Second Red Scare

American Exceptionalism and Fear

Overview of Themes (1946-1991)

  • Central themes: American Exceptionalism and Fear

  • Focus on the Second Red Scare


Fear of Communism Post-WWII

  • Continued fear about communism stemming from the Cold War.

  • Political cartoons and their implications regarding societal anxieties around communism.

  • Comparison to calling wolf: The legitimacy of concerns about communist infiltration.

Societal Impact
  • Fear gripped American society, affecting both domestic politics and international relations.

  • Communism is viewed as both an international threat and a domestic issue.

  • The sacrifice of civil liberties for national security was a recurring theme throughout American history (e.g., Japanese internment).

  • Immigration from Europe


Government Response to Communism

Formation of HUAC (House of Un-American Activities Committee)
  • Established in 1938 to investigate allegations of communist and fascist activities.

  • Extended investigations to various groups labeled as the political left.

  • Significance increased after 1947 due to high-profile hearings.

Claims of Infiltration
  • Allegations of communist infiltration into essential sectors: government, schools, and entertainment industries.

  • George Keenan: Feared the political left would be used to convert the U.S. to communism.

  • Similar discussions to those during the First Red Scare, following World War I.

  • 1938: Investigate Communist and Fascist Organizations

The Truman Doctrine and Containment (1947)
  • Laid the foundational American foreign policy regarding the Cold War and the strategy to contain communism.

  • Enabled HUAC to target anyone deemed un-American—including civil rights discussions, equality initiatives, and governmental complaints.

Controversial Tactics of HUAC
  • Ferret out suspected communists

  • Use of subpoenas, hearings, and public interrogations to press individuals about their political affiliations.

  • Direct pressure on subpoenaed individuals to name others involved in communist activities.

  • Pleading the Fifth Amendment led to adverse inferences regarding guilt.

  • Consequences of HUAC Investigations:

    • Significant negative impacts on the lives of those called before HUAC.

    • Careers ruined, blacklisted individuals found it difficult to secure employment.

    • Organizations like the NAACP distanced themselves from those targeted by HUAC due to fear of guilt by association.


Focus on Hollywood

The Red Channels Pamphlet
  • Claimed that the motion picture industry harbored communists seeking to spread propaganda.

  • HUAC used this to justify major investigations of Hollywood figures in the 1950s.

The Hollywood 10

  • A group of 10 actors, writers, and directors who refused to cooperate with HUAC.

  • Pleaded the Fifth to protect their interests and criticized HUAC’s methods during hearings.

  • Resulted in contempt charges and prison sentences for all 10.

Resulting Fallout
  • Many in Hollywood were blacklisted without evidence, leading to career destruction.

  • Major studios remained silent against these unconstitutional tactics.


Notable Cases

  • Alger Hiss: High-ranking State Department official convicted of perjury related to espionage for the Soviet Union.

  • Hiss consistently claimed his innocence.

Public Backlash Against HUAC
  • Criticism from various factions, including protests highlighting violations of citizens' constitutional rights.

  • Argument that HUAC tactics infringed on the First Amendment rights of free speech and political opinion.


Joseph McCarthy and His Tactics

  • Senator Joseph McCarthy: A central figure during the Red Scare who leveraged the fear of communism for political gain.

  • As his re-election campaign approached, he exaggerated claims about communist ties among government officials to gain support.

  • McCarthyism: a term used to describe the harassment and persecution of suspected political radicals.

  • HUAC served as a blueprint for McCarthy’s tactics

  • Fueled anti-communist hysteria

The Army-McCarthy Hearings (1954)
  • McCarthy's overreach with the U.S. Army led to his downfall.

  • The media played a critical role in bringing unethical tactics and abuse of power to public attention, resulting in his censure by Congress.

End of McCarthy's Political Career
  • While McCarthy was censured, the damage inflicted upon numerous individuals was irreversible.


Legacy of the Red Scare

  • Fear of communism persisted notably even in post-Red Scare America (e.g., societal fears present in the 1990s).

  • Discussion around the lasting impact of fear tactics and government overreach during this era.


Conclusion

  • This lecture concluded the discussion on the Second Red Scare, with plans to address the Cold War structure, culture, and nuclear strategy in subsequent sessions.

  • Emphasis on understanding domestic policies and their political repercussions in the following modules.

  • Invitation for questions and engagement with the course material.