Comprehensive Study Notes: Disaster Risk Reduction, Gender, and Climate Change Workshop
Workshop Overview and Context
Title: Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR)
Speaker: Dr Sithabiso Gandure, The Wahenga Institute
Event: Multiparty Women’s Caucus Capacity Development Workshop
Theme: Gender and Climate Change
Location: Cape Town
Date: 19 October 2011
Global Incidences and Trends of Natural Disasters
The frequency of natural disasters is increasing globally. Key examples cited from recent history include: - Malawi Drought (February 2002): Resulted in the deaths of people. - India Drought (July 2002): Affected people. - South Africa Drought (January 2004): Affected people. - Haiti Earthquake (January 2010): Resulted in fatalities. - Japan Tsunami (March 2011): Resulted in fatalities. - Somalia (1991/92 to 2011): Experienced the worst drought since the early 1990s, with people in a state of crisis.
Trend Analysis (1975-2009): According to the EM-DAT database (The OFDA/CRED International Disaster Database), there has been a significant upward trend in the number of world natural disasters. The number of occurrences has risen from under in the mid-1970s to highs reaching between and on an annual basis.
Regional Impacts (2009 Data): - Asia consistently records the highest share of natural disaster impacts across all categories: occurrence, numbers killed, total affected, and economic damage. - Other monitored regions include Africa, the Americas, Europe, and Oceania.
Natural Disasters and Outlook for South Africa
Future Projections: Based on the Long Term Mitigation Study (LTMS) released on 26 September 2011, South Africa should expect an increase in the frequency and severity of natural disasters.
Recent Local Examples: - KwaZulu-Natal (KZN): Hit hard by floods on 7 January 2011. - Limpopo: Families suffered significant losses after a major storm on 18 December 2010.
Political Stance: Minister Edna Molewa (Water & Environmental Affairs) emphasized that the government must not negotiate for South Africans but with them, ensuring the voices of the poor, the underdeveloped, women, and the youth are central to the discourse.
Statistical Breakdown (1992 to 2011): - Reported Fatalities by Disaster Type: - Flood: - Epidemic: - Storm: - Wildfire: - Earthquake: - Extreme Temperature: - Reported People Affected by Disaster Type: - Drought: - Storm: - Flood:
Defining Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR)
Disaster Risk Reduction refers to the policies and practices implemented to minimize (and ultimately prevent) disaster losses. It consists of three primary pillars: - Mitigation: Actions taken to reduce the frequency, scale, intensity, and impact of hazards. - Preparedness: Strengthening the capacity of communities to respond to and recover from hazards, and ensuring governments and partners have the infrastructure for effective response. - Advocacy: Influencing social, political, economic, and environmental factors that contribute to the causes and magnitude of disaster impacts.
The Disaster Equation: A disaster occurs when a hazard (e.g., a storm or drought) impacts a vulnerable, exposed, and ill-prepared community. A natural hazard is not a disaster in and of itself; the magnitude of the impact depends on the scale of the hazard and the vulnerability of the people it hits.
The Link Between Climate Change and Vulnerability
Impact of Climate Change (CC): The IPCC reports indicate that CC is increasing the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events (hurricanes, floods, and droughts). This makes weather-related hazards more common, fatal, and costly.
Determinants of Vulnerability: Vulnerability is defined by social variables, including: - Gender and age. - Health status and economic status. - Ethnicity and local socio-economic/political conditions.
The Proactive Shift: Successful DRR must happen before a disaster occurs. Currently, DRR tends to be reactive because of: - Limitations in Early Warning Systems. - Limitations in institutional capacities for mitigation.
Shared Goals: DRR and CC adaptation should be treated as cross-cutting development issues. They share the goals of reducing vulnerability, increasing resilience, and achieving sustainable development.
The Rationale for Gender Concerns in DRR and Climate Change
Rights Dimension: Gender equality is a principle enshrined in international and regional protocols as well as national policies.
Economic and Environmental Dimension: Gender inequality actively undermines the development potential of a nation or community.
Social Dimension: Women have unique and vital roles in household and community structures that are traditionally undervalued and under-recognized.
Mainstreaming Challenges: Effectively integrating gender into these sectors requires shifting cultural norms, creating entitlement legislation, and enforcing/monitoring existing gender balance within legislative and executive bodies.
Gendered Impacts and Case Studies
Bangladesh Cyclone and Flood (1991): - Among those aged , the death rate was for women compared to only for men. - Causes included warning information being transmitted only in public spaces between men and women being socially restricted from leaving homes without a male relative.
Global Mortality Rates: Research by IUCN/WEDO (2007) shows women and children are more likely than men to die during disasters.
Post-Disaster Realities: - Gender inequalities are often exacerbated after the event. - Increased workloads may force girls to drop out of school. - Vulnerability to domestic and sexual violence increases as families are displaced into overcrowded, private-less emergency or transitional housing.
Social Rights Correlation: A London School of Economics analysis of countries found that gender differences in death rates are directly linked to women's economic and social rights. Where rights are equal, disasters kill roughly the same number of men and women.
Frameworks and Tools for Implementation
Global Cornerstone: The Hyogo Framework for Action (): Building the Resilience of Nations and Communities to Disasters (adopted by Governments).
Regional Policy: SADC Disaster Risk Reduction Strategic Plan ().
South African Legislation: Disaster Management Act of , which established the National Disaster Management Centre (NDMC).
National Platforms: Mechanisms for coordinated, participatory DRR. South Africa utilizes the National Disaster Management Advisory Forum (NDMAF), which meets quarterly.
Strategy for a Gender-Sensitive Approach
Programming: Integrate gender concerns into the entire lifecycle of DRR and CC programming.
Data: Disaggregate all data by gender to inform specific strategies.
Analysis: Conduct thorough gender analysis for all interventions.
Preparation & Prevention: Ensure both men and women are involved in creating emergency plans and receiving capacity training.
Response: Provide psycho-social counseling and support tailored to the specific needs of men and women.
Recovery: Interventions must address the unique needs of both genders.
Concluding Insights
Gender equality is not about focusing only on women's issues; it is about addressing the concerns of both men and women.
Gender inequality remains a root cause of why women are more vulnerable to CC and disasters.
Women should not be viewed merely as helpless victims; they are active agents and are already in the forefront of adaptation and coping strategies.