AP English Language and Composition: Comprehensive Rhetorical Analysis and Summer Reading Notes
AP English Language and Composition Course Overview
Course Description & Academic Focus:
- AP English Language and Composition is an advanced, college-level writing course that focuses on the critical reading of non-fiction prose.
- The curriculum explores how language shapes arguments across multiple disciplines, including politics, history, social sciences, and current events.
- Core skill development emphasizes analyzing written texts, constructing sound reasoning and argumentation, and evaluating the persuasive power of language.
Course Expectations & Grading Structure:
- Marking Period Grade Weight: Major assessments account for of the overall marking period grade.
- Summer Assignment Standing: The summer assignment is classified as a major assessment due on the very first day of school.
- Initial In-Class Assessments: Additional major assessments—including objective tests, essay writing, and analytical discussions—occur during the first two weeks of the school year.
Summer Reading Assignment Checklist:
- Read and annotate "Interrogating Texts: 6 Reading Habits to Develop in Your First Year at Harvard" by Susan Gilroy.
- Read and annotate "How to Read Like a Writer" by Mike Bunn.
- Study the comprehensive foundational notes on Rhetoric, Argument, and Style.
- Read and carefully annotate Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption by Bryan Stevenson.
- Read, analyze, and annotate the transcript/presentation of "The Danger of a Single Story" by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie.
- Read, analyze, and annotate "The Perils of Indifference" by Elie Wiesel.
- Complete handwritten Rhetorical Situation Analysis Charts for Just Mercy, "The Danger of a Single Story", and "The Perils of Indifference".
Required Preparatory Habits & Academic Integrity:
- Active News Consumption: Students must read quality news sources (covering political, environmental, cultural, military, social, global, economic, educational, and scientific issues) from syndicated American columnists to build real-world background schema and evaluate opposing arguments.
- Grammar & Mechanics Proficiency: Competency in grammar, mechanics, usage, and sentence structure is assumed. Review is recommended through William Strunk Jr. and E.B. White's The Elements of Style (available online at
http://www.bartleby.com/141/). - Academic Integrity Policy: All work must represent strictly individual effort. Plagiarism or collaboration—including copying from websites, classmates, or external AI/online tools—results in a score of zero ().
Foundational Active Reading Habits: Harvard University Guidelines
Core Philosophy:
- Critical reading requires active engagement and interaction with a text rather than passive eye movement across the page.
- Research demonstrates that students who read deliberately retain more information for significantly longer periods.
- College-level reading assignments feature increased volume and complexity, making re-reading long texts an unviable luxury; reading must be meaningful on the first pass.
Habit 1: Previewing
- Involves inspecting the structural elements surrounding a text prior to reading to form preliminary expectations regarding its scope, aim, and focus.
- Key Inspectable Features:
- Headnotes, abstracts, and prefatory materials.
- Author reputation, credentials, or editorial biographical introductions.
- Discourse conventions distinguishing text types (e.g., newspaper articles vs. scholarly journal essays vs. textbooks).
- Visual disposition and layout, including section headers, subtopics, paragraph length, and text block structures that indicate the arc of the argument.
Habit 2: Annotating
- Places the reader in an immediate, intensive intellectual dialogue with the author.
- Prohibition of Highlighting: Highlighting is a passive strategy that creates cryptic colored lines lacking contextual memory triggers. Pen or pencil interaction is required.
- Marginalia: Writing words, phrases, immediate reactions, and connections to broader course themes directly in the text margins to serve as memory triggers for future exams and essays.
- Symbol Systems: Developing personalized symbols (e.g., asterisks
*for essential points, exclamation points!for surprising or bizarre claims) to capture fleeting insights. - Explicit Questioning: Writing down active inquiries in margins or notebooks (e.g., "What does this mean?", "Why is the writer drawing that conclusion?") to mark unresolved points for class discussion.
Habit 3: Outlining, Summarizing, and Analyzing
- Outlining: Deconstructs the structural skeleton of an argument by tagging thesis statements, primary claims, supporting evidence, and conclusions using hierarchical numbering () or lettering.
- Summarizing: Restates core arguments in coherent, self-authored sentence and paragraph form with explicit logical connectors.
