Chapter 2

Managing Interdependence, Social Responsibility, and Ethics

Introduction

  • Author: Mohamad Sepehri, Ph.D., Jacksonville University

  • Chapter Focus: Managing Interdependence, Social Responsibility, and Ethics

The Body Shop: An Ethical Framework

  • Foundation: Early pioneer in corporate ethical practices.

  • 5 Corporate Values:

    1. Against Animal Testing

    2. Support Community Fair Trade

    3. Activate Self Esteem

    4. Defend Human Rights

    5. Protect the Planet

  • Ethical Trade Definition:

    • Ethical Trading involves corporations taking responsibility for the working conditions of their suppliers.

    • Emphasizes fair treatment, dignity, and respect for workers.

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR)

  • Definition:

    • The impact of a company’s actions on society.

    • Requires managers to assess their actions within a social system context.

    • Involves engaging with stakeholders such as customers, suppliers, and communities.

    • Synonymous with corporate citizenship and ethics.

  • Source: Harvard Law School

Benefits from CSR
  • Key Benefits:

    1. Improved access to capital.

    2. Secured license to operate.

    3. Revenue increase and risk reduction.

    4. Enhanced brand value and customer loyalty.

    5. Better employee recruitment and retention.

  • Example of CSR Issues: VW’s 'Dieselgate' scandal.

Stakeholders of Multinational Corporations (MNCs)

  • Stakeholders:

    • Owners, Customers, Employees, Unions, Suppliers, Distributors, Strategic Allies, Community, Economy, Government.

  • Interconnectedness within the Global Economy:

    • Impacts on standard of living, environment, and sustainable resources.

Tensions in MNC Relations

  • Challenges:

    • Conflict between parent company and subsidiary regarding decisions and policies.

    • Variance in diversity commitments across different regions (e.g. Deloitte UK vs US).

Carroll’s Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility

  • Pyramid Layers:

    1. Philanthropic: Business giving and volunteerism.

    2. Ethical: Norms and values, societal expectations not codified in law.

    3. Legal: Compliance with laws and regulations.

    4. Economic: Financial responsibility and profitability to shareholders.

Ethical Challenges for MNCs

  • Global Consensus vs. Regional Variation:

    • MNCs face different ethical practices when entering international markets, informed by their home country's norms.

    • Example cases: Primark, GAP, NIKE.

    • Global corporate culture reflects integration of business environments.

Creating Shared Value (CSV)

  • Definition:

    • CSV is the integration of economic and social value.

    • Policies and practices that enhance competitiveness while improving social conditions.

    • Three Strategies:

    1. Reconceive needs, products, and customers.

    2. Redefine productivity in the value chain.

    3. Strengthen the clusters upon which the company depends.

  • Examples:

    • Unilever’s germ soap combatting cholera.

    • Tata’s Nano car for low-income consumers ($2500).

Case Studies of Ethical Practices

Starbucks
  • Value Chain:

    • Direct procurement of coffee, no intermediaries.

    • Educating farmers on sustainable practices.

Coca-Cola
  • Campaign:

    • Advertisement addressing obesity, introducing smaller cans with lower sugar.

Ethical Guidelines and Codes of Conduct

  • Moral Philosophies:

    1. Moral Universalism: A single moral standard accepted by all cultures.

    2. Ethnocentric Approach: Home country moral standards applied in all contexts.

    3. Ethical Relativism: Adopting the local moral code of the host country.

  • International Codes of Conduct:

    • Various industries hold standards preventing child labor and ensuring safe work conditions.

    • Entities such as the International Chamber of Commerce and the OECD provide guidelines.

Ethical Dilemmas in Global Management

  • Statistics:

    • 48% of employees reported unethical actions in the past year.

    • Annual cost of unethical actions: $400 billion in the U.S.

  • Examples of Unethical Acts:

    • Lying, falsifying records, sexual harassment, stealing, conflicts of interest.

Global Corruption Barometer & CPI 2023

  • 2023 Corruption Perception Index (CPI):

    • Metrics ranking countries based on perceived levels of corruption.

  • High-Risk Countries (selected):

    • Chad: 187

    • Haiti: 188

    • Eritrea: 189

    • Somalia: 190

  • Low-Risk Countries (selected):

    • New Zealand: 3

    • Denmark: 5

    • Finland: 1

Managing Corruption and Ethical Compliance

  • Compliance Program Requirements:

    • Organizations must exercise due diligence and promote ethical culture.

  • Legal Framework:

    • Foreign Corrupt Practices Act prohibits bribery of foreign officials.

Ethical Challenges in China

  • Business Environment:

    • Attraction due to cheap labor, but risks involve uncertain legal environment and IP protection.

  • Risks:

    • Geopolitical tensions increasing operational challenges.

Common Criticism of MNC Subsidiaries

  • Problems Identified:

    • Concentration of key positions among expatriates.

    • Technology not being adapted to local conditions.

    • Excessive focus on luxury markets while neglecting basic consumer needs.

Benefits and Costs of MNCs to Host Countries

  • Benefits:

    • Access to capital, technology, job creation, and infrastructure development.

  • Costs:

    • Increased interest rates, limited local skill development, dominance in industrial sectors.

Nationalism and Protectionism Risks

  • Concepts:

    • Nationalism: Rise of public sentiment favoring national over foreign interests leads to protectionist policies.

    • Governmentalism: Use of industrial policy to support national industries through subsidies.

Ethical Codes of Conduct from Various Corporations

  • Examples:

    • Google, Apple, LinkedIn, Yahoo, Intel, etc., promote ethical conduct and responsibility.

Examples of Top CSR Firms Globally

  • CSR Leaders (Asia and Worldwide):

    1. Keppel Land

    2. IKEA

    3. Microsoft

    4. Google

    5. Natura (Brazil)

Conclusion

  • End of Presentation: Summary of key ethical and CSR challenges faced by MNCs globally.

  • Further Education Requirements: Need for continuous revision and understanding of ethical responsibilities in varied international contexts.