Errors in Measurement: Relative Error and Percentage Error

Measurement Error Fundamentals and Mathematical Definitions

  • Measurement errors occur inherently in all empirical observations due to limitations in measuring instruments, human reading precision, and experimental constraints.

  • Two primary categories exist for defining and evaluating measurement inaccuracy depending on whether the true value of the measured object is known:

    • Case 1 (Actual value is known): The precise reference value of the quantity is available, allowing exact determination of error relative to reality.

    • Case 2 (Actual value is not known): Only an empirical measurement from an instrument is available, requiring the evaluation of potential error boundaries based on the instrument's smallest division.

  • Absolute error represents the magnitude of the difference between an actual value and a measured value:

    • Applied when the actual true value is known.

    • Retains the exact same physical unit of measurement as the quantity being measured.

  • Maximum absolute error represents the maximum possible discrepancy between the true value and the value recorded by an instrument:

    • Equal to half of the smallest scale interval (precision unit) of the measuring device:     Maximum absolute error=scale interval2\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{\text{scale interval}}{2}

    • Applied when the true actual value is unknown.

    • Retains the same unit of measurement as the measured value.

Relative Error Principles and Formulations

  • Relative error is a dimensionless metric representing the proportion of error relative to the total size of the quantity measured.

  • Mathematical formulation when the actual value is known:   Relative error=absolute erroractual value\text{Relative error} = \frac{\text{absolute error}}{\text{actual value}}

    • Example calculation:

    • Given actual value = 25 cm25\,\text{cm}, absolute error = 5 cm5\,\text{cm}

    • Application:       Relative error=5 cm25 cm=0.2\text{Relative error} = \frac{5\,\text{cm}}{25\,\text{cm}} = 0.2

  • Mathematical formulation when the actual value is not known:   Relative error=maximum absolute errormeasured value\text{Relative error} = \frac{\text{maximum absolute error}}{\text{measured value}}

    • Example calculation:

    • Given measured value = 250 g250\,\text{g}, maximum absolute error = 1 g1\,\text{g}

    • Application:       Relative error=1 g250 g=0.004\text{Relative error} = \frac{1\,\text{g}}{250\,\text{g}} = 0.004

  • Essential properties of relative error:

    • Relative error has no units (it is a pure dimensionless scalar) because identical units in the numerator and denominator cancel out.

    • A smaller relative error indicates a more accurate measured value.

    • Relative error normalizes measurement discrepancy across different scales and magnitudes, enabling direct comparisons between different measuring instruments and quantities.

Worked Problems on Relative Error

  • Problem 1: Comparison of Measured Values with Known Reference Values

    • Given specifications:

    • Measured value AA: Actual value = 32 s32\,\text{s}, Absolute error = 0.2 s0.2\,\text{s}

    • Measured value BB: Actual value = 75 s75\,\text{s}, Absolute error = 0.3 s0.3\,\text{s}

    • Part (a)(i) Solution for measured value AA:     Relative error of A=0.2 s32 s=0.00625\text{Relative error of } A = \frac{0.2\,\text{s}}{32\,\text{s}} = 0.00625

    • Part (a)(ii) Solution for measured value BB:     Relative error of B=0.3 s75 s=0.004\text{Relative error of } B = \frac{0.3\,\text{s}}{75\,\text{s}} = 0.004

    • Part (b) Comparative accuracy determination:

    • Comparing numerical magnitudes: 0.004<0.006250.004 < 0.00625

    • Measured value BB is more accurate than measured value AA because its relative error is smaller, despite BB having a larger absolute error (0.3 s0.3\,\text{s} versus 0.2 s0.2\,\text{s}).

  • Problem 2: Measurement Tools of Differing Precision

    • Context: Two surveyors measure the height of a building, and both report a measured height of 125 m125\,\text{m}.

    • Surveyor AA employs a measuring tool correct to the nearest 5 m5\,\text{m}.

    • Surveyor BB employs a measuring tool correct to the nearest  m\,\text{m} (1 m1\,\text{m}).

