Pantomine

Introduction to the Author: Derek Walcott

Derek Walcott was born on January 2323, 19301930, in Castries, Saint Lucia.

  • Background: He is recognized as a Caribbean poet and playwright. He attended the University of the West Indies in Jamaica and later resided in Trinidad and the United States.

  • Cultural Identity: His identity is described as fragmented, positioned between his Caribbean upbringing, his English education, and his African origins.

  • Achievements: Walcott won the Nobel Prize for Literature in 19921992.

  • Significant Poetry Collections:

    • *In a Green Night: Poems 19481948–19601960

    • The Castaway and Other Poems (19651965)

    • The Gulf (19691969)

Genesis and Content of Pantomime

  • Performance and Publication:

    • The play was first performed in 19781978 at the Little Caribbean Theatre in Port of Spain, Trinidad. This performance occurred the year before St. Lucia achieved full independence from the UK.

    • It was first published in 19801980.

  • Structure: It is a two-act play that adheres to the Aristotelian unity of time.

  • Central Premise:

    • The play features two protagonists: Harry Trewe and Jackson Phillip.

    • The narrative depicts the relationship between an employer (Harry) and an employee (Jackson) as they contemplate staging a reverse rendition of Robinson Crusoe for hotel guests.

    • The play serves as a metaphorical examination of the post-Independence relationship between the Colony and the Empire.

Historical and Geographical Context

  • Trinidad and Tobago:

    • Independent from British colonizers since August 3131, 19621962.

    • Became a republic in 19761976.

    • It is a one-state, two-island nation located near the Venezuelan coast. This is the setting where Robinson Crusoe is stranded in Daniel Defoe's novel.

  • Colonization of the West Indies:

    • The region saw various colonizers throughout the 17th17^{th} and 18th18^{th} centuries, including the Dutch, Spanish, French, Danish, and British.

    • This period was defined by white supremacy, Eurocentric ideology, and plantation colonies fueled by slavery (primarily sugar production).

    • Slavery was abolished between 18341834 and 18381838, resulting in the immediate freeing of 750,000750,000 slaves.

  • Decolonization:

    • The decolonization wave was inspired by geopolitical events such as the Cold War.

    • In Trinidad and Tobago, the transition was relatively peaceful compared to other regions that suffered racial hostility or genocide.

    • The West Indies Federation: Created in 19581958 (including Trinidad, Jamaica, and Barbados) as a way to establish a democratic sovereign state. Britain resisted a "myriad of island states."

    • Jamaica left the federation in 19611961, which accelerated decolonization elsewhere.

Spatial and Temporal Setting

  • Temporal Setting: The play is set between 19621962 (independence) and 19801980 (publication). Textual evidence includes mentions that "Dem days gone" regarding British ownership and racist comments implying the proximity of the colonial era.

  • Spatial Setting:

    • The action takes place in a gazebo on the edge of a cliff, part of a guesthouse on the island of Tobago.

    • The guesthouse is named Castaways, which serves as an intertextual reference to Defoe's Robinson Crusoe and Walcott’s own 19651965 poetry bundle.

    • The guesthouse is described as old and in need of repair, serving as a symbol for the postcolonial state of the Caribbean.

    • The setting remains stationary in the gazebo, though actors are noted to leave and re-enter to indicate moving elsewhere (e.g., using the bathroom).

Character Analysis: Jackson Phillip and Harry Trewe

  • Jackson Phillip:

    • A man in his mid-forties from Trinidad working for Harry on Tobago.

    • He is a retired Calypsonian (a singer of traditional Latin American music called Calypso).

    • He represents "Creole acting," focusing on Creole language and identity.

    • Attributes: Sarcastic, witty, and sharp-tongued. He mocks Harry's language, asking if "fuflee" is "Anglo-Saxon English."

  • Harry Trewe:

    • A British man in his mid-forties and the owner of the guest house.

    • Portrayed as the antagonist (though this is debated) and a representation of the British Empire.

    • Attributes: Dramatic personality, maintainer of a "stiff upper lip," but emotionally vulnerable.

    • He believes that for him, "war is over," implying a belief that independence has settled all historical debts.

Character Dynamics and Colonial Binaries

  • Initial Interaction:

    • Defined by colonial standards and a professional hierarchy. Harry is the white employer; Jackson is the black employee.

