Ch1 POLI 308

Part A — Week 2 Master Notes

1. What is law?

Slide definition: Law is a set of rules governing public and private activities and relationships. Those rules may come from legislation, legal codes, and judicial decisions, depending on the legal system.

The professor's opening discussion asked what everyone in Canada should know about the legal system. The central ideas include where law comes from, how it is applied, and how different legal systems operate.

Public law governs the exercise of government authority and public legal relationships. It includes constitutional, criminal, administrative, and tax law.

Private law governs legal relationships primarily between individuals, businesses, and other private parties. It includes contract, property, family, and tort law.

A single event can raise both public-law and private-law issues. For example, an assault may lead to a criminal prosecution and a separate civil lawsuit for damages.

2. Common law versus civil law

Common law

Origin: England

  • Judicial precedent

  • Stare decisis

  • Inductive reasoning

  • Case-based development

  • Dissenting opinions

Civil law

Origin: Roman law

  • Comprehensive codes

  • Statutory interpretation

  • Deductive reasoning

  • Legal treatises

  • Less emphasis on precedent

Common law: Developed in England, particularly under Henry II during the twelfth century. Travelling royal judges helped establish legal rules that applied across the kingdom. By the fourteenth century, precedent had become important.

Stare decisis means to stand by things decided. Courts follow applicable precedents to promote consistency and predictability, treating legally similar cases alike.

Inductive reasoning means examining individual cases to develop or identify broader legal principles.

Civil law: Developed from Roman law, particularly Justinian's sixth-century Corpus Juris Civilis. Important later developments included the Napoleonic Code of 1804 and the Civil Code of Lower Canada in 1866.

Civil law emphasizes comprehensive written codes. Judges typically interpret and apply general code provisions to particular disputes.

Deductive reasoning means moving from a general legal rule to a specific conclusion.

The distinction is not absolute. Common-law countries use legislation extensively, and civil-law courts consider earlier decisions.

Canadian application: Quebec generally uses civil law for provincial private-law matters and common-law traditions for public law. The other provinces primarily use common law, while federal criminal legislation applies across Canada.

3. Religious legal systems

Religious legal systems derive important legal rules from religious texts, doctrines, and authorities.

Canon law: Historically administered by Catholic Church institutions and ecclesiastical courts. These courts dealt with matters such as marriage, adultery, and heresy.

Islamic law: Developed through interpretation of the Quran and teachings associated with the Prophet Muhammad. It has historically influenced legal systems across the Middle East and South Asia.

Religious legal traditions may coexist with civil or common-law institutions.

4. Customary and Indigenous law

Customary law develops through longstanding practices, traditions, and shared understandings within communities. It may be transmitted orally rather than through a comprehensive written code.

Indigenous legal traditions existed before European colonization. Colonial institutions, including the Indian Act and reserve system, disrupted Indigenous governance and legal practices.

The Truth and Reconciliation Commission called attention to the importance of revitalizing Indigenous legal traditions.

Your slides identify examples including Akwesasne Mohawk, Anishinaabe, and Wet'suwet'en governance and legal traditions.

Indigenous legal resurgence means strengthening, practising, and revitalizing Indigenous legal orders as living systems of law.

5. Natural law theory

Central idea: Law should be connected to higher moral principles, justice, reason, or the common good.

St. Augustine: Associated with the statement that an unjust law is no law at all.

Thomas Aquinas: Argued that human-made law should serve the common good and conform to higher moral or divine principles.

Martin Luther King Jr.: Used the distinction between just and unjust laws to defend civil disobedience against racial segregation.

Natural law asks whether a rule deserves legal or moral authority, rather than focusing only on whether a government enacted it.

Exam application: A person argues that an officially enacted law lacks legitimacy because it violates fundamental moral principles.

6. Legal positivism

Central idea: Legal validity depends on recognized legal sources and legitimate procedures, rather than whether a law is morally good.

H. L. A. Hart: Associated with the separation of law and morality. A law can be legally valid while being morally unjust.