    • Part (a) Analysis for Surveyor AA:

    • Maximum absolute error:       Maximum absolute error=5 m2=2.5 m\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{5\,\text{m}}{2} = 2.5\,\text{m}

    • Relative error:       Relative error=2.5 m125 m=0.02\text{Relative error} = \frac{2.5\,\text{m}}{125\,\text{m}} = 0.02

    • Part (b) Analysis for Surveyor BB:

    • Maximum absolute error:       Maximum absolute error=1 m2=0.5 m\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{1\,\text{m}}{2} = 0.5\,\text{m}

    • Relative error:       Relative error=0.5 m125 m=0.004\text{Relative error} = \frac{0.5\,\text{m}}{125\,\text{m}} = 0.004

  • Problem 3: Graduated Measuring Cup Error Analysis

Graduated measuring cup filled with juice to the 600 mL mark
  • Part (a) Measured volume reading:

    • The liquid meniscus levels exactly at the line labeled 600 mL600\,\text{mL}.

    • Measured volume = 600 mL600\,\text{mL}

  • Part (b) Calculation of relative error (to 3 significant figures):

    • Smallest scale interval on the cup = 100 mL100\,\text{mL}

    • Maximum absolute error:     Maximum absolute error=100 mL2=50 mL\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{100\,\text{mL}}{2} = 50\,\text{mL}

    • Relative error computation:     Relative error=50 mL600 mL=112≈0.0833\text{Relative error} = \frac{50\,\text{mL}}{600\,\text{mL}} = \frac{1}{12} \approx 0.0833

    • Relative error to 3 significant figures = 0.08330.0833

Percentage Error Principles and Formulations

  • Percentage error expresses the relative error in the form of a percentage.

  • Core relationship:   Percentage error=relative error×100%\text{Percentage error} = \text{relative error} \times 100\%

  • Formulation when the actual value is known:   Percentage error=absolute erroractual value×100%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{\text{absolute error}}{\text{actual value}} \times 100\%

    • Example calculation:

    • Given actual value = 25 cm25\,\text{cm}, absolute error = 5 cm5\,\text{cm}

    • Application:       Percentage error=5 cm25 cm×100%=20%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{5\,\text{cm}}{25\,\text{cm}} \times 100\% = 20\%

  • Formulation when the actual value is not known:   Percentage error=maximum absolute errormeasured value×100%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{\text{maximum absolute error}}{\text{measured value}} \times 100\%

  • Essential properties of percentage error:

    • A smaller percentage error indicates a more accurate measured value.

    • Serves as a standard metric in scientific and engineering reporting to evaluate measurement tolerance and reliability.

Worked Problems on Percentage Error

  • Problem 4: Comparative Accuracy with Known Reference Values

    • Given specifications:

    • Measured value PP: Actual value = 15 kg15\,\text{kg}, Absolute error = 3 kg3\,\text{kg}

    • Measured value QQ: Actual value = 40 kg40\,\text{kg}, Absolute error = 6 kg6\,\text{kg}

    • Part (a)(i) Percentage error of measured value PP:     Percentage error of P=3 kg15 kg×100%=20%\text{Percentage error of } P = \frac{3\,\text{kg}}{15\,\text{kg}} \times 100\% = 20\%

    • Part (a)(ii) Percentage error of measured value QQ:     Percentage error of Q=6 kg40 kg×100%=15%\text{Percentage error of } Q = \frac{6\,\text{kg}}{40\,\text{kg}} \times 100\% = 15\%

    • Part (b) Accuracy comparison:

    • Comparison of percentage values: 15%<20%15\% < 20\%

    • Measured value QQ is more accurate than measured value PP because it yields a smaller percentage error, demonstrating that larger absolute deviations can still be more accurate if the total quantity being measured is substantially larger.