    • Jackson fears social repercussions if Harry acts abnormally (e.g., being naked in front of him) because his "name is immediately mud" in the eyes of society.

    • The duo's worldviews are mocked by a "pre-colonial parrot."

  • Role Reversal:

    • During the "play-within-a-play," Jackson takes the role of the master (Crusoe) and Harry takes the role of the servant (Friday).

    • Jackson eventually enjoys the master role, even suggesting names like "Thursday" to reject the names imposed by colonizers.

    • Harry finds the reversal hilarious until it becomes "offensive" and he realizes the depth of cultural erasure. He realizes that a true reversal would require unlearning 2,0002,000 years of Western civilization.

  • Rapprochement in Act II:

    • Act II begins with a man-to-man apology from Harry to Jackson.

    • Total vulnerability is shown as Jackson role-plays as Harry’s divorced wife to help Harry process the death of his son and his failed marriage.

    • This leads to a cathartic climax and mutual respect. By the end, Harry addresses Jackson as "Mr. Phillip" rather than just Jackson, and Jackson feels empowered to ask for a pay raise "man-to-man."

Genre and Style Analysis

  • Pantomime as Title and Genre:

    • Outside Britain: Refers to miming (acting without speech using body and face).

    • In Britain ("Panto"): A funny musical play based on children's stories, often performed at Christmas, featuring singing, dancing, and role reversal.

    • Walcott uses both: exaggerated gestures/imaginary props (miming) and the adaptation of a classic story with role reversal (panto).

  • Chamber Play and Two-Hander:

    • A Chamber Play focuses on emotion/mood over action with a small cast and intimate setting.

    • A Two-Hander is written specifically for two characters, focusing on their relationship and social standing.

  • Postcolonial Play and Metatheatre:

    • It critiques colonial discourse by rewriting classic colonial texts to expose the duplicity of authority.

    • Metatheatre involves a "play-within-a-play" (the Crusoe skit) to express this critique.

  • Calypso and Cabaret:

    • Calypso: An Afro-Caribbean genre with syncopated rhythms, often containing improvised political commentary.

    • Cabaret: Theatrical entertainment performed in hotels/restaurants. Harry suggests turning the guest house into a cabaret with "witty acts."

Key Themes: Mimicry and Carnivalesque

  • Mimicry:

    • Homi K. Bhaba's Definition: The colonized mimics the colonizer (habits, values) to mock them—"almost the same, but not quite."

    • V.S. Naipaul’s View: Mimicry in the Caribbean is uncreative, unauthentic, and a sign of a lack of originality.

    • Walcott’s Counter-Response: Walcott argues mimicry is universal (e.g., American culture is mimicry) and is the first stage of invention. It is a survival strategy/imagination needed to rebuild identity from "nothing."

  • Carnivalesque:

    • Based on Mikhail Bakhtin's theory regarding the subversive influence of popular humor/grotesque satire.

    • Involves the "world upside-down" and the inversion of social structures.

    • Critique of Colonial Ideology: Jackson satirizes Christianity by equating communion with cannibalism ("kneel down and eat this man"), challenging the colonial notion of a universal religion.

Gender Roles and Masculinity

  • Colonial Masculinity: Colonialists relied on paternalist masculinity to legitimize rule, while anti-colonialists used resistance masculinity to reclaim dignity.

  • Dominance Struggles: Both Harry and Jackson try to establish dominance and fear being seen as vulnerable or feminized.

  • Homosexual Panicked Sequences:

    • Both characters use anecdotes of violence against homosexual advances to assert their heterosexuality and power.

    • Jackson tells a story of using an ice pick on a man who harrassed him.

    • Harry tells a story of playing a "vamp" (transvestite role) in a panto while in the army and later attacking a sergeant who "pinched his arse."

  • Cross-gender Roleplaying:

    • Jackson plays Harry's wife, Ellen, to facilitate Harry's emotional healing.

    • Harry previously played the servant (Friday) to his wife's Crusoe in a panto, an experience that was submissive and humiliating for him. He wants to redo the play to reaffirm his manhood.


