Attitudes, Self-Perception, and Rationalization

Components and Measurements of Attitudes

What are attitudes, and how are they measured?

  • Attitudes can have multiple components, and researchers use a variety of methods to measure them

Can be a person, group, object, or issue

The Components of Attitudes

Attitude - An evaluation of an object in a positive or negative fashion that includes three components

  1. Affect - How we feel about it

  2. Cognition - how we think about it

  3. Behavior - How we act about it

Measuring Attidues - Self Reporting Measures

Likert Scale - A numerical scale used to assess attitudes; includes a set of possible answers with labeled anchors on each extreme

  • How do you feel about a certain think based on one through five

Response Latency - The amount of time it takes to respond to a stimulus, such as an attitude question

  • The speed of the response tells about how strong/accessable an attitude is on our mind

Measuring Attitudes When people don’t report

Implicit Attitude Measure - A indirect measure of attitudes that does not involve a self-report

  • IAT test

Nonverbal Measures - Degree of physical closeness to another person

Psychological measures - increased heart rate or sweaty palms in response to an attitude object

Predicting Behaviors from Attitudes

Additudes may be poor predictors of behavior

La Piere Study in the 1930s

  • Traveling accross the US with a chinese couple at time when anti-chinese prejudice was high

  • Supprisingly, they were denied service at only one of the 250 places they visited

  • However, when each place was later contacted and asked if they would not serve chinese customers, 90% said they would not

Why don’t our attitudes match with our behavior?

Attitudes can Conflict with other Powerful Determinants of Behavior

Attitudes may conflict with other influences on behavior

  • Social norms, other conflicting attitudes, and situational factors may also influence behavior

Introspecting about the Reasons for our Attitudes

Introspection may influence attitudes

  • Introspection may fail to capture the full cause of our attitudes

  • Introspection may cause a rift between your expressed attitude and subsequent behavior, put primarily when the basis of an attitude is affective (emotion)

    • In these cases, cognitive (thoughtful) analysis of your reasons for the attitude may yeild misleading congitive reasons

The Mismatch between general attitudes and specific target

General attitudes may not match specific targets

  • Attitudes are more accurate predictions of bevahior when specific attitudes towards a specific behavior are measured

  • People can feel passionate about the enviorment, but they do not recycle

Predicting Attitudes from Behavior

Attitudes may be poor predictors of behavior, but behaviors can be good predictors of attitudes

  • Attitudes may change in order to be consistent with behavior

If we behave in a certain way, it can adjust your attitudes on a certain topic

Cognitive Dissonance Theory

Cognitive Consistency Theories

  • Theories that maintain that the impact of behavior on attitudes reflects our tendency to justify or rationalize our behavior and minimize any inconsistences between our attitudes and actions

Cognitive Dissonance Theories

  • Theory that inconsistencies among a person’s throughts, sentiments, and actions cause an averse emotion state (dissonance) that leads to efforts to restore consistency

    • Soemone who thinks smoking is bad, but still smokes → causes dissonance

      • They can change their behavior to stop smoking

Our brains would rather change reality then admit it was wrong

Reducing Cognitive Dissonance

Cognitive Dissonacne can be reduced by changing throughts, feelings, or behaviors in order to make them consistent

  • For instance, smoking may cause dissonance becuase its bad for health and most people want to be healthy

  • Dissoance can be reduced by quitting smoking

Can also be reduced by adding thoughts, feelings, or behaviors to reduce apparent inconsistance

  • people may find it too difucult to quit smoking

  • Dissonance can be reduced by adding such thoughts such as “Yes, I know its bad for me but it helps me relax” → They have added a justification that makes the dissonance less unfomforatble

When does Rationalization Occur?

