Advanced Financial Accounting: Step Acquisitions, NCI, and Goodwill
Overview of Step Acquisitions, NCI, and Goodwill
- A step acquisition occurs in a business combination when an investor already owns a pre-existing interest in an investee and subsequently purchases additional shares until control is obtained.
- The transition of investment nature follows specific thresholds and accounting standards:
- 0% to 20%: Classified as a passive investment under PFRS 9.
- 20% to 50%: Classified as significant influence or joint control under PAS 28 or PFRS 11.
- 50% to 100%: Classified as control under PFRS 10 and PFRS 3.
- Example transition scenario: An investor holds a 15% passive investment and purchases an additional 60% interest, resulting in a 75% controlling interest.
- The fundamental rule for step acquisitions is that when the nature of the investment changes because control is obtained, the previously held interest must be remeasured at its acquisition-date fair value.
Learning Objectives and Strategic Focus
- Identification of step acquisitions and the specific point when an investment shifts from passive or influential to a controlling interest.
- Computation of the acquisition-date fair value of identifiable net assets.
- Calculation of goodwill and Non-Controlling Interest (NCI) using both the partial-goodwill approach (proportionate basis) and the full-goodwill approach (fair value basis).
- Understanding the "deemed sale and deemed purchase" conceptual framework when control is achieved in stages.
- Accounting for the remeasurement of previously held interests classified as Fair Value Through Other Comprehensive Income (FVOCI), Fair Value Through Profit or Loss (FVTPL), or those previously treated as associates/joint ventures.
Measurement of Identifiable Net Assets
- Before calculating goodwill, the acquiree’s identifiable assets and liabilities must be adjusted to their acquisition-date fair values.
- The formula for the fair value of net assets is:
Fair Value (FV) of Net Assets=FV of Identifiable Assets−FV of Liabilities
- Taking the Pares and Serap case as an example:
- Book value of identifiable assets: ₱3,900,000
- Book/Fair value of liabilities: ₱1,900,000
- Book value of net assets: ₱2,000,000
- Fair value of identifiable assets: ₱5,100,000
- Calculated Fair value of net assets: ₱5,100,000−₱1,900,000=₱3,200,000
- The resulting fair-value step-up is ₱1,200,000 (calculated as ₱3,200,000−₱2,000,000), which must be reflected before determining residual goodwill.
Remeasurement of Previously Held Interests
- The fair value of the initial interest is often implied by the purchase price of the additional controlling block.
- Calculation process using the Pares case (where a 60% interest was purchased for ₱2,160,000):
- Implied total fair value of the company (100%): 60%₱2,160,000=₱3,600,000
- Fair value of the previous 15% interest: ₱3,600,000×15%=₱540,000
- Teaching Point: The original cost (e.g., ₱500,000) is not used in the goodwill calculation. Only the remeasured fair value of ₱540,000 at the control date is used.
Partial-Goodwill Approach (Proportionate Basis)
- Under the partial-goodwill approach, goodwill is recognized only for the parent's portion, and the NCI is measured based on its proportionate share of the acquiree's identifiable net assets.
- Computation for Pares (75% ownership):
- Consideration transferred (60%): ₱2,160,000
- Fair value of previous interest (15%): ₱540,000
- Total fair value attributed to the 75% ownership: ₱2,700,000
- Less: Parent's share (75%) of FV of net assets (₱3,200,000×75%): ₱2,400,000
- Partial goodwill: ₱300,000
- Non-Controlling Interest (25%) calculation under this approach:
- Identifiable Net Assets (100%): ₱3,200,000
- NCI Share: ₱3,200,000×25%=₱800,000
- Important Note: If a problem specifies the "proportionate share of identifiable net assets," the partial-goodwill method is required.
Full-Goodwill Approach (Fair Value Basis)
- Under full goodwill, NCI is measured at fair value, and goodwill includes portions attributable to both controlling and non-controlling shareholders.