Adherence to Classical Unities:

  • Unity of Time: The action takes place within a single day, respecting the classical requirement

  • Unity of Place: The action occurs entirely in a single location: the guest house in Tobago

  • Unity of Action: There are no subplots. While there are two focal points—the aftermath of colonialism (affecting both) and Harry’s private trauma—they are inextricably linked. Harry's trauma is resolved through the rapprochement of the characters during their psychodrama .

  • Dramatic Device: The play utilizes a play-within-a-play, defined as a performance inserted into the main play

  • Analysis of Dramatic Arcs:

    • Two Possible Readings:

      1. Single Arc across Two Acts: This arc involves reluctance, followed by overenthusiastic participation, quarrelling, a truth-revealing psychodrama (as per Yeats: "Give a man a mask, and he will talk the truth"), and an apparently harmonious resolution

      2. Separate Arcs per Act:

        • Act I: Begins with Harry's proposal of the satirical pantomime based on Robinson Crusoe. It moves through reluctance, participation (where Jackson attempts to dominate), and ends with unresolved tension.

        • Act II: Opens with renewed conflict and power struggles. It centers on a psychodrama where Jackson confronts Harry's insecurities by performing as Harry's wife. This leads to a partial reconciliation/rapprochement and a lighter tone

  • The Semi-Open Ending:

    • The play has an open ending, which Preis defines as one that leaves plot resolution ambiguous, fails to fulfill emotional expectations of a climax, and questions existing ideologies rather than reassuring them.

    • In Pantomime, while there is rapprochement and shared laughter at the end, the power balance is not reversed; Harry remains the boss and Jackson remains the employee who must assert that "man must live"

Intertextual References to Robinson Crusoe

  • Context of the Original Work: Robinson Crusoe was written by Daniel Defoe in 17191719 during the rise of the British Empire. It is the definitive colonial adventure narrative.

  • The Robinsonade Genre: Defined by Lipski as a narrative involving adventures before/after a calamity, an island setting, isolation, physical challenges for a castaway, encounters with alien Others, and eventual rescue.

  • Character Parallels:

    • Robinson Crusoe: In Defoe, the European colonizer. In Walcott, represented by Harry Trewe (the white master employer).

    • Friday: In Defoe, the native "cannibal" rescued and converted by Crusoe to be his servant. In Walcott, represented by Jackson Phillip (the black servant employee).

  • Strategic Rewriting:

    • Walcott challenges the colonial ideas in Defoe’s work by setting his play in post-independence Tobago.

    • Role Reversal: Jackson resists submission. He argues that in a free society, he can play anyone—Crusoe, Columbus, or Sir Francis Drake—and refuses to let Harry "draw the line" on his performance.

    • The Name Change: Jackson renames the character Friday to Thursday, symbolizing a break from the original script and a refusal of the submissive role.

    • Religion and Culture: Jackson suggests a reversal where the "cannibal" (now Christian) must teach the African, forcing the colonizer into the position of the colonized.

Play-Within-the-Play as Postcolonial Criticism

  • Metatheatre: Defined as "drama about drama" (Baldick 20152015: 305305). It is an artistic agency of self-reference and self-reflection (Fischer 20072007: 1212). In Pantomime, characters actively reflect on the performance they are creating.

  • Types of Postcolonial Metatheatre:

    • Counter-Discursive Metatheatre: Rewrites a "classical" colonial text. Jackson’s interpretation of Crusoe uses "Creole acting" to go against Defoe’s original narrative, suggesting a future social reorganization

    • Allegorical Metatheatre: Re-situates history. Harry Trewe acts as a personification of the Empire, while Jackson Phillip represents the colonized Otras. When Trewe becomes uncomfortable with the reenacted colonial violence, he uses an "imaginary camera" to avert the audience's gaze

    • Mimicking/Parodic Metatheatre: Involves the desire to parody and provides an ironic comment on the original. It contains both "Imitation" and "Menace."

  • The Concept of Menace:

    • Repetition with a difference (critical distance).

    • The Parrot Metaphor: Jackson kills the guest house parrot. The parrot represents the mimicry of pre-colonial, racist ideology (repeating racist discourse with a different accent). Jackson's violent reaction is a postcolonial critique of this mindless repetition.

    • Acting Styles: Trewe tries to contain Jackson’s performance by calling it "savagery" when it becomes too real and threatening, but Jackson’s independence from the role positions him as the "real master".

