Lecture 9
Discretionary Fiscal Policy
Definition: Changes to existing taxation and spending programs, intended for increasing or decreasing total spending in the economy.
Keynesian Theories
Discretionary Fiscal Policy is typically associated with Keynesian theories:
Expansionary Fiscal Policy: Intended to increase total spending for recessionary gaps.
Contractionary Fiscal Policy: Intended to decrease total spending for inflationary gaps.
Approval Process
Discretionary Fiscal Policy must be approved by:
Legislative Branch (Congress): Responsible for passing fiscal laws.
Executive Branch: Responsible for carrying out the approved policies.
Government Budget Deficits and Surpluses
Budget Deficit (G > T): An excess of government spending over tax revenue.
Government Debt: The accumulation of past government borrowing.
Budget Surplus (T > G): An excess of tax revenue over government spending, leading to the ability to repay some government debt.
Balanced Budget (G = T): When government spending equals tax revenue.
Effects of Budget Deficits and Surpluses
**Budget Deficits: **
Reduce national saving.
Decrease the supply of loanable funds.
Result in rising interest rates and falling investment.
Budget Surpluses:
Increase national saving.
Increase the supply of loanable funds.
Reduce interest rates and stimulate investment.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) Expenditure Equation
For the discussion on fiscal policy:
(open economy)
For a closed economy:
Expansionary Fiscal Policy
Tools of Expansionary Fiscal Policy:
Increase government spending (G).
Decrease taxes (which increases consumption (C) and investment (I)).
Deficit Spending
Definition: Government resorts to borrowing money instead of taxing citizens.
Example to illustrate difference: Comparing borrowing from a brother when young to taxation.
Government Bonds
Defined as government-issued I.O.U.s promising to pay the holder a specific amount at a future date.
Treasury Bonds: U.S. government bonds issued by the Treasury Department, representing government debt securities.
The History of U.S. Government Debt
Government Financing Deficits: Occurs through borrowing via the sale of government bonds.
Debt-to-GDP Ratio: A measure of government indebtedness relative to the ability to raise tax revenue, with notable behaviors:
Rises during wartime.
Falls during peacetime until the early 1980s.
Increases during economic downturns.
Graph Reference: U.S. government debt as a percentage of GDP from 1971-2020 (exact data not provided, refer to sources).
The Balanced Government Budget Debate
Arguments for a Balanced Budget:
Burden on Future Taxpayers: Government debt impacts future individuals through increased taxation.
Investment Crowding Out: Deficits may lead to higher interest rates, insufficient investment reduces overall growth.
Arguments Against a Balanced Budget:
Exaggeration of Debt Concerns: Debt is a small percentage of an individual's lifetime income.
Potential Harm from Cutting the Deficit:
Reductions in education may hinder human capital growth and future living standards.
Increased taxes may disincentivize work and savings efforts.
Focus on Debt/Income Ratio: This ratio may be more relevant than the absolute debt amount.
Contractionary Fiscal Policy
Definition: A policy that entails decreasing government spending and increasing taxes.
Possible Offsets to Fiscal Policy
Definition: Effects from private individuals, households, and businesses that counter government policies, reducing effectiveness.
Key Offsets:
Crowding Out Effect: Increased government borrowing may elevate interest rates, reducing private investment due to limited funds available for households and businesses.
Ricardian Equivalence: Suggests that government borrowing parallels taxation; reducing taxes without real income change may not incentivize spending.
Example: Government cuts taxes while borrowing the same amount, leading to no real benefit for the taxpayer in terms of spending capabilities.
Direct Expenditure Offsets: If government spending substitutes for private sector spending, it doesn’t increase total spending.
Example: Providing free milk may reduce personal spending on the item, leading to dollar-for-dollar offsets without increases in total spending.
Supply-side Effects of Tax Changes
Supply-side Economics: Advocates argue tax cuts can increase real GDP by enhancing supply rather than demand.
Lower marginal tax rates are said to incentivize workers to enhance productivity.
Conversely, higher marginal rates can suppress productivity.
The Laffer Curve
Visual Concept: Represents the relationship between tax rates and tax revenue, indicating how tax cuts might lead to higher revenue by boosting economic activity.
Time Lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy
Recognition Time Lag: The duration needed to assess the current state of the economy accurately.
Action Time Lag: The period between recognizing an economic issue and the enactment of policy solutions, often long due to the requirement of congressional approval.
Effect Time Lag: The interval that elapses between policy implementation and observable effects on the economy.
Automatic Stabilizers (Nondiscretionary Fiscal Policies)
Definition: Policies that automatically take effect without needing congressional approval, thus stabilizing the economy.
Examples of Automatic Stabilizers:
Tax System: A reduction in income leads to lower tax revenues, thus acting as an automatic tax cut during recessions.
Unemployment Compensation: Provides stability to aggregate demand when individuals are unemployed, thus reducing negative economic impacts.
Income Transfer Payments: Programs like Supplemental Security Income and Temporary Assistance stabilize aggregate demand during downturns when incomes fall.