Lecture 9 (Constitutional Law & Political Institutions)
Foundations and Origins of the Fifth Republic
Key Historical Protagonists:
Charles de Gaulle (the initiator):
Championed distinct constitutional ideas following the Liberation of France at the end of World War II.
Vehemently opposed the Constitution of 1946 (Fourth Republic) and campaigned against its drafts twice:
The first referendum in 1946 resulted in a negative vote, successfully rejecting the initial draft.
The second referendum passed the text by a narrow, short majority despite de Gaulle's continued opposition.
Largely retired from active politics during the Fourth Republic until recalled in 1958 to resolve the "Algerian crisis" (the Algerian War of Independence, referred to as a "crisis" at the time to downplay independence demands and avoid acknowledging a civil war).
Michel Debré (variously referenced as Michel Dubreuil / De Gret):
Served as legal and constitutional advisor to de Gaulle.
Trained as a lawyer rather than a career politician, taking charge of the technical details of drafting the 1958 Constitution.
Presided over the committee of legal experts drafting the text.
Divergent Constitutional Visions and Resulting Synthesis:
Debré favored a model patterned after British parliamentarism with a prime ministerial focus.
De Gaulle favored a presidential system featuring a dominant head of state.
The Constitution of 1958 represents a compromise between both stances, producing a hybrid regime situated between pure parliamentarism and pure presidentialism.
Constitutional Rigidity and the 1946 Amendment Procedure
Constitutional Rigidity in French History:
Most French constitutions established since the French Revolution have been rigid constitutions.
The Third Republic Exception: The Third Republic did not have a single, rigid constitutional document; instead, it was governed by three distinct constitutional laws enacted in 1875.
Rigidity of the Fourth Republic (Constitution of 1946): Enshrined in Article 90, which governed the procedure for constitutional revision.
Article 90 Amendment Procedure (Fourth Republic):
Constituted an elaborate, multi-step process requiring broad inter-institutional consensus.
First Step: Required the adoption of a resolution by an absolute majority of the National Assembly.
Second Step: Required a reading and examination by the Council of the Republic (the upper chamber, equivalent to the contemporary Senate).
Third Step (Second Reading): Required approval by a supermajority across both chambers of Parliament:
A majority in the National Assembly, or
A majority in each of the two chambers (the National Assembly and the Council of the Republic).
Institutional Balance: The procedure secured a dominant parliamentary role, requiring substantial parliamentary agreement to accomplish any constitutional revision.
The Transition of 1958: Legal Mechanism and Drafting Process
The Legislative Authorizations of June 3, 1958:
Faced with the rigid hurdles of Article 90, de Gaulle required extraordinary legal authority to execute an in-depth regime overhaul rather than minor textual adjustments.
Law of June 3, 1958 (): Authorized the government to draft a revision of the 1946 Constitution.
Concomitant Full Powers Law: Passed on the exact same date () through the same legislative vote, granting full emergency powers to de Gaulle and his government to address the Algerian War.
Revision versus Total Replacement Debate:
Unlike the Constitution of Spain, which explicitly organizes procedures for a total constitutional revision, French constitutional texts historically allowed only partial amendments.
Chronological Evolution: While June 3, 1958, formally authorized a revision of the 1946 text, the exercise of full powers over the summer of 1958 transformed the mandate into the preparation of an entirely new constitution for the Fifth Republic.
Atypical Constituent Process:
Deviated completely from traditional French and international constituent practices:
No constituent assembly was elected (contrasting directly with 1946).
No protracted parliamentary debates took place.
The process was rapid, executive-driven, and conducted primarily in secret over a few months.
Drafting Committees:
First Committee: Composed primarily of members of de Gaulle's government.
Second Committee: Composed of legal experts appointed and presided over by Michel Debré.
Parliamentary Consultative Role: The sitting chambers of Parliament were permitted only non-binding comments after drafting concluded; some comments were adopted, but most were dismissed.
