Chapter 6
Environmental Impact Analysis (EIA)
Definition: EIA is a step-by-step way to find and study the environmental changes that might happen because of a project.
It usually looks forward at future projects (ex ante), but can also look back at past ones (retrospective) to see if earlier guesses were right.
It is used for all kinds of actions, from local rules to national laws.
Who Does It?: Mostly scientists who study nature and ecosystems to see how everything is connected.
Social Value: EIAs don't decide if the impacts are "good" or "bad" for society; they just list the physical effects.
The Law: In the s, the United States passed the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). This law says that formal documents called Environmental Impact Statements (EISs) must be created using the EIA process.
What’s Included:
Physical effects: Changes to the land, water, and wildlife.
Economic and human reactions: How people changing their behavior (like moving or spending money) causes more environmental changes.
Role of Economists: Economists help figure out how human behavior and economic links might make the environmental impacts larger or smaller.
Economic Impact Analysis
Definition: This studies how a specific event—like a new law, a technological discovery, or a change in trade—affects the economy.
Policy Focus: It often looks at how environmental rules change economic growth and other big factors on a local, regional, or global scale.
How It Works: It maps out how different business sectors and markets are linked together.
Examples:
How many jobs are lost or gained because of a new rule.
How the pollution-control business grows because of new laws.
How companies change their products or packaging to follow laws.
Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA)
Definition: RIA is a full check-up on the effects of a proposed or existing rule.
Context in the U.S.: These are often used to compare the costs and benefits of different ways to solve a problem.
Purpose: It helps leaders see the big picture, including who wins, who loses, and how much it will cost overall.
Comparison of Analyses
Environmental Impact Analysis (EIA)
Main Goal: To see physical and nature-based effects.
Question: How does this project change the environment?
Impacts: Living things, species, and pollution levels.
Law: Required by NEPA.
Economic Impact Analysis
Main Goal: To see money-related results and links.
Question: How does this action change the economy?
Impacts: Jobs, growth, and industry.
Law: Not required as a standalone rule.
Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA)
Main Goal: To see the total effect of a rule.
Question: Should we do this, and how?
Impacts: Benefits, costs, and who is affected.
Law: Required for big federal rules.
Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Definition: This compares different ways to reach a specific goal to find which one costs the least money.
Instead of changing the goal, you just look for the cheapest path.
Policy Efficiency: For a policy to be smart, it must be cost-effective at the very least.
Example: If a town's water is dirty, they might:
Drill new wells.
Get water from a town nearby.
Build a reservoir.
They would choose based on the lowest cost per gallons.
Real Life: This happened in Flint, MI () and Jackson, MS ().
Damage Assessment
Goal: To figure out how much a damaged natural resource is worth so the person responsible can pay for it.
The Law: This is tied to the Superfund law (CERCLA) from .
Rules for Cost:
The Department of Interior (DOI) makes the rules.
Formula: Damages = the lower number between "lost value of the resource" or "the cost to fix it."
Example: If a resource loss is worth but fixing it costs , the damages are .
Lost Value Sources: Includes things like hiking, mining, farming water, and shipping.
Challenges: It is hard to know how clean the area was before the damage or what counts as a "fair" fix.
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA)
Overview: This adds up every cost and every benefit and compares them to see if a project is worth doing.
Scope Problem: It is hard to decide who should be counted (just local people? the whole country? the whole world?).
Example: A chemical standard (ammonium perchlorate) in water:
EPA wanted a strict limit of to protect babies.
The Pentagon wanted a loose limit of because they only looked at healthy adults.
Sensitivity Analysis: This is a way of testing the results to see what happens to the benefits if you change the size of the program.
Temporal Considerations in Cost-Benefit Analysis
Time Matters: Usually, you pay for environmental policies today, but the rewards come much later.
Discounting: This is a tool to compare values from different times by converting "future money" into "today's money" ().
Discounting
Present Value (PV): This is the most you would pay right now to get a specific amount of money in the future.
Most people prefer today over next year because of uncertainty.
Example Math: If you expect in one year and in two years with a discount rate:
Choosing a Discount Rate
The Effect: A high discount rate means you care less about the future. For big issues like climate change, a low rate is usually better because it values the world our grandchildren will live in.
Social vs. Market Rates:
Market rates use banks/treasury bills as a guide.
Social rates might be lower because society wants to protect future generations even if it's not "profitable" right now.
Efficiency vs. Distribution
Efficiency: Getting the most total benefit possible.
Distribution (Equity): Making sure the benefits and costs are shared fairly.
Horizontal Equity: Treating people in similar situations the same.
Vertical Equity: Looking at how a policy affects rich vs. poor people.
Risk Analysis
Purpose: Since we don't know the future for sure, we use risk analysis to handle uncertainty.
Three Parts:
Assessment: How likely is the bad thing to happen, and how bad is it?
Valuation: How much are people willing to pay to avoid that risk?
Management: Deciding whether to fix the risk, control it, or just live with it based on the data.
Risk Estimation Techniques
Experts use old data and computer models (simulations) to guess the odds of an event.
Public perception often differs from reality (e.g., people being more afraid of planes than cars even though cars are riskier).
Importance of Risk Estimation
Expected Value: This is (the cost of a disaster) multiplied by (the chance it happens).
Math Example: If a climate disaster costs :
At a chance:
At a chance:
Perspectives on Risk
Risk Neutral: You only care about the mathematical average (expected value).
Risk Averse: You are very careful and want to avoid even a small chance of a huge disaster.
This is very common when talking about things we can't get back, like endangered species or a healthy climate.