Stock-Based Compensation at Twitter: Accounting, Management, and Valuation
Core Dilemma: GAAP vs. Non-GAAP Metrics at Twitter
Reporting Divergence in Q4 2017:
- Under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), Twitter recorded a net loss of for fiscal year 2017.
- On the earnings call, Chief Executive Officer (CEO) Jack Dorsey and Chief Financial Officer (CFO) Ned Segal emphasized non-GAAP net income of .
- The self-defined non-GAAP metric was created when Twitter went public in 2013 and primarily differed from GAAP by excluding stock-based compensation (SBC) expense.
Analytical & Strategic Questions:
- Whether stock-based compensation represents a genuine operating expense.
- Why market analysts and regulators condone or scrutinize non-GAAP earnings metrics.
- How non-GAAP reporting impacts corporate profitability, stock valuation, and operational management.
History and Growth of Twitter
Founding and Early Mechanics:
- Spun out of the failed podcasting startup Odeo in 2006, Twitter was founded by Jack Dorsey, Evan Williams, Noah Glass, and Biz Stone.
- The first tweet was sent by Jack Dorsey on March 21, 2006: "just setting up my twttr".
- Designed for short status updates called "tweets," originally constrained to 140 characters to match the maximum allowable length of a short message service (SMS) text message sent to 40404.
- Evolved from a social network into an information network for breaking news, public debate, and real-time events.
- Raised capital at a valuation in 2009 despite generating zero revenue.
Pre-IPO and Commercial Expansion under Dick Costolo:
- Dick Costolo assumed the CEO role in 2010 to build an advertising-backed business model using "promoted tweets."
- Scale from 2010 to IPO:
- Employee head count grew from 30 to 2,000.
- Monthly Active Users (MAUs) increased from approximately to .
- Annual revenue expanded from to .
Initial Public Offering (IPO) and Subsequent Challenges:
- Listed on November 7, 2013; shares rose 73% on the first day of trading to close at , valuing Twitter above .
- Struggled to meet growth expectations relative to competitors like Facebook, Instagram, and Snap (Snapchat).
- Leadership changes and stock trajectory:
- Costolo stepped down in July 2015; Jack Dorsey returned as CEO.
- Stock reached an all-time low of in May 2016 (a ~70% drop from its first trading day).
- CFO Anthony Noto transitioned to Chief Operating Officer (COO) before leaving in February 2018.
- Ned Segal joined as CFO in August 2017.
Foundations of Stock-Based Compensation (SBC)
Definition and Primary Instruments:
- Non-cash remuneration granting employees ownership equity in the enterprise.
- Stock Options:
- Gives the employee the right to purchase common shares at a predetermined exercise price.
- Example: An employee granted 400 options at an exercise price of per share when the stock later trades at pays to acquire 400 shares valued at , generating a profit.
- Restricted Stock Units (RSUs):
- "Phantom stock" that converts into common shares at vesting with an effective exercise price of .
- Retains residual value as long as the share price remains above , unlike options which become worthless if underwater.
- Adopted by public firms and late-stage private companies staying private longer (e.g., Twitter, Airbnb, Dropbox).
Vesting Schedules & Forfeiture Accounting Rules:
- Standard linear 4-year vesting schedule with a 1-year "cliff" (25% vests after 12 months) and quarterly vesting thereafter (6.25% per quarter).
- Departure before vesting results in forfeiture of unvested equity.
- Accounting Standard Update (ASU) 2016-09 (Topic 718: Improvements to Employee Share-Based Payment Accounting):
- Effective fiscal year 2017, allowed firms to account for forfeitures as they occur rather than estimating expected future forfeitures.
- Adopted by Twitter in 2017.
Strategic Rationales for SBC:
- Recruiting & Talent Acquisition: Offers upside participation in high-growth scenarios without immediate cash expenditure; critical for recruiting senior executives to scale pre-IPO companies.
