BIO153 Lecture 5 notes

Classification by Similarity

  • The study of how closely organisms are related through classification is pivotal in understanding biodiversity.

Traits Used to Classify Species

  • Organisms can be assessed on their relationships based on various traits:

    • Morphological Traits: This includes body shape, tissue structure, and organelle presence.

    • E.g., Comparison of vertebrate limb structures.

    • Biochemical Traits: Refers to metabolic pathways and other biochemical signatures.

    • Genetic Traits: Looks at gene presence and absence as well as gene sequence variations.

Taxonomy Using Morphological Traits

  • Organisms with shared complex traits (like bone structure) are likely from a common ancestor.

  • It is less likely for complicated traits to evolve independently in unrelated organisms, and end up looking near-identical by chance; instead, these traits are often indicative of evolutionary relationships and adaptive strategies that have been favored in similar environments.

  • Example: Skull morphology is heavily used in classifying various species due to its complexity.

  • Although similar morphology does not always mean relatedness.

  • Convergent Evolution: This is the phenomenon where unrelated organisms independently evolve similar traits due to adaptations to similar environments.

    • E.g., Australian mole (marsupial) vs. North American mole (placental).

    • evolved under selective pressure for their ground-burrowing lifestyle, leading to analogous characteristics.

Homology vs. Analogy

  • Homology: Refers to traits inherited from a common ancestor.

    • Example: All mammals have the trait of feeding milk, suggesting a shared ancestry.

  • Analogy: Traits that appear similar but evolved independently in different lineages.

    • Example: Mole-like traits in Australian and placental moles.

Categorizing Homologous Traits

  • Shared Ancestral Character: Traits held by a common ancestor and passed to all descendants.

    • E.g., Milk feeding in mammals.

  • Shared Derived Character: Unique traits developed in a lineage after divergence.

  • E.g., The pouch in marsupials.

  • Shared ancestral/derived characters are relative terminologies, it changes depending on who you set as the common ancestor.

  • “Bag for infants” is a shared derived character unique to marsupials, if you use the common ancestor of all mammals as a reference.

  • “Bag for infants” is a shared ancestral character, if you use the common ancestor of all marsupials as the reference.

  • The milk-feeding trait of mammals becomes a shared derived trait in reference to all vertebrates, same logic applies to other traits.

Convergent evolution happens a lot

  • Different lineages of marine mammals, for example: Dolphins and whales, seals, and manatees

  • These traits are shared derived characters in relation to entire mammals.

  • These traits are analogous to each other since they were acquired independently in their lineages.

Telling them apart homology and analogy

  • Very complicated traits are unlikely to emerge in multiple independent lineages by convergent evolution

  • “forelegs” of humans and birds share clear similarities, this would be quite low chance for them to have evolved independently and match structures to this extent.

  • Forelegs of bats and birds are also shared-ancesteral homologs, however, they’re wing structures differ as birds have reduced digits (Metacarpals/Phalanges) with feathers attached to their forelimbs

  • Whilst in contrast bats have elongated digits, forming their wings through a stretched membrane that extends between the fingers, like an umbrella.

  • The ancestral ‘foreleg’ structure evolved differently bats and birds due to their adaptation to distinct environmental pressures and giving rise to a flying mechanism.

  • The wings of birds, bats, and dragonflies are all analogous

  • Birds and bats share homologous forelimbs whilst a dragonfly does not.

Importance of Understanding Traits

  • Recognizing whether traits are homologous or analogous helps deduce evolutionary relationships.

  • Similarities and differences in structures provide evidence of evolutionary relatedness.

Molecular Genetics in Taxonomy

  • Genes serve as indicators of evolutionary relationships. Types include:

    • Orthologous Genes: Genes in different species that have evolved from a common ancestor.

      • Example: Human and Chimpanzee share a common ancestral gene.

    • Paralogous Genes: Genes that have duplicated within a species and evolved separately.

Gene Evolution and Phylogeny

  • Genes evolve at differing rates, influencing their utility in studying evolutionary history:

    • Slow-evolving Genes: Retain similarities over long periods and are useful for deep evolutionary comparisons.

    • Fast-evolving Genes: Accumulate mutations quickly and are better suited for recent evolutionary events.

Conclusion on Trait Classification

  • Understanding both morphological and genetic traits aids in piecing together the tree of life.

  • Traits provide crucial insights into the relationships and evolutionary pathways of organisms across time.