Comprehensive Exam Notes: Edward Scissorhands & Noughts and Crosses (Film and Novel Essay Prep)
Four-Question Strategy and On-the-Day Plan
- On Wednesday you’ll receive four questions for the essays (Edward Scissorhands and Noughts and Crosses). Your job is to pick one question, break it down, and figure out what you need for each body paragraph.
- After choosing a question, brainstorm your approach:
- If you’re doing Edward Scissorhands (film essay): brainstorm film techniques to cover in the body paragraph.
- If you’re doing Noughts and Crosses (novel essay): brainstorm how you’ll explain the chosen quote for each paragraph and which quotes to use.
- Each essay has pros and cons:
- Edward Scissorhands (film): film techniques are useful; a close-up can show emotion, but you should explain how techniques work together to create meaning (the idea of “how film techniques work together”).
- Noughts and Crosses (novel): you’ll focus on quotes and unpack their significance; the emphasis is on the quote itself, but you also should unpack its significance within the context.
- You don’t need to write how multiple quotes work together in the same way for the novel; you can use one quote per body paragraph. However, connect the quote to the idea, explain its significance, and relate it to the author’s purpose.
- If you do the film essay, you’ll typically unpack film techniques and discuss how they interact; if you do the novel essay, you’ll unpack a quote and explain its significance in depth.
- Remember: connect each quote or technique to the broader theme and to the author/director’s purpose.
- The teacher will staple the quote sheet for the novel essay to avoid rewriting quotes; the quote sheet may be lost, so keep your own copy if possible.
- Structure is crucial for the best marks: a well-structured intro, body paragraphs, and a concise conclusion.
- The hamburger metaphor: the structure holds your points together; the top bun (intro) and bottom bun (conclusion) hold the fillings (your arguments) in place.
- Introduction (must-have elements): include the title, the director (Edward Scissorhands) or the author (Noughts and Crosses), and provide framing context.
- For Edward Scissorhands: explain the plot (creation, moving to suburbia, struggle to fit in).
- For Noughts and Crosses: explain that it is a dystopian future where Africa colonizes Britain, set in Albion; crosses are the ruling class; noughts are oppressed.
- Plot framing is essential to frame your argument and connect your points.
- If you don’t mention the setting explicitly, your points may feel random; framing with the setting strengthens your argument.
- Hamburger and setting: the setting acts as the frame that makes your points stronger when discussing how characters, events, or symbols operate within that world.
Setting and Context (Edward Scissorhands vs. Noughts and Crosses)
- Edward Scissorhands: the suburbia setting; the town as a context for isolation, otherness, and conformity.
- Noughts and Crosses: a dystopian Albion where Africa colonizes Britain; social hierarchy where Crosses (ruling class) are privileged and Noughts (oppressed) are marginalized.
- Physical vs. social setting (useful for argument):
- Physical settings (e.g., school, courtroom) can reveal prejudice or societal dynamics.
- Social settings show power structures and oppression (e.g., hospitals and how Noughts are treated).
- A convincing point could be that even without showing a Cross hospital, the Noughts hospital description can imply prejudice and inequality; use details to justify points.
- Setting framing helps anchor your argument and tie it to themes of prejudice, conformity, power, and humanity.
Key Concepts: Understanding, Convincing, and Perceptive Understanding
- Three core aims: Understanding, Convincing, Perceptive Understanding.
- Understanding: answer the question with evidence.
- Convincing: explain the evidence in detail and justify your point well.
- Perceptive Understanding: show deeper connections to themes, lessons about humanity, and broader implications.
- To achieve excellence, you should move beyond surface readings and show how the text/textual world reflects larger ideas about people and society.
- Conclusion: summarize what you’ve shown and tie back to the themes; keep it concise and directly related to the question.
What to Include in Each Paragraph (PEEL-like approach)
- Paragraph structure (often described as PEEL):
- P (Point): What the paragraph is about (the claim).
- E (Evidence): Introduce and explain the quote (for the novel) or the film technique (for the film essay).
- E (Explain): Explain how the evidence supports the point and its significance.
- L (Link): Link beyond the text to broader themes or to the question’s larger implications.
- An alternative phrasing observed:
- What sentence is the paragraph about? (the point)
- How does the evidence illustrate it? (the explanation with the quote/technique)
- Why is this important? (the why, connecting to themes and author/director’s purpose)
- Newer/alternative phrasing in class materials emphasizes a three-step “what, how, why” approach and the addition of a perceptive link.
Using Quotes (Novel: Noughts and Crosses) and Film Techniques (Edward Scissorhands)
- For Noughts and Crosses:
- Focus on one or more key quotes per paragraph.
- Unpack the quote: what it says, why it matters, and how it reveals themes like prejudice, power, or identity.
- Connect the quote to the setting (Albion) and social dynamics (Crosses vs Noughts).
- If a film technique isn’t part of the task, you don’t need to discuss film techniques for this essay; however, you should still discuss how the setting and events illuminate the themes.