- Retention & Alignment: One-year cliffs and multi-year vesting discourage early departures; performance "refresh grants" retain high-performing existing staff.
- Cash Preservation: Preserves cash reserves for early-stage or cash-constrained firms unable to match market-rate cash salaries.
- Market Prevalence: A 2017 FW Cook study revealed 34% of all public companies and 70% of information technology firms used Employee Stock Purchase Plans (ESPPs).
Governance Criticisms & Empirical Findings:
- Tying compensation tightly to stock prices can distort managerial decision-making, encouraging short-term focus during grant windows.
- Studies indicate CEOs with large equity packages take greater corporate risks and show higher incidence of earnings manipulation.
- Research shows higher SBC levels do not correlate with superior long-term firm performance.
Regulatory History and Accounting Evolution of SBC
Accounting Principles Board Opinion No. 25 (APB 25):
- Intrinsic Value Method: .
- Options granted at-the-money (exercise price equal to market price) carried zero intrinsic value, resulting in zero recorded compensation expense.
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards (SFAS) No. 123 (1995):
- Rerecommended fair value accounting for stock grants.
- Permitted companies to either expense fair value on the income statement or continue using APB 25 intrinsic value and disclose pro-forma fair value impact in footnote disclosures.
- By 2000, virtually all major option-issuing companies selected the footnote disclosure approach.
Reform & Mandatory Expensing (SFAS 123R):
- Post-2000 corporate accounting scandals (Enron, WorldCom) and the dot-com crash increased regulatory oversight.
- Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 Section 404 mandated strict internal financial control disclosures.
- In December 2004, Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued SFAS 123R (Share-Based Payment), eliminating the intrinsic value method and requiring all share-based payments to be valued at fair value on the grant date and expensed over the service period.
Black-Scholes Option Pricing Mechanics:
- Models fair value based on grant-date variables. Directional sensitivity on option value:
- Current Share Price (): Increase Increase
- Exercise Price (): Increase Decrease
- Stock Price Volatility (): Increase Increase
- Expiration / Exercise Length (): Increase Increase
- Risk-Free Interest Rate (): Increase Increase
Debate: Is Stock-Based Compensation a True Expense?
Arguments Supporting Expensing (Pro-SFAS 123R):
- Represents real economic consideration paid for employee labor; omitting it distorts true operating profitability.
- Non-expensing allows management to mask labor costs and extract excess compensation without impacting reported profits.
- A 2001 study showed mandatory SBC expensing reduced median growth firm earnings per share (EPS) by 14%.
Arguments Opposing Expensing:
- Non-cash nature and valuation uncertainty: Employee equity contracts contain non-transferability, vesting cliffs, and forfeiture clauses that violate standard option model assumptions.
- Historical grant-date valuation mismatch: Compensation expense is fixed at grant-date fair value and never marked-to-market. If stock price drops, recorded expense is overstated relative to actual value delivered; if stock price surges, recorded expense is understated.
- Double-counting concern: Dilution is already captured in the denominator of Diluted EPS (higher share count). Recording an expense in the numerator (lower net income) penalizes financial performance twice.
Twitter's Implementation and Magnitude of SBC
Operational & Cultural Drivers:
- High technical talent competition in the San Francisco Bay Area.
- Real-time product architecture required top-tier engineering talent to manage site capacity outages.
- Executive turnover: Twitter had 3 CEOs in its first four years; frequent replacement of the Head of Product (a position likened to the "Defense Against the Dark Arts" professor in Harry Potter) generated recurring, large equity grant packages.
Downward Spiral Risk & Refresh Grants:
- Declining stock prices reduced the realized value of employee equity, prompting company-wide refresh grants in 2016 to prevent talent loss to competitors.
- Downward Spiral Dynamics: Falling stock price Lower realized equity pay Higher employee turnover risk Issuance of additional SBC grants Increased reported GAAP losses and share dilution Further stock price pressure.