Before or after the decision is made, when you have to justify it

Cognitive Dissonance Theory and Decisions

Because behaviors cannot be taken back, cognitive dissonance often causes changes in throughts and/or feelings to rationalize behaviors

  • Difficult choices can induce cognitie dissonance

  • Dissonance can be aroused by the inconsistency of accpeitng the negative of one choice with the

Rationaliztions Can Reduce Decision Dissonance

Decision dissonance typically is resolved by emphasizing the positives and minimizing the negatives of the selected choice

  • Also resolved by emphasizing the negatives of the unselected choices and minimizing the positves

Cognitive Dissonance Theory: Effort Justification

Effort Justification - The tendency to reduce dissonance by justifying the time, effort, or money devoted to something that turned out to be unplesent or disappointing

Greater effort expanded leads to more dissonance and more attempts to rationalize behavior

  • Club Initiations, Fraternity Hazing, “Sweet Lemons Rationality” (it’s not so bad after all to justify a costly effort)

    • People want to believe that the effort put in was worth it

Cognitive Dissonance Theory: Induced (forced) Complience

Induced Complience - Subtly compelling people to behave in a manner that is inconsistent with their beliefs, attitudes, or values in order to elicit dissonance, and therefore a change in their original views

  • Being paid one dollar vs twenty dollars to lie

Cognitie Dissonancy Theory: “Forbidden Toy” Study

Forbiden Toy Study:

  • Children are given a set of toys and asked to rate each one

  • They are then told that they could play with any of teh toys, except for one

  • They are then told that playing with the forbidden thoy would make an addult “annoyed” (Mild Threat) or “very very angry” (Severe Threat)

  • All children resisted playing with the forbidden toy.

  • Later, children were asked to rate the toys again.

  • Many children given a mild threat found the toy less desirable than before, but children given a severe threat found the toy more desirable. Why

  • Mild threats of punishment are a weak reason for resisting something that is desired, so attitude changes to rationalize behavior.

    • That toy isn’t so great after all.”

  • Severe threats are a good reason to resist a behavior but may
    result in the behavior seeming even more appealing

When Does Inconsistency Produce Dissonance?

Free Choice

Free choice - Choosing to engage in a behavior that is inconsistent with beliefs will cause dissonance.

  • Forced behavior does not cause dissonance, since the reason for the behavior is clear

    • “I didn’t have a choice”

  • There is no need to rationalize behaviors we didn’t choose.

Insufficient Justification

Insufficient Justification - Dissonance may occur when the reason for a behavior is weak or unclear.

  • Payment of $1 may be insufficient justification for lying.

  • Annoying an adult may be insufficient punishment to resist playing with a favorite toy.

With sufficient justification (that is, more money, larger threat), the behavior doesn’t need to be rationalized.

Negative Consequences

Negative consequences - Freely chosen inconsistent behaviors may not cause dissonance if there was no negative consequence of the behavior.

  • Lying may not cause dissonance if the person doesn’t believe what you say anyway.

If nothing happened as a result, there is nothing to rationalize.

Forseeability

Foreseeability - Dissonance may not occur if the negative consequence was not something that could be foreseen. Anticipate the negative consequences

  • If you give someone food they are allergic to but you had no prior knowledge of the allergy, then you have no reason to rationalize your behavior.

Self-Affirmation and Dissonance

Cognitive dissonance results from challenges or threats to people’s sense of themselves as rational, moral, and competent.

  • self-affirmation

    • boosting our self-esteem and identity by focusing on important aspects of the self

  • Self-affirmation can reduce dissonance

Is Dissonance Universal?

Cognitive dissonance may be universal across cultures but may be aroused by different situations.

  • European Canadians’ cognitive dissonance may result from threats to how people see themselves.

  • Asian Canadians’ cognitive dissonance may occur from threats to how people believe they are seen by others

Cognitive Dissonance and Culture

Culture and decision dissonance

  • European Canadians experienced more dissonance when making a choice for themselves than for a friend.

  • Asian Canadians experienced more dissonance when making a choice for a friend than for themselves.

  • Asian Canadians are more likely to experience dissonance when primed with thoughts of how other people would view their choices and behavior.

Culture and Priming


Self Perception Theory

Like all prominent theories that have been around for a long time, cognitive dissonance theory has faced many theoretical challenges, and there have been numerous critiques.

