Investigating Writing: Threshold Concepts, Transfer, and Writing Studies

Research Visualizations and Everyday Writing Genres

  • Research Project Visualization (Colette Frommeyer Collage):

    • Created using Canva by Miami University student Colette Frommeyer to illustrate findings on everyday writing habits.

    • Uses the structural metaphor of a tree to map writing practices:

    • Roots: Represent the foundational collection of genres in which a person writes.

    • Trunk and Stems: Represent how individual genres funnel into a strong core writing foundation that branches into stems and leaves.

    • Branches and Leaves: Represent intersecting genres, channels, and target audiences that merge to create new, culturally-relevant sub-genres.

    • Environmental Forces (Weather): Represent social forces that impact, shape, and determine the longevity of various writing genres.

  • Categorization and Distribution of Writing Practices:

    • 11 percent to self: Facebook, YouTube, Instagram, and bar charts for data visualization.

    • 65 percent of texts: Functional organizational forms including lists, folders, and text messages.

    • 89 percent to others: Directed communications including emails, mail, and Kindle reading/writing.

    • 90 percent technology-mediated: GroupMe, Google services, and email platforms.

  • Intersecting Genres and Sub-genres: Replies, comments, direct messages (DMs), code, formal reports, to-do lists, grocery lists, future planning documents, questions, non-word expressions, thank you notes, presentation notes, tapbacks, case studies, narrative stories, how-to guides, recipes, social media posts, music searches, written reflections, margin annotations, peer evaluations, data entry, and internet memes.

Foundations and Purpose of Writing Studies

  • Core Inquiries in Writing Studies:

    • Explores why different instructors enforce distinct writing rules.

    • Investigates why writing poses varying degrees of difficulty across individuals.

    • Examines why specialized jargon and complex vocabulary are deployed across specific contexts.

  • Definition of Writing Studies:

    • An academic discipline analogous to biology or psychology that conducts empirical and theoretical research on writing processes.

    • Focuses on three primary areas: how writing functions, how individuals write, and how writing is best learned and taught.

    • Positions writing as an object of knowledge (something to be known and researched) rather than merely a mechanical skill (something to do).

  • Primary Learning Objectives of Writing Research:

    • Achieving a deeper conceptual understanding of personal writing habits and underlying mechanisms of text construction.

    • Developing transferable knowledge about writing to navigate unfamiliar academic, professional, and personal communication settings.

    • Gaining experience reading and analyzing scholarly literature.

    • Participating in conversational inquiry—an approach to research driven by unanswered, open-ended questions.

  • Rationale for Studying Writing:

    • Modifying underlying knowledge and beliefs about writing directly alters writing performance and strategic choices.

    • Directly challenges widespread everyday assumptions (e.g., that personal voice is forbidden in academic settings, that writing capability is an innate fixed trait, or that literacy is strictly tied to reading comprehension).

    • Writing remains universally relevant as a primary medium for social, academic, and professional communication.

    • Learners possess prior firsthand experience as writers, placing them in a knowledgeable position to investigate language practices.

    • Conducting writing research allows individuals to generate original knowledge rather than summarize existing findings.

Two Competing Conceptions of Writing

  • The Traditional School Narrative (Error-Avoidance Paradigm):

    • Defines writing as a basic, mechanical, grammatical skill focused on transcribing spoken language into printed text.

    • Assumes universal transferability: asserts that writing skills learned in basic English classes apply unaltered across all contexts, from chemistry laboratories to corporate bank boardrooms.

    • Defines "good writing" strictly through error avoidance, rule adherence, and formal correctness.

    • Views skilled writers as individuals who commit the fewest rule infractions and compose effortlessly.

    • Attributes difficulty in writing solely to the challenge of memorizing and following complex grammar rules.

    • Reinforced through systemic educational practices:

    • Teachers focusing exclusively on mechanical grammar corrections while ignoring substantive ideas and arguments.

    • Standardized timed writing tests (such as thirty-minute SAT prompts) scored by external evaluators who prioritize correctness and basic organization over factual accuracy and original insight.

    • Media narratives alleging that modern digital communication (e.g., texting) degrades language skills.

  • The Research-Based Narrative (Rhetorical Paradigm):

    • Defines writing as a complex, dynamic, context-bound process encompassing multiple dimensions:

    • Content/Material: The substantive ideas being expressed.