- Analyzing: Adds evaluative judgments to summarization by testing logic, evidence credibility, and emotional impact. Evaluates what is asserted, tests whether evidence is compelling, and assesses overall argument efficacy.
Habit 4: Looking for Repetitions and Patterns
- Identifies implicit priorities, underlying ideological positions, hidden agendas, and authorial bias.
- Focuses on tracking recurring visual imagery, repeated words or key phrases, structural patterns in examples, and consistent characterizations of key figures or events.
Habit 5: Contextualizing
- Frame the reading within its historical, cultural, material, and intellectual circumstances at the time and place of its original publication.
- Re-examine the text through the lens of individual reader background, values, and personal experiences.
Habit 6: Comparing and Contrasting
- Positions individual readings within the broader context of a course curriculum.
- Evaluates how a text builds upon, expands, shifts, or contradicts the arguments presented in preceding texts.
Reading Like a Writer (RLW) Framework

Origin and Concept:
- Conceptualized by Mike Bunn (2011) based on his experience in 1997 working as a recent college graduate at the Palace Theatre in London’s West End.
- Assigned to wear a bright red tuxedo jacket and sit inside dark auditoriums watching three-hour performances of Les Misérables eight times a week to satisfy antiquated city fire-safety laws.
- Reading line-by-line with a tiny flashlight amid loud stage noise forced intense focus, revealing that writing is an incremental, word-by-word, sentence-by-sentence process composed of deliberate authorial choices.
Core Definition of Reading Like a Writer:
- RLW is the systematic identification of choices made by an author to understand how those techniques function and evaluate whether to adopt similar strategies in one's own writing.
- Contrasts sharply with reading for information or content; it focuses on how a text is constructed rather than merely what it says.
Architectural and Carpentry Analogies:
- Allen Tate Metaphor (1940): Reading for content is like a historian analyzing the origin of Corinthian columns. Reading like a writer is like an architect examining every beam, nail, and peg in a building to learn how to construct a building oneself.
- David Jauss Metaphor: RLW requires examining a book the way a carpenter examines a house built by someone else, studying structural construction details.
Scholarly Perspectives on RLW:
- Wendy Bishop: Shifted from recording personal reactions to uncovering how a writer evokes specific emotions and creates memorable phrasing.
- Charles Moran: Notes that because readers are writers themselves, they possess a built-in advantage to participate in choices and observe how authors handle consequences.
- Nancy Walker: Asserts that RLW transforms published prose from an unchangeable "stone tablet" into a living utterance that could have been improved or altered through alternate choices.
Prereading Contextual Questions:
- What is the author’s explicit purpose?
- Who is the specific intended audience?
- What is the text's genre (e.g., essay, poem, newspaper article, legal brief, instruction manual)?
- Is the text published or student-produced?
- Does the text serve as a direct structural model for an upcoming writing assignment?
Active Questions During Reading:
- Is the level of language formality effective, appropriate, too formal, or too informal?
- What types of evidence are deployed (e.g., statistical data, expert quotes, personal anecdotes, historical citations), and is the evidence compelling?
- Where do points of confusion occur, and what specific syntactic or stylistic choices caused the breakdown?
- How are transitions between distinct ideas executed?
Three-Step Note-Taking Method for RLW:
- Identify and highlight/underline the specific writerly technique used.
- Evaluate whether the technique is effective in its context.
- Analyze the explicit advantages and disadvantages of adopting the same technique in personal writing.
Worked Example Analysis (Opening Paragraph of Bunn’s Essay):
- Original Sentence: "In 1997, I was a recent college graduate living in London for six months and working at the Palace Theatre owned by Andrew Lloyd Webber."
- Omitted Detail Revision: "In 1997, I was living in London and working at a theatre that showed Les Miserables."
- Choice Analysis: Including "recent college graduate" builds initial credibility and connects directly with student readers; referencing "Andrew Lloyd Webber" drops a recognizable cultural name to frame context; using "antiquated" instead of "old" establishes a formal tone and clear critical bias against fire laws; choosing "performance" over "show" maintains elevated stylistic diction.
Principles of Rhetoric, Argument, and Rhetorical Analysis
Definition of Rhetoric:
- Defined by Aristotle () as "the faculty of observing in any given case the available means of persuasion."
- Represents the strategic use of language to persuade, inform, educate, or entertain across written, visual, and spoken modes.
