Chapter 2
Managing Interdependence, Social Responsibility, and Ethics
Introduction
Author: Mohamad Sepehri, Ph.D., Jacksonville University
Chapter Focus: Managing Interdependence, Social Responsibility, and Ethics
The Body Shop: An Ethical Framework
Foundation: Early pioneer in corporate ethical practices.
5 Corporate Values:
Against Animal Testing
Support Community Fair Trade
Activate Self Esteem
Defend Human Rights
Protect the Planet
Ethical Trade Definition:
Ethical Trading involves corporations taking responsibility for the working conditions of their suppliers.
Emphasizes fair treatment, dignity, and respect for workers.
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)
Definition:
The impact of a company’s actions on society.
Requires managers to assess their actions within a social system context.
Involves engaging with stakeholders such as customers, suppliers, and communities.
Synonymous with corporate citizenship and ethics.
Source: Harvard Law School
Benefits from CSR
Key Benefits:
Improved access to capital.
Secured license to operate.
Revenue increase and risk reduction.
Enhanced brand value and customer loyalty.
Better employee recruitment and retention.
Example of CSR Issues: VW’s 'Dieselgate' scandal.
Stakeholders of Multinational Corporations (MNCs)
Stakeholders:
Owners, Customers, Employees, Unions, Suppliers, Distributors, Strategic Allies, Community, Economy, Government.
Interconnectedness within the Global Economy:
Impacts on standard of living, environment, and sustainable resources.
Tensions in MNC Relations
Challenges:
Conflict between parent company and subsidiary regarding decisions and policies.
Variance in diversity commitments across different regions (e.g. Deloitte UK vs US).
Carroll’s Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility
Pyramid Layers:
Philanthropic: Business giving and volunteerism.
Ethical: Norms and values, societal expectations not codified in law.
Legal: Compliance with laws and regulations.
Economic: Financial responsibility and profitability to shareholders.
Ethical Challenges for MNCs
Global Consensus vs. Regional Variation:
MNCs face different ethical practices when entering international markets, informed by their home country's norms.
Example cases: Primark, GAP, NIKE.
Global corporate culture reflects integration of business environments.
Creating Shared Value (CSV)
Definition:
CSV is the integration of economic and social value.
Policies and practices that enhance competitiveness while improving social conditions.
Three Strategies:
Reconceive needs, products, and customers.
Redefine productivity in the value chain.
Strengthen the clusters upon which the company depends.
Examples:
Unilever’s germ soap combatting cholera.
Tata’s Nano car for low-income consumers ($2500).
Case Studies of Ethical Practices
Starbucks
Value Chain:
Direct procurement of coffee, no intermediaries.
Educating farmers on sustainable practices.
Coca-Cola
Campaign:
Advertisement addressing obesity, introducing smaller cans with lower sugar.
Ethical Guidelines and Codes of Conduct
Moral Philosophies:
Moral Universalism: A single moral standard accepted by all cultures.
Ethnocentric Approach: Home country moral standards applied in all contexts.
Ethical Relativism: Adopting the local moral code of the host country.
International Codes of Conduct:
Various industries hold standards preventing child labor and ensuring safe work conditions.
Entities such as the International Chamber of Commerce and the OECD provide guidelines.
Ethical Dilemmas in Global Management
Statistics:
48% of employees reported unethical actions in the past year.
Annual cost of unethical actions: $400 billion in the U.S.
Examples of Unethical Acts:
Lying, falsifying records, sexual harassment, stealing, conflicts of interest.
Global Corruption Barometer & CPI 2023
2023 Corruption Perception Index (CPI):
Metrics ranking countries based on perceived levels of corruption.
High-Risk Countries (selected):
Chad: 187
Haiti: 188
Eritrea: 189
Somalia: 190
Low-Risk Countries (selected):
New Zealand: 3
Denmark: 5
Finland: 1
Managing Corruption and Ethical Compliance
Compliance Program Requirements:
Organizations must exercise due diligence and promote ethical culture.
Legal Framework:
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act prohibits bribery of foreign officials.
Ethical Challenges in China
Business Environment:
Attraction due to cheap labor, but risks involve uncertain legal environment and IP protection.
Risks:
Geopolitical tensions increasing operational challenges.
Common Criticism of MNC Subsidiaries
Problems Identified:
Concentration of key positions among expatriates.
Technology not being adapted to local conditions.
Excessive focus on luxury markets while neglecting basic consumer needs.
Benefits and Costs of MNCs to Host Countries
Benefits:
Access to capital, technology, job creation, and infrastructure development.
Costs:
Increased interest rates, limited local skill development, dominance in industrial sectors.
Nationalism and Protectionism Risks
Concepts:
Nationalism: Rise of public sentiment favoring national over foreign interests leads to protectionist policies.
Governmentalism: Use of industrial policy to support national industries through subsidies.
Ethical Codes of Conduct from Various Corporations
Examples:
Google, Apple, LinkedIn, Yahoo, Intel, etc., promote ethical conduct and responsibility.
Examples of Top CSR Firms Globally
CSR Leaders (Asia and Worldwide):
Keppel Land
IKEA
Microsoft
Google
Natura (Brazil)
Conclusion
End of Presentation: Summary of key ethical and CSR challenges faced by MNCs globally.
Further Education Requirements: Need for continuous revision and understanding of ethical responsibilities in varied international contexts.