Presentation of the Other

  • Colonial Stereotypes: Traditional colonial texts (like Robinson Crusoe) use textual practice to maintain hierarchies of power. The "Other" (Black/non-Westerner) is typically painted as irrational, dark, or savage.

  • Jackson’s Use of Stereotypes:

    • Jackson performs the stereotypes (mimicry) exaggeratedly to show the gap between the construction and his real self.

    • Cannibalism: Jackson rejects the term while referencing it: "Carnival, but not cannibal" (Walcott 19801980: 9696). Stam (19891989) notes cannibalism is the "name of the other" in Western tradition.

    • The "Wicked Nigger" Trope: Jackson mocks the assumed superiority of colonizers by rolling on the floor laughing and crying "Friday bad boy! Friday wicked nigger".

  • Reality vs. Performance: In reality, Jackson is more sensible and composed than Harry, often correcting or advising him. This contrast highlights that the "Other" is a construction.

  • Carnivalesque Reversal:

    • Defined as the moment symbolic categories of hierarchy are inverted

    • It is not a simple binary flip; instead, hierarchy is blurred. This reveals the inextricably mixed nature of cultural life and exposes the arbitrary exercise of power.

Use of Language

  • Standard English vs. Creole: Standard English is the site of authority/colonial power; Creole reflects Caribbean identity and local culture.

  • Linguistic Resistance:

    • Jackson utilizes code-switching to challenge Harry's authority and destabilize the hierarchy.

    • Initial Dynamic: Harry uses Standard English to control and organize the performance.

    • Strategic Subversion: Jackson imitates and parodies Harry's Standard English to expose its artificiality.

  • Language Creation: The play highlights linguistic hybridity. Through improvisation and "Creole acting," Jackson produces new forms of expression that reflect Caribbean identity, showing that language is flexible and constructed rather than fixed.

"The Figure of Crusoe" Essay (19651965)

  • Background: The essay was foundational for the play Pantomime. Walcott identifies Crusoe as part of the "mythology of every West Indian child".

  • The Shape-Shifter (Proteus): Walcott compares Crusoe to the Greek god Proteus because his identity is not fixed. He can be Adam (the namer), Columbus, a Missionary, or a Beachcomber. Walcott relates to Crusoe as the Craftsman and the Namer (Adam) because he acts by conscience rather than authority.

  • Crusoe vs. Prospero: Walcott prefers Crusoe over Shakespeare’s Prospero because Crusoe is more humble, a worker with "human beginnings," making him a more real symbol for the West Indian experience.

  • Cultural Shipwreck:

    • Metaphor: The shipwreck represents the wreckage of English literary heritage left to the West Indian writer.

    • Response to Naipaul: V.S. Naipaul famously claimed "nothing was created in the West Indies." Walcott counters this, asserting that because West Indians must build from the "scraps" of colonial culture, the result will be "like nothing any one has ever seen before".

    • The Writer’s Position: West Indian writers are like Crusoe—stranded with the English language and a "wreckage" of colonial literature, they must use these tools to name their own reality.

Questions and Discussion

  • Can the Empire ever be fully unwritten?

    • The class concluded that while it is difficult since the tools are inherited from the Empire, postcolonial writers can criticize the discursive universe by rewriting canonical texts.

  • Is Harry Trewe the antagonist?

    • Interpreted multiple ways: He represents colonial ideas, but also shows growth through the play. Jackson acts as a "helper" or catalyst for Harry’s rapprochement.

  • Is the play comical?

    • Yes, it uses mimicry which is inherently funny, but the parody always carries a deeper social criticism.

  • Analysis of the Quote: "In that sun that never set, they’s your shadow, you can’t shake them off"

    • The "sun that never set" refers to the British Empire.

    • The quote implies that even after independence, the history follows both the colonizer and the colonized like a shadow. Their post-independence relationship is forever affected by the colonial past.


  1. Harry and Jackson both play Crusoe during the play at different times. Which version do you think Walcott identifies with the most (the original, the reversed, neither, both)?

  2. Do you think Freytag’s pyramid could be applied to this play? To what extent?

  3. Do you think that Pantomime is a Robinsonade?

  4. To what extent do you think Phillip's foreshadowing of a social rearrangement came true? (Would you say it is a full role reversal, blurred hierarchy or equality between the two men?)