Popular Ratification (Referendum of September 28, 1958):
Without an elected constituent assembly, popular validation relied solely on an ex-post constitutional referendum held on September 28, 1958 ().
Campaign Iconography: Official campaign propaganda featured the figure of Marianne wearing the Phrygian revolutionary bonnet in the foreground, with the shadow of de Gaulle standing behind her with raised arms.
Cultural and Historical Context of the Pose: De Gaulle's characteristic stance with outstretched arms served as the inspiration for the French nickname of a curved wing-lever bottle opener (called a de Gaulle). Historically, the gesture corresponds to his speech delivered from the balcony in Algiers during the Algerian crisis, where he proclaimed, "I understood you" (Je vous ai compris).
Referendum Outcome: The text received an overwhelming "Yes" majority and officially entered into force on October 4, 1958 ().
The Shift in the Representative Paradigm and Presidential Primacy
Break with the Revolutionary Parliamentary Paradigm:
For roughly two centuries post-1789, French constitutional tradition held that sovereign representation was embodied exclusively by Parliament as the organ of the general will.
The 1958 Constitution ended this exclusive legislative representative paradigm, transferring the central representative mantle to the executive branch, specifically the President of the Republic.
De Gaulle's Bayeux Speech (Discours de Bayeux):
Delivered in Bayeux, Normandy, in 1946 while de Gaulle was head of the provisional government, commemorating the Allied Normandy landings and fallen soldiers.
Served as the initial programmatic blueprint for the executive authority realized in 1958, articulating the duties of the head of state through repetitive anaphora: "to him, the duty of…" and "to him, the charge of…"
Direct Translation into Article 5 of the 1958 Constitution:
The phrasing and structural prerogatives outlined at Bayeux correspond directly to Article 5 of the 1958 text:
Presidential Arbitration: The President is designated as an arbiter (arbitre). Rooted in de Gaulle's distrust of political parties—deemed unstable, untrustworthy, and responsible for the downfalls of the Third and Fourth Republics—the arbiter was intended to stand entirely above partisan divisions. In subsequent constitutional practice, however, every Fifth Republic president has functioned as the leader of a political party or parliamentary majority.
Guarantor of State Continuity: The President ensures the proper functioning of public authorities and the continuity of the state, serving as the constitutional rationale for assigning extensive normal and emergency powers to the office.
The Dual Executive and Presidential Prerogatives Under Article 19
The Bicephalous Executive (Exécutif Bicéphale):
The 1958 regime establishes a dual executive comprising two distinct institutional heads: the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister.
The actual balance of power between both heads is dynamic and variable, dictated by parliamentary configurations and the personalities of the officeholders.
The Principle of Ministerial Countersignature (Article 19):
Standard parliamentary regimes require acts of the head of state (whether monarch or president) to be countersigned by the prime minister or competent ministers.
Doctrinal Function: Because heads of state are politically irresponsible and cannot be unseated by votes of no confidence, countersigning ministers assume political accountability before Parliament for executive acts.
Article 19 preserves this general parliamentary rule as a default principle.
The Category of Autonomous "Personal Powers":
Article 19 establishes an extensive, atypical list of constitutional exceptions where presidential acts do not require any ministerial countersignature.
Article 8, Paragraph 1: Appointment of the Prime Minister. The President possesses total discretion to appoint the Prime Minister without countersignature (though appointment of other ministers requires the Prime Minister's recommendation).
Article 9: Presiding over the Council of Ministers (Conseil des ministres). While the Prime Minister directs the government, the President presides over its weekly meetings, determining and controlling the official governmental agenda.
Article 10: Promulgation of laws.
Article 11: Submission of government bills or treaties to a national legislative referendum.
Article 12: Dissolution of the National Assembly.
Article 16: Implementation of full, exceptional emergency powers in situations of serious and immediate threat to the nation and the interruption of public authorities.
