Chicago School Theorists and Social Disorganization

Theoretical Foundations of the Chicago School

  • Researchers associated with the Chicago school were deeply fascinated by the emergence of urban centers.
  • Their work focused on the significant and new role urban centers played in American social life.
  • A central concern for these theorists was the ability of both communities and individuals to sustain themselves.
  • This sustainment was particularly scrutinized within contexts specifically defined by the condition of disorganization.
  • Theorists were instrumental in identifying what a city or a community could not provide to its inhabitants.
  • By identifying these gaps, they opened up new possibilities for criminologists to consider alternatives to formal social control.
  • A key focus was on helping the most troubled neighborhoods develop a capacity for collective action.
  • Another primary goal was to assist these communities in the achievement of specific community goals.

The Search for the Common Good and Community Organizing

  • At the very heart of the Chicago school's work is a philosophical and practical question regarding the absence of shared values.
  • The researchers investigated what occurs in settings where the idea of a "public good" or a "common good" has been lost or discarded.
  • Because of this focus, significant efforts were directed toward activities that would be categorized today as community organizing.
  • Social disorganization scholars throughout history have shared a fundamental assumption regarding reform:
    • Improvement in social conditions is central to the reform process.
    • Social conditions are the primary drivers of action, process, and change.

Inequality, Poverty, and the Recourse to Crime

  • The absence of resources creates a vacuum that influences human behavior.
  • This lack of resources is most prominent in contexts defined by:
    • Durable poverty.
    • Persistent inequality.
  • The theorists posited that when the city cannot or will not provide for its citizens, actors are forced to look elsewhere.
  • Crime is identified as one of the alternative ways through which individuals organize their lives and create opportunities for themselves.

Historical Context: Migration and Urban Alienation

  • Theories linking crime to urban disorganization did not emerge in a vacuum; they developed against a specific historical backdrop.
  • They were informed by the experiences of two primary groups during the birth of the American city:
    • Migrants.
    • Immigrants.
  • The central themes of this development were the isolation and alienation experienced by these populations.
  • These historical perspectives on urban struggle continue to echo throughout popular culture today.

Social Disorganization in Popular Culture and Film

  • Modern popular culture reflects many of the core tenets of social disorganization theory.
  • "Hood" films are noted for concentrating specifically on the concept of social disorganization itself.
  • Other films, such as Taxi Driver and The Brave One, explore different facets of urban struggle:
    • They are primarily interested in the "dynamics of exclusion."
    • They highlight the "failure of social institutions" to address what is termed "social suffering."
  • In these cinematic contexts, the underlying social conditions that structure isolation are often less visible than the "virulent pathology of exclusion."
  • The Hollywood portrayal of these dynamics typically involves characters who are:
    • Sympathetic but troubled.
    • Left entirely alone.
    • Socially cut off.
    • Fundamentally powerless.
  • The narrative resolution for these characters often involves an attempt to salvage their lives through the use of violence.