Eco 101 Lecture Notes - LEC 6

Vibe Check

  • The speaker starts with a casual vibe check, ensuring everyone is engaged and on the same page.
  • Last class, we discussed supply and demand, building upon previous lectures.
  • We're now combining supply and demand concepts on the same graph.

Equilibrium in Markets

  • The central question is: Why does the market behave at the point where quantity supplied equals quantity demanded?
  • It's illogical for the market to operate elsewhere because:
    • If quantity is less than equilibrium, businesses can profit by producing more.
    • If quantity is more than equilibrium, firms produce goods that cost more than consumers are willing to pay, leading to losses or unsold inventory.
  • Equilibrium implies balance; forces push the market back towards it if it deviates.
  • If production is too high or too low, profit incentives drive behavior back to equilibrium.
  • Equilibrium is a state where no participant can improve their situation by changing behavior.

Trump's Tariffs and Film Industry

  • Trump imposed tariffs on American film companies producing movies outside the US.
  • Many countries, like Canada, offer significant tax credits to attract film production (e.g., 65%65\% of movies filmed in Canada for a decade).
  • Example: X-Men movies CGI-ed the Statue of Liberty into a park in Oakland.
  • Silent Hill was filmed in Brantford, Ontario, due to its desolate appearance.
  • The speaker jokes about the extent of tariffs, possibly around 10%10\%. He does not know for sure.
  • Marvel may be affected, with Avengers: Doomsday being filmed in London.
  • Toronto is often used as a stand-in for New York City in films.

Encouraging American Production

  • Trump aimed to increase American production to bolster the US economy.
  • The US primarily generates money through its financial and government systems by moderating the international financial system and being the world's bank.
  • This increases the value of the American dollar, benefiting the financial system but not necessarily others.
  • Trump foresaw a future where the US only provides banking services and consumes, questioning its long-term viability.
  • The US has offshored manufacturing jobs and now faces the loss of industries like Hollywood.
  • While actors may still be American, filming increasingly occurs elsewhere.

Math as a Tool

  • Graphs are used as tools to extract more information using math.
  • The demand curve represents demand in reality, and the supply curve represents supply. The market operates where these two equalize.
  • By using the equations of these lines, we can solve for the equilibrium point, finding equilibrium quantity and price.

Equilibrium Example: Xboxes

  • A business owner selling Xboxes for $300 finds 200 people in line but only has 100 units.
  • Instead of selling to the first 100 and leaving the rest unhappy, the owner can raise the price.
  • The owner increases the price until only 100 people remain in line, ensuring everyone there values the Xbox at or above the asking price.
  • This maximizes profit, as some people in the original line were willing to pay more than $300.
  • By raising the price to $350 and then $400, the line is reduced to 100 willing buyers.

Housing Market in Canada

  • The housing market in Canada operates at equilibrium, but with extremely high prices.
  • There are a limited number of houses; prices must be high enough so only a certain number of people can afford them.
  • The population grows faster than housing supply, lengthening the line of potential buyers and increasing prices.
  • To own a house in Canada, one must be among the wealthier individuals who can afford the limited supply.
  • The market is starting to show cracks in "dog shit" products like Toronto condos (less than 600 square feet).
  • There's enough housing for students and individuals, but not for families.
  • Government projects have focused on building condos rather than houses.
  • Condos are down 40% from 2022 peaks, while houses remain expensive.

Auctions and Rent

  • Buying a house is essentially an auction where people bid what they're willing to pay.
  • The auction system whittles down the number of interested parties until only one remains at the highest price.
  • Rent prices aren't exactly auctions, but they function similarly, with landlords looking at comparable properties.
  • Factors increasing housing prices include population growth and the amount of money people are willing to spend.
  • Low interest rates and government money in 2022 led to bidding wars, driving prices up significantly.

Waterloo's Housing Market

  • Waterloo is more expensive than Kitchener due to factors like property taxes.
  • Waterloo is now more expensive than Downtown Toronto.
  • Waterloo has a history of lucrative industries, including brewing, distillation, production, engineering, and tech (BlackBerry).
  • The Seagram distillers were based in Waterloo and heavily involved in prohibition.
  • Numerous startups and significant insurance companies (Manulife, Sun Life) contribute to the wealth in the area.
  • High wealth leads to expensive housing.

Solving for Equilibrium

  • The goal is to use math to solve for the equilibrium, combining supply and demand equations.
  • The speaker asks for the equations from the previous class. 40 - 1/50p (Demand) and 5 + 1/100p (Supply).
  • At equilibrium, quantity supplied (QS) equals quantity demanded (QD).
  • In math, having three variables and only two equations would typically be unsolvable. However, economic principles clarify an equilibrium, enabling the solution to be found.

Equilibrium Calculation

  • The equations are set equal to each other: 40150p=5+1100p40 - \frac{1}{50}p = 5 + \frac{1}{100}p. To simplify, multiply by 100, resulting in 40002p=500+p4000 - 2p = 500 + p.
  • Group like terms: 3500=7p3500 = 7p.
  • Solve for p: p=35007=500p = \frac{3500}{7} = 500. The equilibrium price is $500.
  • Plug the equilibrium price ($500) into either the demand or supply equation to find the equilibrium quantity.
  • Using the demand equation: QD=40150(500)=4010=30QD = 40 - \frac{1}{50}(500) = 40 - 10 = 30.
  • Using the supply equation: QS=5+1100(500)=5+5=10QS = 5 + \frac{1}{100}(500) = 5 + 5 = 10.

Analysis of the Equilibrium Price

  • Previously, the optimal price for the speaker to sell 90s was $1000. Why is the equilibrium price now $500?
  • The previous calculation assumed a monopoly. Now, with competition, the price is lower.
  • The equilibrium price maximizes total surplus, not just profit. Competitive markets lead to total allocated efficiency.

Manipulating the Model

  • Now that we have a model, we can manipulate it to see how changes affect price and quantity.
  • Examples: demand shifts, quotas, declaring war (grades don't matter), Trump tariffs.
  • This model can predict the behavior of commodity prices.

Profit and Happiness

  • We want to understand how changes in price and quantity affect firms' profits and consumers' happiness.
  • This helps governments determine whether policies are beneficial.

Measuring Firm Happiness (Profit)

  • We want to measure how good the market is for firms, measured by profit (price minus costs).
  • The supply curve represents how much a firm is willing to sell something for.
  • It is reasonable to assume that the supply curve represents the marginal cost of production.
  • Under some assumptions, the supply curve is a measurement of the cost of production.
  • The competitive model proves that the supply curve is the aggregation of all firms' marginal cost functions.

Producer Surplus

  • Producer surplus is the area between the price and the supply curve.
  • Surplus measures welfare, the amount of happiness or well-being produced by a market operator.
  • In the context of the firm, the producer surplus is their profit.
  • Producer surplus represents the difference between the cost to produce and the selling price.

Consumer Welfare

  • Consumer welfare is more complex to measure than firm profit.
  • Consumers gain happiness when they can purchase goods for less than what they are willing to pay.
  • The difference between a consumer's internal value and the price they actually have to pay is