Chapter 2

SELF ESTEEM AND PSYCHOLOGICAL CONCEPTS

  • Terms Related to Self Esteem:

    • Firmness

    • Veneration

    • Approbativeness

    • Conscientiousness

    • Hope

    • Friendship

    • Cunning Love

    • Cautiousness

    • Combativeness

    • Sublimity

    • Spirituality

    • Secretiveness

    • Benevolence

    • Imitation

    • Ideality

    • Constructiveness

    • Suavity

    • Human Causality

    • Mirthfulness

    • Amativeness

    • Vitality

Historical, Cultural, and Ethical Considerations in Psychological Testing

Psychological Tests from a Historical Perspective

  • Major Points Covered:

    • The history and evolution of psychological tests

    • Cultural considerations affecting testing

    • Legal and ethical frameworks surrounding psychological assessments

Learning Objectives

  • Key Learning Goals:

    • Utilize historical knowledge of psychological testing to understand its significance over time.

    • Consider cultural factors in the context of testing information use.

    • Comprehend the legal and ethical considerations central to psychological assessments.

Historical Perspective on Psychological Testing

  • 19th Century Origins:

    • Psychological assessments formally emerged.

    • Francis Galton (1869): Influential in measuring individual differences.

    • Wilhelm Wundt (1832-1920): Established the first experimental psychology lab focused on measurement.

    • James McKeen Cattell (1888): Coined the term "mental test," pioneering modern intelligence testing.

  • 20th Century Developments:

    • First actual tests of abilities and intelligence were developed.

    • Binet and Simon (1905): Created the first intelligence test for children.

    • David Wechsler (1939): Developed an intelligence test for adults.

    • Psychological assessments began being adopted across various settings:

      • Educational institutions

      • Clinical settings

      • Legal frameworks like courts

      • Hospitals and prisons

    • Group intelligence testing was prominent during WWI and WWII for military recruitment.

    • Post-WWII, psychological tests expanded into corporate and private use.

  • Testing Landscape by 1930s:

    • Over 4,000 psychological tests published.

    • Woodworth Psychoneurotic Inventory:

      • This was the first widely adopted self-report personality test.

      • Self-Report Features:

        • Advantages: Easy data collection and insight into subjective experiences.

        • Disadvantages: Susceptible to bias; relies on self-perception.

    • Projective Tests:

      • Focused on how individuals project their needs and emotions onto ambiguous stimuli.

      • Example: Hermann Rorschach's Inkblot Test (1921).

Cultural Considerations in Psychological Testing

Test Bias and Test-Related Discrimination

  • Understanding Culture in Psychological Testing:

    • Culture defined as the socially transmitted behaviors, values, beliefs, and products.

    • Historically, cultural differences were often ignored in psychological assessments.

    • Example of Ignored Cultural Bias:

      • Henry Goddard's classification of immigrant populations as “feeble-minded.”

    • Importance of recognizing cultural influence on psychological testing.

Specific Cultural Considerations

  • Verbal Communication Issues:

    • Absence of equivalent terms/events can skew assessments.

    • Specialized vocabulary in psychology may require trained interpreters.

    • Dialects and linguistic nuances can lead to misunderstandings.

  • Non-Verbal Communication and Behavior:

    • Interpretation of non-verbal cues varies by culture.

    • Differences in types, urgency, and pacing of behavior across cultural contexts.

  • Standards of Evaluation:

    • Evaluative judgments can be culturally relative, leading to biased assessments.

    • Variations in views about gender roles and mental health issues across cultures.

    • Conformity and collective goals valued in collectivist cultures versus independence in individualistic cultures.

  • Cultural Formulation Interview:

    • This is a semi-structured interview that complements DSM-5 symptom assessments.

    • Comprises 16 questions and was field-tested on 321 participants by clinicians across six countries.

Legal and Ethical Considerations in Psychological Testing

Legal Frameworks

  • Definitions:

    • Laws: Rules that societies are obligated to follow.

    • Ethics: Principles guiding proper conduct.

Ethical Guidelines in Assessment

  • Psychological testing is managed by a code of professional ethics, which shapes appropriate conduct in assessments.

  • Public Policy Implications:

    • Laws like the Every Student Succeeds Act (2015) and Common Core State Standards (2010) impact how assessments are conducted.

    • Historical legislations have shaped the approach to psychological assessments:

      • Minimal Competency Testing (1970s): Ensured high school graduates met essential standards.

      • Truth in Testing (1980s): Mandated clarity on evaluation standards affecting test-takers.

      • Civil Rights Act of 1964: Received guidelines for creating and implementing psychological tests.

Roles of Psychologists in Society

  • Significant Roles Include:

    • Acting as expert witnesses in civil and criminal matters.

    • Daubert Ruling: Provides judges broader discretion in determining what constitutes valid scientific evidence.

    • Frye Standard (1923): Dictates that scientific evidence must be widely accepted in the relevant scientific community.

    • Conducting fitness evaluations and high-stakes psychological assessments, such as those related to Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act (ODDA).

Considerations for Testing Privileges

  • Key Ethical Questions:

    • Who should have access to psychological test data?

    • Who can purchase psychological test materials?

    • Who is qualified to administer, score, and interpret psychological assessments?

    • Should testing privileges be regulated at all?

Test-Taker Rights and Ethical Protocols

  • Informed Consent:

    • Important for ensuring individuals understand the testing process.

    • Certain groups may lack the capacity for informed consent, which must be assessed based on choice, understanding, and rationality.

    • Rights to test results and maintaining confidentiality of test data, even when it is not guaranteed.

    • Use of the least stigmatizing labels in sharing assessment outcomes.