Twitter's Defense Arguments to Shareholders:
- GAAP expense overstates true cost when stock price drops because expenses are locked in at higher grant-date valuations.
- SBC expense is lower than the operational cost and disruption of elevated employee turnover.
- Granting additional equity restores employee compensation to intended retention and ownership levels.
Capitalized Software Engineering SBC:
- Capitalizes internal-use software development costs into Property and Equipment, net (PP&E).
- Capitalized labor includes SBC components:
- 2015: total capitalized ( SBC).
- 2016: total capitalized ( SBC).
- 2017: total capitalized ( SBC).
- Amortization of capitalized labor included in cost of revenue (useful life up to 4 years):
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
Financial Reporting and Market / Regulatory Dynamics
Twitter's Non-GAAP Earnings Metrics:
- Reports Adjusted EBITDA and Non-GAAP Net Income, both excluding SBC expense, acquired intangibles amortization, and non-cash interest expense.
- Stated rationale: Helps management and investors identify underlying operational trends, set internal budgets, and compare core performance across periods.
Analyst & Industry Practices:
- Sell-side analysts historically relied on Adjusted EBITDA for enterprise value multiples (EV/EBITDA) and target pricing, ignoring GAAP net losses.
- Analyst questions regarding SBC were virtually non-existent on earnings calls between Q4 2013 and Q2 2018 (asked only three times total: Lyman Zerga in Q2 2017, Eric Sheridan of UBS in Q1 2016, and Justin Post of Bank of America Merrill Lynch in Q1 2014).
Regulatory Actions & Peer Policy Shifts:
- SEC Chair Mary Jo White (2015) and updated SEC Compliance & Disclosure Interpretations (C&DIs, May 2016) increased scrutiny on prominent non-GAAP reporting.
- Twitter received an SEC comment letter in 2017 regarding non-GAAP prominence, agreeing to display directly comparable GAAP metrics with equal or greater prominence.
- Peers Alphabet and Facebook ceased non-GAAP reporting in 2017:
- Alphabet CFO Ruth Porat: "Although it's not a cash expense, we consider it to be a real cost of running our business because [stock-based compensation] is critical to our ability to attract and retain the best talent in the world."
- Facebook CFO David Wehner: Investors "should focus primarily on our GAAP metrics given that stock-based [compensation] is an important part of our compensation mix."
- Lifecycle context: Snap Q2 2018 SBC was 60% of revenue ( SBC on revenue); Dropbox Q2 2018 SBC was 16% of revenue ( SBC on revenue). Twitter committed in its 2017 10-K to reduce SBC to high single digits or low teens as a percentage of revenue.
Twitter's Shift in Compensation Strategy
- Introduction of Performance Cash Bonuses (2017):
- Historically provided no cash bonuses, relying on equity to conserve cash prior to GAAP profitability.
- Instituted an annual performance-based cash bonus program in 2017 for non-executive employees to rebalance compensation, reduce SBC, and match tech industry norms.
- Named Executive Officers (NEOs) remained excluded from cash bonuses to preserve long-term equity alignment; by 2019, 50% of target executive equity compensation was structured as performance-based equity.
Illustrative Accounting Journal Entries & Calculations
Stock Options Fair Value Accounting (Exhibit 6):
- Assumptions: Jan 1, 2018 grant of 400 options at fair value, exercise price, par value. 4-year linear vesting (16 quarters). Exercised Jan 1, 2022 when market price is .
- Quarterly Entry (Mar 31, 2018 – Dec 31, 2021):
- Debit: Compensation Expense (
- Credit: Paid in Capital – Stock Options
- Exercise Entry (Jan 1, 2022):
- Debit: Cash (
- Debit: Paid in Capital – Stock Options (
- Credit: Common Stock (
- Credit: Paid in Capital – Stock Options / APIC
Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) Accounting (Exhibit 7):
- Assumptions: Jan 1, 2018 grant of 100 RSUs at market price, par value. 4-year linear vesting (16 quarters).
