Lecture 4: E-Cigarettes

  • this is a paper from the US and quite old

  • approx ten years ago, rechargeable vapes with replaceable pods drops drastically in popularity (47% to 15% by 2024)

  • disposable vapes became drastically more popular (lower than 10% in 2014 to 30% in 2024)

  • everyone on this graph is a regular vaper

  • less than ten % of vapers have never smoked but continue to vape

  • the solid black line is dual users, so they smoke tobacco and vape

  • the solid black and dotted black line move in parallel, aka when people started to quit smoking tobacco they have moved to be an ex tobacco smoker but vape instead

  • thus vaping and smoking tobacco are quite closely linked

  • overtime the number of adults that smoke have gone down, almost parallel to the number of adults that picked up vaping

  • very recent trend shows that the total number of vapers had outnumber the amount that smoke

  • relatively low in 11-15 year olds, but has made a drastic and increasing leap in recent years

  • shows its not really older adults that increased use of disposable vapes, but overwhelmingly popular within the younger population

  • one Dr results show that ecigarettes/ vapers are safer than cigarettes

  • it is the tar in the cigarettes that cause the harmful toxins to enter our bodies, this is not an issue in vapes

  • The tobacco industry has a long history of denying the negative and harmful consequences of tobacco, but now that they have transitioned their interests into vapes people are concerned and suspicious of a repeat in strategies, denial and refusal of accountability

  • if inhaled they are dangerous, but carbonyls are only released if the e-cigarette is overheated.

  • this only happens if your towards the bottom of the liquid tank and is much less likely if your liquid tank is full

    • so this is a lot less likely

  • 1.79 odds ration: you are 79% more likely to have a heart attack if you are an e-cigarette smoker than someone who is not

    • 2.72: 172% more likely if you are a smoker

  • cardiovascular disease and other harmful health issues only appear after a decade or two, so we would not know the relationship between this and e-cigarettes, because it is too new

    • we have to wait for these epidemiological studies

  • a lot of the scents and flavouring or flavourings that have been used in foods, so there is no reason to believe they would be particularly harmful is inhaled

    • however, this does not directly indicate that they are as safe when inhaled

  • the vapes produce the carbonyls when you burn the liquid, as said before

    • so the one observation is that this makes you feel physically sick once it happens, which indicates that it probably is not happening often

      • we would know if it was because people would have physical symptoms

  • when used as intended, there is not too much evidence of them being severely harmful

    • most harmful when swallowed or slathered on skin so not common issue

  • many would say that e-cigarettes and nicotine are as harmful as caffeine

    • though some would argue against this

  • back in 2014 very few were incorrect, however, this has increased drastically by 2024

  • this might have implications for use of e-cigarettes on those that could be trying to stop smoking in the future

  • doesn’t follow up overtime, gets people representative of the uk

  • across a ten year time periods, for every 1% increase in the pop prevalence of E-Cig use among tobacco smokers, the success rate of attempts to quit tobacco smoking increased by 0.1%

  • among tobacco smokers who actually start vaping, they do not find any evidence they are less likely to quit

  • in 2013, a majority of E-Cig users are also smoking tobacco

    • but at some point this cross over occurs, so in 2024 53% used to smoke tobacco but quit

    • over time people are leaving the group of vapers who smoke to vapers who used to smoke

  • no manipulation of variables, not that they are always observed

  • e-cig use reduces the chance of quitting by 27%

  • these groups may differ in the extent they want to quit, why they are using e-cigs and the frequency of use

    • they differ in various ways

  • maybe if we just focussed on people who used e-cigs and really want ot quit, we could see different results in smoking sensations than included others who have no intention of quitting

  • twice as likely to quit if you use an e-cig than behavioural support

  • pretty clearly, the answer is yes