- The teacher suggests one quote per body paragraph is acceptable.
- For Edward Scissorhands:
- Discuss film techniques (e.g., close-ups to show emotion) and how they work together to convey meaning.
- Explain how the techniques contribute to themes (conformity, otherness, suburbia, identity).
- Use evidence from the film (visuals, shots, pacing) to support claims.
Evidence, Quote Sheets, and Resources
- Quote sheets: for the novel essay, you can attach the quote sheet instead of rewriting quotes; ensure you have a copy if it’s lost.
- Planning sheets: planning aids are available to help structure your analysis.
- Google Classroom resources: classwork sections contain the novel study and film study materials, including PowerPoints and exemplar body paragraphs.
- The Edward Scissorhands and Noughts and Crosses exemplars show intro, body paragraph structure, and conclusions.
- The Edward Scissorhands exemplars include a two-paragraph structure and note about missing two intro components; they provide a model to adapt.
- Practice questions and unpacking guides: detailed in-class materials show how to convert questions into three-point paragraphs; multiple methods are provided, including different ways to answer.
- General notes: include issues like using keywords from the question; ensuring the response remains aligned with the prompt; avoiding overlong paragraphs in notes; one-sided note sheets.
Writing Mechanics, Keywords, and Exam Practices
- Use keywords exactly from the question; avoid substituting with synonyms unless the meaning is preserved.
- Practice materials include specific prompts (e.g., how events show up, how relationships show up) to help anticipate possible essay angles.
- General notes include starter structures and how to adapt common planning components to any question.
- When practicing, you should be able to adapt prepared notes for any fitting question, even if the exact question differs from past papers.
- Some students might use bullet-point outlines for the introduction; that is acceptable as long as the actual essay uses precise wording and the required keywords.
- The overarching goal is to demonstrate different depths of understanding: basic understanding, convincing argumentation with detailed support, and perceptive, consequential insights.
Practice, Feedback, and Class Resources
- Tomorrow, practice paragraph drafting and receive feedback.
- Exemplars and practice paragraphs are available for both Edward Scissorhands and Noughts and Crosses; use them to inform your own writing.
- When reviewing, focus on: what the paragraph is about (the point), how the evidence supports it (quote or technique), and why it matters (link to themes and author/director’s purpose).
- If you’re unsure whether a question fits the standard essay plan, prepare a general notes approach (why this setting matters, what the key quotes show, etc.) so you can adapt quickly if needed.
- Printing and resource management notes:
- Budget constraints have affected printing; one-sided note sheets are required to keep the process fair.
- The teacher may staple quote sheets for you; you’ll still need to bring your own planning documents and notes.
- Class resources include a dedicated “Novel Study” and “Film Study” section with exact samples and introductions.
Practical Examples Mentioned in Class
- Edward Scissorhands sample essay structure included: introduction (four components) and two body paragraphs; some parts missing in the exemplar, prompting students to identify what’s needed.
- Edward Scissorhands exemplars show how a three-part paragraph (what, how, why) can be framed, with a concluding link to the wider themes.
- Noughts and Crosses: exemplar notes show how to connect to the dystopian setting, social prejudice, and racial/class dynamics through quotes and analysis.
- Quotes and symbolism example: orange juice in Noughts and Crosses discussed as a symbol of wealth and elitism; interpret how such symbols contribute to thematic arguments about power and inequality.
Miscellaneous Context and Class Logistics
- The teacher highlighted practical matters, such as real-world constraints (photocopying budget), and the decision to print materials in class as needed.
- The teacher encouraged looking at exemplars tomorrow (and possibly again the next day) to reinforce understanding and practice.
- A discussion about the importance of the setting for each text and how to frame points within that setting.
- The teacher shared personal reflections about potential career paths (design vs English) and classroom experiences that influenced how she teaches structure and planning.
Quick Reference: Key Phrases to Use in Essays
- What sentence is the paragraph about? What is the paragraph's focus?
- How does the evidence (quote or technique) illustrate that focus?
- Why is this point significant? How does it connect to themes and the author/director’s purpose?
- Link beyond text: what broader human or societal lesson does this point suggest?
- Use keywords from the exam question to stay aligned with the prompt.
Final Advice for Exam Day
- Choose a question you can break into three clear body paragraphs at a minimum.
- For Edward Scissorhands: plan around 1–3 film techniques per paragraph, showing how they work in concert to convey emotion and meaning.
- For Noughts and Crosses: plan around one strong quote per paragraph, unpack its significance, and connect to dystopian setting, prejudice, and power dynamics.
- Always tie back to the prompt with the setting and themes; ensure your introduction frames the plot and context; your conclusion succinctly sums up and links to broader implications.
- Keep notes concise and bullet-pointed on a one-sided sheet; avoid full paragraphs in the note sheet.
- Use the Practice and Exemplars as a guide to structure, language, and to validate your approach.