The Rhetorical Triangle (Aristotelian Triangle):

Speaker/Writer (Persona): The individual or group creating the text. The persona ("mask") represents the specific face, authority, or character projected to the audience, which may differ from the author's real-life identity.
Audience: The intended primary, secondary, or unintended recipients of the text. Evaluated based on shared/individual values, background knowledge, and initial stance (friendly, neutral, or hostile).
Subject / Message: The central argument, claim, or position conveyed regarding a specific topic.
- The Six Components of the Rhetorical Situation:

Writer: Identity, background, perspective, values, and projected persona.
Message: The core assertion, thesis, or claim supported by evidence and reasoning.
Purpose: The explicit outcome or action the writer seeks to accomplish (e.g., to persuade, narrate, inform, evaluate, call to action).
Exigence: The specific spark, obstacle, trigger, or urgent situation that prompts the writer to create the text at that moment.
Context: The broad historical, political, social, cultural, spatial, and temporal circumstances surrounding text creation.
Audience: The targeted readership, including their pre-existing beliefs, values, needs, and assumptions.
- Classical Rhetorical Appeals:
Ethos (Character & Credibility): Establishes author trustworthiness, expertise, authority, sincerity, and shared values with the audience.
Logos (Reason & Logic): Appeals to logic through clear main ideas, precise definitions, clear cause-and-effect reasoning, factual evidence, statistics, expert testimony, and quantitative visual data (charts/graphs).
- Counterargument Structure: Concession (acknowledging the validity of opposing views) Refutation (denying overall validity using evidence) Rebuttal (offering a contrasting perspective that proves competing positions unfounded).
Pathos (Emotion): Appeals to emotional needs, desires, hopes, fears, values, or prejudices. Pure emotional appeal without logical grounding degenerates into unpersuasive propaganda.
- Stylistic Elements & Language Choices:
Diction: Strategic choice of words.
- Denotation: Literal dictionary definition of a word.
- Connotation: Implicit emotional triggers and societal associations tied to a word.
- Vivid Modifiers & Active Verbs: Precise descriptive elements and action verbs that energize sentences and appeal to the senses.
- Formality Level: Formal diction (strict adherence to grammatical rules, avoidance of slang) vs. Informal diction (conversational expressions, colloquialisms to build rapport).
Syntax: The intentional arrangement of words, phrases, and clauses into sentence patterns to emphasize specific ideas.
Grammar & Punctuation Mechanics: Precise deployment of commas, colons, semicolons, dashes, hyphens, parentheses, italics, and boldface to define relationships between ideas or signal intentional shifts in tone and logic.
Tone: The writer's structural attitude toward the subject, characterized by precise adjectives (e.g., ceremonial, urgent, somber, detached, ironic). Tone shifts highlight qualifications or re-evaluations of arguments.
- Structure of Argument & Types of Claims:
Claim: An arguable assertion taking a definitive position on a subject.
Claims of Fact: Assert that something is or is not true; become arguable when factual interpretations are contested.
Claims of Value: Argue the worth, moral stance, or quality of something (good/bad, right/wrong) based on established evaluation criteria.
Claims of Policy: Direct proposals advocating for legal, institutional, or behavioral changes.
- Types of Supporting Evidence:
Personal Observation & Experience: Humanizes abstract concepts, particularly in introductory or concluding sections.
Anecdotes: Stories regarding third-party experiences gathered through observation or research.
Analogies: Comparative explanations connecting unfamiliar concepts to familiar ones.
Current Events: Contemporary real-world occurrences used to illustrate arguments.
Historical Information: Grounding context that builds ethos by demonstrating thorough research.
Expert Opinion: Direct evidence sourced from domain-specific, authoritative figures.
Quantitative Evidence: Statistically measurable data (surveys, polls, empirical experiments) represented textually or graphically.
Primary Reading Analysis: Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson
Background and Overview:
- Author Bryan Stevenson, a young Harvard-educated attorney, founded the Equal Justice Initiative (EJI) to represent indigent, wrongly convicted, and marginalized individuals trapped in the criminal justice system.
- Central narrative focuses on Walter McMillian, a young Black man sentenced to death in Alabama for a high-profile murder he did not commit.
