Critical Reflection and the STAR Approach Study Notes

Tutorial Administration and Module Objectives

  • Course and Context: 1011PSY Tutorial 2, Week 4, Griffith University.

  • Online Workbooks: Students are instructed to access workbooks via the "Resources" tab in PebblePad.     - Historical data indicates that completing the Online Workbook significantly enhances content understanding.     - Completion directly improves performance on the scenario-based questions in the final examination.

  • Tutorial Aims:     - Reviewing reflective thinking and writing practices.     - Engaging in critical thinking exercises.     - Developing skills in writing evidence for attributes and skills using the STAR approach.

Reflective Thinking and Writing

  • Definition of Reflection: Conceptualized as an analysis of an event, including the "FAST EVENT" acronym or framework.

  • Reflective Practice Case Study: "The Park" (Version 1):     - Scenario: A narrator visits a park on a hot day, notices a child around 10 years old wearing too many clothes. The child struggles to keep up with others, falls, and eventually lies in a half-sitting/half-lying position calling out to others.     - Narrator Perspective: The narrator passes by quickly, preoccupied with personal tasks (buying fresh chili peppers for a party for their twins).     - The Next Day: A newspaper report reveals the child was taken seriously ill and is fighting for his life due to a delay in hospital transport. The article is titled "Why do they 'Walk on by'?" and critiques the lack of action from passers-by.

  • Reflective Practice Case Study: "The Park" (Version 4):     - Perspective Shift: The narrator initially interprets the child's behavior as "faking it" or "play-acting" and "manipulation" because they believe the children are a "gang of bullies" who have bothered their own children (Charlie).     - Emotional Frame of Mind: The narrator identifies that a breakfast conversation about bullying had primed them to see the children negatively.     - Transformation of Reflection: A year later, the narrator realizes their emotional state distorted their perception.     - Critical Self-Inquiry: The narrator asks: "What mechanism could I have used in order to see if there were any other ways of construing it?" and "How can I know that my perceptions in respect of some event are not distorted?"

  • Reflective Analysis Questions:     - Identify key points the writer makes in each version.     - Pinpoint specific areas of analysis within the reflection.     - Assess the quality of the reflection.     - Determine which version is "most reflective" based on the level of self-interrogation and perspective-taking.

Practical Framework for Reflective Writing

  • Guidance Questions:     - What were your thoughts and feelings at the time and since then?     - What was positive, negative, effective, or not effective about the experience?     - Why was a specific action or approach chosen?     - Which theories explain or challenge the understanding of the experience?     - How could the situation be interpreted differently?     - What was learned, and did it affirm or challenge existing understandings?     - How will this knowledge guide future actions in professional practice?

  • Note for Assessments: For Assignments 1 and 2, students should specifically answer the reflection questions provided in the marking criteria.

Critical Thinking Fundamentals

  • Definition (APA, 1990): "It is purposeful, reflective judgement which manifests itself in reasoned consideration of evidence, context, methods, standards, and conceptualisation in deciding what to believe or what to do."

  • Characteristics of a Critical Thinker: Continually questions the truth of statements, the source of knowledge, the presence of evidence, and the reliability of that evidence.

  • Barriers and Consequences:     - Factors such as bias, emotion, and lack of information can impede critical thinking.     - Failing to think critically can lead to negative personal and professional outcomes.

The STAR Approach for Evidencing Skills

  • S — Situation: Explain the context. Where and when did it happen? (Specific but brief).

  • T — Task: Explain the objective. What was being achieved and why?

  • A/R — Actions: Specify what YOU did and HOW you did it. Highlight specific knowledge, skills, or abilities used.

  • R — Results: Explain the outcome. Describe the accomplishments and the lessons learned.

Application: Selection Criteria Sample

  • Criterion: Demonstrated effective written and interpersonal communication skills.

  • Opening Statement: I possess strong communication skills developed through studies and work history.

  • Situation: Studying "Communication in Organisations" at Southern Cross University.

  • Task: Serving as group leader for a research assignment on "Internet Use and Plagiarism" presented to a tutorial group.

  • Action:     - Used interpersonal communication to define the topic and divide tasks.     - Negotiated workloads and assigned tasks based on team comfort levels.     - Created and distributed a timeline.     - Collated input, wrote, and edited the final report.     - Created a PowerPoint and handouts for the lecturer/students.     - Facilitated group discussion by inviting questions during the presentation.

  • Result: Awarded a Distinction. The assessor commended the "lively debate" and "high standard." Prepared for workplace tasks like report writing and client presentations.

Peer Exercises and Submission Checklist

  • Exercise 1: Write a STAR paragraph targeting "well-developed interpersonal skills" or "ability to work as part of a team."

  • Exercise 2 (Evidence as a Learner): Use STAR to describe learning something new, such as coffee making at a new job or mastering a new software system during a workplace update.

  • Peer Review Feedback Points:     - Does the STAR description convince the reader the person is an effective learner?     - What additional information is needed to strengthen the evidence?

Final Reminders

  • Assignment 1 (A1): Check the Info Sheet before submitting.

  • Week 5: Complete Worksheet 3 in the Online Workbook.

  • Consultations: Attend sessions or email staff for assistance.

  • Continuous Learning: Keep reading the Course Learning Guide and completing online modules.