    • Form/Arrangement: The structural organization of the text.

    • Invention: The systematic generation of ideas.

    • Process: The cognitive and physical acts of thinking, drafting, and revising.

    • Rhetoric: The alignment of text with the demands of a specific situation, purpose, and audience.

    • Views error avoidance as a minor sub-component of writing, prioritizing effective real-world communication and functional impact.

    • Rejects universal writing rules in favor of localized habits, conventions, and norms adopted by specific social and professional groups (e.g., legal writing vs. engineering writing vs. historical analysis).

    • Asserts that what transfers across contexts is not a static set of rules, but rhetorical awareness—the ability to observe, analyze, and ask informed questions about new writing environments.

    • Supported by everyday non-school literacy practices (e.g., texting friends, where success is determined by mutual understanding and desired social response rather than formal grammar).

Mental Frameworks and Threshold Concepts

  • Constructs and Conceptions:

    • Conceptions and internal narratives dictate writing behaviors, willingness to attempt complex tasks, and emotional responses to feedback.

    • Constructs are defined as mental frameworks built by individuals to organize and interpret the world around them.

    • Operating under inaccurate constructs (e.g., believing writing ability is an innate talent or that good writing requires perfect first drafts) causes cognitive blocks, frustration, reduced text production, and avoidance.

    • Conceptions shape reality, aligning with the philosophical principle attributed to Buddha: "With our thoughts we make the world."

  • Threshold Concepts (Meyer and Land):

    • Identified by United Kingdom researchers Jan Meyer and Ray Land as concepts central to mastering any specific discipline.

    • Key characteristics of threshold concepts:

    • Transformative: Once understood, they fundamentally alter a learner's perception of the subject.

    • Irreversible: Once grasped, they are unlikely to be unlearned.

    • Integrative: They reveal hidden connections between previously disparate ideas or experiences.

    • Troublesome: They are frequently counterintuitive, alien, or in direct conflict with popular, commonsense assumptions.

    • The Liminal Space:

    • A transitional state of ambiguity, anxiety, and instability experienced while working to understand a threshold concept.

    • Learners move back and forth between old, unworkable assumptions and new, unmastered frameworks.

    • Troublesomeness in Writing Studies is intensified because long-standing, non-research-based beliefs about writing are heavily reinforced by years of schooling.

  • Disciplinary Example (Historical Studies):

    • Professional historians do not view history as a single authoritative story to be memorized.

    • Instead, history is conceptualized as the systematic analysis of past evidence yielding competing narratives and interpretations, which are debated within the discipline.

    • Students must undergo a liminal period to abandon the belief in a single historical narrative before they can engage in historical analysis.

Meta-Concept: Writing as an Object of Inquiry

  • Core Definition:

    • Writing is not merely an activity people perform; it is an active domain of scholarly study.

  • Historical Evolution of Writing Research:

    • The study of persuasion and rhetoric dates back to ancient scholars, including Aristotle (c. 350 BCE).

    • The formal, empirical study of writing processes and composition emerged relatively recently, during the 1950s.

    • Initial studies focused primarily on student writers in classroom settings; research later expanded to encompass non-academic, workplace, digital, and community environments.

  • Central Open Research Questions in Writing Studies:

    • How writers successfully compose texts.

    • Factors and constraints that impede writing performance.

    • The psychological and operational impacts of rules, mechanical errors, and internalizing an instructor's evaluation voice.

    • How prior literacy experiences, personal identity, and home or community languages shape writing capability.

    • The origins and persistence of cultural beliefs regarding literacy.

    • Why text interpretation varies across readers and how context dictates textual meaning.

    • Methods for collaborative meaning-making, especially during disagreement.

    • Strategies writers employ to navigate unfamiliar situations and genres.

Key Threshold Concepts in Writing Studies

  • Threshold Concept 1: Writing is a Process, and All Writers Have More to Learn:

    • Composing requires sustained time, practice, feedback, and iterative revision.

    • Writing is not perfectible; it is not in the category of human activities that can reach absolute perfection.

    • Textual effectiveness is relational and contingent upon how readers construct meaning within specific environments.

    • Writing performance varies depending on topic familiarity, genre complexity, technology, and text length.

    • Realizing that writing capability is developed through practice and circumstance frees writers from fixed "bad writer" identities.

