Case Studies in Fluency Disorders

Matteo: Intermediate Stuttering

  • Background: Bright social grader referred due to increased quietness and avoidance of speaking in group activities.
  • Speech Behaviors:
    • Part-word repetitions and prolongations with increasing pitch and tension.
    • Examples: "sometimes I want."
    • Secondary behaviors: blinking, head nodding, word substitutions (e.g., "same bike" instead of "scooter").
  • Avoidance: Avoids speaking in situations where he anticipates stuttering.
  • Impact: Class participation is significantly impacted.
  • Emotional State: Expresses embarrassment and helplessness.
  • Level: Intermediate stuttering.

Ava: Typical Disfluencies

  • Background: Talkative, curious three-year-old with recent "bumpy speech."
  • Speech Behaviors:
    • Occasional part-word repetitions (e.g., "mum mum mummy").
    • Interjections (e.g., "um").
    • Revisions (e.g., "I want I want the red one").
    • Frequency: 5-7 disfluencies per 100 words, especially when excited or tired.
  • Secondary Behaviors: None observed.
  • Awareness: Generally relaxed, confident, and unaware of any difficulty.
  • Teacher Report: No concerns reported.
  • Language Skills: Expressive language within age expectations.
  • Parental Concern: Parents are more concerned than Ava or her teacher.
  • Level: Normal fluency/typical disfluencies.

Jordan: Advanced Stuttering

  • Background: Student seeking help due to stuttering limiting opportunities, particularly in formal settings.
  • Speech Behaviors:
    • Sound and syllable repetitions, prolongations, and tense blocks lasting 3-5 seconds.
    • Subtle tremors in jaw and lips during emotional topics.
  • Covert Strategies:
    • Scanning ahead for "safe words."
    • Avoiding his name.
    • Rarely initiating speech in class.
  • Secondary Behaviors:
    • Blinking, throat clearing, jaw shifting, finger tapping during blocks.
  • Avoidance: Avoids situations like ordering food or talking on the phone.
  • Emotional State: Deep shame, anxiety, and frustration; feels like his voice disappears when needed.
  • Motivation: Motivated to work on his speech to achieve his goals.
  • Self-Concept: Strong negative self-concept.
  • Age Range (Inferred): Late teens.
  • Level: Advanced stuttering.

Elias: Beginning Stuttering

  • Background: Four and a half years old, previously an eager talker, now with more effortful speech.
  • Speech Behaviors:
    • Rapid, tense repetitions (e.g., "banana").
    • Abrupt syllable repetitions with a schwa vowel (e.g., "open").
    • Tension in face and around mouth during disfluency.
  • Secondary Behaviors:
    • Frequent eye blinks and squeezing.
    • Slight head nods.
  • Awareness: Appears aware of difficulty; says "I can't say it" or changes topic.
  • Language Skills: Age-appropriate language skills.
  • Level: Beginning stuttering.

Nora: Borderline Stuttering

  • Background: Three and a half years old, referred by pediatrician after parents reported fluency concerns.
  • Speech Behaviors:
    • Frequent part-word and whole-word repetitions (e.g., "I I want that and").
    • Repetitions are loose and relaxed, without physical tension.
    • Disfluency rate: High, around 2323 disfluencies per 100 words, varying with topic and excitement.
  • Secondary Behaviors: None noted.
  • Awareness: Does not blink or show visible physical effort; seems unaware of disfluencies.
  • Fluency Variation: Disfluencies come and go; some days fluent, others not, especially when excited or tired.
  • Development: Language, articulation, and cognitive development are age-appropriate; socially engaged and outgoing.
  • Level: Borderline stuttering.

Key Differences Between Ava (Typical) and Nora (Borderline)

  • Number of Disfluencies: Nora exhibits a significantly higher number of disfluencies compared to Ava.
  • Recent Onset: Nora's disfluencies have appeared more recently.