Week 7: Comprehensive Study Notes on Unfair Contract Terms

Overview of Unfair Contract Terms and Legal Controls

  • Classification of Contractual Clauses Regulating Liability:

    • Exclusion Clauses: Terms that seek to completely eliminate liability for breaches of obligation, duty of care, or statutory duties.
    • Limitation of Liability Clauses: Terms that place a monetary cap or procedural restriction on a party's legal exposure in the event of a breach.
  • Dual Framework of Protection:

    • Common Law Rules: Judicial mechanisms focusing on the threshold requirements of incorporation and rigorous principles of contractual interpretation (such as the contra proferentem rule).
    • Statutory Frameworks: Legislative regimes that actively invalidate or limit the enforceability of unfair terms:
    • Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 (UCTA 1977): Primarily controls business-to-business (B2B) transactions.
    • Consumer Rights Act 2015 (CRA 2015): Governs business-to-consumer (B2C) contracts.

Common Law Protections: Incorporation and Interpretation

  • Incorporation of Terms:

    • At common law, an exclusion or limitation clause must be properly incorporated into the contract to have legal effect.
    • Notice for Onerous or Unusual Terms: Higher and more explicit standards of notice are required for a clause to be sufficiently incorporated if the term is particularly onerous or unusual.
  • Interpretation and the Contra Proferentem Rule:

    • Definition: Contra proferentem dictates that any ambiguity in a contractual term is interpreted strictly against the party who drafted it or seeks to rely upon it.
    • Exclusion of Negligence Liability:
    • Full legal effect will be given to an express exclusion of liability for negligence at common law, provided statutory provisions do not intervene to prevent it.
    • If the wording of a clause does not explicitly refer to negligence and can reasonably be construed as referring to another head of liability (such as strict contractual liability), it will not be effective to exclude negligence.
    • Authoritative Precedent: Canada Steamship Lines Ltd v R [1952] sets the criteria for interpreting clauses purporting to exempt liability for negligence.

Statutory Protection: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 (UCTA 1977)

  • Scope and Objective:

    • UCTA 1977 is largely concerned with clauses seeking to exclude or limit liability for breach of obligations, including:
    • Breach of an express or implied contract term.
    • Breach of a common law duty of care (negligence).
    • Interplay with Consumer Legislation: Since the enactment and commencement of the Consumer Rights Act 2015, UCTA 1977 no longer applies to consumer contracts; its scope is restricted to business-to-business agreements and non-consumer transactions.
  • Section 2: Control of Negligence Liability:

    • Section 2(1): A person cannot by reference to any contract term or to a notice given to persons generally or to particular persons exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence under any circumstances (absolute statutory bar).
    • Section 2(2): In the case of other loss or damage (such as financial loss or property damage), liability for negligence cannot be excluded or restricted except insofar as the term or notice satisfies the requirement of reasonableness.
    • Section 2(4): Explicitly states that Section 2 does not apply to a term within a consumer contract.
  • Schedule 2: Statutory Guidelines for the Reasonableness Test:

    • When assessing whether a contractual term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness under UCTA 1977, regard is had to statutory guidelines, including:
    • The relative strength of the bargaining positions of the parties, taking into account alternative means by which the customer's requirements could have been met.
    • Whether the customer received an inducement to agree to the term.
    • Whether the customer, in accepting the term, had the opportunity of entering into a similar contract with other persons without having to accept a similar term.