  • Threshold Concept 2: Writing is Impacted by Identities and Prior Experiences:

    • Literacy practices are deeply bound to identity and individual personal history.

    • Kathleen Blake Yancey notes that "each writer is a combination of the collective set of different dimensions and traits and features that make us human."

    • Literacy histories begin in early childhood homes and expand through clubs, religious groups, digital communities, hobbies, and formal schooling.

    • Andrea Lunsford's research on early writing memories revealed widespread negative or traumatic associations, such as left-handed children being forced to write right-handed, or writing punitive repetitive sentences (e.g., writing "I will not X" 100 times).

    • Cultural alignment: Individuals whose home language practices match the dominant school culture experience smoother transitions into academic writing, whereas multilingual individuals or speakers of non-dominant dialects face marginalization when educational institutions invalidate their native language competencies.

  • Threshold Concept 3: "Good" Writing is Contextual:

    • Writing quality is not absolute; it is contingent upon whether a text successfully fulfills its intended purpose for its specific audience within a given context.

    • Texts operate rhetorically within defined situational constraints.

    • Disciplinary variations in writing conventions:

    • Natural and Physical Sciences: Frequently utilize passive voice construction (e.g., "Tests were conducted") to emphasize objective methodology, standardized procedure, and collective discovery over individual agency.

    • Humanities: Discourage passive voice, emphasizing active agent construction (e.g., "Shakespeare plays with the meaning of words") because individual agency, authorship, and interpretation are central to the discipline.

    • Digital audience expansion: Modern online communication platforms allow texts to circulate far beyond their intended initial context, leading to unintended social, financial, or political consequences (e.g., former Los Angeles Clippers owner Donald Sterling, whose private racist recorded comments circulated publicly, resulting in a mandatory 2.5 million2.5\text{ million} fine and a lifetime NBA ban).

  • Threshold Concept 4: People Collaborate to Get Things Done with Writing:

    • Writing functions as a social, collaborative tool to accomplish work, establish communities, and negotiate meaning.

    • Joseph Petraglia conceptualized traditional school writing as "pseudotransactional"—simulating real-world communication while actually serving only as an evaluative exercise for a teacher.

    • Authentic writing is transactional and socially collaborative, involving feedback, co-authoring, peer input, and shared rhetorical goals (e.g., workplace reports, community guidelines, gaming chatboards, Wattpad fanfiction communities).

    • Social groups establish implicit, unspoken norms, specialized vocabularies, and discourse hierarchies (e.g., surgical teams using precise medical terminology and structured communication hierarchies to protect patient safety).

Transfer of Learning: Near vs. Far and High-Road Strategies

  • Definition of Transfer:

    • The cognitive process of taking knowledge, skills, and strategies acquired in one context and applying them to new, unfamiliar situations.

  • Near Transfer vs. Far Transfer:

    • Near Transfer (Low-Road Transfer):

    • Occurs automatically when a new task closely resembles previous experiences.

    • Involves minimal conscious reflection or mental restructuring (e.g., returning a standard verbal campus greeting, driving a small pickup truck after driving a standard car, or writing a basic grocery shopping list).

    • Far Transfer (High-Road Transfer):

    • Required when encountering unfamiliar, complex, or high-stakes writing contexts (e.g., academic entrance exams, discipline-specific research papers, new professional genres).

    • Cannot occur automatically; requires deliberate mental effort, conscious abstraction, and reflective analysis.

  • Concept of Repurposing:

    • Far transfer rarely allows direct, unmediated application of old rules; prior knowledge must be adapted and restructured ("repurposed") to fit new constraints.

    • Example: A student moving from high school to college history courses must repurpose their knowledge of thesis claims and evidence support by abandoning the rigid five-paragraph essay structure to construct longer, evidence-based historical arguments utilizing specialized citation systems (e.g., Chicago-style notes and bibliography).

  • High-Road Transfer Framework (Perkins and Salomon):

    • Developed by researchers David Perkins and Gavriel Salomon.

    • Requires active metacognitive reflection, systematic analysis of target genre examples, explicit questioning, deliberate drafting, and seeking iterative feedback.

Metacognition, Reflection, and Critical Incident Analysis

  • Definitions:

    • Meta-awareness / Metacognition: The ability to step outside oneself to monitor, evaluate, and reflect upon one's own thinking processes and performance in real time.