  • Problem 5: Table Length Measurements with Differing Degrees of Precision

    • Measurement by Gary:

    • Measured length = 82.4 cm82.4\,\text{cm}

    • Stated precision: Correct to the nearest 0.1 cm0.1\,\text{cm}

    • Maximum absolute error:       Maximum absolute error=0.1 cm2=0.05 cm\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{0.1\,\text{cm}}{2} = 0.05\,\text{cm}

    • Percentage error calculation:       Percentage error=0.05 cm82.4 cm×100%≈0.0606796%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{0.05\,\text{cm}}{82.4\,\text{cm}} \times 100\% \approx 0.0606796\%

    • Correct to 3 significant figures: 0.0607%0.0607\%

    • Measurement by Sally:

    • Measured length = 82 cm82\,\text{cm}

    • Stated precision: Correct to the nearest 2 cm2\,\text{cm}

    • Maximum absolute error:       Maximum absolute error=2 cm2=1 cm\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{2\,\text{cm}}{2} = 1\,\text{cm}

    • Percentage error calculation:       Percentage error=1 cm82 cm×100%≈1.2195%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{1\,\text{cm}}{82\,\text{cm}} \times 100\% \approx 1.2195\%

    • Correct to 3 significant figures: 1.22%1.22\%

  • Problem 6: Analog Dial Scale Measurement

Mechanical dial scale measuring bananas with pointer at 2.6 kg
  • Part (a) Measured weight determination:

    • Inspection of dial face: The dial spans 0 kg0\,\text{kg} to 3 kg3\,\text{kg}.

    • The interval between each consecutive whole kilogram mark (1 kg1\,\text{kg}) is divided into 55 equal divisions.

    • Weight per subdivision:     Scale division=1 kg5=0.2 kg\text{Scale division} = \frac{1\,\text{kg}}{5} = 0.2\,\text{kg}

    • The pointer sits 33 divisions past the 2 kg2\,\text{kg} graduation mark:     Measured weight=2 kg+(3×0.2 kg)=2.6 kg\text{Measured weight} = 2\,\text{kg} + (3 \times 0.2\,\text{kg}) = 2.6\,\text{kg}

  • Part (b) Percentage error calculation (to 3 significant figures):

    • Maximum absolute error calculation:     Maximum absolute error=0.2 kg2=0.1 kg\text{Maximum absolute error} = \frac{0.2\,\text{kg}}{2} = 0.1\,\text{kg}

    • Percentage error formulation:     Percentage error=0.1 kg2.6 kg×100%=126×100%≈3.846%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{0.1\,\text{kg}}{2.6\,\text{kg}} \times 100\% = \frac{1}{26} \times 100\% \approx 3.846\%

    • Correct to 3 significant figures: 3.85%3.85\%

Advanced Applications and Reverse Error Calculations

  • Problem 7: Determining Absolute Error and Range from Percentage Error Limits

    • Context: The height of a tower is measured as 200 m200\,\text{m}, with an associated percentage error of 5%5\%.

    • Part (a) Finding the maximum absolute error:

    • Percentage error formula setup:       Percentage error=maximum absolute errormeasured value×100%\text{Percentage error} = \frac{\text{maximum absolute error}}{\text{measured value}} \times 100\%       5%=maximum absolute error200 m×100%5\% = \frac{\text{maximum absolute error}}{200\,\text{m}} \times 100\%

    • Isolation of maximum absolute error:       maximum absolute error200 m=0.05\frac{\text{maximum absolute error}}{200\,\text{m}} = 0.05       Maximum absolute error=0.05×200 m=10 m\text{Maximum absolute error} = 0.05 \times 200\,\text{m} = 10\,\text{m}

    • Part (b) Finding the range of the actual height of the tower:

    • Relation for actual value boundaries:       Actual value=measured value±maximum absolute error\text{Actual value} = \text{measured value} \pm \text{maximum absolute error}

    • Lower bound calculation:       Lower limit=200 m−10 m=190 m\text{Lower limit} = 200\,\text{m} - 10\,\text{m} = 190\,\text{m}

    • Upper bound calculation:       Upper limit=200 m+10 m=210 m\text{Upper limit} = 200\,\text{m} + 10\,\text{m} = 210\,\text{m}

    • Formal range representations:

      • Inequality format:         190 m≤actual height≤210 m190\,\text{m} \le \text{actual height} \le 210\,\text{m}

      • Interval descriptor: From 190 m190\,\text{m} to 210 m210\,\text{m}