- The case exposes systemic racial bias, political machination, legal misconduct, and law enforcement conspiracy.
Analytical Rhetorical Situation Questions:
- Writer/Speaker:
- Identity & Expertise: Bryan Stevenson, founder of EJI, veteran capital defense attorney.
- Credibility (Ethos): Established through direct courtroom experiences, personal risk, legal victories, and firsthand representation of death row clients.
- Core Values: Equal justice, human dignity, mercy, systemic reform, and moral accountability.
- Message:
- Flaws in the American legal system systematically criminalize poverty and race.
- "The opposite of poverty is not wealth; the opposite of poverty is justice."
- Core thesis statement: Every human being is worth more than the worst thing they have ever done.
- Evidence Base: Combined legal case briefs, statistical data on mass incarceration, historical records of lynching and racial terror, and deeply personal biographical narratives.
- Purpose:
- Expose structural racism and corruption within capital punishment and prison systems.
- Inspire public empathy, humanize condemned prisoners, and motivate legal and policy reforms.
- Exigence:
- Escalating rates of mass incarceration, disproportionate death row sentencing among racial minorities, and systemic neglect of impoverished defendants in the United States.
- Context:
- Published in 2014 following decades of "tough on crime" legislation, expansion of the prison-industrial complex, and ongoing racial disparities in Southern judicial systems.
- Audience:
- American citizenry, legal professionals, policy makers, and individuals holding comfortable assumptions regarding judicial fairness.
Supplemental Speech Analysis: "The Danger of a Single Story" by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
Background and Delivery:
- Delivered as a TED Talk in 2009 by Nigerian author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie.
Key Narrative Evidence & Examples:
- Childhood Reading & Writing:
- Began reading at age 2 or 4 and writing at age 7 with crayon illustrations.
- Wrote stories modeled strictly on British and American children's books: characters were white, blue-eyed, played in snow, ate apples, discussed sunny weather, and drank ginger beer—despite Adichie living in Nigeria, eating mangoes, never experiencing snow, and never needing to discuss the weather.
- Discovery of African Literature:
- Reading works by Chinua Achebe and Camara Laye produced a mental shift, revealing that girls with chocolate skin and kinky hair could exist in literature.
- Saved her from having a single story of what literature is.
- Domestic Help (Fide):
- Adichie's mother emphasized only that house boy Fide's family was "very poor." When visiting Fide's village, Fide's mother presented a beautifully patterned raffia basket crafted by Fide's brother.
- Adichie was shocked because poverty had become her single story of Fide's family.
- American College Roommate (Age 19):
- Expressed default patronizing pity; was shocked by Adichie's fluent English (Nigeria's official language);
- Expected "tribal music" and was disappointed by a Mariah Carey cassette tape; assumed Adichie could not operate a kitchen stove.
- Historical Western Narrative Roots:
- Cites London merchant John Locke’s 1561 voyage log describing Sub-Saharan Africans as "beasts who have no houses" and "people without heads, having their mouth and eyes in their breasts."
- References Rudyard Kipling’s characterization of non-Western peoples as "half devil, half child."
- Academic Criticism:
- A literature professor stated Adichie's novel was not "authentically African" because her characters were educated, middle-class, drove cars, and were not starving.
- Guadalajara, Mexico Travel Experience:
- Realized she had bought into American media coverage depicting Mexicans exclusively as illegal immigrants fleecing healthcare systems and sneaking across borders.
- Felt deep shame upon observing citizens in Guadalajara working, rolling up tortillas, smoking, and laughing.
- Student Exchange on American Psycho:
- A male student remarked it was a shame Nigerian men were physical abusers based on her novel's father character.
- Adichie countered that it was a shame young Americans were serial killers based on Bret Easton Ellis's novel American Psycho.
Theoretical Frameworks & Concepts:
- Power Dynamics (Nkali):
- Igbo noun translating to "to be greater than another."
- Power dictates how stories are told, who tells them, when they are told, how many are told, and making a single story the definitive narrative of a people.
- Dispossession Mechanism (Mourid Barghouti):
- Palestinian poet Mourid Barghouti noted that to dispossess a people, the simplest method is to start their story with "secondly" (e.g., starting with Native American arrows rather than British arrival, or starting with African state failure rather than colonial state creation).
