Chapter 2
SELF ESTEEM AND PSYCHOLOGICAL CONCEPTS
Terms Related to Self Esteem:
Firmness
Veneration
Approbativeness
Conscientiousness
Hope
Friendship
Cunning Love
Cautiousness
Combativeness
Sublimity
Spirituality
Secretiveness
Benevolence
Imitation
Ideality
Constructiveness
Suavity
Human Causality
Mirthfulness
Amativeness
Vitality
Historical, Cultural, and Ethical Considerations in Psychological Testing
Psychological Tests from a Historical Perspective
Major Points Covered:
The history and evolution of psychological tests
Cultural considerations affecting testing
Legal and ethical frameworks surrounding psychological assessments
Learning Objectives
Key Learning Goals:
Utilize historical knowledge of psychological testing to understand its significance over time.
Consider cultural factors in the context of testing information use.
Comprehend the legal and ethical considerations central to psychological assessments.
Historical Perspective on Psychological Testing
19th Century Origins:
Psychological assessments formally emerged.
Francis Galton (1869): Influential in measuring individual differences.
Wilhelm Wundt (1832-1920): Established the first experimental psychology lab focused on measurement.
James McKeen Cattell (1888): Coined the term "mental test," pioneering modern intelligence testing.
20th Century Developments:
First actual tests of abilities and intelligence were developed.
Binet and Simon (1905): Created the first intelligence test for children.
David Wechsler (1939): Developed an intelligence test for adults.
Psychological assessments began being adopted across various settings:
Educational institutions
Clinical settings
Legal frameworks like courts
Hospitals and prisons
Group intelligence testing was prominent during WWI and WWII for military recruitment.
Post-WWII, psychological tests expanded into corporate and private use.
Testing Landscape by 1930s:
Over 4,000 psychological tests published.
Woodworth Psychoneurotic Inventory:
This was the first widely adopted self-report personality test.
Self-Report Features:
Advantages: Easy data collection and insight into subjective experiences.
Disadvantages: Susceptible to bias; relies on self-perception.
Projective Tests:
Focused on how individuals project their needs and emotions onto ambiguous stimuli.
Example: Hermann Rorschach's Inkblot Test (1921).
Cultural Considerations in Psychological Testing
Test Bias and Test-Related Discrimination
Understanding Culture in Psychological Testing:
Culture defined as the socially transmitted behaviors, values, beliefs, and products.
Historically, cultural differences were often ignored in psychological assessments.
Example of Ignored Cultural Bias:
Henry Goddard's classification of immigrant populations as “feeble-minded.”
Importance of recognizing cultural influence on psychological testing.
Specific Cultural Considerations
Verbal Communication Issues:
Absence of equivalent terms/events can skew assessments.
Specialized vocabulary in psychology may require trained interpreters.
Dialects and linguistic nuances can lead to misunderstandings.
Non-Verbal Communication and Behavior:
Interpretation of non-verbal cues varies by culture.
Differences in types, urgency, and pacing of behavior across cultural contexts.
Standards of Evaluation:
Evaluative judgments can be culturally relative, leading to biased assessments.
Variations in views about gender roles and mental health issues across cultures.
Conformity and collective goals valued in collectivist cultures versus independence in individualistic cultures.
Cultural Formulation Interview:
This is a semi-structured interview that complements DSM-5 symptom assessments.
Comprises 16 questions and was field-tested on 321 participants by clinicians across six countries.
Legal and Ethical Considerations in Psychological Testing
Legal Frameworks
Definitions:
Laws: Rules that societies are obligated to follow.
Ethics: Principles guiding proper conduct.
Ethical Guidelines in Assessment
Psychological testing is managed by a code of professional ethics, which shapes appropriate conduct in assessments.
Public Policy Implications:
Laws like the Every Student Succeeds Act (2015) and Common Core State Standards (2010) impact how assessments are conducted.
Historical legislations have shaped the approach to psychological assessments:
Minimal Competency Testing (1970s): Ensured high school graduates met essential standards.
Truth in Testing (1980s): Mandated clarity on evaluation standards affecting test-takers.
Civil Rights Act of 1964: Received guidelines for creating and implementing psychological tests.
Roles of Psychologists in Society
Significant Roles Include:
Acting as expert witnesses in civil and criminal matters.
Daubert Ruling: Provides judges broader discretion in determining what constitutes valid scientific evidence.
Frye Standard (1923): Dictates that scientific evidence must be widely accepted in the relevant scientific community.
Conducting fitness evaluations and high-stakes psychological assessments, such as those related to Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act (ODDA).
Considerations for Testing Privileges
Key Ethical Questions:
Who should have access to psychological test data?
Who can purchase psychological test materials?
Who is qualified to administer, score, and interpret psychological assessments?
Should testing privileges be regulated at all?
Test-Taker Rights and Ethical Protocols
Informed Consent:
Important for ensuring individuals understand the testing process.
Certain groups may lack the capacity for informed consent, which must be assessed based on choice, understanding, and rationality.
Rights to test results and maintaining confidentiality of test data, even when it is not guaranteed.
Use of the least stigmatizing labels in sharing assessment outcomes.