  • Metacognitive Analysis Questions for Unfamiliar Tasks:

    • What similarities and structural differences exist between this new writing task and previous tasks I have completed?

    • What specific element needs to be altered, and what successful genre models can be analyzed to identify required conventions?

    • What new domain knowledge, citation standards, or evidence rules must be learned?

    • Am I flexibly adapting to the new environment, or am I engaging in "boundary guarding"?

    • Boundary Guarding (Bawarshi and Reiff): Termed by Anis Bawarshi and Mary Jo Reiff to describe a student's rigid, defensive attachment to previously learned writing habits, resisting adaptation to new rhetorical contexts.

  • Critical Incident Analysis and M&M Conferences:

    • Derived from medical Morbidity and Mortality ("M&M") conferences (highlighted by surgeon Atul Gawande), where medical professionals systematically analyze errors, adverse outcomes, and deaths to establish systemic accountability and prevent future mistakes.

    • Analogous to critical incident reviews utilized by air traffic controllers.

    • Applied to writing by scholars Liane Robertson, Kara Taczak, and Kathleen Blake Yancey to reframe writing setbacks as necessary data points for updating mental models.

    • Three-Step Writing Critical Incident Review Process:

    1. Case Presentation: Formally state the context, target audience, goal, and constraints of the writing task.

    2. Error Diagnosis: Explicitly detail what went wrong, identifying structural, stylistic, or rhetorical breakdowns.

    3. Peer Examination and Strategy Formulation: Solicit structured feedback from peers or instructors to identify early warning signs, refine strategies, and document actionable revisions for future writing situations.

Chapter Activities and Discussion Prompts

  • Activity 1.1: Reflective Baseline Identification:

    • Requires recording initial unedited beliefs regarding five baseline prompts: "Writing is…", "Good writing is…", "Good writers do or are…", "Writers are influenced by…", and "Learning to write involves…".

  • Activity 1.2 & 1.3: Analyzing Composing Processes and Abandoning Perfection:

    • Compare the processes used for a recent complex writing task (e.g., asking for money, quitting a job) against a routine task.

    • Reframing prompt: If writing is not perfectible, replace "getting it right" with rhetorical alignment, situational effectiveness, and audience connection.

  • Activity 1.4 & 1.5: Literacy History and Language Valuation:

    • Draft a ten-minute freewrite mapping early reading, writing, and speaking memories across home, community, and school.

    • Analyze moments when writing habits failed or generated outsider feelings, evaluating language background as a linguistic asset rather than a deficit.

  • Activity 1.6 & 1.7: Disciplinary Rule Breakdown and Thought Experiments:

    • Identify specific writing rules taught in school that proved unworkable in other settings.

    • Reframe school writing by approaching academic assignments with the communicative freedom, purpose, and feedback expectations typical of personal, self-sponsored writing.

  • Activity 1.8 & 1.9: Social Dependency and Genre Auditing:

    • Log all weekly writing reasons, identifying audiences, direct/indirect collaborators, and social impacts.

    • Select a functional genre (e.g., class lecture notes), tracing how conventions were acquired, who reads them, and criteria for textual effectiveness.

  • Activity 1.10, 1.11, & 1.12: Transfer Mapping and Knowledge Integration:

    • Document an automatic routine activity (low-road transfer).

    • Detail a situation requiring task repurposing to overcome new constraints.

    • Describe an experience requiring the integration of existing skills with newly learned domain information.

  • End-of-Chapter Discussion and Journaling Questions:

    • Identify personal surprises, conceptual confusions, and "aha moments" within the text.

    • Select one primary threshold concept for semester-long study and align it with specific course units.

    • Perform a key term audit using bolded textbook terms.

    • Map threshold concepts to other disciplines (e.g., mathematics, art, history) or personal hobbies (e.g., video gaming, baking, fanfiction).

    • Analyze how personal assumptions impact real-world execution and outline strategies to combat damaging writing misconceptions.

Major Writing Assignments and Project Guidelines

  • Assignment Option 1: Challenging and Exploring Your Conceptions About Writing:

    • Objective: Conduct an empirical, inquiry-based study tracking how personal writing conceptions have evolved, culminating in a public-facing text designed to educate an external audience.

    • Step-by-Step Execution:

    1. Comparative Assumption Audit: Re-examine baseline responses from Activity 1.1, comparing them against post-reading perspectives.