Article 18: Formal communication with Parliament:
Original 1958 Conception: Grounded in strict separation of powers. Ministers and members of Parliament were declared strictly incompatible (accepting a ministerial post requires forfeiting one's parliamentary seat). The President was physically barred from entering Parliament; communication was limited to written messages read aloud by a presiding officer.
July 23, 2008 Amendment: Modified Article 18 to allow the President to convene both chambers of Parliament in Congress to deliver an address directly. This power does not equate to an annual American State of the Union; it has been deployed infrequently (e.g., twice by Emmanuel Macron, once by François Hollande).
Articles 54, 56, and 61: Powers governing appointments to and referrals before the Constitutional Council.
Presidential Accountability, Immunity, and Impeachment (Articles 67, 53-2, and 68)
The Dilemma of Autonomous Executive Authority:
The existence of personal powers unencumbered by countersignatures creates a fundamental constitutional issue: significant political and legal actions are executed without political accountability.
Article 67 (General Immunity): Dictates that the President incurs no liability for acts performed in an official capacity and cannot be subjected to legal proceedings or parliamentary votes of no confidence during tenure.
Unlike the government, which is continually accountable to Parliament under threat of censure, the President faces only periodic electoral accountability at the end of each five-year term.
Constitutional Exceptions to Presidential Immunity:
Article 53-2 (International Law Exception):
Recognizes the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court (ICC) at The Hague for war crimes and crimes against humanity.
Resulted from the ratification of the 1998 Rome Statute, which required a targeted amendment to the French Constitution.
Article 68 (Removal via the High Court):
Pre-2007 Text: Permitted presidential destitution exclusively in cases of "high treason" (haute trahison), an undefined Cold War-era concept colloquially understood as selling state secrets to foreign adversaries (e.g., Russia).
2007 Constitutional Reform: Replaced high treason with "a breach of his duties patently incompatible with his continuing in office" (manquement à ses devoirs manifestement incompatible avec l'exercice de son mandat).
Doctrinal Scope: Not designed for political disagreements over legislative policy. It envisions extreme situations, whether criminal or non-criminal (e.g., severe dereliction of duty, betrayal of secrets, arbitrary violent acts, or clinically certified mental incapacity rendering governance impossible).
Removal Procedure under Article 68:
Requires supermajorities across consecutive stages:
Adoption of a removal motion by a majority in the National Assembly.
Adoption of the motion by a majority in the Senate.
Convocation of both chambers together as the High Court (Haute Cour), which must vote by a supermajority to formally strip the President of office.
Historical Deployments: Initiated four times since 2007; none succeeded:
Attempted once against François Hollande (failed to pass the initial committee stage in the National Assembly).
Attempted three times against Emmanuel Macron.
One Macron attempt arose from his refusal to appoint the Prime Minister proposed by the leading left-wing legislative coalition; this effort stalled because Article 8 grants the President complete constitutional discretion in appointing the Prime Minister, precluding a charge of constitutional breach.
Direct Democracy, Referendums, and Article 11
Constitutional Sovereignty and Direct Democracy (Article 3):
Article 3 states: "National sovereignty shall vest in the people who shall exercise it through their representatives and by means of referendum."
Formulates a theoretical compromise between representative and direct democracy, placing both mechanisms on equal footing in the constitutional text, even though direct democratic practice has been historically scarce.
Typology of Referendums in the Fifth Republic:
Constitutional Referendum (Article 89): Used to ratify constitutional amendments. Across more than 15 constitutional revisions in Fifth Republic history, only one has been submitted to a popular referendum: the 2000 amendment reducing the presidential mandate from seven to five years. All other amendments were enacted by Parliament convened in Congress.
Local Referendums: Organized at sub-national levels to determine local administrative decisions.
National Legislative Referendum (Article 11): Authorizes the adoption of legislation via popular vote, bypassing standard parliamentary procedures.
Presidential Initiative Under Article 11:
For its first fifty years (), Article 11 authorized only presidential-initiated referendums upon formal governmental recommendation.
