media & crime

true crime: ‘‘sensational’ versions of murder stories, emotionally charged content mainly focused on violent crime, to a broad public’ e.g.

criticisms

  • distorted, glamourised, unrealistic portrayals of offenders can impact social attitudes & social attitudes

  • can negatively influence how we view the justice system

  • misleading depictions of serial killers - insensitive to victims

  • desensitise the audience

  • increase fear of crime

  • can result in fan communities - declarations of love towards violent offenders

strengths

  • can make people more vigilant

  • improves understanding of the CJS

  • increases empathy with victims of crime

  • helps solve crimes that would’ve otherwise gone unsolved

  • improved understanding of criminals & their motivations


how true crime audiences understand offenders

  • Geier & Mooney - negotiation of tension between understanding offenders & recognising the risks of offender-centred rep

  • victims can become peripheral

  • the mediated representation of crime - various forms of media that are influential in shaping perceptions of crime, CJS, crime types

contradictory nature of crime

  • crime is sold through the crime control complex (private policing/security) & the media

  • crime is controlled through traditional crime management & the media


true crime in history

  • execution broadsides & crime pamphlets (16th-18thC) - earliest mass-market true crime stories often sold at executions → criminals becoming celebrities

  • the illustrated police news 1843-1939 - one of the first tabloids in England, most famous for its coverage of Jack the Ripper



crime news - articulates shared norms & values and reinforces them

trial by media

OJ Simpson - car chase watched by 95 million

  • difficulties when selecting a jury - preconceived perceptions → bias’

  • sensualised - ‘if it doesn’t fit, acquit’

  • 1995, 150 million watched the verdict

  • headlines - ‘loss of a hero in an age without any’ - placed on a pedestal, fame overrides possibility of guilt, media perceptions created without taking into account the evidence or harm to victims'/their family

  • celebrity status → difficulties & may lead the defendant to believe their image, power, & wealth will allow them to get away with atrocities - high media coverage → desensitisation, removal of a victim,

Depp v Heard

  • ‘ a mega pint of wine’ - quickly turned into a meme → the public seeing Depp in a better light and putting the allegations held against him to the side

  • Depp’s carefree demeanour throughout the trial (laughing during Heard’s testimony & making small but memorable jokes in his own testimony) led to public assumption that Depp was completely innocent (fans crowding outside the courthouse to show support & multiple accounts online dedicated to proving Depp’s innocence & mocking Heard)

  • the recording of the trial - turns the very real court case into somewhat of a show for the publics entertainment → the public to forget the existence of a real victim


scandal hunting & media justice - investigations aimed at exposing the corruption of the powerful

online provision - crime being a profitable commodity → countless platforms & sites circulating 24/7 breaking news globally, e.g. 2021 - The Guardian Newspaper sold 105,000 print copies per day - its website attracted more than 305 million daily page visitors