    2. Peer Exchange: Trade pre- and post-reading notes with a partner to generate categorized lists of altered vs. persistent assumptions.

    3. Focused Exploratory Freewrite: Produce a one-page freewrite exploring why a specific conception changed and its practical implications.

    4. Field Inquiry & Observation: Spend several days gathering field data—observing, interviewing, and inspecting draft artifacts from designated "good writers" (friends, instructors, parents) to analyze real-world writing processes.

    5. Rhetorical Drafting: Select a target audience (e.g., a former high school teacher who emphasized strict grammar over content) and an appropriate genre (e.g., formal letter, blog post, editorial).

    6. Integration of Evidence: Draft the text using personal evidence, field observations, interview quotes, and synthesized academic citations from writing studies literature.

    • Evaluation Criteria: Depth of self-reflection, logical coherence of claims, quality of empirical field evidence, appropriate genre adaptation, and audience engagement.

  • Assignment Option 2: What is Writing and How Does it Work in the World? A Collage and Artist's Statement:

    • Objective: Execute a one-week comprehensive empirical tracking log of personal writing habits, converting data into a multimodal collage and analytical statement.

    • Step-by-Step Execution:

    1. One-Week Logging: Carry a paper notebook or digital logging tool. Record every writing act immediately, capturing six empirical metrics: exact date/time/location, text content, genre format (e.g., lists, texts, code), technology medium used (e.g., mobile phone, pen, laptop), driving motivation/purpose, and intended audience.

    2. Data Analysis: Categorize log entries into comprehensive master lists based on form, tech medium, audience, and functional purpose; write a 10–15 minute analytical freewrite.

    3. Multimodal Collage Creation: Assemble a visual visual artifact (digital, paper cut-out, or 3D visual object) representing research findings on how writing functions in daily life.

    4. Artist's Statement: Author a single-spaced, one-page document explaining the primary visual message, material media choices, research conclusions, and target viewer impact.

    • Submission Materials: Empirical writing log, analytical data categorization notes, multimodal collage visual, and artist's statement.

    • Evaluation Criteria: Thoroughness of empirical tracking data, visual clarity of threshold concepts within the visual collage, deliberate visual choices, and analytical depth of the artist's statement.

Cited Scholarly Works and Theoretical Foundations

  • Adler-Kassner, Linda, and Elizabeth Wardle, editors:

    • Naming What We Know: Threshold Concepts of Writing Studies. Utah State University Press, 2015.

  • Bransford, John D., James W. Pellegrino, and M. Suzanne Donovan, editors:

    • How People Learn: Brain, Mind, Experience, and School: Expanded Edition. National Academies Press, 2000.

  • Elon University Seminar on Writing Transfer:

    • Elon Statement on Writing Transfer. 2013.

  • Lunsford, Andrea A.:

    • "Writing Is Informed by Prior Experience." Naming What We Know: Threshold Concepts of Writing Studies, edited by Linda Adler-Kassner and Elizabeth Wardle, Utah State University Press, 2015, pp. 54–55.

  • Meyer, Jan H. F., and Ray Land:

    • "Threshold Concepts and Troublesome Knowledge (2): Epistemological Considerations and a Conceptual Framework for Teaching and Learning." Higher Education, vol. 49, no. 3, 2005, pp. 373–88.

  • Perkins, David N., and Gavriel Salomon:

    • "Transfer of Learning." International Encyclopedia of Education, 2nd ed., Pergamon Press, 1992, pp. 2–13.

  • Reiff, Mary Jo, and Anis Bawarshi:

    • "Tracing Discursive Resources: How Students Use Prior Genre Knowledge to Negotiate New Writing Contexts in First-Year Composition." Written Communication, vol. 28, no. 3, 2011, pp. 312–37.

  • Robertson, Liane, Kara Taczak, and Kathleen Blake Yancey:

    • "Notes Toward a Theory of Prior Knowledge and Its Role in College Composers' Transfer of Knowledge and Practice." Composition Forum, vol. 26, Fall 2012.

  • Yancey, Kathleen Blake:

    • "Writers' Histories, Processes, and Identities Vary." Naming What We Know: Threshold Concepts of Writing Studies, edited by Linda Adler-Kassner and Elizabeth Wardle, Utah State University Press, 2015, pp. 52–54.