Substantive Scope: Limited to bills regarding the organization of public authorities, economic, social, or environmental policies, public services, or the ratification of international treaties.
De Gaulle's Plebiscitary Practice: De Gaulle organized half of all legislative referendums ever held under the Fifth Republic, routinely transforming them into plebiscites by conditioning his continued tenure on their passage. In 1969, following a negative vote on local authority decentralization and Senate reform, he immediately resigned.
Modern Decline: The last presidential legislative referendum under Article 11 occurred in 2005; none have been initiated for over twenty years.
The Mixed Initiative Referendum (Référendum d'Initiative Partagée):
Introduced into Article 11 by the constitutional reform of July 23, 2008, often mischaracterized as a popular initiative.
Procedural Thresholds:
Initiative must be introduced by of the members of Parliament (deputies and senators combined).
Must subsequently be signed and supported by of registered voters on electoral rolls within a nine-month period (approximately French voters).
Implementation and Track Record:
It required five years of parliamentary debate to pass the implementing organic law in 2013.
Attempted seven times in total; six failed mandatory preliminary scrutiny by the Constitutional Council.
The sole proposal to pass constitutional review (in 2019, regarding the privatization of Paris airports) garnered between and signatures, falling far short of the required threshold.
The Watershed Moment: The 1962 Referendum and Direct Presidential Elections
The Original 1958 Electoral Mechanism:
The President was initially selected by an indirect electoral college comprising members of Parliament, departmental council presidents, and representatives of overseas territories (including Algeria), totaling approximately 80,000 local dignitaries.
Direct universal suffrage was excluded in 1958 because advisors (such as Debré) argued it was too close to the memory of the authoritarian Vichy regime under Philippe Pétain.
The 1962 Constitutional Reform:
In 1962, de Gaulle resolved to establish direct universal suffrage for presidential elections to consolidate direct popular legitimacy.
Procedural Violation: Amending the Constitution required the procedure outlined in Article 89, which requires approving votes by both the National Assembly and the Senate. Facing explicit parliamentary opposition, de Gaulle bypassed Article 89 entirely and invoked Article 11 (legislative referendum) to amend the constitutional text directly.
Institutional Conflict and Repercussions:
The use of a legislative referendum to amend the supreme legal document was widely regarded by jurists and parliamentarians as unconstitutional.
The referendum passed with over of the vote.
Constitutional Council Declines Jurisdiction: When the referendum was challenged, the Constitutional Council declared itself incompetent to review expressions of direct popular sovereignty, ruling that it could not strike down a text adopted directly by the people.
Parliamentary Retaliation via Motion of No Confidence: Because Article 67 prevented Parliament from sanctioning the President, the National Assembly targeted the government under Article 50, passing a successful motion of no confidence that forced Prime Minister Georges Pompidou's cabinet to resign.
Dissolution and Re-election: De Gaulle countered by deploying Article 12 to dissolve the National Assembly. In the November 1962 legislative elections, de Gaulle's party won a decisive majority.
Establishment of the Modern Constitutional Regime:
The dual popular endorsement (the referendum vote and the subsequent legislative election) established the principle that a direct popular vote by the sovereign constituent people legitimizes procedural deviations.
Direct election under Article 7 (absolute majority requirement across two rounds) transformed the Fifth Republic into its enduring operational form, establishing high voter turnout and conferring unmatched executive authority.
Constitutional Classification and Rationalized Parliamentarism
Regime Typology:
The regime is classified as a "parliamentary system of a presidential nature" (or presidentialized parliamentary / semi-presidential / hybrid system):
Parliamentary Core (Article 50): The government is politically accountable to the National Assembly. A motion of no confidence or failure to pass a general policy vote obligates the Prime Minister to tender the cabinet's resignation to the President.
Presidential Character (Article 7): The President is directly elected through universal suffrage in a two-round system requiring an absolute majority of votes cast.
