Study Notes on Evaluating IEPs and 504 Plans for Students with ADHD
Evaluating the Content of Individualized Education Programs and 504 Plans of Young Adolescents with Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder
Purpose and Importance of the Study
- Evaluated how well Individualized Education Programs (IEPs) and 504 Plans for middle school students with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) align with best practices and include evidence-based services.
- Examined statement of students' present level of academic achievement and functional performance (PLAAFP) and students' measurable annual goals and objectives (MAGOs).
- Compared services in these plans with recommendations from the U.S. Department of Education (ED) and reviews of evidence-based practices.
Background
ADHD and Educational Support
- ADHD affects approximately 8.8% of the youth population (Visser et al., 2014).
- Students with ADHD show significant academic impairments: poor grades, incomplete assignments, high rates of course failure (Barkley et al., 2006; Kent et al., 2011).
- High costs: The annual cost of educating a student with ADHD is estimated at 5,007 more than a student without ADHD (Robb et al., 2011).
- Various laws provide for educational services for students with ADHD including IDEIA and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.
Differentiation between IDEIA and Section 504
- IDEIA focuses on ensuring a free and appropriate public education for children with disabilities, stipulating individualized services documented in an IEP.
- Section 504 is a civil rights law promoting full participation for individuals with disabilities in federally funded institutions, with less stringent requirements for documentation.
Research Design and Methodology
Participants
- Study included 97 middle school students
- 61.9% had IEPs
- 38.1% had 504 Plans
- Recruitment occurred over three academic years across nine schools.
Data Collection
- PLAAFP and MAGO sections of IEPs were coded using a cutting and sorting technique to categorize important themes, ensuring a thorough examination of needs and services outlined in the documents.
Coding Procedures
- Coding Results:
- Identified 10 themes for academic/behavioral concerns in PLAAFP and MAGOs.
- Interrater Agreement for PLAAFP: 83.6%; MAGO: 96.1%.
Key Findings
Academic and Behavioral Deficits Identified in IEPs
- PLAAFPs indicated:
- 90.9% diagnosed with academic concerns.
- 84.8% diagnosed with nonacademic/behavioral concerns. - MAGOs: Less than 47% contained goals addressing nonacademic/behavioral issues.
Comparison between IEP and 504 Plan Services
- Students with IEPs typically received more extensive services:
- More services regarding behavioral modification, individualized supports, and resource allocations.
- Services such as extended time and one-on-one interventions were more prevalent in IEPs than 504 Plans. - IEPs: 25.8% included behavior modification, while 80.3% included extended time despite mixed research results on its effectiveness.
Analysis of Research-Based Services
- Importance of Research-Based Services:
- Services should ideally be aligned with peer-reviewed research to ensure their effectiveness.
- Only 16.6% of the services in the study were established as research-based.
- High percentage (88%) of services listed matched those recommended by ED, but many lacked solid effectiveness evidence.
Implications for Policy and Practice
- Findings indicate that IEP teams struggle to provide need-based, effective interventions for students with ADHD.
- The high discrepancy between recommended services and those actually employed raises concerns over adherence to federal mandates for research-based practices.
Limitations of the Study
- The sample from specific schools may not generalize to other settings.
- Information about the disability categories for students was not collected, which could affect understanding service quality.
- Future studies needed to assess broader samples and ensure comprehensive data collection.
Recommendations for Future Research
- Reevaluate the ED service recommendations to enhance their relevancy to existing research.
- Investigate the effectiveness of frequently used services that currently lack research backing, prioritizing better services for student outcomes.