Global Strategic Supply Chain Management and Corporate Strategy

Relationship Between Strategy Levels, Business, and Corporate Strategy

  • Strategy Definition: A high-level plan of direction designed to achieve a long-term goal or overall aim. In the corporate context, it is an agreed plan among main actors setting out goals to achieve operational intentions.

  • Tactics Definition: Basic operational activities and actions that make the strategy a reality. In supply chains, strategy relates to overarching direction (e.g., deliver goods worldwide), while tactics relate to specific acts like negotiations, tendering, or purchasing.

  • Four Core Principles of Strategy (Thomas Hult, 2007):

    • Speed: Time to delivery.

    • Quality: Of goods or services.

    • Cost: Price of goods plus processing costs.

    • Flexibility: Capacity to change and adapt to circumstances.

  • Geographical Company Types:

    • Multi-national Corporations (MMCs): Operate across many countries in a tiered fashion (e.g., Google, Procter & Gamble, Ford).

    • Transnational Corporations (TNCs): Operate from one country into another; span boundaries but are less global than MNCs.

    • National Companies: Operate within a single geographical territory.

  • Organisational Structures:

    • Horizontal Differentiation: Functions are split (e.g., one Marketing department HQ serving multiple regions).

    • Vertical Differentiation: Functions are located nearer to customers, leading to duplicated units in each region to enhance specialization and customisation.

    • Matrix Organisation: Companies align around specific projects, regions, or products. Resources are allotted from operational silos to specific projects. Authority is diffuse as there are several "owners" per project.

  • Internal Hierarchical Levels:

    • Corporate Level: The overarching umbrella managing a diverse selection of operating units.

    • Business Level: A section with a separate main function, brand, or production emphasis (e.g., Buick as a unit of General Motors).

    • Functional Level: Subsections concerned with specific areas like Finance, Production, or Logistics.

  • Joint Vehicles (JVs): Specially arranged legal structures where multiple companies dedicate resources to a single large capital or product investment project.

Strategic Goals: Growth, Diversification, and Stability

  • Growth Strategies: Aim to increase market share, revenue, or profitability via expansion of portfolio or geography.

  • Boston Consulting Group (BCG) Matrix:

    • Stars: High relative market share and high market growth rate. Scope for greatest growth.

    • Cash Cows: High relative market share in a mature (low growth) market. High consistent returns.

    • Problem Children: Low market presence in a high-growth environment. Requires strategic reconsideration.

    • Dogs: Low growth, low presence. Resources should be reallocated elsewhere.

  • McKinsey Matrix: Ranks "Industry Attractiveness" against "Competitive Position." Unlike BCG, it focuses on competitiveness rather than just market share.

  • Diversification Levels:

    • Low: Single business under the corporate banner.

    • Moderate: Constrained to 70%70\% of trade through single business/market.

    • High/Very High: No common links between businesses under the banner (e.g., Yamaha’s "Kando" philosophy across vehicles, instruments, and white goods).

  • Stability Strategy: Favours incremental changes and consistent annual dividends. Often adopted by dominant firms avoiding monopoly commission interference (e.g., Boeing) or those recovering from institutional shocks.

  • Porter's Generic Strategies:

    • Cost Leadership: Lowest cost producer for the market rate, leveraging economies of scale (EOSEOS).

    • Differentiation: Rivals cannot match the unique offering, allowing a price premium.

    • Cost Focus: Seeking cost advantage in a specific target segment.

    • Differentiation Focus: Unique product offering for a defined target market (e.g., Apple's direct store network).

Impact of Supply Chain Management on Performance and Profitability

  • Performance Impacts:

    • Improved material flow through design-to-realisation speed.

    • Information improvement via Supplier Relationship Management (SRMSRM) tools.

    • Market responsivity through upstream communication of downstream demand.

  • Profitability Factors:

    • Profit is the difference between production/fulfillment costs and sale price.