Case Law on the Statutory Test of Reasonableness Under UCTA 1977

  • Philips Products v Hyland [1987] 1 WLR 659:

    • Concerned the application of the Section 2(2) requirement of reasonableness regarding negligence liability.
    • Key Factual Factors Determining Unreasonableness on Balance:
    • Bargaining Inequality: The hirer was placed in a "take it or leave it" situation.
    • Lack of Control: The hirer had no role or choice in selecting the specific operator/driver provided.
    • Absence of Warranty: The provider gave no warranty regarding the fitness or competence of the driver/operator.
    • Expertise Differential: The hired operator was an expert, meaning the hirer was not in a position to give meaningful instructions or direct the technical performance.
    • Insurance Opportunity: As determined by the trial judge, there was little practical opportunity for the plaintiffs to arrange insurance cover for risks arising from the first defendant's negligence.
  • St Albans City and District CC v International Computers Ltd [1996] 4 All ER 481:

    • Concerned a limitation of liability clause for breach of contract governed by Section 3 of UCTA 1977.
    • Procedural Rule: The legal burden of proof to establish that a clause satisfies the requirement of reasonableness rests entirely on the defendant seeking to rely on it.
    • Key Grounds for Finding the Term Unreasonable:
    • Resources: The defendants were a "very substantial company" with the financial capacity to meet the liability, and they offered no commercial justification for capping their liability.
    • Insurance: The defendants carried substantial product liability insurance coverage. They produced no evidence to demonstrate that it was fair and reasonable to limit their liability, while the local council was uninsured for the specific risk.
    • Bargaining Position: The defendants held an excessively strong bargaining position because they were one of a very limited number of suppliers able to fulfill the council's requirements, and all comparable suppliers operated under standard terms with similar limitations.
    • Absence of Inducement: The council received no commercial inducement to accept the limitation clause, nor did they have access to alternative suppliers willing to contract without such a clause.
    • Judicial Principle: "I do not think it unreasonable that he who stands to make a profit (ICL) should take the risk."

Statutory Protection: Consumer Rights Act 2015 (CRA 2015)

  • Scope and Legislative Background:

    • Applies exclusively to business-to-consumer contracts (contracts between "traders" and "consumers").
    • Originates from previous European Union Regulations, and judicial case law interpreting those underlying EU directives remains authoritative in interpreting the CRA 2015.
    • Replaced UCTA 1977 in respect of consumer agreements and codified substantial aspects of the Sale of Goods Act.
  • Core Substantive Provisions Under Section 62:

    • Section 62(1): An unfair term in a consumer contract is not binding on the consumer.
    • Section 62(3): The non-binding nature of an unfair term does not prevent the consumer from relying on the term or notice if they choose to do so.
    • Section 62(4) General Test of Unfairness: A term is unfair if, contrary to the requirement of good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations under the contract to the detriment of the consumer.
  • Section 65: Absolute Prohibition on Negligence Exclusion:

    • Governed under CRA 2015 Part 2, Section 65.
    • A trader cannot, by means of a consumer contract term or consumer notice, exclude or restrict legal liability for death or personal injury resulting from negligence.
  • Schedule 2: "The Grey List" (Section 63):

    • Section 63 introduces Schedule 2, an indicative, non-exhaustive list of contractual terms that may be regarded as unfair:
    • Terms that have the object or effect of inappropriately excluding or limiting the legal rights of the consumer in relation to the trader (or another party) in the event of total non-performance, partial non-performance, or inadequate contractual performance by the trader.
    • Terms that have the object or effect of making an agreement binding upon the consumer where the provision of services by the trader is subject to a condition whose realisation depends entirely on the trader's will alone.
  • Institutional Enforcement:

    • Application and enforcement of the CRA unfair terms provisions operate through judicial interpretation in litigation and proactive administrative enforcement by regulatory bodies, notably the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA).

Practical Impact and Regulatory Enforcement

  • Regulatory Intervention vs Private Litigation:
    • Empirical scholarship by Susan Bright ('Winning the Battle Against Unfair Contract Terms', Legal Studies, Vol. 20, No. 3, 2000) demonstrates that administrative regulation and preventative scrutiny are far more effective at combating unfair terms in practice than individual consumer litigation.
    • In the period spanning 2000 to 2005, a total of 5,000 unfair contract terms were either amended or completely abandoned following investigations by the Office of Fair Trading (OFT).