Self-perception theory - the theory that people come to know their own attitudes by looking at their behavior and the context in which it occurred, and then inferring what their attitudes must be

  • “You keep going to the gym, so you figure that exercise must be important to you”

Inferring our own Attitudes

Self-perception theory suggests a different interpretation of the cognitive dissonance research.

  • Cognitive dissonance theory argues that people change attitudes to fit their behavior because inconsistencies are mentally unpleasant.

  • Self-perception theory argues that an unpleasant mental state is not needed as explanation for the results of the cognitive dissonance studies. We just observe our own behavior and infer our attitudes from it!

Inferring our own attitudes from behaviors

Self-perception argues that people didn’t change their attitudes; instead, they inferred their attitudes from their behavior in the situation.

  • “I told them that the task was fun, so it must have been fun because there wasn’t any other reason to say it was

Reconciling the Dissonance and Self-Perception Accounts

Cognitive dissonance may occur when behavior doesn’t fit a preexisting attitude, and the attitude is important to the self- concept.

  • Inconsistency is threatening to self-concept, so dissonance is aroused.

    • “If you think of yourself as a honest person, then you lie it creates dissonance”

Self-perception may occur when attitudes are weak or ambiguous.

  • no strong prior attitude → no sense of inconsistency → no dissonance

  • Many attitudes are relatively weak and changeable.

The Embodied Nature of Cognition and Emotion

A variety of physical actions are associated with different psychological states.

  • If we’re induced to make the bodily movements associated with certain attitudes, beliefs, or emotions, we might come to have—or find it easier to have—those very attitudes, beliefs, or emotions.

    • Smiling makes you happy. Confident posture makes you confident

Beyond Cognitive Consistency to Broader Recognition

The core of dissonance theory is the idea that people find cognitive inconsistency uncomfortable and therefore try to find ways to relieve the discomfort

System Justification Theory

The theory that people are motivated to see the existing sociopolitical system as desirable, fair, and legitimate

  • Even when it does not benifit everyone equally

  • Believing that the system is fair reduces discomfort about inequality

I didn’t know monkeys can feel class conciousness

System Justification Reduces Dissonance

System justification reduces dissonance.

promotes the virtues of the status quo’

“If I could go to school and get a job, then people who are homeless could do the same thing.”

positive or compensatory stereotypes

“Sure, women make less money for the same job, but they are better liked at work.”

Terror Management Theory (TMT)

the theory that people deal with the potentially crippling anxiety associated with the knowledge of the inevitability of death by striving for symbolic immortality through preserving valued cultural worldviews and believing they have lived up to their standards

Terror Mangement Theory and Symbolic Imortality

Ways to achieve symbolic immortality:

  • view self as connected to broader culture, worldview, and social institutions

    • stronger identification with family, country, religion, and so on

  • high self-esteem

    • view self as a good, valued member of the culture

Terror Mangement Theory and Mortality Sailence

Tests of TMT use mortality salience manipulations (reminding people about the fact that they will die)

  • Possibly by having people write about death, read information about death, or look at images associated with death

Often compared to a pain salience condition

  • Thinking of your death versus thinking of feeling pain at the dentist

  • Researchers then examine how thinking about death changes their attitude/behavior vs people who thought about the dentist

Effects of Mortality Sailence

More commitment to ingroups and more hostility to outgroups

Increased hostility to people who criticize one’s country

More punitive to people who challenge prevailing laws

Reluctance to use cultural artifacts for mundane purposes

More acceptance of positive feedback about the self

During the 2004 election, mortality salience made people feel more favorable toward Bush and less favorable toward Kerry.

  • Possibly because Bush was already president and was seen as defending the country from outside threats

Caution in Evaluating TMT Evidence

A large-scale replication of 21 TMT studies failed to replicate the worldview defense hypothesis of TMT.

Further inquiry is needed to draw conclusions about what tenets of TMT are and are not replicable, and under what conditions.