    • Mark-up: A percentage added to costs (e.g.,Cost £100+fulfilment £20+10% profit =£132e.g., \text{Cost } \pounds 100 + \text{fulfilment } \pounds 20 + 10\% \text{ profit } = \pounds 132).

    • Production Cost Reduction: Procurement managers negotiate terms, seek substitute products, or partner for bulk discounts.

    • Working Capital: Current assets minus current liabilities. Healthy ratios are identified as between 1.2 and 21.2 \text{ and } 2. Ratios less than 11 indicate liabilities exceed available assets.

  • Supply Chain Risk Types:

    • External Supply Risks: Interrupted flows, poor quality, lead time variability.

    • External Demand Risks: Unpredictable end-customer demand, innovative competitors, inaccurate forecasts.

    • External Environmental Risks: Macro shifts, exchange rate fluctuations, natural disasters.

    • Internal Manufacturing Risks: Equipment breakdown, capacity bottlenecks.

    • Internal Business Risks: Personnel changes, supplier instability.

    • Internal Security Risks: Data loss, counterfeiting, piracy.

  • Risk Management Strategies (The 4Ts):

    1. Tolerate: Low likelihood/severity or high reward potential (e.g., R&D).

    2. Treat: Adjust activities to reduce risk (e.g., using more experienced teams).

    3. Transfer: Shift risk to third parties via insurance or management consultants.

    4. Terminate: Stop the activity entirely (e.g., halting the use of asbestos).

Comparative Advantage and Competitive Advantage

  • Comparative Advantage (David Ricardo): Specialisation benefits all participants. Example: If England produces cloth in 100 hours100\text{ hours} and Portugal in 90 hours90\text{ hours}, and wine in 120 and 80 hours120\text{ and } 80\text{ hours} respectively, Portugal has absolute advantage, but trade is maximized when each focuses on their most efficient output relative to the other.

  • Porter's Five Forces: Bargaining Power of Buyers, Bargaining Power of Suppliers, Threat of New Entrants, Threat of Substitutes, and Rivalry among existing competitors.

  • Components of Competitive Advantage:

    • Superior Efficiency: Ratio of inputs to outputs.

    • Superior Quality: Longevity, utility, and reliability.

    • Superior Responsivity: Satisfying customer demands better/faster than rivals.

    • Superior Innovation: Improved processes and products.

  • Cost Advantage Specifics: Absolute price advantage, consistency of price (avoiding fluctuation), low setup costs, and manageable switching costs.

  • Time to Market: Comprises fast order fulfillment, reduced tooling/setup times, and consistency of delivery. Nearshoring (sourcing from an adjacent country) helps reduce transportation time.

  • Enterprise Profit Optimisation (EPO): Automated balancing of price with supply facilitation. It dynamically optimizes Capital, Procurement, Sales, Production, and Information.

Sourcing Strategies: Offshoring, Outsourcing, Inshoring, and Insourcing

  • Offshoring: Relocating activity to another country. Drives cost advantage through lower labor/overhead but faces challenges with lead times, language barriers, and environmental compliance (ESG).

  • Outsourcing (Make-or-Buy): Transferring functions to external providers. Core competencies (unique production processes) are typically kept in-house. Non-core (Facilities Management, payroll) are outsourced.

    • Outsourcing Decision Matrix: High strategic importance/High contribution = Keep in-house. Low strategic importance/High contribution = Outsource.

  • Inshoring (Onshoring): Bringing processes back to the home country to reduce lead times and carbon emissions. Nearshoring involves moving to an adjacent country (e.g., US moving production from Far East back to Mexico).

  • Insourcing: Bringing previously outsourced activities back in-house to protect intellectual property or restore control over quality.

STEEPLED Analysis of the Business Environment

  • Social: Lifestyles, beliefs, income distribution, and labor skills.

  • Technological: Internet-of-Things (IOTIOT), Blockchain (anti-counterfeit), and Artificial Intelligence (AIAI) for demand forecasting.

  • Economic: Interest rates (central bank borrowing rates) and exchange rates.