- Net Method (Quarterly):
- Debit: Compensation Expense (
- Credit: Paid in Capital – Stock Awards
- Net Method (Vesting Date - Jan 1, 2022):
- Debit: Paid in Capital – Stock Awards
- Credit: Common Stock (
- Credit: Paid in Capital – Stock Awards / APIC
- Gross Method (Grant Date - Jan 1, 2018):
- Debit: Deferred Compensation Expense (contra-equity)
- Credit: Common Stock
- Credit: Paid in Capital – Stock Awards
- Gross Method (Quarterly):
- Debit: Compensation Expense
- Credit: Deferred Compensation Expense
EPS Impact of SBC Expense and Dilution (Exhibit 9):
- Assumptions: GAAP Net Income = ; SBC Expense = ; Net Income without SBC = ; GAAP Basic Shares = 14 million; Dilutive Equity Awards = 2 million; Diluted Shares = 16 million; Tax Rate = 0%.
- GAAP Diluted EPS =
- EPS without SBC = (Difference =
- Numerator Effect (SBC Expense per basic share) =
- Denominator Effect (Dilution on basic EPS) =
- Combined Bridge = \$1.79 + \$0.85 = \2.64 \approx \ (subject to rounding).
Financial Exhibits and Comprehensive Data
Exhibit 1: Annual Income Statements (in $ thousands, except per share data):
- Revenue:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- Cost of Revenue:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- Research & Development:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- Sales & Marketing:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- General & Administrative:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- GAAP Net Loss:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- Non-GAAP Net Income (Loss):
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
- Adjusted EBITDA:
- 2013:
- 2014:
- 2015:
- 2016:
- 2017:
Exhibit 2: Balance Sheet Highlights (in $ thousands):
- Cash & Cash Equivalents (2017):
- Short-Term Investments (2017):
- Property & Equipment, net (2017):
- Total Assets (2017):
- Convertible Notes (2017):
- Total Liabilities (2017):
- Total Stockholders' Equity (2017):
Exhibit 3: Operating Data & SBC Breakdown (in $ thousands):
- Monthly Active Users (2017 Total): (US: 68 million; International: 262 million).
- Stock-Based Compensation Expense by Function:
- Cost of Revenue: 2013 = ; 2014 = ; 2015 = ; 2016 = ; 2017 =
- Research & Development: 2013 = ; 2014 = ; 2015 = ; 2016 = ; 2017 =
- Sales & Marketing: 2013 = ; 2014 = ; 2015 = ; 2016 = ; 2017 =
- General & Administrative: 2013 = ; 2014 = ; 2015 = ; 2016 = ; 2017 =
- Total SBC Expense: 2013 = ; 2014 = ; 2015 = ; 2016 = ; 2017 =
Exhibit 8: ESPP Prevalence by Industry (FW Cook 2017):
- Information Technology: 70% overall (75% Small Cap, 55% Mid Cap, 80% Large Cap).
- Consumer Discretionary: 37% overall.
- Industrials: 27% overall.
- Financials: 20% overall.
- Energy: 18% overall.
- All Industries Combined: 34% overall.
Exhibit 10: Peer SBC as % of Revenue Comparison (2015–2017):
- Twitter: 2015 = 31%; 2016 = 24%; 2017 = 18%
- Amazon: 2015 = 2%; 2016 = 2%; 2017 = 2%
- Alphabet (Google): 2015 = 7%; 2016 = 7%; 2017 = 7%
- Facebook: 2015 = 17%; 2016 = 12%; 2017 = 9%
- Salesforce.com: 2015 = 11%; 2016 = 9%; 2017 = 10%
- Square: 2015 = 6%; 2016 = 8%; 2017 = 7%
- Autodesk: 2015 = 8%; 2016 = 11%; 2017 = 13%