Rationalized Parliamentarism (Parlementarisme Rationalisé):
Theoretical Origin: Coined by legal scholar Boris Mirkine-Guetzévitch (Boris Murchin Getzovich, who died in 1955) to denote institutional and procedural mechanisms designed to curb parliamentary omnipotence, cabinet instability, and unrestrained legislative supremacy (which had characterized the Third Republic).
While Fourth Republic attempts to rationalize parliamentarism collapsed, the Fifth Republic systematically codified executive mechanisms that strictly circumscribe parliamentary leverage.
The Mechanics of Governance: The Majoritarian Fact, Cohabitation, and Modern Parliamentary Fragmentation
The Majoritarian Fact (Fait Majoritaire):
When the President and the majority in the National Assembly share the same political alignment, the President functions as the undisputed leader of the parliamentary majority.
Under these conditions, the Prime Minister acts as an executive subordinate assisting the President, while the constitutional assignment of government policy conduct under Article 20 is largely directed from the presidency.
Electoral Alignment Reforms (2000 and 2001):
The 2000 Reform: A constitutional amendment reduced the presidential term from seven to five years, matching the five-year legislative term of the National Assembly.
The 2001 Electoral Calendar Law: Reorganized national elections so that the presidential election (April) directly precedes the legislative elections (May/June).
The Mirror Effect: This sequence transformed legislative elections into an endorsement of the newly elected President, reliably producing an aligned parliamentary majority (observed continuously from 2002 to 2022).
Cohabitation:
Occurs when the President and the parliamentary majority belong to opposing political coalitions (manifested three times in Fifth Republic history for a cumulative duration of roughly ten years).
Shift in Prime Ministerial Authority: Although Article 8 gives the President formal discretion, the President is politically coerced into appointing a Prime Minister supported by the parliamentary majority to avoid immediate votes of no confidence under Article 50.
During cohabitation, the Prime Minister assumes primary leadership over domestic and legislative policy pursuant to Articles 20 and 21, reducing the President's domestic influence.
2024 Dissolution and Parliamentary Fragmentation:
Emmanuel Macron's 2024 dissolution of the National Assembly uncoupled the electoral alignment with the 2027 presidential calendar.
Breakdown of Majorities: While the presidential coalition held a relative majority from 2022 to 2024, the 2024 elections yielded an entirely fragmented assembly where no party or coalition holds an absolute majority.
Institutional Impact: Lacking a tradition of formal legislative coalitions (unlike Germany or Spain), the President ceases to function as the majority leader.
Ascendance of the Prime Minister: Governed by Prime Minister Sebastian Legrand, the government must continually negotiate with diverse minorities and oppositions to pass core legislation, such as the annual national budget.
This dynamic elevates the Prime Minister's role, bringing executive governance closer to the original text of Articles 20 and 21 ("The Government shall determine and conduct the policy of the nation" and "The Prime Minister shall direct the actions of the Government").
Questions and Interactive Discussion
Identification of the Non-Rigid French Constitution:
Question: Which French constitutional framework studied previously was not a rigid constitution?
Response: The Third Republic. It did not feature a single rigid constitutional document, but rather three distinct constitutional laws enacted in 1875.
Bicephalous Nature of the Executive:
Question: Who serves as the definitive head of the executive branch under the Fifth Republic?
Response: There is no single or straightforward answer; the 1958 Constitution establishes a dual, two-headed (bicéphale) executive sharing authority between the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister. The actual preeminence of one head over the other depends on shifting political configurations (e.g., presidential alignment versus cohabitation) and personal leadership dynamics.
Parliamentary Calculation for the Mixed Initiative Referendum:
Prompt: Calculation of the parliamentary threshold required under Article 11 based on total parliamentary membership ( deputies in the National Assembly plus senators in the Senate):
Sum of parliamentary seats:
Calculation of the required threshold:
Rounding up to whole members of Parliament, an initiative requires at least parliamentary signatures to proceed alongside the electoral threshold (approximately voters).