Lecture 9

Discretionary Fiscal Policy

  • Definition: Changes to existing taxation and spending programs, intended for increasing or decreasing total spending in the economy.

Keynesian Theories

  • Discretionary Fiscal Policy is typically associated with Keynesian theories:

    • Expansionary Fiscal Policy: Intended to increase total spending for recessionary gaps.

    • Contractionary Fiscal Policy: Intended to decrease total spending for inflationary gaps.

Approval Process

  • Discretionary Fiscal Policy must be approved by:

    • Legislative Branch (Congress): Responsible for passing fiscal laws.

    • Executive Branch: Responsible for carrying out the approved policies.


Government Budget Deficits and Surpluses

  • Budget Deficit (G > T): An excess of government spending over tax revenue.

  • Government Debt: The accumulation of past government borrowing.

  • Budget Surplus (T > G): An excess of tax revenue over government spending, leading to the ability to repay some government debt.

  • Balanced Budget (G = T): When government spending equals tax revenue.

Effects of Budget Deficits and Surpluses

  • **Budget Deficits: **

    • Reduce national saving.

    • Decrease the supply of loanable funds.

    • Result in rising interest rates and falling investment.

  • Budget Surpluses:

    • Increase national saving.

    • Increase the supply of loanable funds.

    • Reduce interest rates and stimulate investment.


Gross Domestic Product (GDP) Expenditure Equation

  • For the discussion on fiscal policy:

    • GDP=C+I+G+NXGDP = C + I + G + NX (open economy)

    • For a closed economy: GDP=C+I+GGDP = C + I + G


Expansionary Fiscal Policy

  • Tools of Expansionary Fiscal Policy:

    • Increase government spending (G).

    • Decrease taxes (which increases consumption (C) and investment (I)).

Deficit Spending

  • Definition: Government resorts to borrowing money instead of taxing citizens.

  • Example to illustrate difference: Comparing borrowing from a brother when young to taxation.


Government Bonds

  • Defined as government-issued I.O.U.s promising to pay the holder a specific amount at a future date.

  • Treasury Bonds: U.S. government bonds issued by the Treasury Department, representing government debt securities.


The History of U.S. Government Debt

  • Government Financing Deficits: Occurs through borrowing via the sale of government bonds.

  • Debt-to-GDP Ratio: A measure of government indebtedness relative to the ability to raise tax revenue, with notable behaviors:

    • Rises during wartime.

    • Falls during peacetime until the early 1980s.

    • Increases during economic downturns.

  • Graph Reference: U.S. government debt as a percentage of GDP from 1971-2020 (exact data not provided, refer to sources).


The Balanced Government Budget Debate

Arguments for a Balanced Budget:

  • Burden on Future Taxpayers: Government debt impacts future individuals through increased taxation.

  • Investment Crowding Out: Deficits may lead to higher interest rates, insufficient investment reduces overall growth.

Arguments Against a Balanced Budget:

  • Exaggeration of Debt Concerns: Debt is a small percentage of an individual's lifetime income.

  • Potential Harm from Cutting the Deficit:

    • Reductions in education may hinder human capital growth and future living standards.

    • Increased taxes may disincentivize work and savings efforts.

  • Focus on Debt/Income Ratio: This ratio may be more relevant than the absolute debt amount.


Contractionary Fiscal Policy

  • Definition: A policy that entails decreasing government spending and increasing taxes.


Possible Offsets to Fiscal Policy

  • Definition: Effects from private individuals, households, and businesses that counter government policies, reducing effectiveness.

Key Offsets:

  1. Crowding Out Effect: Increased government borrowing may elevate interest rates, reducing private investment due to limited funds available for households and businesses.

  2. Ricardian Equivalence: Suggests that government borrowing parallels taxation; reducing taxes without real income change may not incentivize spending.

    • Example: Government cuts taxes while borrowing the same amount, leading to no real benefit for the taxpayer in terms of spending capabilities.

  3. Direct Expenditure Offsets: If government spending substitutes for private sector spending, it doesn’t increase total spending.

    • Example: Providing free milk may reduce personal spending on the item, leading to dollar-for-dollar offsets without increases in total spending.


Supply-side Effects of Tax Changes

  • Supply-side Economics: Advocates argue tax cuts can increase real GDP by enhancing supply rather than demand.

    • Lower marginal tax rates are said to incentivize workers to enhance productivity.

    • Conversely, higher marginal rates can suppress productivity.

The Laffer Curve

  • Visual Concept: Represents the relationship between tax rates and tax revenue, indicating how tax cuts might lead to higher revenue by boosting economic activity.


Time Lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy

  • Recognition Time Lag: The duration needed to assess the current state of the economy accurately.

  • Action Time Lag: The period between recognizing an economic issue and the enactment of policy solutions, often long due to the requirement of congressional approval.

  • Effect Time Lag: The interval that elapses between policy implementation and observable effects on the economy.


Automatic Stabilizers (Nondiscretionary Fiscal Policies)

  • Definition: Policies that automatically take effect without needing congressional approval, thus stabilizing the economy.

Examples of Automatic Stabilizers:

  1. Tax System: A reduction in income leads to lower tax revenues, thus acting as an automatic tax cut during recessions.

  2. Unemployment Compensation: Provides stability to aggregate demand when individuals are unemployed, thus reducing negative economic impacts.

  3. Income Transfer Payments: Programs like Supplemental Security Income and Temporary Assistance stabilize aggregate demand during downturns when incomes fall.