Beyond Polished Prose: Lens-Based Inquiry Writing Unit Guide

Unit Overview and Course Context

  • Course Title: College Writing (12th-Grade12\text{th-Grade} Dual Credit English)
  • Unit Classification: Semester 11, Unit 22
  • Unit Title: Beyond Polished Prose: Process-Centered Writing in the Age of AI — Lens-Based Inquiry Writing Unit
  • Unit Duration: 4 weeks4\,\text{weeks}
  • Scope and Sequence Integration: Functions as an instructional bridge connecting personal narrative writing from Unit 11 to formal academic evaluation writing in Unit 33
  • Conceptual Focus:
    • Frames writing as an ongoing, meaning-making process of inquiry rather than solely focusing on a polished end product.
    • Investigates how diverse interpretive lenses alter and shape human understanding of personal experiences, texts, culture, and society.
    • Requires selecting one interpretive lens to analyze a personally meaningful experience, text, or cultural issue, and extending that analysis into a broader evaluative claim.

Core Objectives

Throughout the unit, students will:

  • Navigate the relationship between personal identity and the critical analysis of worldly texts.
  • Practice writing as an authentic meaning-making process within a post-AI environment.
  • Analyze the specific ways interpretive lenses shape comprehension and perspective.
  • Connect individual personal experiences to broader cultural critique.
  • Draft iteratively by gathering and applying peer feedback, teacher feedback, and AI feedback.
  • Reflect deeply on individual rhetorical decisions and revision choices.

Summative Assignment Instructions and Workflow

  • Assignment: Lens-Based Inquiry Essay
  • Core Task: Compose a lens-based inquiry essay analyzing a personally meaningful experience, text, or cultural issue through a chosen interpretive lens, extending that analysis into a broader evaluative claim.
  • Sequential Inquiry Process:
    1. Formatively explore lens-based readings and text analyses from the designated Lens Menu.
    2. Select one specific interpretive lens for the summative essay.
    3. Apply the chosen lens to a meaningful experience, text, or issue.
    4. Develop and articulate a broader evaluative claim based on the lens analysis.

Sample Inquiries and Evaluative Claims

  • Sample Evaluative Claim:
    • Using a gender lens helped me examine how expectations surrounding masculinity shaped my participation in athletics.
  • Sample Inquiry Topics paired with Lenses:
    • Analyzing burnout culture through a psychological lens
    • Analyzing immigrant family expectations through a cultural lens
    • Analyzing athletics through a gender lens
    • Analyzing access to educational technology through a socioeconomic lens
    • Analyzing online learning through a technological lens
    • Analyzing code-switching at school or work through a linguistic lens

AI Usage Guidelines

  • Core Rule: AI tools can and should support student thinking, but they may not replace original student thinking.
  • Permitted AI Applications (Students MAY use AI to):
    • Brainstorm possibilities
    • Generate counterarguments
    • Clarify confusing feedback
    • Test organizational structures
    • Ask rhetorical questions
    • Identify areas needing elaboration
  • Prohibited AI Applications (Students MAY NOT use AI to):
    • Generate full drafts for submission
    • Replace drafting or revision processes
    • Fabricate sources or evidence
  • Writing Integrity Expectation: All written work must demonstrate the student's individual thinking, decision-making, and revision process.

Draft and Feedback Requirements

  • First Draft Requirements:
    • Minimum length: 1,250 words1,250\,\text{words}
    • Response focus: Direct response to the summative prompt
  • Feedback Reflection Requirements:
    • Required reflection on the reception and planned implementation of:
    • Peer feedback
    • Teacher feedback
    • AI-generated feedback
    • Detailed explanation of how independent and holistic feedback shaped revision plans
  • Final Draft Requirements:
    • Minimum length: 1,250 words1,250\,\text{words}
    • Revision standard: Demonstrates meaningful revision and development
    • Implementation standard: Incorporates intentional application of feedback