- Computation for Pares/Serap:
- Consideration transferred (60%): ₱2,160,000
- Fair value of previous interest (15%): ₱540,000
- Fair value of NCI (25%): ₱900,000
- Total fair value of the acquiree (100%): ₱3,600,000
- Less: Total Fair Value of identifiable net assets: ₱3,200,000
- Full goodwill: ₱400,000
- Comparative difference in NCI:
- Full NCI equals Partial NCI (₱800,000) plus the NCI's share of goodwill (₱100,000), totaling ₱900,000.
- Goodwill difference: Full goodwill (₱400,000) minus Partial goodwill (₱300,000) equals ₱100,000, representing the NCI share of goodwill.
Conceptual Interpretation: Deemed Sale and Purchase
- Acquiring additional shares that lead to control terminates the old accounting basis and initiates a new control-based relationship.
- Old Interest Treatment: The existing investment is measured under its previous standard until the moment control is achieved.
- Remeasurement: The prior interest is brought to its acquisition-date fair value.
- New Relationship: The new controlling investment/subsidiary relationship is recognized.
- Conceptual Framework: This is interpreted as a "deemed sale" of the old interest at fair value followed by a "deemed purchase" of the new controlling interest at fair value.
Accounting for the Remeasurement Gain or Loss
- If the previous interest was FVOCI (Fair Value Through Other Comprehensive Income):
- Interest is remeasured to acquisition-date fair value.
- The gain or loss is recognized in Other Comprehensive Income (OCI).
- Under equity-investment treatment, accumulated OCI gains/losses are not recycled to profit or loss but may be transferred within equity.
- Example: ₱540,000 (FV)−₱500,000 (Carrying Amount)=₱40,000 OCI gain.
- If the previous interest was FVTPL (Fair Value Through Profit or Loss):
- Interest is remeasured to acquisition-date fair value.
- The remeasurement gain or loss is recognized directly in profit or loss, affecting current net income.
- If the previous interest was an Associate or Joint Venture (PAS 28 / PFRS 11):
- Determine the carrying amount under the equity method immediately before control is achieved.
- Remeasure the interest to its acquisition-date fair value.
- Recognize the difference as a gain or loss in profit or loss.
- Example: If an associate with a carrying amount of ₱700,000 has a fair value of ₱760,000 at the date control is achieved, a ₱60,000 gain is recognized in profit or loss.
Illustrative Journal Entry
- For the Pares and Serap example where the prior interest was FVOCI and control was achieved:
- Total Controlling Investment recognized: ₱2,700,000 (₱2,160,000 new cash + ₱540,000 fair value of old interest).
- Debit: Investment in Subsidiary / Controlled Entity: ₱2,700,000
- Credit: Previous FVOCI investment: ₱500,000
- Credit: Cash: ₱2,160,000
- Credit: OCI — Gain on remeasurement: ₱40,000
Summary Sequence for Solving Step Acquisitions
- Step 1: Identify the specific date control is obtained.
- Step 2: Measure identifiable net assets at acquisition-date fair value (FV assets−FV liabilities).
- Step 3: Remeasure the previously held interest to its acquisition-date fair value.
- Step 4: Identify or choose the NCI measurement method: fair value (full) or proportionate (partial).
- Step 5: Compute goodwill or recognize a bargain purchase.
- Step 6: Recognize the appropriate remeasurement gain or loss based on the prior investment's classification (OCI vs. Profit or Loss).
Questions & Discussion
- Question: A company owns 15% of an investee and later buys 60% more. What type of transaction is this?
- Answer: This is a step acquisition.
- Question: Why is the previous 15% interest measured at fair value when control is achieved?
- Answer: The remeasurement reflects the new control-date basis for the investment.
- Question: In the Pares–Serap example, what is the fair value of the prior 15% interest?
- Answer: The fair value is ₱540,000.
- Question: What is partial goodwill? What is full goodwill?
- Answer: Partial goodwill includes only the portion belonging to the parent. Full goodwill includes both the parent and NCI portions of goodwill.
- Question: Where is the remeasurement gain recognized if the old interest was FVOCI? What if it was FVTPL?
- Answer: For FVOCI, the gain is in Other Comprehensive Income (OCI). For FVTPL, the gain is recognized in profit or loss.