- Definition of Stereotypes:
- Stereotypes are problematic not because they are inherently false, but because they are incomplete; they make one story become the only story, robbing people of dignity.
Positive Counter-Narratives:
- Publisher Mukta Bakaray and Farafina Trust establishing affordable literature in Nigeria.
- A female TV messenger in Lagos taking active ownership of Adichie's book and prescribing plot details for a sequel.
- Fumi Onda hosting TV shows on difficult Nigerian history; advanced heart surgeries performed in Lagos hospitals; Nollywood filmmakers; contemporary musicians mixing Jay-Z, Fela, and Bob Marley.
- Alice Walker’s account of northern-migrated Southern relatives regaining "a kind of paradise" upon reading literature about their former lives.
Synthesis Connection to Just Mercy:
- Criminal defendants are frequently reduced to a "single story" of criminality by prosecutors, media, and juries. Stevenson’s legal defense work restores multi-dimensional human dignity to condemned individuals.
Supplemental Speech Analysis: "The Perils of Indifference" by Elie Wiesel
Background and Delivery:
- Delivered on April 12, 1999, at the White House in Washington, D.C., as part of the Millennium Lectures series hosted by President Bill Clinton and Hillary Clinton.
Historical Circumstance & Liberation Context:
- Delivered exactly years after Wiesel’s liberation as a 16-year-old boy from Buchenwald concentration camp on April 11, 1945.
- Recalls the rage and compassion in the eyes of liberating American soldiers.
- Coincides with the exact anniversary of President Franklin D. Roosevelt's death (April 12, 1945).
Etymology & Definition of Indifference:
- Etymological meaning: "No difference."
- Defined as an unnatural, dangerous state in which boundaries blur between light and darkness, dusk and dawn, cruelty and compassion, good and evil.
- Indifference reduces fellow human beings to meaningless abstractions.
- The Muselmänner Metaphor: Highlights the ultimate victims of Auschwitz—prisoners wrapped in torn blankets who stared vacantly, feeling no pain, hunger, thirst, or fear; they were dead without knowing it.
- Theological Dimension: Asserts that being ignored or abandoned by humanity and God is a harsher punishment than suffering God's active anger. An unjust God is preferable to an indifferent God.
Rhetorical Contrast: Passion vs. Indifference:
- Anger: Can be creative, prompting great poetry, symphonies, and active struggles against injustice.
- Hatred: Elicits direct opposition; can be fought, denounced, and disarmed.
- Indifference: Elicits zero response; it is not a beginning but an end. Indifference always benefits the aggressor and betrays the victim by exiling them from human memory.
Catalog of 20th-Century Historical Failures:
- Atrocities: Two World Wars, civil wars, gulags, Hiroshima, Auschwitz, Treblinka, and bloodbaths in Cambodia, Algeria, India/Pakistan, Ireland, Rwanda, Eritrea/Ethiopia, Sarajevo, and Kosovo.
- Political Assassinations: Mahatma Gandhi, John F. Kennedy, Robert F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King Jr., Anwar Sadat, Yitzhak Rabin.
- U.S. Governmental Indifference:
- Pentagon, State Department, and FDR possessed documented knowledge of Nazi death camps but failed to bomb railways leading to Birkenau.
- The S.S. St. Louis Incident: In 1939, following Kristallnacht, a ship carrying nearly Jewish refugees was turned away from American shores and forced back to Europe.
- Corporate Complicity: Major American corporations continued trading with Nazi Germany until 1942; the German Wehrmacht relied on American oil during the invasion of France.
- Post-War Priority Inversion: Greater international effort was expended securing safe passage for fleeing SS murderers after the war than saving victims during the war.
Signs of Historical Progress & Hope:
- Defeat of Nazism, collapse of Soviet communism, rebirth of Israel, demise of South African apartheid, Egypt-Israel peace treaty, Irish peace accords, and the Rabin-Arafat peace handshake at the White House.
- Kosovo Intervention: Commends the joint US/NATO military intervention in Kosovo as a decisive break from historic indifference to halt ethnic cleansing.
Synthesis Connection to Just Mercy:
- Indifference allows legal abuses, solitary confinement, and execution of innocent people to persist unmonitored. Stevenson’s advocacy represents an active, courageous rejection of indifference.