  • Environmental: Carbon reporting, climate change (melting polar caps by 2050), and direct vs. indirect impacts (e.g., employee mileage vs. office waste paper).

  • Political: Systemic (policy swings), Procedural (corruption/bribes at ports), and Distributive (legislative changes targeting foreign investment).

  • Legal: Tax policies, employment laws, and competition regulations (e.g., Monopolies commissions rebuffing Fox Corporation acquisitions).

  • Ethical: Modern slavery acts, bribery acts (UK Bribery Act 2010; US Foreign Corrupt Practices Act), and Transparency International indices.

  • Demographic: Lifespan, age (global population projected at 9.37 billion9.37\text{ billion} by 2050), and marital status.

Supply Chain Design and Segmentation

  • Fisher’s Matching Framework (1997):

    • Functional Products: Predictable demand, life cycle >2 years> 2\text{ years}, contribution margin 5%−20%5\%-20\%, low variety.

    • Innovative Products: Unpredictable, life cycle 3 months to 1 year3\text{ months to } 1\text{ year}, margin 20%−60%20\%-60\%, high stock-out rates (10%−40%10\%-40\%\text{)}.

  • Gattorna’s Dominant Buying Behaviours (2017):

    • Collaborative: Predictable, trust-based partnerships.

    • Efficient: Transactional, low-cost focus, adversarial.

    • Dynamic: Ad hoc, opportunism, low loyalty.

    • Innovative Solutions: High flexibility and risk, focus on new ideas.

  • Product/Market Growth (Ansoff Matrix):

    • Market Penetration: Existing products to existing markets.

    • Product Development: New products to existing markets.

    • Market Development: Existing products to new markets.

    • Diversification: New products to new markets (highest risk).

  • Kraljic Portfolio Matrix (KPMKPM):

    • Non-Critical: Low risk/Low profit impact. Focus on efficiency.

    • Leverage: Low risk/High profit impact. Use bulk discounts.

    • Bottleneck: High risk/Low profit impact. Scarcity issues; seek substitution.

    • Strategic: High risk/High profit impact. Develop long-term collaborative partnerships.

Advanced Supply Chain Modelling and Feedback

  • Value Stream Mapping: Cross-functional analysis to identify bottlenecks and eliminate non-value adding activities (mudamuda). Includes identifying direct, indirect, and quality assurance sub-activities.

  • Network Optimisation Models (NOM):

    • Linear Programming: Identifies the shortest path based on distance, cost, and time.

    • Centre of Gravity: Analyses geographic coordinates of facilities relative to markets.

    • Maximum Flow: Aims to move the maximum number of items from suppliers to production points.

  • Reverse Logistics and the Circular Economy: Regenerative systems focused on repair, refurbishment, remanufacture, and recycling (technicalcycletechnical cycle) or composting (biologicalcyclebiological cycle). EU regulations demand 90%90\% recycling of plastic bottles by 2025.

  • Lean and Agile Supply Chains:

    • Lean (Just−in−Time,JITJust-in-Time, JIT): Minimizes inventory and waste (TIMWOODSTIMWOODS: Transport, Inventory, Motion, Waiting, Over-processing, Over-production, Defects, Skills).

    • Agile: Maximizes flexibility; uses buffer stocks to handle volatile markets.

  • The Balanced Scorecard (Kaplan and Norton, 2000):

    • Financial Perspective: EBIT, EBITDA, ROCE.

    • Customer Perspective: Satisfaction scores.

    • Internal Processes: Cycle times, accuracy.

    • Learning and Growth: Training counts, employee engagement.

  • Knowledge Management (SECI Model):

    • Socialization (Tacit-to-Tacit): Guidance and observation.

    • Externalization (Tacit-to-Explicit): Codifying experience into manuals.

    • Combination (Explicit-to-Explicit): Merging reports to create new knowledge.

    • Internalisation (Explicit-to-Tacit): Learning and internalizing codified standards.