Investments in Education and Healthcare: Improve opportunities for the underprivileged.
CASE STUDY: THE BIRNBAUM FAMILY
- Residence: Florida, USA.
- Property: Six-bedroom house valued at $4.1 million in 2012.
- Income:
- Mrs. Birnbaum: $1 million - $1.6 million per annum as an investment banker.
- Mr. Birnbaum: Approx. $700,000 per annum as a partner in an accounting firm.
- Family Expenses: Children attend private school costing $40,000 per term; ownership of four cars and a yacht.
GETTING STARTED
- Comparison of Living Standards:
- Developed Nations: Good standards of living, ownership of property, vehicles, consumer durables, and regular leisure activities.
- Developing Nations: High poverty, basic needs unmet, lack of clean water, and minimal possessions.
- Case Study: The Gwengwe Family in Malawi:
- Living conditions: Mud hut with no consistent income; food scarcity; reliance on aid.
- Children: No education or healthcare; one child died from an infection linked to contaminated water.
INCOME INEQUALITY
- Examples of Income Levels:
- France:
- Shop Assistant: €17,600 p.a. (minimum wage).
- Teacher: €48,000 p.a.
- Company Director: €2.4 million p.a.
- In the USA (2014 Data):
- Top 0.1%: Average income = $6,087,113.
- Bottom 90%: Average income = $33,068.
- Ratio: Top earners earn over 184 times that of the bottom 90%.
ABSOLUTE POVERTY
- Definition: Lack of sufficient resources to meet basic human needs including food, water, and shelter.
- In 2015, 702 million people (9.6% of the global population) lived in absolute poverty, down from 902 million in 2012.
- Geographical Distribution: Many of these individuals reside in Africa and Asia.
- Statistical Data: Recorded by the World Bank and represented through figures depicting the decline in absolute poverty over the years.
RELATIVE POVERTY
- Definition: Measured relative to average living standards; lack of income compared to the median income levels.
- EU Threshold: Individuals earning below 60% of the median income are considered in relative poverty.
- Example: In an EU country with a median income of €21,500, a household income of €11,400 indicates relative poverty, as it is below €12,900 (60% of median).
- Variation Over Time: Changes in median income can shift the relative poverty benchmarks over time.
RAISE LIVING STANDARDS
- Impact of Reducing Poverty: Leads to higher living standards overall.
- Health Implications: Individuals in relative poverty have lower life expectancy and higher susceptibility to health problems.
- Economic Benefits: A workforce adequately educated is more productive, leading to higher GDP and increased tax revenue for public services.
ETHICAL REASONS FOR REDUCING INEQUALITY
- Moral Duty: Beliefs that reducing inequality is a shared responsibility of individuals and governments.
- Example Calculation: A contribution of US$2,300 by the Birnbaum family could lift the Gwengwe family out of absolute poverty.
- Wealth Disparities: Notable discrepancies in GDP per head between wealthy and poor nations highlighted.
REASONS TO REDUCE POVERTY AND INEQUALITY
- Basic Needs Fulfillment: Essential for survival; affects food security.
- Undernourishment Rates: High in countries like Zambia (47.8%) and Central African Republic (47.7%).
- Child Mortality: High rates of childhood deaths due to starvation and correlated health issues.
- Economic Productivity: Meeting basic needs can lead to a healthier, more productive workforce.
GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION TO REDUCE POVERTY AND INEQUALITY
- Economic Growth Link: Growth does not eliminate inequality, but reduces overall poverty.
- Measures to Address Inequality:
- Progressive Taxation: Higher taxes on the rich to redistribute effectively.
- Redistribution through Benefits: Direct payments to the most vulnerable populations.
- Investment in Education and Healthcare:
- Education improves employability and life skills.
- Access to health services reduces child mortality and improves economic productivity.
CASE STUDY: PROGRESSIVE TAX IN FRANCE
- Tax rate structure in 2016:
- Up to €9,700: 0% tax.
- €9,701 to €26,791: 14% tax.
- €26,792 to €71,826: 30% tax.
- €71,827 to €152,108: 41% tax.
- Over €151,109: 45% tax.
- Calculation: Tax based on income illustrates the progressive nature.
CASE STUDY: POVERTY IN INDIA
- Current Statistics: Approx. 30% living in absolute poverty, or 224 million individuals (2016).
- Government Initiatives: Increased funding towards education, focusing on poverty reduction through literacy and infrastructural improvements.
- GDP Trends: Significant economic growth indicated by rising GDP per capita from US$300 in the 1960s to nearly US$1800 in 2016.
KEY STATISTICS
- Child Mortality due to Starvation: 3.1 million children died in 2011 (45% of total child deaths).
- Literacy Rates: Improved from 52% in 1995 to 75% in 2016.
- Infrastructure Improvement: Electrification in rural areas leading to socioeconomic growth.
CHAPTER QUESTIONS
- Define absolute poverty.
- Analyze why poverty in India has decreased, providing two reasons.
- Discuss how investment in education can mitigate poverty.
- Why is it important to further reduce poverty in India? Provide at least two reasons in your analysis.