Equal Protection Standards Overview

The Big Picture

The Equal Protection Clause asks:

Can the government treat different groups differently?

The answer depends on:

  1. What classification is being used?

    • Race?

    • Sex?

    • Disability?

    • Immigration status?

    • Sexual orientation?

  2. What level of scrutiny applies?

    • Strict Scrutiny

    • Intermediate Scrutiny

    • Rational Basis

    • Rational Basis with Bite


Scrutiny Levels Cheat Sheet

Classification

Standard

Government Must Show

Race

Strict Scrutiny

Compelling interest + narrowly tailored

Sex

Intermediate Scrutiny

Important interest + substantially related

Disability

Rational Basis

Legitimate interest + rational relationship

Sexual Orientation (Romer)

Rational Basis with Bite

Cannot be based on animus

Undocumented Children (Plyler)

Enhanced Rational Basis

Substantial state interest required


I. Race Cases


Loving v. Virginia (1967)

Facts

Virginia banned interracial marriage.

Holding

Law unconstitutional.

Rule

Race classifications receive strict scrutiny.

Importance

Foundation of modern Equal Protection analysis for race.

Exam Rule

Government cannot classify people by race unless the classification is necessary to achieve a compelling governmental interest.


Regents of the University of California v. Bakke (1978)

Facts

UC Davis reserved 16 seats for minority applicants.

Holding

Quota unconstitutional.

But...

Race may be considered as one factor among many.

Importance

Created diversity rationale.

Exam Rule

  • Quotas ❌

  • Race as one individualized factor ✅

Connection to Loving

Loving established strict scrutiny. Bakke applies strict scrutiny to affirmative action.


Fisher v. University of Texas (2013)

Facts

UT considered race as one factor in admissions.

Holding

Court did not invalidate program outright.

Instead:

  • Courts must actually apply strict scrutiny.

  • Universities get no deference on narrow tailoring.

Importance

Strengthened Bakke.

Exam Rule

Universities must prove:

  • Diversity is compelling.

  • Race-neutral alternatives won't work.


Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard/UNC (2023)

Facts

Harvard and UNC used race in holistic admissions.

Holding

Programs unconstitutional.

Importance

Effectively ends race-conscious admissions under Bakke/Grutter/Fisher framework.

Exam Rule

Universities cannot use race as an admissions preference.

Applicants may discuss experiences involving race, but admissions decisions cannot award benefits based on racial identity itself.


Race Cases Timeline

Loving (1967)
       ↓
Strict Scrutiny for Race

Bakke (1978)
       ↓
Race may be one factor, quotas forbidden

Fisher (2013)
       ↓
Real strict scrutiny required

Students for Fair Admissions (2023)
       ↓
Race-conscious admissions largely prohibited

II. Sex Discrimination Cases


Reed v. Reed (1971)

Facts

Idaho automatically preferred males over females as estate administrators.

Holding

Unconstitutional.

Importance

First Supreme Court case striking down sex discrimination under Equal Protection.

Exam Rule

Administrative convenience cannot justify sex discrimination.


Craig v. Boren (1976)

Facts

Women could buy 3.2% beer at 18. Men had to wait until 21.

Holding

Unconstitutional.

Importance

Created Intermediate Scrutiny.

Rule

Sex classifications must:

  • Serve an important governmental objective

  • Be substantially related to achieving that objective

Exam Rule

Craig = Intermediate Scrutiny case.


United States v. Virginia (1996)

Facts

Virginia Military Institute (VMI) admitted only men.

Virginia created a separate women's program (VWIL).

Holding

Unconstitutional.

Importance

Strengthened Intermediate Scrutiny.

Key Language

Government must provide an:

"Exceedingly persuasive justification."

Exam Rule

Stereotypes about how men and women generally behave cannot justify exclusion.


Sex Cases Timeline

Reed (1971)
       ↓
First sex discrimination case

Craig (1976)
       ↓
Intermediate Scrutiny created

United States v. Virginia (1996)
       ↓
Intermediate Scrutiny strengthened

III. Disability Case


City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center (1985)

Facts

City denied permit for group home for intellectually disabled residents.

Holding

Unconstitutional.

Importance

Court refused to make disability a suspect class.

Scrutiny

Officially Rational Basis.

Reality

More searching than normal Rational Basis.

Exam Rule

The Court said:

  • Disability is NOT a suspect classification.

  • Government action still cannot be based on prejudice.

Key Theme

Government cannot justify laws by:

Irrational fears, stereotypes, or prejudice.


IV. Immigration Status / Education


Plyler v. Doe (1982)

Facts

Texas denied free public education to undocumented children.

Holding

Unconstitutional.

Important Point

Court says:

  • Undocumented immigrants are NOT a suspect class.

  • Education is NOT a fundamental right.

Yet Texas still loses.

Why?

Because:

  • Children were not responsible for their status.

  • Denial creates a permanent underclass.

Exam Rule

State needs a substantial justification before imposing serious lifelong burdens on innocent children.

Scrutiny

Often called:

Enhanced Rational Basis or Rational Basis with Bite


V. Sexual Orientation


Romer v. Evans (1996)

Facts

Colorado constitutional amendment prevented legal protections for gay people.

Holding

Unconstitutional.

Scrutiny

Officially Rational Basis.

Reality

Much more searching than ordinary Rational Basis.

Key Principle

Law cannot be motivated by:

Animus (hostility toward a group)

Exam Rule

Government cannot single out a group for disadvantage merely because the majority dislikes them.


Comparing the Cases

Case

Classification

Scrutiny

Loving

Race

Strict

Bakke

Race

Strict

Fisher

Race

Strict

SFFA

Race

Strict

Reed

Sex

Beginning of heightened review

Craig

Sex

Intermediate

US v Virginia

Sex

Strong Intermediate

Plyler

Undocumented children

Enhanced Rational Basis

Cleburne

Disability

Rational Basis with Bite

Romer

Sexual Orientation

Rational Basis with Bite


Most Important Rules to Memorize

Loving

Race classifications → Strict Scrutiny.


Reed

Sex discrimination cannot be justified by administrative convenience.


Craig

Intermediate Scrutiny:

Important government interest + substantially related means.


United States v. Virginia

Exceedingly persuasive justification.


Plyler

Undocumented children are protected by Equal Protection.


Cleburne

Disability is not a suspect class.


Romer

Animus is not a legitimate governmental interest.


Bakke

Quotas unconstitutional. Race may be one factor in admissions.


Fisher

Universities bear burden of proving narrow tailoring.


Students for Fair Admissions

Race-conscious admissions programs violate Equal Protection.


One-Sentence Exam Summary of the Whole Unit

The Equal Protection Clause requires increasingly rigorous judicial review as government classifications become more likely to threaten equality, with strict scrutiny for race, intermediate scrutiny for sex, and varying forms of rational-basis review for classifications such as disability, undocumented status, and sexual orientation.

For exam prep, remember this progression:

Loving → Bakke → Fisher → SFFA (Race)

Reed → Craig → Virginia (Sex)

Plyler → Cleburne → Romer (Other Equal Protection classifications)

That's the roadmap your professor is most likely to test.