Your professor specifically highlighted these four characteristics:

  1. Law consists of rules distinct from informal customs and conventions.

  2. Rules are enacted and applied by public officials.

  3. Rules are enacted through legitimate procedures.

  4. Law is backed by the force of the state.

Likely MCQ distinction: The statement that rules must be enacted in a legitimate manner points to legal positivism, not natural law.

7. Legal realism

Legal realism focuses on how law actually operates, rather than assuming legal decisions are determined entirely by abstract principles or formal rules.

It emphasizes empirical investigation and the effects of social, economic, political, and technological circumstances.

Legal realists question whether formal rules always produce one clear outcome. This connects to legal indeterminacy, where legal materials do not uniquely determine a result.

Realism challenges natural law's abstract moral reasoning and positivism's potentially narrow focus on officially recognized rules.

8. New institutionalism

New institutionalism examines how institutions shape behaviour and outcomes.

Institutions include formal rules, procedures, organizational arrangements, and informal norms. These structures both enable and constrain judges and other political actors.

Courts operate within a broader system of government. Their authority, procedures, relationships, and internal norms affect their decisions.

Charter example: The Charter changed the role of Canadian courts by increasing the importance of constitutional rights litigation and judicial review.

Exam application: Two courts approach similar cases differently because their institutional powers and procedures differ.

9. Critical Legal Studies (CLS)

CLS developed partly from legal realism and questions the idea that law is neutral or separate from political and socioeconomic power.

Its major claims include:

  • Law reflects historical, political, and economic circumstances.

  • Legal institutions can legitimize existing power relationships.

  • Private property and individual rights may receive stronger protection than competing social or economic needs.

  • Judges and lawyers may come from privileged social backgrounds that influence institutional perspectives.

Exam application: A scholar argues that apparently neutral property rules disproportionately protect wealthy and powerful groups.

10. Feminist legal theory

Feminist legal theory examines how laws and legal institutions may reproduce or challenge gender inequality.

It questions historical male bias, traditional gender roles, and unequal treatment within legal systems.

Different feminist approaches exist, but a common concern is whether law produces genuine equality rather than merely applying identical rules.

Your slides also include a statistic describing women's legal rights globally as approximately three-fifths of men's. Treat this as a slide-specific point, not as a timeless or universally applicable measure.

11. Critical Race Theory (CRT)

CRT examines how law and institutions may construct, reinforce, or reproduce racial inequality.

It developed in the United States in relation to critical legal scholarship but can also be applied to Canada.

The slides connect CRT to slavery, segregation, voting restrictions, racialized poverty, and incarceration.

Structural racism: Inequality sustained through institutional arrangements and their effects.

Individual or folk understanding of racism: A narrower focus on individual prejudice and intentionally discriminatory actions.

CRT emphasizes that unequal institutional outcomes do not always require explicit racist intent by every participant.

12. Critical Indigenous legal theory

This approach examines how Canadian law has been connected to colonization and the displacement of Indigenous legal systems.

The slides emphasize three historical effects:

  1. Dispossession of Indigenous lands.

  2. Undermining Indigenous governments and legal traditions.

  3. Assimilation policies, including practices described by the TRC as cultural genocide.

They also identify two broad responses: revitalizing independent Indigenous legal traditions and engaging Canadian courts and institutions to challenge colonial legal relationships.

13. The comparisons you must understand

Comparison

Main distinction

Natural law vs. positivism

Moral legitimacy vs. recognized legal validity

Positivism vs. realism

Formal legal rules vs. law as actually practised

Realism vs. institutionalism

Contextual judicial behaviour vs. institutional rules and constraints

CLS vs. feminist theory

General power structures vs. gender inequality

CLS vs. CRT

General political and economic power vs. racial structures

CRT vs. critical Indigenous theory

Racial inequality vs. colonialism, Indigenous governance, and legal orders

Common vs. civil law

Precedent-centered vs. code-centered traditions

Inductive vs. deductive reasoning

Cases to principles vs. principles to cases

Week 2 exam boundary: These are the lecture topics to study. The detailed privacy cases, constitutional references, and judicial-process material from the old 465-card deck should not automatically be treated as Week 2 memorization requirements. We'll address relevant material in its proper lecture section.