Comprehensive Study Notes on Embedded Questions Redundancy and Vocabulary Builder Part II and Vocabulary
Introduction to the Session and Topic Context
Instructor: Syed Etesham Ali (English Teacher).
Session Context: A Sunday class continuing the series on types of questions.
Previous Topic Review: The class previously discussed "Tag Questions," which are used for confirmation.
Today's Primary Agenda:
Embedded Questions (also known as Included Questions).
Redundancy (Wordiness) and common grammatical errors.
Vocabulary Builder Series (Part 11).
Embedded Questions (Included Questions)
Definition: An embedded question is an indirect question that is included within another short question or a sub-statement.
Purpose: It is used to get the listener’s attention or to make the inquiry more polite. By adding a lead-in phrase, the speaker ensures the listener is focused before the actual core question is asked.
Classification: These are considered "Indirect Questions."
Direct vs. Embedded Comparison:
Direct Question Example: At a railway station, asking the inquiry counter directly: "When will the train arrive?"
Embedded Question Example: "Can you tell me when the train will arrive?" Here, "Can you tell me" is the lead-in question that includes the main inquiry.
Statement Example: "I want to know how much you bought this shirt for." Here, "I want to know" is the sub-statement.
Rules for Constructing Embedded Questions
1. Word Order (Crucial Rule):
Embedded questions do not follow the standard "Question Word Order" ().
Instead, they follow the "Statement Word Order" ().
Direct Question Order: "What is your name?" (Is = Verb, Your name = Subject).
Embedded Question Order: "Please tell me what your name is." (Your name = Subject, Is = Verb).
2. Punctuation:
Unlike direct questions that always end in a question mark (), embedded questions usually end with a full stop (period) if the introductory part is a statement.
Example: "I don't know where he is."
3. No Inversion:
Inversion refers to switching the placement of the subject and verb to form a question. In embedded questions, this inversion is removed (reverting to statement form).
4. Removal of Do, Does, and Did:
Auxiliary verbs used solely for question formation are removed when the question becomes embedded.
Rule for 'Does': When 'does' is removed, the main verb takes an 's' or 'es' ending.
Direct: "What time does the class start?"
Embedded: "Do you know what time the class starts?"
Rule for 'Did': When 'did' is removed, the main verb changes to its second form (past tense).
Direct: "Why did she leave?"
Embedded: "I wonder why she left."
Weak Interrogatives (Yes/No Questions) in Embedded Form
Definition of Weak Interrogatives: These are questions starting with a helping verb (e.g., Is, Are, Can, Will) that can be answered with a simple "Yes" or "No."
The 'If/Whether' Requirement: When embedding a Yes/No question, you must use the conjunctions "if" or "whether" to join the lead-in phrase and the question.
Example 1 (Direct): "Is he coming?"
Example 1 (Embedded): "I don't know if he is coming."
Example 2 (Direct): "Can you swim?"
Example 2 (Embedded): "Tell me whether you can swim."
Collaborative Practice: Embedded Question Transformations
Scenario 1:
Direct Question: "Where does Ali live?"
Lead-in: "Can you tell me…"
Embedded Result: "Can you tell me where Ali lives?" (Note: 'Does' is removed, 'live' becomes 'lives').
Scenario 2:
Direct Question: "Why did they cancel the meeting?"
Lead-in: "I want to know…"
Embedded Result: "I want to know why they cancelled the meeting." (Note: 'Did' is removed, 'cancel' becomes 'cancelled').
Scenario 3:
Direct Question: "Is the shop open?"
Lead-in: "Can someone tell me…"
Embedded Result: "Can someone tell me if the shop is open?"
Scenario 4:
Direct Question: "What is your name?"
Lead-in: "Please tell me…"
Embedded Result: "Please tell me what your name is."
Instructional Caveat: Saying "Please tell me your name" is an Imperative Sentence, not technically an embedded question structure.
Redundancy (Wordiness)
Definition: Redundancy refers to using more words than necessary to express an idea. It involves the repetition of meaning, which makes writing "wordy" or unclear.
The Principle of Vertiness: Sentences are most impressive when they are concise. Avoiding wordiness is essential for effective communication.
Urdu Analogies for Concept Clarity:
Example 1: "Sang-e-marmar ka pathar." Since 'Sang' means stone, adding 'pathar' (stone) at the end is redundant.
Example 2: "Abe-zamzam ka pani." Since 'Ab' means water, saying 'pani' (water) is redundant.
Example 3: "Catch pakro." Catch inherently means to catch/hold; adding 'pakro' is redundant.
Common English Redundancies:
Repeat again: 'Repeat' means to do something again. Adding 'again' is redundant.
Monday wale din: 'Monday' already contains the word 'day'.
Types of Redundancy
1. Word Redundancy: Repetition of similar words.
Each and Every: "Each and every child should be here." (Use one or the other).
True Fact: A fact is inherently true. If it were false, it would be a myth, not a fact.
2. Phrase Redundancy: Using a long phrase where a single word would suffice.
Example: "At this point in time" vs. "Now."
Example: "That which cannot be avoided" vs. "Inevitable."
3. Concept Redundancy: Using words that are already conceptually implied in another word.
Unexpected Surprise: A surprise is, by definition, unexpected. If you were expecting it, it would be "news," not a surprise.
Final Conclusion: A conclusion is the final part; it cannot be initial.
Practice Exercises: Identifying Redundant Words
Exercise 1: "This is a true fact."
Error: 'True'. Correct: "This is a fact."
Exercise 2: "Go fetch some water for me."
Error: 'Go'. 'Fetch' means to go and bring. If you are already at the water source, you use 'bring'; if you need to travel there and back, you use 'fetch'. Adding 'go' is unnecessary.
Exercise 3: "Elevated highways are built to solve traffic jams."
Error: 'Elevated'. Highways are inherently built at an elevation compared to parallel local roads. Underground paths are "subways."
Exercise 4: "We don't have sufficient enough financial information."
Error: Use either 'sufficient' or 'enough', not both.
Exercise 5: "She has returned back from her college."
Error: 'Back'. 'Return' means to come back.
Vocabulary Builder Series (Part 11)
1. Postpone: To put off (delay until a later time).
2. Stalked: To track (carefully following someone/something).
3. Swamp: A soft wetland (maddy, water-logged ground unsuitable for construction without clearing).
4. Equilibrium: Balance (maintaining stability).
5. Chat: Friendly discussion. (Contrast: A serious discussion is a dialogue).
6. Acquire: To gain or obtain (e.g., acquiring wealth).
7. Resolved: To be firmly decided or to have promised oneself to take action.
8. Genuine: Real or authentic. (Contrast: Imitation or Replica refers to a copy).
9. On the spur of the moment: To do something without previous thought (impulsively).
10. At random: By chance (without a specific pattern or selection process).
Questions & Discussion
Student Question (Munawwar Qasim): Which topics should be given the most priority for the NET (NUST Entrance Test)?
Teacher Response: No single topic is "most important." The test can draw from any area of the syllabus. Being too selective can lead to problems. Students must focus on every topic thoroughly to get desired results.
Student Question (Bilal Zia): How was NET-1?
Teacher Response: It likely went well; the instructor prompted the student to share their personal experience with it.
Student Question (Sufia): Why don't embedded questions end with a question mark?
Teacher Response: Because the grammatical structure is that of a statement (Assertive), and punctuation follows the structure of the sentence. If the structure isn't interrogative, it uses a full stop.
Student Question (Sana): Do these errors appear in "Spotting Errors"?
Teacher Response: Yes. These concepts are tested in Error Detection, Sentence Correction, and Sentence Completion sections.