l24-Interspecific Competition, Population Dynamics, and Life History Review
Interspecific Competition and Substrate Effects on Plant Biomass
The lecture concludes the discussion on interspecific competition, focusing on data that illustrate competition's effects on species and populations.
A specific study evaluated different plant species grown in mixed cultures within different substrates to observe how nutrient concentration affects total biomass and competitive outcomes.
Observations on Nutrient Concentrations:
All species showed an increase in total biomass as nutrient concentrations increased, benefit from the higher availability of energy.
The relative success and dominance of species changed depending on the specific nutrient levels.
Low Nutrient Concentration: Carthamis lanatus (the "purpley-blue" one) exhibited the highest biomass compared to other species.
High Nutrient Concentration: Sillybum (the yellow line) performed best, reaching the highest biomass at the upper levels of nutrient availability.
Cardus natans (the red line) performed poorly across the board, being the least abundant or simply smaller in size.
This example mirrors the previous trout example, illustrating that abiotic conditions (like nutrient levels or temperature) determine which species are most capable of outcompeting others.
The Competitive Exclusion Principle and Niche Theory
Species cannot coexist when they perfectly overlap in their fundamental niches. If niches overlap, species must "split the difference," or one will outcompete the other.
Realized Niches: These are the actual conditions species occupy in the presence of competition, often representing a shift or contraction from the fundamental niche.
Competitive Exclusion: The idea that complete competitors cannot coexist indefinitely if they are not plastic enough to shift their needs. One species will eventually win completely.
Case Study: Gray Wolves and Coyotes in North America
Gray Wolves: Enormous social animals that utilize pack-hunting behaviors. Historically, they ranged across almost all of North America.
Coyotes: Somewhat social but smaller than wolves. Historically, they were restricted largely to the Rockies and the Intermountain West.
European settlement led to the extirpation and hunting of gray wolves across non-mountainous regions, particularly the East Coast.
Loss of the Gray Wolf allowed Coyotes to colonize the East Coast and even urban environments like New York City, filling the vacant niche left by wolves.
Resource Partitioning and Evolutionary Speciation
Coexistence typically occurs through the splitting of realized niches, which can lead to long-term evolutionary changes and speciation.
Partitioning: Species shift how or where they utilize resources to minimize direct competition.
Case Study: Warblers
Warblers are a classic study of recent evolutionary radiation species.
They are foliage-leaning insectivores that eat insects off leaves.
While a common ancestor likely foraged throughout entire trees, modern species have specialized in different sections of the tree (e.g., some forage only at the top, some in the middle, some at the bottom).
This specialization allows them to avoid intense competition.
Case Study: Chipmunks in the Sierra Nevadas
Four species of chipmunks live on the Eastern slopes of the Sierra Nevadas in California.
They have heavily overlapping food requirements but live in distinct elevational zones (high vs. low elevation).
This spatial partitioning avoids direct competition.
Lotka-Volterra Competition Equations and Coefficients
Competition Coefficients ( and ) quantify the impact of one species on another. These coefficients account for factors like food consumption, body mass, and behavioral exclusion.
Mathematical Model for Species 1:
Example Calculation: Big Antelope (Species 1) and Little Antelope (Species 2)
Species 2 is half the mass and eats half as much as Species 1.
(the impact of one individual of Species 2 on Species 1).
(the impact of one individual of Species 1 on Species 2, because it consumes twice as much).
Step-by-step Math for Species 1 Growth Rate:
Calculate :
Calculate effective density:
Calculate the remaining capacity:
Multiply by intrinsic growth:
Final Growth Rate:
Carrying Capacity Adjustments:
If Species 2 is half the size, the environment can sustain twice as many of them compared to Species 1. Therefore, if , then .
The Allee Effect and Negative Density Dependence
Standard Density Dependence: Fitness per individual decreases as density increases due to competition for resources.
Allee Effect: A phenomenon where, at very small population sizes, fitness actually increases as the population grows (positive density dependence at low density).
Biological Mechanisms:
Vigilance: Individuals share the load of looking for predators (e.g., Vancouver Island Marmot).
Thermal Regulation: Individuals need each other for warmth (e.g., Monarch butterflies huddling in winter).
Social Interactions: Altruistic behaviors, nest helping, and pack hunting (e.g., lions and wolves).
Case Study: Vancouver Island Marmot
Endangered species that hibernates and needs fat reserves to survive winter.
At low numbers, individuals spend too much time watching for predators instead of eating.
This leads to insufficient fat storage, shorter hibernation, lower survival, and increased predation risk.
General Examples: Schooling fish, herds of zebras, and penguin colonies benefit from "safety in numbers."
Life History Tables and Demographic Math
Life Table Definitions:
: Age class (0, 1, 2, 3, etc.).
: Number of individuals in the cohort still alive at age .
: Survivorship; the proportion of the original cohort still alive at age ().
: Age-specific mortality rate.
: Average birth rate per individual in that age class.
Reproductive Rates:
Gross Reproductive Rate: The average total number of offspring a female would have if she survived through her entire possible lifespan ().
Net Reproductive Rate (): The average number of females produced by a newborn female during her lifetime, accounting for mortality rates ().
Population Projection Calculation (Squirrel Example):
Initial Population: 20 Juveniles (), 10 One-year-olds ().
Survival Probability: 30% for juveniles survive to age 1 (); 50% for age 1 survive to age 2 ().
Fecundity (): Age-1 individuals produce 2 pups; Age-2 individuals produce 3 pups.
Step 1: Calculate Survivors for Next Year:
(new One-year-olds).
(new Two-year-olds).
Step 2: Calculate New Births:
.
.
Step 3: Total Population Calculation:
Survivors + New Births = .
Questions & Discussion
Question on Competition Coefficients: Do they take into account resources that one species prevents another from using?
Response: Yes. While simplified examples often look at food and mass, and incorporate behavioral exclusion and other interactions. If growth rates and carrying capacities are known, these coefficients can be back-calculated.
Question on Parasite Definitions: What is the difference between a parasite and a pathogen?
Response: Parasites rely on a specific organism for part of their life cycle, remain on/in the host, and cause negative effects (unlike commensal barnacles). Pathogens specifically describe the agent causing disease and a physiological response (making the host "sick").
Question on Host Recovery Time: How is the recovery time of a host quantified?
Response: It is measured through field-based data, observing how long a host shows signs of disease and how long they are "shedding" the virus or pathogen. It varies by species (e.g., a cold vs. the flu).
Exam Strategy Advice:
The test includes multiple-choice and short-answer questions.
For math questions: Type out the steps and define the terms. Partial credit is awarded if the setup is correct even if the final calculation is wrong.
Do not write essays for short-answer questions; keep responses concise and specific to the question asked.